I've at least HEARD (because I haven't seen Morris' version) All three versions of this (Morris, Krakowski, Cruz). Each version has its quirks. This is one is definitely the MOST CREATIVE and well done. I mean the curtain she's wrapped up in at the beginning and end is GENIUS!!!
I saw the original on Broadway with Anita Morris. Men were literally unable to breath after her performance. SHE was a woman! The kind of woman even women love. The film took a few moves from the original but couldn't compare. There's a rough cut of her on youtube to give you a vague idea.It's been 30 years and I remember it vividly.
It's really HARD to sing while doing what she does... She's really talented! I saw her in London in "Guys and Dolls" with Ewan McGregor... she is really good!
By the way... I saw the movie... I think the movie lost the comedy and wasn't that good...
It wasn't bad, but not as good as it could have been...
Penelope's accent is obvious in her singing, but i think that's what made her version more exotic and sexy.. I liked jane's but I also preferred Penelope's. :)
LOL you could see her putting on the safety bracelet at 3:18 (not that it would be visible at all from the stage...and even if it was, im sure noone would think of that after THAT performance ;D)
Jane did a very wonderful job singing and acting, but the dancing/contorting they had Anita do in the original in 1982 was just out of this world compared to this!
Jane made her B'way debut in Starlight Express in 1987 and then went on to star in Grand Hotel the Musical in 1989 as Flaemchenn. She originally started on stage!
I know the focus is on her, but couldn't he a be a bit more facially expressive in the scene, yet trying to disguise? He stays there like a robot as in a pure business call, no reaction...I know he's trying to convey it's one, but it's not., so he should've slipped on the feeling out at certain moments as in giving himself away. But what do I know? Sorry!
I think Penelope combined the best of Anita and Jane's interpretations and created some real heat without taking anything away from what the two brought to the character.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
so my school is going to be doing Nine for our school m usical, and i got casted as Carla and my director asked do you want to do it the "Penelope way or the Jane " and i was like lets combien the two and omfg it is so scary to do what she does at 3:19. i was fucking scared out of my mind. I kept thinking omfg i'm gonna fall!! and your like really really high up lol so its scary it really is.
Penelope Cruz might look gorgeous singing the song, but they lowered the key for her, as they did Jane's. Anita Morris was the only one could do a kick-ass belt AND a high C... but Jane does do well here. :)
Can Penelope Cruz sing? I hope she doesn't warble out the song in her horrible English and yes Penelope Cruz's English is awful. I hope I am proven wrong but I'm not getting my hopes up.
just saw a clip of her doing this on Leno. Yes! She can definitely sing. But if I din't know the words already i would never have been able to understand her.
Anita Morris gave one of the legendary performances of this great song. She was a sexy, sexy woman. Much missed. Penelope C is going to steal the movie with this song.
I agree 100%. Jane was sexy and her acting was good, but Anita Morris blew this number (and the rest of her role) out of the ballpark. One of those unforgettable Broadway performances. (I think even Jane would agree.)
Call from the Vatican and Simple are the only clips ever posted. Does anyone have clips of Jane or Anita in the comical "nun's habit' scene right before Be Italian?
I've at least HEARD (because I haven't seen Morris' version) All three versions of this (Morris, Krakowski, Cruz). Each version has its quirks. This is one is definitely the MOST CREATIVE and well done. I mean the curtain she's wrapped up in at the beginning and end is GENIUS!!!
VidWatcher45673 17 hours ago
I saw the original on Broadway with Anita Morris. Men were literally unable to breath after her performance. SHE was a woman! The kind of woman even women love. The film took a few moves from the original but couldn't compare. There's a rough cut of her on youtube to give you a vague idea.It's been 30 years and I remember it vividly.
damejayne 3 weeks ago
Wow, Jenna Maroney just got way sexier!
withalittlehelpfrom3 4 months ago
Haha!! this version always makes me laugh , this scene wasn't so funny in the film
Haimfan 8 months ago
@Haimfan Not to mention, the film actually made the number MORE theatrical. But movie adaptations typically tend to do that, which is odd.
overthemoo 3 months ago
wowwwwww
really good version of this song.
its really interesting how much the musicall numbers change from brodway to movies
not only this one
all that jazz and the cell block tango from chicago were so diferent when saw them in the movie and when i saw the live video from youtube
sarizonana 10 months ago 3
WOW!
It's really HARD to sing while doing what she does... She's really talented! I saw her in London in "Guys and Dolls" with Ewan McGregor... she is really good!
By the way... I saw the movie... I think the movie lost the comedy and wasn't that good...
It wasn't bad, but not as good as it could have been...
PPforever 11 months ago 4
Penelope's accent is obvious in her singing, but i think that's what made her version more exotic and sexy.. I liked jane's but I also preferred Penelope's. :)
andrealovesclassics 1 year ago 2
Wow you just can't really beat penelope cruz in my opinion on this one.
Biogirl52 1 year ago
huh...i prefer penelope cruz's version much more. she's good though.
patmrhottiepantz 1 year ago
le queda mejor a penelope cruz
lucypinkfloyd 1 year ago
Her voice is so sexy and I love how they staged this number. Great work.
Troublemaker1991 1 year ago 4
woooo!
LOL you could see her putting on the safety bracelet at 3:18 (not that it would be visible at all from the stage...and even if it was, im sure noone would think of that after THAT performance ;D)
mysweetsmile23 1 year ago
Oh man this was good! But I would be so afraid to hang upside down like that at the end! OH BOY!
gerardbutlerlurver 1 year ago
LMAO!!!!
i like this one much better than the one in the actual movie!
well done
katinanewnewjarrett 1 year ago 2
she is amazing and this makes me love her
AdamEfimoff 1 year ago 3
jaja muy wenoo (Y)
TheCatitaaa90 1 year ago
This is phenomenal! She deserved the Tony. But even so, as rlee1976 said, it isn't comparable to Anita Morris's performance.
zne09 1 year ago
Jane did a very wonderful job singing and acting, but the dancing/contorting they had Anita do in the original in 1982 was just out of this world compared to this!
rlee1976 1 year ago
love herr
sarajh914 1 year ago
She ROCKED this. Love it. :D
heringtonchick 1 year ago
I didn't know Jane could sing. She did a good job.
RajaMCool 2 years ago 3
AND it won her a Tony Award! :D lol.
broadwayguy1992 1 year ago 4
Jane made her B'way debut in Starlight Express in 1987 and then went on to star in Grand Hotel the Musical in 1989 as Flaemchenn. She originally started on stage!
rlee1976 1 year ago
This video is amazing! Could you please upload something else from this show? I would love to see My Husband Makes Movies and Be Italian!
PattiLuponeFan216 2 years ago
I know the focus is on her, but couldn't he a be a bit more facially expressive in the scene, yet trying to disguise? He stays there like a robot as in a pure business call, no reaction...I know he's trying to convey it's one, but it's not., so he should've slipped on the feeling out at certain moments as in giving himself away. But what do I know? Sorry!
rosemaravilha 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
the film is terrible.
end of.
tonyoutterside 2 years ago
I wouldn't say it was terrible. It just tried WAY too hard to be 8 1/2 the Musical instead of being Nine the Movie.
AngelofMusic04 2 years ago
penelope was much sexier
ilamusicalssm 2 years ago 4
damn
FrenchToastPro 2 years ago 2
I think Penelope combined the best of Anita and Jane's interpretations and created some real heat without taking anything away from what the two brought to the character.
lf1234 2 years ago 4
two different mediums.
two different artists.
two different interpretations.
two different visions.
stop making it a competition. it's not.
ktabianchi 2 years ago 63
This comment has received too many negative votes show
so my school is going to be doing Nine for our school m usical, and i got casted as Carla and my director asked do you want to do it the "Penelope way or the Jane " and i was like lets combien the two and omfg it is so scary to do what she does at 3:19. i was fucking scared out of my mind. I kept thinking omfg i'm gonna fall!! and your like really really high up lol so its scary it really is.
imtheone121 2 years ago
I prefer Jane Krakowski's performance to Penelope Cruz's. Just sayin'
isakborg88 2 years ago 6
This comment has received too many negative votes show
penelope kicked this bitch's bony ass with this song
TanyaMarie4ever 2 years ago
absolutely not. She can sing. Penelope can't. There is no denying that Penelope is good. But no one can top Jane in this. No one.
spriingawakeniing 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
wrong. penelope owned this song. Jane can kiss penelope's hot spanish ass.
TanyaMarie4ever 2 years ago
whatever, think whatcha wanna think.
spriingawakeniing 2 years ago
she's considered a modern actor by a culture stuck in the old days of the profession. when fudgers of cinema acting rule.
thanks, penelope. another step backwards for our arts world. you are a trailblazer.
TheAxelrob 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i think penelopes is better, its sexier and cuter, this one seems skanky and janes voice isnt sexy neither are her movements
didaDIthatsme 2 years ago
@didaDIthatsme well, this is theatre, so the performance can't be as subtle. it has to be big and exaggerated.
dudewheresmydignity 2 years ago 4
@didaDIthatsme jane's voice is sexy
h8nessa 2 years ago 3
LMFFFAAOOO!!
OMG!
LMFFFAAOOO!!!
good performance :)
cant wait to see penelope do it ;)
tiannathompson15 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Penelope Cruz might look gorgeous singing the song, but they lowered the key for her, as they did Jane's. Anita Morris was the only one could do a kick-ass belt AND a high C... but Jane does do well here. :)
lyricsop03 2 years ago
the caracter that penelope acting is italian, and have an accent obviously.
papitilla 2 years ago 6
This has been flagged as spam show
Can Penelope Cruz sing? I hope she doesn't warble out the song in her horrible English and yes Penelope Cruz's English is awful. I hope I am proven wrong but I'm not getting my hopes up.
johnyzero2000 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
just saw a clip of her doing this on Leno. Yes! She can definitely sing. But if I din't know the words already i would never have been able to understand her.
tristanchord85 2 years ago
No .. Penelope Cruz's english is Latin English ... so it is perfect ... and sexy ... :E
BellatrixL23 2 years ago 15
great, now YOU'RE telling us how our language should be spoken - with a toe thick incomprehensible accent.
mysticgirl1000 2 years ago
Comment removed
BellatrixL23 2 years ago
Penelope, i can't wait for see your performance in Nine
papitilla 2 years ago 7
can you possibly put up "be italian"?! Its the best :)
bwaybaby315 2 years ago
so sexy without being trashy i love it
tannertheactor1 2 years ago 7
Woah. That's all I can say.
Killerrabbit2342 2 years ago 8
Anita Morris gave one of the legendary performances of this great song. She was a sexy, sexy woman. Much missed. Penelope C is going to steal the movie with this song.
chucknyc123 2 years ago 6
Everytime I see this again I still say "WOW"!!!!
jimmyrae 2 years ago
Cant wait to see Penelope Cruz singing this!!!
roberto4810 2 years ago 8
I saw the original Carla of broadways nine Anita Morris
Im sorry but she was a lot hotter & sexier then Jane kranowsk!
IDRIS1130 2 years ago
I agree 100%. Jane was sexy and her acting was good, but Anita Morris blew this number (and the rest of her role) out of the ballpark. One of those unforgettable Broadway performances. (I think even Jane would agree.)
Scott3843 2 years ago 3
Call from the Vatican and Simple are the only clips ever posted. Does anyone have clips of Jane or Anita in the comical "nun's habit' scene right before Be Italian?
lf1234 2 years ago
i love it! thank you :-)
brendabignose 3 years ago 4