true HD Haley Reinhart "Earth Song" Top 4 American Idol 2011 (May 11)

[hgrebnesor]

I honestly don't understand why this wonderful performance is so under appreciated. It truly is inspirational.

[AriellaEvyKosovic]

Did I missed something on TV?! :O

[bannelee]

JLo and Randy made me so mad that i may be done with this show.They didn't like Haley personally,probably JLo felt threatened by someone that can actually sing,unlike her.Whatever their reasons,I can't stand either of them.At least Steven called them out a few times for being wrong.

[RobloxMeggehXD]

This totally deserved a standing ovation! Man "judges" can be really stupid sometimes. :\

[jpsymingtonjj]

loved it..unfortunately Jennifer L messed it up once again for haley..I think J.L is ans was jealouse of Haley still is..shame on you J.L.

[hgrebnesor]

No doubt L.A. Reid would have loved this performance. Move on over randy - you have been replaced!

[gekoulagekoula123]

In that video she seems so much older than she is...but she still always be wonderful!!!

[hgrebnesor]

After a hard day it's so nice to be able to sit back and feel the power of this message.

[SuperIknow123]

This is my favorite until I'm listening to another vid of hers. LOL

Why isn't this on her EP?

[SuperIknow123]

vote Naima and Jacob on faxo wall vote if you can. If not then don't dog my request.

[boundlessloans]

Haley is awesome here. Good Job! She hit it out of the park!

[13monkeysrcool]

it looks like her hair is red/orange!! haha

[hgrebnesor]

I've watched this at least 200 times and I still find myself amazed with the Quality of both the HD picture and sound. Repd - you R THE man!

[hgrebnesor]

Did you ever stop to notice what a jerk Randy is!

[hgrebnesor]

Just sit back and listen to the message. Gotta love it/her!

[floodedtick]

you can tell she felt it just by the way she moved and her facial expressions

[dmp1549]

BTW, i love how this is edited. We get to see Haley's huge smile, the crowd going crazy. If MJ wasn't such a sacred cow to Randy this would have been one of her greatest moments, really.

[dmp1549]

What was wrong with this again?

[hgrebnesor]

@dmp1549 The ONLY thing wrong with this was that yo-yo Randy dumbass Jackson

[ashj6094]

Randy and JLOwere bobbing their heads to the music. You don't do that if you don't like the music. They are clearly trying to be negative! Those BITCHES!!

[hgrebnesor]

My inspirational listen for the day! All lost souls are welcome here.

[JanisJoplin1943]

This is so perfect ..

repad I love your videos!

[WHERESDACHEESE]

She sooooooooooooo should have won..... ;(

[hgrebnesor]

This performance - and the Studio version as well - are truly under appreciated. It takes a few listens but I very much enjoy the passion she brings to a classic Michael Jackson song. Randy you become a bigger fool each and every day!

[9999noi]

Everytime I watch this I get goosebumps all over me, I can't help it. When the choir comes out and at 1:49 when she gets really into the song. Magical!!

[supermusicfreak101]

I honestly got goosebumps

[kmc9008]

gotta love 1:49!  doesn't get much more passionate than that! love love love her!!!!

[jtma91]

loved the choir! i think i saw an asian there.. haha

[lalalauren409]

i don't see what the judges thought was wrong?! It was perfect and the song!....omg the best!

[MrLadiesfirst]

Great job Haley, I don't know what the judges were talking about, I know Michael Jackson version to and if you were yelling then so was Michael.

[Thebadinrams]

Magic pure magic

[bluewhale18]

The studio recording haley did of this song is unbelievable!

my favourite recording ever on idol

[mpmh9]

jlo and randy are crazy, all MJ songs are hits! haley is so amazing

[WHERESDACHEESE]

OMG THE PART WHERE THE CHOIR COMES AND BACKS HER UP IS JUST SOOOO MAGICAL I ALWAYS GET UPLIFTED AND JUST WOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!!!!

[WHERESDACHEESE]

ONE M0:00RE TIME

[goodboyhoward]

oh christ, i'm in love with this girl...

[ronhep49]

I can never understand why Randy and Jlo didn't like this sing. It is one of the best performances of the year by anyone as far as I am concerned. The more I listen to this , I keep liking it more and more. It is hauntingly beautiful. There isn't one performance by Lauren or Scotty that comes close to this in feeling and passion! The judges must be on drugs

[hgrebnesor]

@ronhep49 I agree with you. I've put all the live performances on my Iphone (I purchased all Studio versions). Listening to this one more and more. Sad that the Studio version can't compare due to the tacky musical accompaniment.

[dHoyhee10]

1:49 she so felt the song

[MrLadiesfirst]

I thought she did a great job and the studio version of this song is wonderful!

[jojoyacita]

GOOSEBUMPS HUNDRED TIMES!

[lonestar7703]

I hope she wins

[SCARMAN888]

fuck you RANDY!!!

thumbs up please,if you AGREE!!!

tnx...

[mawsley9]

Am I mistaken but didn't I hear Randy complement James on the degree of difficulty of his song 'Dont Stop Believing', compared to this joke joke. Jlo, Haley deserves praise for not taking the easy option, not criticism, in fact, her options, like this one and B and the J, have made the very best television and exposed Randy as an idiot.

[jaysean12344444]

haley and scotty for the finale, haley wins!!:D

[jaysean12344444]

i can't stand the fact that scotty and lauren have poor performances, and Randy says "YO DAWG!!! YOU ARE IN IT TO WIN IT!!!!" and Jlo says," OMG, THAT WAS LIKE, SO TOTALLY ADORABLE". Then when haley sings her beautiful ass off, Randy says, "YO DAWG THAT WAS SCREECHY AND PITCHY AND ALL OVER THE PLACE" i mean wtf?!?!

[lard3man]

UNFUCKINGBELIEVABLE! SHE IS AMAZING!

[whitefireheart]

Beautiful! I would have preferred if Haley sang the verses with just a little bit of angst, but I think she did great. The passion not just from her, but from the choir singers, plus those harmonies, and the balance overall. I think she, the musicians, and the backing choir enjoyed performing this and did a wonderful job! I wish all the judges could have at least seen, heard, and appreciated that as much as the audience and the viewers did..

[wankatana]

nice ass baby

[Mark6024]

Lets not get racist. ..lol Nah she was just doing what jennifer wanted....growliing.

[toxicity1969]

Randy's crazy. Such an emotionally charged performance. That does not equate to screaming, you buffoon.

[sueryanart]

yuck

[femaleexpressions]

I definitely don't understand the remarks from Randy and Jennifer Lopez. I thought Haley as fantastic. I am 66 years old and she absolutely made me "shake my booty". She rocks and gets me moving. Can't wait for her album to come out because I know producers will be knocking at her door soon. Way to go Steve you know what you are talking about. Haley don't stop believing!

[ashj6094]

@femaleexpressions i highly doubt that you are 66 years old! no 66 year old i know has a youtube account

[iamjaris]

if that's her screaming, i like her to scream every song she sings.

[snoophip]

shut up randy is my fave

[tanjatanjarian]

Haley u did amazing... Real disappointed in JLo for treating another woman with such unfairness! Yeah she stood up with Haley's other song, but this one was

just as good, JLO and Randy suck as judges!!!

[tanjatanjarian]

we showed the judges they were wrong.. hahaaa!!! GOOOOO HALEY!!!!

[Sparklight5]

she was screaming... this is pop... its not her thing.... wrong song choice .... the judges were right though... i donno abt her winning... Scotty is very original..

[DaLeadBull]

@Sparklight5 Scotty original? lol what's unique about him? He just has a deep voice for a young kid, thats all.

[Sparklight5]

@DaLeadBull yeah there are a lot of young people with deep voices and old people as well.... but most of them can't sing with those kind of voices... by original i meant you cant take the country out of him... he won anyways so .... woop woop .....

[BreakPics]

feisty!

[pionero82]

Haley's studio version of this song is AMAZING!!!

[elvise101]

Once Again, Amazing

[derrickyong2000]

she doesn't deserve the critics !!

[KatieStevensRocks]

@derrickyong2000 Agreedd she doesn't. They judges ALWAYS find something to pick on her for! ALWAYS!