JR Replication of Whipmag OC MPMM

[mimi1girl2dempsey3]

you forgot to install the electric motor in the back. What were you thinking?

[krizpy86]

you say frictionless but I can hear the cheap bearings making noise

[SuperMardiGrasBros]

@krizpy86 It still wouldn't accelerate even if everything was suspended in place above magnetic fields, with no physical contact to the base or axis whatsoever, and the ability to spin freely for several minutes, even hours, in a vacuum, with no gravity.

But yeah, it would probably spin for a few minutes longer if he had better bearings...

[jasondaletegart]

what if you had a stronger magnet that would sway in and ourusing gravity that way it would offset the energy in bursts like a person peddaling a bike but since gravity is causing the motion and the magnet pulls it self tward the motor it would work. In theory for a little while. If you placed the swinging magnet controled swing of course just at the perfect distance it should always do the same motion. try it im interested to see what it would do

[ShamblerDK]

I think you should stop spending money on magnets and buy yourself a better camera.

[alienhddna]

some self runing magnet motor do work

[BlackRoof]

There is NO SUCH THING as "frictionless" unless you are floating in space, so no wonder it doesn't work.

To extract energy from it, it has to EXPEND energy, which it doesn't have. It will only ever settle in a trough of minimal competing magnetic forces once it has spent any initial spinning forces you put in.

CLUE: Magnetism is UNIVERSAL and you cannot negate the opposite poles' energies. (you cannot hide the negative magnetic forces) Otherwise it would be easy.

[Secondlifecreator]

@BlackRoof

I think the problem is pretty simple, the main wheel bearing sucks. By the looks of it this has been a very cheap low fi project. So i get it why he does not spend cash on good ones. I would try different bearings, the bearing (you can hear that noise when he spins the wheel) that is your friction right there.

The magnets are never strong enough, plus sound stupid why are the magnets spinning? Think of it, wheel spins, magnet too..were does it resist ? The field changes too on spi

[BlackRoof]

@Secondlifecreator Wrong!

As I said, there is no such thing as "frictionless" when two surfaces rub (or roll) against each other. Therefore you are always "losing" energy, so long as there is motion. Even the motion of a solid object against the air HAS FRICTION

Unless new energy is being put in (or "created") by the magnetic forces, the motion will eventually stop.

Magnetism is a UNIVERSAL CONSTANT and you cannot simply ignore the negativ magnetic poles. So magnetic attraction cannot make power

[forgetfuldays]

The problem are the free moving magnets on the outside.

When the machine gains momentum the free moving magnets become unpredictable and are not able to keep up.

Even though the magnetic force that moves them is "frictionless" the free moving magnets are bound by friction because of the bearing used to hold them.

This is why this machine will never work, the free moving magnets are terribly unpredictable and will never keep up with the magnetic forces that alter their positions.

[interxmen]

you need to set different power magnets man

[domeafava]

That's....................real­ly good.

[jeyfree]

Y el puto motor no funciono!?? para que coño lo suben!?!! Parecen ustedes parte de un proyecto maldito de las grandes transnacionales de la energía, para desprestigiar la idea de energía libre. Hay mucha gente investigando en internet... y de tantos videos como estos terminan tachando la idea de imposible, y a los que lo intentan de frikies. Si no funciona no monten una mierda. Y si pretenden aportar algo, al menos digan por q no funciono y díganlo de un principio para no decepcionar. COÑO!

[Zechariahstickpage]

you got that bilt alll rong thats y its not werking

[gippi86]

oooh... it doesn't work... you are a genius

[mr1000rx]

the holy grail with magnet use is James Roney magnet shielding.

[NuArkdUBSTEp]

have you got it to work?

[kempercom1]

JR,

Would you like to sell you model? I would like to buy it.

[bananaman387]

use a central pin for the rotor to freely float in a sense less friction. prolly still wont work tho.

[SM96UK]

hum...

to make sure that a magnetic motor can generate free energy it must be always spinning forever, because if you have to rotate, that means it will eventually find a neutral point where the magnetism balances out and stops.

[djpeyoooo]

stop les vidéos de merde sur youtube , on veut du concret !!!!!

[nabz32x]

@djpeyoooo

please keep talking english.

[MrCruzen6972]

The magnets are off set on the original. They work against each other. You are close, but re-think.

[jib1000]

Why on earth did you need to spend money to know this couldn't work?????

[muddymuddymuddmann]

OK I WAS INTRIQUED WHEN I SAW THE FIRST ONE A YEAR AGO. THE ONLY DIFFERENCE I SEE BETWEEN YOURS AND THE ORIGIONAL ONE IS, THE MAGNETS ON THE ROTOR ARE CENTERED ON YOURS. THE ORIGIONAL WAS OFFSET A LITTLE. I BELIEVE IT WAS TO THE CCW DIRRECTION. I SPENT 4 HOURS ANALYZING THE VIDEO BEFORE I MOVED ON TO THE NEXT. GOOD LUCK. AND MANY GOOD THINGS TO YOU AND YOURS.

MUDDy

[Ebdan88]

I didnt believe in Free Energi until i saw the Shah of Iran's Speech about Oil, and the fact that we shouldnt use oil as a source of energi. He used to say that oil was to preshes to be used as energi. He knew very well about Free energi, but Because of Blady Polotics he couldnt talk about it. Research and you will find out that Chek's had invented a free Energi motor in the 50's and 60's....!!??

[Ebdan88]

Anyone can tell you the you need a moving part. If it was so easy then somebody had think of it many years ago. Please look at my channal, and you will find many working Free Energi machines

You need a system which can pull and push at the right moments...!!?

[Tcll5850]

it really only requires 1 free magnet, and 2 stationary magnets...

in my opinion, I think you only need the 1 free mag.

never played with it before so IDK...

[bichn01]

there is a link in here of a working one that shows how he started it

[bichn01]

you need to spin the stator magnet oposite to the main wheel by hand, this will make it work, it may not work first up it may need a few trys until it syncs, spin the main wheel clockwize and spin one of the stators anti both at same time

[jotacril]

ACME MAGNET FACTORY INC.

Our wish to thanks the thousands of dreamers that persist thinking perpetual machines are possible and buy our neodimiun magnets.

Our technician say that as more magnets you use better results you will get.

Buy our ACME MAGNETS

-----discounts for quantities

[boulderdashbilly]

Remember when we thought the world was flat, and the sun revolved around, us? what about when we thought we were the centre of the universe? or when we thought the atom was the smallest thing in existance. Shove your magnets up your ass and sit on a steel chair would you, and then have a think about your poxy insignifacant existance

[chrisofnottingham]

What you have here is basically a magnetically coupled gear system, like cogs but without needing physical contact. And just like with cogs, there is no reason for it to turn of its own accord.

[henrykay01]

Why are only fraudulent inventions shown on youtube?

[zzytrewq]

@henrykay01 - because it is impossible to show a working one. Cos they don't. They are a chance to scam people.  Like convincing people to buy magnets to build one. Nice piece of fraud.

[henrykay01]

It is possible to show a working one - I can do it if I have enough $ (I need $3 million for a prototype).

[henrykay01]

A magnet engine will not work, something else will.

[zzytrewq]

@henrykay01 - what is the "something else". If it promises over-unity or perpetual motion or free energy it will not work.

[henrykay01]

I have a proof that it is possible to violate the law of conservation of energy. I would disclose it under a confidentiality agreement, but youtube does not let me to put my e-mail address here.

[zzytrewq]

@henrykay01 - WOW! Send me your email address to my personal messages and all problems are solved!

[henrykay01]

I do not know how to send my e-mail address to your personal messages.

My telephone number is +48-512-933-540

[zzytrewq]

@henrykay01 -click on my moniker (zzytrewq) - go to bottom of page and provide email address in comment section. Cheers

[21Wakeup]

the purpose of the magnets is to somehow use them to amplify the energy put into it. magnets already have a constant force of energy. so use the larger wheel to make the smaller wheels to go faster then harness the energy of their rotation. good device just not used right

[JmanNo42]

What kind of magnets is the stationary ones that rotate. Do they have polarity as painted upon them?

Where did you buy them?

[RockManAU]

Tried spinning both large mags at once?

Maybe you forgot to include the magnets like the Mythbusters did when testing the Bedini device!

[highguard01]

Try electric current period add a side polarity changer so you can change directions of the spin maybe add three bearing to the bottom spin bearings should be offset to generate other points of your magnetic field. this will releave the stress bearing down on it given more free space to rpm up

[jabberwock11]

The reason why it doesn't work is you forgot to add the electric motor to make it spin.

[adamalden]

ur magnets are wrong i bet... also what is the point of the bearings?

[JRBeaman]

Terrific, you uploaded a video of a failure. Wheee.

[MattBlytheTheOne]

did you try spinning the stator at various speeds? it didn't look like you were spinning it fast enough to overcome the gate, it is frequency dependant I believe...

[KWMCD]

Come on Really. If people find this so amazing that the magnets make it move forever well then i got another thing that will blow your mind. You know those magnetic hanging balls where one hits one side and the other one gets repelled(dont know what they are called). This really isnt n e different but you can't get usable power from it. Oh heres another one. How about those bird things that dip into the water over and over again.

[satortenet]

the rear stator should be spun anti-gearwise, I think... have you tried that?

[Individualism101]

Expensive toy.

[waldo2020]

another fancy flywheel! perpetual NOTHING!

[hueyshell]

Any metal pieces close enough to the magnets are drawing away from the process.Remove any thing not meant to push pull the device.

[djedi81]

I know why it doesn't work.. It doesn't have a frickin motor on it. Weeeeee!

[Xikkub]

fail

[karecar12345]

dude your not turning it right

if you turn the roter cockwise

turn the stator magnets clockwise or anti gear wise it should work

you got to spin both quite fast for it to work

[Woolfer81]

I think that in original working video is used sound resonance to promote moving of the disc...Very very clever...

[zzytrewq]

Another fake.

[waldo2020]

ha ha - scammed by magnet freaks!

[johnnytheprick]

WALDO, says the man who actually WATCHED the vid and then COMMENTED on it.

wots rong with magnet freaks anwyway? i think any1 trying 2 develop free nrg devices is cool.

have u got a sister?

[UssenterprizeDv2]

I'm inclined to believe it works except as the laws of physics require the magnets demagnetize.

[Drevtoobe]

I found out who the perpetrator of this fraud is. It's the user "TinselKoala" on YouTube.

Look here before he deletes my comments:

watch?v=OxEpSX2Hd54&feature=ch annel_page

[foupana]

take a look to this vid in youtube: (Project Camelot looks at George Green's magnetic motor)

[adisharr]

What you're missing is the power source that Alsetalokin used. It would work fine then.

[MaskedSkeptic]

You spent some big money on that.

[countcake]

all we need now is the flux capacitor

[Jesusdragon737]

You're not spinning the black disk fast enough, and you're also not spinning the magnet fast enough.

[pistander]

Where can tha plans be obtained

[Memory7hief]

he spins the magnet the wrong way?! what a noob, like Anticitizen0001 said... Clockwise motion, people like this shouldn't be allowed to study physics.

[wingnut4427]

try mounting Horse shoe magnets around the edge of the wheel.

[ketamunke]

This is sad. Do you think that if someone really found a PM machine that it wouldn't be on the news and the buzz of every science community. Oh wait, it's a conspiracy. I forgot.

[magnusmatt]

Where could I obtain parts such as the rotor and bearings?

[AdminOnDuty]

Search the Fizzx Forum There you will find a comprehensive compilation of data of this ongoing open source project.

Cheers :)

[Anticitizen0001]

ANTICLOCKWISE.

[hoodedwonder]

in the other video where it did work, didnt he spin the outer magnet anti clockwise? your just spinning it clockwise

[augustBody]

why do you have the 8 bearings? Did you check the North/South of the magnets? What are your Magno-kinetic jetson dampers made of?

[banghelmi]

We should call this technique is whipping magnet technique. I have a great technique that I've been working on, it punch better and more powerful spin.. I will post my creation later on youtube.

bless me ok..

[pjotri65]

If two people do the same things, they aren't the same things

[sinjaninja]

Perhaps the whole thing is BULLSHIT!

[serpentphoenix]

u need more energy !

[KnightChatX]

The outter magnets are moving, try angling magnets and making them stay still. While just the center rotates with a controlled and constant applyied force not requiring manual interaction.

[RetroTheory]

Perhaps you have a design flaw. I'd look into the magnets distance and positioning. They seem to far apart and not enough of them.

[adisharr]

The main design flaw is the lack of bullshit in this model.

[VandalSword]

lawl

[spitfire2101]

thumbs up

[Hilary155]

A functioning perpetual motion machine in a youtube video does not constitute scientific evidence in support of perpetual motion. A non-functioning perpetual motion machine in a youtube video does not constitute scientific evidence against perpetual motion. Science is fairly clear on what constitutes scientific evidence.

[Hilary155]

Present the original model that is claimed to work, or any working version to a group of people versed in the scientific method and with a background in electrodynamics / physics who are capable of examining it and determining how it functions (if it indeed does function). Physics college students, science fairs, university professors and electronics hobbyists all would be acceptable. Present them with a working model. Allow them to check for fakery.

[mutwa]

I noticed none of the replications used the copper strip on the original design. I think the purpose was just visual, but given that copper has an interaction with magnetic fields, it should have been at least noted, namely for the lenz law factor..

[fritmore]

maybe ur rig is too perfect too symmetric try to introduce some slight ASYMMETRY into the field...

[devilfirestorm]

if ur ever selling it, just send me a message, coz imight be intrested/

[JRreplication]

Yadaraf15, please see my other videos. I removed the extra stator bearings.

I used grade N42 as specified in the design.

I am convinced this is a hoax.

[phoenixblazestorm]

hey dude, i think u need to spin that little magnet anticlockwise even faster, try using an mini airgun , that can make that little magnet go faster..

[Rocky1990]

@JRreplication you need an electromagnetic coming from outside that just switches all the time and then the motion begins. you cant just use all permanent magnets.

[Yadaraf15]

JR,

Nice rig, but oddly slow.

1. You need to remove the extra stator bearings from your rig, because they are parasitic.

2. Make certain that you don't have any magnets or ferromagnetic material devices(screwdriver, etc.) nearby.

3. What grade magnets are using in the rotor?

Cheers :)

Yada ..

[Lalogcia]

Good try,

but if it works?? what would we do with gas and electricity??

I would love it works but it is not posible,

I will stay tuned to see what happens

[JRreplication]

The magnets are correct. See other videos. This video only shows what I did on one spin in front of a camera. Off camera I do all sorts of things to the device, spinning it faster, for instance. This was my first video in front of a camera.

[Danster82]

Have you got the magnets on the main wheel configured correctly? Alot of these magnet energy sources say one magnets needs to be in the opposite polarity or try removing 1 magnet from the wheel so theres a gap.

[digitalgenitals]

you should watch that other dudes video and exam what he did more carefully.

[basementexperiments]

Thanks for attempting this replication, the most genuine I've seen so far. Good job, I'll be watching.

[JRreplication]

Thanks for the comments...I will try and do what you guys say. Stay tuned...

[flagtube]

You must spinn the little magnet FASTER. Much more faster then the BIG wheel.

[AutogenicMotor]

get rid of those bearings around the outside, in fact drop it down to just one stator with a magnet, and play with that, it takes a while to get a feel for how to make it sync AGW

[AdminOnDuty]

Also, I notice your rotor spins down quite fast. I think your bearings a bit tight on the rotor. It should take about 120 seconds to wind down completely.

[AdminOnDuty]

You say you havn't been able to get AGW sync? I notice your rotor magnets are not marked. Perhaps they flipped on you?

[jimgolian]

I've done everything I could...see my other videos. It's a hoax.