This was the real showstopper, not "Ladies Who Lunch." God bless Beth Howland -- just look at her concentration while having everyone come at her between takes with their comments. And she went on to "Alice."
I don''t see how anybody can do this song while keeping a straight face! XD Or even be in the same room as somebody doing this without bursting out laughing! Beth Howland is the original singer and she sets the bar so high it's hard for anyone to compete. I've seen a few different people do this and I have to say the only one who does her justice would be Madaline Kahn. That's my opionion only though. And I admit to it being a bit bias because I love Madaline so increadibly. ^_^
It could be that he wanted to make sure that this was exceptional. When you're doing it live one expects a margin of error. Being that this is the definitive version I can see why he pushed fir perfection.
She deserved a tony just for that rehearsal. She was adorable and incredibly talented as well as the orhestra other vocalists. The sheer raw brilliance of Sondheim. Thank you.
@timjmoran this is why Sondheim is a maniacal genius, all of his numbers, as well as all the comedy in them, are so taxing, its amazing when it works, but boy is it physically and emotionally difficult to exicute, Beth Howland's clarity is amazing, this musical is hilariously funny because of the talent that launched Sondheim's and Furth's fantastic creation.
she may have sung this at the correct tempo, but those who sing it a little slower give the audience time to react to the jokes... if it's too fast, it flies right by you
@livelifealwaysx3 actually i got ALL of the jokes, and it requires the audience to hold laughter in and listen to EVERY word she says and laugh at the end of the song. An actor does in fact play to an audience, but an actor plays (or should play) what THEY feel, not what the audience is asking for. If we as actors did what we did on stage just because an audience asked for it, we might as well just perform in a circus, ya know? Just my thoughts anyways. Haha.
This may be a dumb question, but why is Beth Howland receiving so much coaching regarding pitches, phrases/breathing, enunciation...? By the time this was recorded, hadn't she already performed it many times on stage?
I wonder if an actress ever totally tanked while singing this song in a production-like just dropped the words or stopped like Howland did during the recording? I'd pay to see that.
I think painful, or "pained" rather, is precisely how this song is supposed to sound :) She's meant to be having a complete panic attack... Do you not agree?
@ElmoCanto I think its something like that. Except that if you put too much of the "pain" part you get Carol Burnett's version, which I think is funny but not so much into the song.
I think you're supposed to be sort of having a panic attack but at the same time the song is like your inner voice speed talking...
Seriously....SERIOUSLY!!!!! WATCH CAROL BURNETTE SING IT. SJE KICKS ALL ASS EVER BORN, This girl sounds like she has a cold and sings through her nose!!!!!!!!
Stephen Sondheim said that Beth Howland is the only woman who sang this song in a major production (Broadway/Tour/London) who sings it at the tempo he originally wrote it in.
I have to congratulate Beth Howland. Sondheim's songs are 90% all about his lyrics, and you have to hear the words being enunciated. This is a hard song to sing, and I heard Ms. Howland completely sing her lines. I love this song -- and Sondheim.
@stickyfixer I agree. He was sexy. I just saw him in conversation in Toronto last month, and for an 80 year old, he holds himself well. He was definitely an attractive man earlier in life. And his brilliance endures.
This is awesome. I like seeing this side of music. You know, how it's created. Brilliant!
jafufu69 1 week ago
You can just picture Vera Gorman singing something like that, although, unlike neurotic Amy, she did get married. :)
AlbieGray 1 month ago
lets see George Watsky do that
619505drummer 3 months ago
This was the real showstopper, not "Ladies Who Lunch." God bless Beth Howland -- just look at her concentration while having everyone come at her between takes with their comments. And she went on to "Alice."
sporran564 3 months ago
I don''t see how anybody can do this song while keeping a straight face! XD Or even be in the same room as somebody doing this without bursting out laughing! Beth Howland is the original singer and she sets the bar so high it's hard for anyone to compete. I've seen a few different people do this and I have to say the only one who does her justice would be Madaline Kahn. That's my opionion only though. And I admit to it being a bit bias because I love Madaline so increadibly. ^_^
TheNewSailorMercury 5 months ago
have you guys heard Heather Laws do this for the 2009 production of Company? :) Just as fast, and just as neurotic.
pakis 5 months ago 2
she's awesome!!!
jomoses07 6 months ago
@sillybill4
It could be that he wanted to make sure that this was exceptional. When you're doing it live one expects a margin of error. Being that this is the definitive version I can see why he pushed fir perfection.
dmajor050 7 months ago
God bless her fitting in that many words with barely breaths.My theater class watched this and I couldn't say anything afterwards.Absolutely amazing.
BlackCanvasSoul 7 months ago
superhuman!
honeyjbc1 7 months ago
She's freaking amazing.....
allanfisch 9 months ago
Sondheim is still sexy. XD
Heterormorphic 10 months ago
dang! she's fast.
she didn't even look out of breath, amazing!
etraig 10 months ago
Fantastic diction!
MasterIsh91 10 months ago
She deserved a tony just for that rehearsal. She was adorable and incredibly talented as well as the orhestra other vocalists. The sheer raw brilliance of Sondheim. Thank you.
fobesq 10 months ago
She is outstanding.
angeleyez101 11 months ago
wow !! Imagine trying to sing this live in the studio in front of all those people!!
Whew! This had to be one of the toughest tunes ever in any musical.... almost like
Athletics meets music.
timjmoran 1 year ago
@timjmoran this is why Sondheim is a maniacal genius, all of his numbers, as well as all the comedy in them, are so taxing, its amazing when it works, but boy is it physically and emotionally difficult to exicute, Beth Howland's clarity is amazing, this musical is hilariously funny because of the talent that launched Sondheim's and Furth's fantastic creation.
ViveClaire 11 months ago
Heather Laws seems to be doing it at the same tempo to my ear.
sacredlunatic 1 year ago 3
she may have sung this at the correct tempo, but those who sing it a little slower give the audience time to react to the jokes... if it's too fast, it flies right by you
livelifealwaysx3 1 year ago
@livelifealwaysx3 actually i got ALL of the jokes, and it requires the audience to hold laughter in and listen to EVERY word she says and laugh at the end of the song. An actor does in fact play to an audience, but an actor plays (or should play) what THEY feel, not what the audience is asking for. If we as actors did what we did on stage just because an audience asked for it, we might as well just perform in a circus, ya know? Just my thoughts anyways. Haha.
lenlee14 1 year ago
She's got crazy eyes! Perfect for Amy
Straw2daberry 1 year ago
wow try to do that night after night!
Pbsmike 1 year ago 3
"I don't wanna upset ya', but i'd love to have the tune..."
mplsjockboy 1 year ago
"I don't wanna upset ya', but i'd love to have the tune..."
mplsjockboy 1 year ago
I need a 70's man, Get over it.
rayzer1 1 year ago
my friend got to know Sondheim in NY and said he's quite sexy and very kinky, love it!
TheRavendearest 1 year ago
Oh my God, Steve Elmore sounds AMAZING
RainbowTammy 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
This may be a dumb question, but why is Beth Howland receiving so much coaching regarding pitches, phrases/breathing, enunciation...? By the time this was recorded, hadn't she already performed it many times on stage?
sillybill4 1 year ago 2
Comment removed
shadowboxer524 1 year ago
Comment removed
chazsallen 1 year ago
example of an inspired match between song and performer, ditto with Stritch
gabsylv 1 year ago
@ stickyfinger its not just you.
sondheimisGAWD 1 year ago
I wonder if an actress ever totally tanked while singing this song in a production-like just dropped the words or stopped like Howland did during the recording? I'd pay to see that.
bettyboy72 1 year ago
Beth Howland OWNS this song! .. Still the best 40 years later.
1Renbar 1 year ago
The only two versions I like this one and the revival. The follies one with Madeleine Kahn annoys me.
KatrynMerteuil 1 year ago
4:43 - Steve Elmore sounds AMAZING!
manidonno10 1 year ago
@manidonno10 He looks pretty amazing too, not gonna lie.
ggfanjase 1 year ago
You gotta love Youtube! Where else could you search "Company" and get this?
DavidinIrving 2 years ago 6
You know, Teri Ralston is really an amazing singer. It's a shame she wasn't in many more musicals...
VRNProductions 2 years ago 5
Her voice is so cute! People complain about her voice, but voice isn't needed for this song. Just to get all the words out is enough!
hillevifan 2 years ago 8
The only part where it sounds really bad is when she holds out today...It's painful.
brittmstar 2 years ago
I think painful, or "pained" rather, is precisely how this song is supposed to sound :) She's meant to be having a complete panic attack... Do you not agree?
ElmoCanto 2 years ago 8
@ElmoCanto I think its something like that. Except that if you put too much of the "pain" part you get Carol Burnett's version, which I think is funny but not so much into the song.
I think you're supposed to be sort of having a panic attack but at the same time the song is like your inner voice speed talking...
KatrynMerteuil 1 year ago
Beth Howland was married to Michael J. Pollard in the sixties.
wmlfan9 2 years ago
that was super fast.... and she got EVERY word right!
WesleyCappiello 2 years ago 4
that was really fast
Wicactor1028 2 years ago
i like sondheim's clothes at 0:47
meeee46 2 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
Seriously....SERIOUSLY!!!!! WATCH CAROL BURNETTE SING IT. SJE KICKS ALL ASS EVER BORN, This girl sounds like she has a cold and sings through her nose!!!!!!!!
mkmih01 2 years ago
Stephen Sondheim said that Beth Howland is the only woman who sang this song in a major production (Broadway/Tour/London) who sings it at the tempo he originally wrote it in.
fashionglindaguru 2 years ago 71
I have to congratulate Beth Howland. Sondheim's songs are 90% all about his lyrics, and you have to hear the words being enunciated. This is a hard song to sing, and I heard Ms. Howland completely sing her lines. I love this song -- and Sondheim.
astoria25 2 years ago 8
@fashionglindaguru Good Lord that most take skill
RaineaTrenton 1 year ago
Is it just me, or was Sondheim kinda sexy?
stickyfixer 2 years ago 103
IMMENSELY.
[Just had to make sure I said that.]
ImperfectlyPerfect2 2 years ago
It's not just you, I The first time I saw Sondheim when he was younger was in that video when he wins two Tonys for Company, I thought he was sexy.
malletgirl02 2 years ago
He definitely used to be.
soclosetolife 2 years ago
@stickyfixer Sondheim was all kinds of sexy.
airinkincaid 1 year ago
@stickyfixer Oh yeah, I think he's sexy and mysterious, heeeeeeee
FBoobieTubie 1 year ago
@stickyfixer intellectually sexy, yes.
gabsylv 1 year ago
@stickyfixer I agree. He was sexy. I just saw him in conversation in Toronto last month, and for an 80 year old, he holds himself well. He was definitely an attractive man earlier in life. And his brilliance endures.
clojomo 1 year ago
@stickyfixer His talent alone would have made him hot. He was, in a 'shaggy Jew' sort of way. But he probably smelled like an ashtray back then.
tommytimp 8 months ago
@stickyfixer yeah...for sure.
caseyryanmather 2 months ago
@stickyfixer Was?
aqua1993 2 months ago
My goodness, look how young Stephen Sondheim was.
pumpkinheadedmf 2 years ago 6
incredible!! love it and her.
BDaviWA 2 years ago
Uffffff!!!
Great!!
sarahtarjafan 2 years ago
the blond women singing the opera part, is Terri Ralston. she is my teacher, SHE IS AMAZING EVEN NOW
mysonbox 2 years ago 4
Where does she teach?
cmw1226 2 years ago
haha... i just love hal's glasses!
ssondheim 2 years ago
Beth Howland is such a true pro... this is not an easy song and there is so much going on in the background.. wow i love watching pros work..
bigmiamiguy 2 years ago
Beth Howland is my mom's cousin.
shortyxO29 2 years ago
That would make her your cousin too...
brittmstar 2 years ago
Wow. She manages a really fast tempo and I can understand every word she sings!
dangerousmezzo 3 years ago 5
Yeah it must be hard....
maszlagma 3 years ago