I don't know if I'd say it was better than Fantasia's, but I will say she found her own spirit in the song. I'd say that's the mark of a truly great rendition, if you can sound like yourself while singing someone's song. I think she did that.
i thought this version was fantastic....Fantasia's was on a finale night so it was bound to have more passion with it...i really liked Syesha and never knew she could hit that whistle not until this song...fantastic
Vocally stunning. Better voice than Fantasia. But yes she doesn't have a "back ground story" to push her towards the top, which it seems is a requirement in AI.
her outfit was ugly... this is the second the judges were wrong with her... first with the whitney song... just becaz its a trade mark that doesnt mean its untouchable... they tell them 2 take risks and when they do they have a problem
i think the judges have a say in the final score, regarding talent.
and america votes for the rest... i think. lol.
because if the person doesn't get the most votes... then their album won't sell well. can't you see? during the show, you get people to vote for you. and the more people there are, the more fans you have. and when you finally release songs or something, then... yea :)
she got robbed.. too bad american idol is a popularity contest and not an entertainer contest.. the best singer usually never wins.. ie.... clay aiken
I'll admit it..I wasn't a Mercado fan and I'm still not. But this performance is awesome! She hit the notes extremely well, had noticeable emotion and made it her own. Fantasia's was really good but Syesha took this song to a new level.
I agree with you dencraze! This vocal was outstanding in comparasent to Fantasia! Yes hers was full of emotion, thats why it seemed better, but its not about emotion, its about tallent! She is great! Hope to see more of her!
This reminds me of season 1 when at first Simon didn't like Kelly Clarkson, yet she grew better towards the end and won the competition. Syesha has the same mad potential.
This is why I voted for her 10 times...the judges are too hard on her when in fact she is the best vocalist remaining. The others are just popularity voclists and not true talent.
she's so wonderful...she doesn't get enough credit...she's f*ing amazing...i wish peoplewould see that...but remember, fantasia was in the bottom 3 a few times during that season, if i'm correct, and look what happened :)
she's so great, so talented, so confident... I think people may think she's not one of the contestants, n forgot her...so sad that she's usually in the bot 3 though she did so good...
she's one of my faves...i think she is underappreciated on the show...she takes songs by the big voiced people and still makes it her own...i don't understand the judges...she's amazing
Your just another one of these haters on here..... I know it hurts...... U wish you could sing as good as her! Im so sorry she sang fantasias song 10 times better than her. YOU LOW LIFE. I swear if hating was a CRIME they would ARREST YALL Ni99as!!!!!!!
i mean when sanjaya was in the bottom 3 then yeah, but she clearly has the best voice. and i am so glad she made it to the mariah carey episode. she will take it out. her voice is the best
Everyone is clearly delusional if they cannot see that syesha has the voice and potential to go very far, and I hope she at least makes the top three. I admire her charisma, she truely is an American Idol.
how can they compare emotion of her to of fantasia's, when she was singing it was the last song she was going to sing on the show. And then she sang it when she won! Of course your going to be emotional and cry. Syesha's was so much better than Fantasia's and she was incredible. The best of the night by far
Good point. Fantasia had emotion and conviction because she had just won the competition...who wouldn't sing the living daylight out of a song if they've just won the competition.
Damn she is really good but the judges don't like her...WHY...cute little David will make them more money. She damn sure tamed Randy's tiger with this song. VOTE FOR HER SHE DESERVES IT!!!!
She and Archuleta are the only two worth being in the last two. I want David to win, but nonetheless she really shines and I hope she gets the thriviing career she deserves. !!!
Please vote!! she is amazing and talented, i bet u that if she goes Mariah carey's week would be boring because nobody has the range and the ability to hit those keys like Syesha.. please vote!!! please Vote!!! not even in the btm 3 please
randy fatass jackson and dumb britishy simon dont give her enough credit..please please please please vote for SYESHA 1-866-43657-02!! SHE NEEDS TO BE SAFE THURSDAY!!
randy fatass jackson and dumb britishy simon dont give her enough credit..please please please please vote for SYESHA 1-866-43657-02!! SHE NEEDS TO BE SAFE THURSDAY!!
randy fatass jackson and dumb britishy simon dont give her enough credit..please please please please vote for SYESHA 1-866-43657-02!! SHE NEEDS TO BE SAFE THURSDAY!! AND I AM SACRED TOO, So0ul
She is better than FANTASIA~ But Diana's Version still the best and full of emotions!
kyo1223 7 months ago
@MrMalaysia88 no she dont
The123speedy 9 months ago
i like her voice over fantasia's
livetodancexox 1 year ago
Could anyone tell me who sings the original version of this song?
MattewBrasil 1 year ago
@MattewBrasil fantasia barrino
Defensedrew252 1 year ago
@Defensedrew252 Thankful!
MattewBrasil 1 year ago
i love her, has she got an album out yet?
markanddana 1 year ago
@markanddana Its coming in 2011
JoeWesley9 1 year ago
damn, way more superior than the others who performed this. better vocal ability hands down.
5450daniel 1 year ago
WAY underrated... Beautiful, Classy, Elegant, Amazing, Talented...
itzmeeteddy 1 year ago 2
I don't know if I'd say it was better than Fantasia's, but I will say she found her own spirit in the song. I'd say that's the mark of a truly great rendition, if you can sound like yourself while singing someone's song. I think she did that.
sblxi 1 year ago
you rock, girl ...
qtingful 1 year ago
I like Syesha's version better than Donald Duck's.
snapfishfb2 2 years ago 5
I love syesha but no one does it better than fatansia ...............period so bye gurl fly gurl
veeification 2 years ago
its like this song was made for her
TGSchannel 2 years ago 2
I Love Syesha's version and Diana's Version~!
kyo1223 2 years ago 2
i thought this version was fantastic....Fantasia's was on a finale night so it was bound to have more passion with it...i really liked Syesha and never knew she could hit that whistle not until this song...fantastic
bonnerssuitcase 2 years ago 4
fantasia always sing with passion every since she was a child. you can search for some of her clips when she was younger.
for some people it's not just about having a pretty voice.
cdhinton77 2 years ago 2
Vocally stunning. Better voice than Fantasia. But yes she doesn't have a "back ground story" to push her towards the top, which it seems is a requirement in AI.
muskinilukun 2 years ago 8
one of the best season!
carloh011 2 years ago 3
this is really good i mean really reall really goo, but u cant compare it to Tasia's.
takellebootz 2 years ago 3
what people forget is that fantasia did it with passion that's why her performance of this song surpasses those who just have pretty voices
reinadelfutbol10 2 years ago 2
i agree
cdhinton77 2 years ago
gosh she should be famous but theres people like miley cyrus the jonas brothers and whatever useless talent out there that are complete garbage
rearea718 2 years ago 30
This has been flagged as spam show
her version may sound good. BUT NO ONE, NO ONE, DOES IT BETTER THAN FANTASIA!!!!!!
babikakes2001 2 years ago
Omg she so murdered her LMAO
Cowboy2314 2 years ago 3
she murdered Fantasia lol
rickjames720 2 years ago 10
That's a good thing I assume, considering the fact that Fantasia was Donald Ducks' daughter.
CaseyPCarlson 2 years ago 2
don't hate lol
cdhinton77 2 years ago
She totally rocked this song!!! She did s much better than Fantasia
TenorMan90 2 years ago 18
@TenorMan90 no she didnt fantasia did much better than her wtf
The123speedy 9 months ago
ROFL! totally agree.
WAY BETTER than fantasia. ROFL. damn.
druthiee 2 years ago 7
Imo better than Fantasia...
Lwatson09 2 years ago 7
she sang better than fantasia on this song. singing i believe needs no tears.
koolnash101 2 years ago 4
her outfit was ugly... this is the second the judges were wrong with her... first with the whitney song... just becaz its a trade mark that doesnt mean its untouchable... they tell them 2 take risks and when they do they have a problem
misterroyaltee 2 years ago
no...
i think the judges have a say in the final score, regarding talent.
and america votes for the rest... i think. lol.
because if the person doesn't get the most votes... then their album won't sell well. can't you see? during the show, you get people to vote for you. and the more people there are, the more fans you have. and when you finally release songs or something, then... yea :)
God bless~ :)
-Anthony
12zuzus 2 years ago
she got robbed.. too bad american idol is a popularity contest and not an entertainer contest.. the best singer usually never wins.. ie.... clay aiken
osufan2 3 years ago 3
ruben was better than clay and so was kimberley
frazzler9 2 years ago
How did she not win?!!!!!!!! She has an INCREDIBLE voice and a nice personality!
Cimmac17 3 years ago 5
That last note! GO SYESHA! You should have won.
littleman1280 3 years ago 5
BRAVO! SHE NAILED IT!
bigvoice007 3 years ago 2
She's was probably the best girl in the contest
Rugbyballmad 3 years ago 6
evidently she was ...she was the last girl standing
dollarpiece21 3 years ago 4
i think syesha sings clearer than fantasia..
but of course, the original is always the best!
lyju1990 3 years ago
Syeshe's was better than Fantasia's in terms of vocal skills. Fantasia's was better in terms of emotion. Simple.
FurImmerLamm 3 years ago 7
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Her performance is nothing compared to Charice Pempengco's version of I believe. Look it up guys
irrabbit 3 years ago
I'll admit it..I wasn't a Mercado fan and I'm still not. But this performance is awesome! She hit the notes extremely well, had noticeable emotion and made it her own. Fantasia's was really good but Syesha took this song to a new level.
geckobabies 3 years ago 3
I agree with you dencraze! This vocal was outstanding in comparasent to Fantasia! Yes hers was full of emotion, thats why it seemed better, but its not about emotion, its about tallent! She is great! Hope to see more of her!
syrussykes1 3 years ago
she should won...
nicoo619 3 years ago 3
personally, her version was better than fantasia in terms of vocals, but fantasia's version was full of emotion....
dencraze 3 years ago 5
brilliant
christucker765 3 years ago 2
swabe!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
pisidum 3 years ago
This reminds me of season 1 when at first Simon didn't like Kelly Clarkson, yet she grew better towards the end and won the competition. Syesha has the same mad potential.
robbg2006 3 years ago 8
This is why I voted for her 10 times...the judges are too hard on her when in fact she is the best vocalist remaining. The others are just popularity voclists and not true talent.
robbg2006 3 years ago 2
I agree with you completely
lpurvis 3 years ago
Good...I like that she put her own twist on it and didn't copy every single lick and phrase as Fantasia...originality!
robbg2006 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
shes good but nothing special
amazinglynae 3 years ago
she is so amazing more poerful and stronger then fantasia but fantrasia is still great...
MAULOLO123 3 years ago
Well it is...she's underappreciated for the talent she has...and yes, the AMAZING talent she has...
cowtails 3 years ago 3
how the fuck is that now amazing?
what is wrong with them?!!
inlovespell 3 years ago
y does simon hate her, shes so amazin if she doesnt win theres no justicee in this fuckin world lol
20tartley07 3 years ago
true!!!!!!!!
wayneabc123 3 years ago
i luv her shes my fav
lovetooplaytennis 3 years ago
he dosent
lovetooplaytennis 3 years ago
by far one of the best singers.....
america needs to get their ears checked and listen to her, cause she is the future of Idol
Curlytop96503 3 years ago 2
she's so wonderful...she doesn't get enough credit...she's f*ing amazing...i wish peoplewould see that...but remember, fantasia was in the bottom 3 a few times during that season, if i'm correct, and look what happened :)
cowtails 3 years ago 3
she's so great, so talented, so confident... I think people may think she's not one of the contestants, n forgot her...so sad that she's usually in the bot 3 though she did so good...
TomTMinh 3 years ago
she's one of my faves...i think she is underappreciated on the show...she takes songs by the big voiced people and still makes it her own...i don't understand the judges...she's amazing
cowtails 3 years ago
She did the song justice, but I want to see Syesha's signature.. not Fantasia's or Whitney's.
ringorules987 3 years ago
SHE ROCKS. all the other contestants cant match the power of her voice. KALI KUTI.
lahblabli 3 years ago
she has talent,great voice... but she's no melinda d.
69franco 3 years ago
she has talent,great voice... but she's no melinda d.
69franco 3 years ago
she has talent,great voice... but she's no melinda d.
69franco 3 years ago
she did a decent job, but she is no fantasia
freakyblkboi 3 years ago
HEY FREAK FANTASIA SUCKS.
redpitbullz08 3 years ago
syesha sucks more, does bottom 3 mean anything to you, she was lucky to have survived this week
JTB4004 3 years ago
Your just another one of these haters on here..... I know it hurts...... U wish you could sing as good as her! Im so sorry she sang fantasias song 10 times better than her. YOU LOW LIFE. I swear if hating was a CRIME they would ARREST YALL Ni99as!!!!!!!
redpitbullz08 3 years ago
don't get mad, get glad, she never be gr8
JTB4004 3 years ago
i mean when sanjaya was in the bottom 3 then yeah, but she clearly has the best voice. and i am so glad she made it to the mariah carey episode. she will take it out. her voice is the best
vilisoni 3 years ago
I love her!!!She sounded amazing here..so much POWER.I want her to win soooo bad!DEFINITELY THE BEST OF THE NIGHT.
TYEWE 3 years ago 2
Everyone is clearly delusional if they cannot see that syesha has the voice and potential to go very far, and I hope she at least makes the top three. I admire her charisma, she truely is an American Idol.
Skyblue300 3 years ago
how can they compare emotion of her to of fantasia's, when she was singing it was the last song she was going to sing on the show. And then she sang it when she won! Of course your going to be emotional and cry. Syesha's was so much better than Fantasia's and she was incredible. The best of the night by far
Wildebeast93 3 years ago 2
Good point. Fantasia had emotion and conviction because she had just won the competition...who wouldn't sing the living daylight out of a song if they've just won the competition.
robbg2006 3 years ago
She sang the hell out of it on the actual performance night.
frazzler9 3 years ago 2
Damn she is really good but the judges don't like her...WHY...cute little David will make them more money. She damn sure tamed Randy's tiger with this song. VOTE FOR HER SHE DESERVES IT!!!!
planetime 3 years ago 3
this girl is the only thing keeping me alive and staying tune every week on American Idol
Go Syesha!
flickery 3 years ago 4
Woahhh~~~ very nice..... love it....
pegasus08 3 years ago 3
She was the best of the night
yur1944 3 years ago 4
She and Archuleta are the only two worth being in the last two. I want David to win, but nonetheless she really shines and I hope she gets the thriviing career she deserves. !!!
destinyjul 3 years ago 4
actaully she sing the song with her own version....so that they will not say that she copy the version of fantasia.....thats all......
pucchik 3 years ago
actaully she sing the song with her own version....so that they will not say that she copy the version of fantasia.....thats all......
pucchik 3 years ago
actaully she sing the song with her own version....so that they will not say that she copy the version of fantasia.....thats all......
pucchik 3 years ago
actaully she sing the song with her own version....so that they will not say that she copy the version of fantasia.....thats all......
pucchik 3 years ago
I love this girl.
She sings what she feels.
More should be like her.
stephen877041 3 years ago 3
Best of the night.
Ediamond1 3 years ago 3
she's amazing!!!!
foreveraki 3 years ago 4
A-M-A-Z-I-N-G
roseyabby 3 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
copycat with no personality. she doesn't beloang even in top 24
ragedimonyo 3 years ago
You wish you could sing like her
redpitbullz08 3 years ago 4
If she gets voted off I will never watch American Idol AGAIN!!!!! Who cares about fantasia SHE HAS A MOHAWK!!!
redpitbullz08 3 years ago 4
this was the best of the night..I have no idea what the judges were smoking
-mike
residentmikelee 3 years ago 3
as far as i know only kelly clarkson is the only other AI contestant who's done the whistle note
Kimtalento 3 years ago 2
Yeah, I think so to ( on Natural Woman ) yeah. She did that note great though.
idoltyler06 3 years ago 2
Yeah, but I think Syesha's was better, lol...something about Kelly's was weird, LOL.
xxForeverlambxx 3 years ago
She just showed everyone why she deserves to be in the finals....No one can deny that she sang her heart out.
tholmes123 3 years ago
pls vote for syesha... im not from america and cant
that was so inspiring
ps. was that the highest note ever in idol history
jaysphere 3 years ago 3
i can't remember anyone else using whistle register for a money note before.
go syesha!
plaapluu 3 years ago 2
@plaapluu
Kelly Clarkson did when she sang Natural Woman on Season 1...she hit and F#6...it was in the verse you make me feel so alive
dgaller06 1 year ago
@dgaller06 true! thanks, didn't remember that when i commented.
plaapluu 1 year ago
she has the voice just lack of emotion
x3Laurao13x 3 years ago 2
totally totally amazing.. for me, twas the best performance of the night.. very inspiring indeed!
joashgelera 3 years ago
This was really good.
friendly76 3 years ago
Please vote!! she is amazing and talented, i bet u that if she goes Mariah carey's week would be boring because nobody has the range and the ability to hit those keys like Syesha.. please vote!!! please Vote!!! not even in the btm 3 please
talkabout2me 3 years ago
She did the dolphin!!!
thomas2417 3 years ago
go syesha...!
i miss ramiele...=(
changedmark 3 years ago
Fantasia´s version has the emotion. However, Syesha´s vocal took this song a whole new level.. She totally rocked it !
DOQ77 3 years ago 4
dont vote for carly smithson..please please please please vote for SYESHA 1-866-43657-02!! SHE NEEDS TO BE SAFE THURSDAY!!
drcoxrox18 3 years ago 5
why discourage those who vote for carly? that's mean.. syesha will be safe if she deserves it..
identityIIivan 3 years ago
fantastic.
seansantaclarita 3 years ago 2
Not just fantastic it was AMAZING I loved it
Hobbitgirl6 3 years ago 2
100 times better than Carly, GO SYESHA AND PEOPLE VOTE....
jendakub 3 years ago 3
I LOVE HER!!
maviehb 3 years ago 5
awesome performance!
sweetpea058717 3 years ago 5
If you want to be sure to see syesha next week you better vote- dial idol currently has her in last.
dmhuua 3 years ago 4
hey people, vote for her!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
jendakub 3 years ago 6
The best female perfomance of the night, she had two weeks with the best female perfomance for a mille.......
elmister10000 3 years ago 3
fantasia killed this song in the first place. it is the song of her life. syesha did good.
rccraigslist 3 years ago 3
randy fatass jackson and dumb britishy simon dont give her enough credit..please please please please vote for SYESHA 1-866-43657-02!! SHE NEEDS TO BE SAFE THURSDAY!!
drcoxrox18 3 years ago
OMG she has THE voice !!!
you2b2cme 3 years ago
VOTE
qg6ff 3 years ago
randy fatass jackson and dumb britishy simon dont give her enough credit..please please please please vote for SYESHA 1-866-43657-02!! SHE NEEDS TO BE SAFE THURSDAY!!
drcoxrox18 3 years ago
Syesha is awesome in so many ways...extraordinary singing...a smile that lights up the screen...and totally inspiring...thank you Syesha!!!!!!!
shamil3864 3 years ago
thought this was great, one of the best of the night in my opinion, and hopefully the dial idol thing will be wrong....do alot of people use that?
iamrhinocerous 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Fantasia's, Diana's, and Lakisha's were all better
joshholt87 3 years ago
I couldn't disagree more. Syesha was million times better than Lakisha and Diana, million times, check the videos on youtube, u out of your mind.
Syesha has mega vocals, she hits so easily all the notes, and that note at the end was wwoooww
wild7horse 3 years ago 3
vote plz ... she is in danger on dial idol
chukwuma2008 3 years ago
Dial Idol is not reliable.
Wallenstein 3 years ago
ur right its not, like when the top 12 was revealed danny had one of the busiest signals then he gets voted off....
drcoxrox18 3 years ago
randy fatass jackson and dumb britishy simon dont give her enough credit..please please please please vote for SYESHA 1-866-43657-02!! SHE NEEDS TO BE SAFE THURSDAY!! AND I AM SACRED TOO, So0ul
drcoxrox18 3 years ago
Millions times better than Lakisha, and at the same level of my ever fav contestant Fantasia.
Syesha is so under-rated she is so so amazing, she got the best female vocals, and she is so humble and beautiful!
Save - Syesha Mercdao: 1-866-IDOLS-02 (or text VOTE to 5702) I think she will leave ... I'm so afraid
So0ul 3 years ago 4
that high note freaked me out. lol. it came out of nowhere.
izziebee123 3 years ago 4
I want to lay on top of Syesha.
mjp029 3 years ago
That high note sounded like Mariah Carey! She was phenomenal!
VonzellSolomon38 3 years ago 3
I Love It!
DrakeandJosh95 3 years ago 4