It's just the same music as before, she even can't whistle like Mariah Carey. She whistle not like Mariah Carey whistle or i must said ' Worst '. Why don't you try your vocals, and show us?
Mariah Carey is a LEGEND. She has one of the most beautiful, POWERFUL voices I've ever heard! She has sold over 200 million albums worldwide, and been showered with lots of musical awards. Kelly Clarkson will never come CLOSE neither to her level of musicianship nor to her level of success. This video is a JOKE.
Yes i was wondering tthe same with bith pecehemelba and blindwatch. Is this video for real? kelly that i like 2 is good, but mariah is the best and she can do better than just screaming again and again and again, see how mariah sings in wave and her voice is so strong. Obviously some stupid person who like kely do not know about music and post this video lol, its like looking at a kindergarden shool, how can you campare a magical voice with a regular voice?
Lol KELLY IS A WAYYYYYYYYYYYYY BETTER VOCALIST THAN MARIAH! Pple mariah is boring and her notes are dull just bcz she can whistle dsn't mean that she's better! DO NOT HATE ON ME THAT'S MY OPINION! KElly can outsing her ANYTIME :)
Mariah is like billions, trillions time better, not because of the whistle, mariah has hundred times better voice texture, melisma, range and TONE TONE TONE!! she writes stuff and is one of the best female singers of alltimes!!, Kelly isnt even half talented, good soundin or succesful, idol flop who tries hard to be mariah/whitney hahahaha with rock, please stop makin laugh. Kelly is such an irrelvant singer!!!
@JZ311995 omg you are so stupid. The only song i like from kelly is because of you, and that is because of the song not the voice, yes its true it it an insulf even trying to compare the 2,
@JZ311995 After whitney passiing we are in mourning, even back then whitney can not sing with strong beatiful waves like mariah, listen to the song my all and try to compare it to because of you.
@JZ311995 I can scream 2, a lot of people do,kelly deosnot write her songs, while mariah does!! all her lyric or as you said note is so smart and never run out of idea while beacuse of you basically about what?
@JZ311995 when simon cowel said people have to give her credit because out 0f 15 number 1 songs she had, she wrote them except for1 : i ll be there, which was never a part of her albums, but people like it so much, sony realese unpluged album and cd single for that song, people relate 2 jackson five, that unpluged was legendary people from coast 2 coast want to hear it watch it so mtv play that again and again and finallyrealising a video dollars
@enderarias agree, this video is shit, and yes we can sream 2 and stop hating and comparing. Mariahs voice by far is the most magical and you can not compare, especially with kelly, whoever post this vid obv do not like mimi
take this stupid video down... only an idiot would try and compare two different types of talent and instead of enjoy both decide to debate which is better.... have some respect or just all together grow the fuck up.
Can Kelly do Whistle technique? hahahha NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO..NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO..NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO..NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO..NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO.. NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO..NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO..NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO..
@ksionc100 she also doesn't have mariah's power and resonance to her belts... mariah is just perfect. in my opinion her voice and tone sound like honey :) so sweet! why kelly tends to get shouty, like you said, and unsupported when she belts high notes.
@iiAmitx3 if we are talking about upper belts, Kelly does have decent resonance up there. Some of her notes are perfectly fine. The thing is she also has many shouty, throaty notes - something Mariah disciplines herself not to do. Like you, I appreciate Mariah's singing much more than Kelly's however keep in mind that her flawless portfolio comes partly due to dubbed DVDs and lipsynching so she's not perfect
@ksionc100 i agree but i judge the voice not only by live performances, but also studio work. especially mariah who is more of a studio artist. (but also a stunning live performer when she wants to)
@iiAmitx3 You r comparing Mariah with Kelly...Kelly has just started her career but Mariah has gone through many years.. You would see if Kelly is able to sing like this at 40s... Mariah was even way too better than Kelly during Kellly's age..
@iiAmitx3 2 YOU she cant give her best..& it's bcuz she's already given her best 4 over TWENTY years..so unappreciative. We'll see if Kelly can do this in 20 yrs..However, Kelly loves AND respects MC so hey, it is what it is ;)
@carshe209 First of all I love Kelly and did not degrade her. I said she screamed her SUBG G5's along with the Walk Away G5's and a few others. Some were great and nice here but those sucked and Mariah has never screamed like that ever. I stated the facts. Kelly is great in her own right but she is not on Mariah's level.
@Stefano94x yes mariah is hell better than kelly specially on her prime.. a FACT. but kelly screamer? stop hateing.. kelly tends to belt those notes with roughness to make her genre pop/rock sounds more effective.. and besides there where tons of kelly clarkson better g5's..
@Stefano94x bad intonation your ass.. kelly clarkson is a pop rock singer.. the rise and fall of her voice and smooth shift and transition are not necessary on her genre.. but when kelly sang chain of fools, standing infront of you.. my man cover from barbra streisand.. and the 2 song she sang in tony bennet.. her intonation was faultless.. it just dpends on genre she is singing..
@Stefano94x talking to you in civilized way is impossible.. coz you are jerk.. now shove your computer in your stinky foreskin.. uncircumcised italian cunt!.. block user.. bwahahahahah
@carshe209 You're a moron lol. The fact you insult me won't erase that Kelly is a screamer who can barely support the sound over 6 notes, and Mariah shits on her on every note in every register :)
foolish she could never compare to the queen silly silly video. mariah is always effortless! cigarette smoker and all and still sings like a goddess! #FAIL
LOL i love kelly and she slays but her SUBG G5's were screamed. Mariah has never screamed like that ever. Stay pressed! Mariah will always be better than kelly. Lamb 4 Life <3
@musicguy713 this video was made by retarded christina stan.. because kelly fans always defends mariah.. on why she is better and superior compare to christina.. and sad to see that a lamb is degrading kelly.. knowing that kelly clarkson herself is a lamb.. and so is her fans..
This shit is awful!!! It doesn't even do Kelly justice cause she's a good singer and it's like you put all her bad sounding performances together.. the audio is horrible. Kelly is a great singer but Mariah in her prime and even now will always be a better vocalist than Kelly!!!! Awful video total dislike!!!
can kelly still do this? I watched a performances of hers 2011, long shot, and her voice was extremally weak, she wasn't singing it the way it's supposed to be sang, mariah uses lip syinch to preserve her voice, and everytime she is really singing live she is awesome
This is so funny she's just another xtina!!! Mariah at least sounds good when belting and also looks hot doing it... Kelly looks like a cow and answering your vid NO Mariah cannot do that because Mariah sings not squeals like a pig
@JesusDonaldoOFICIAL - Shes done pretty well out of 'screaming'... how many world tours has she sold out? How many albums has she released and how many fans does she have?
i think mariah fans attack kelly because they are afraid, because kelly is more popular on todays music, i think she one of the best things that breakout las decade!!!
I am glad that Mariah cant to this because for me this is not singing is Kelly screaming her head off so she can hit the higher notes that she wouldn't normally achieve. This is awful, poor quality and rubbish.If you can't hear that I am sorry but you are hearing impaired.
Please Don't Compare an Artist with 20 years of career Like Mariah Carey with an Amateur Singer like Kelly she is Good But Mariah use to sing too hihg and she still Can Belt High Notes Easier for example "Subtle Invitation" She hit G5 Tho times and F#5 like 3 times She has Showed that she is a Great Singer So please don't be ridiculous!!
Mariah in her day when she was the age of Kelly here, PULLLLEASE, Mariah would have blown Kelly to smithereens, and Kelly would be the first to admit it, SERIOUSLY, you need to listen to Mariah's first two CD's from the early 90's then GET BACK
Kelly Clarkson isnt only an american idol winner, shes the best singer of them also. Although I think this video is pretty dumb, the truth is Mariah can't hit that note (G5) better than Kelly. Infact, no one can hit that note as well as Kelly Clarkson can. As far as who the better singer is, Mariah, in her prime of course, but don't let the idea of her being an Idol winner blind you of how phenominal a singer she is, 'cause theres a reason she won AI. She's one hell of a singer, don't forget it.
look Kelly is a great singer and I get that you like her and everything but you just can't compare her to Mariah. Yes, Mariah can do everything in the video. that's the truth. listen to anytime you need a friend by mariah and listen to her hit 3 G5's
they have different styles. pls dont compare they are both great. kelly can't outdo mariah's song Forever.. and mariah cant do that rock thing going on with Kelly. dont compare oranges and apples lol.
can kelly loose weight?, can kelly get 18 number ones?, can kelly be worth 500 million, can kelly wear a bikini, can kelly write her own songs?....comparing kelly to mariah is like comparing a cubic zirconia to a diamond...
@TheXwatts You're being ridiculous. Everyone has the ability to lose weight and Kelly DOES write her own material and with all the other things you said,only time can tell whether Kelly can accomplish them. In a year of so, for all we know Kelly may be one of the biggest international stars like she was in 2005-2006. Stop being disrespectful to Kelly because BOTH Mariah and Kelly are amazing artists. This video was made by an Xtincta stan posing as a Kelly Clarkson stan so you don't need to bash
@kozocitow LOL actually mariah has not belted anything higher then this maybe one G#5 these are all G5s and kelly sustains hers mariah has never sustained a G5 or G#5 kelly has sustained G5 G#5 hit A5s Bb5 B5 and sustained C6 belt
Like Mariah says, "Dahling please"
ilikepepsi15 6 hours ago
TO EVEN COMPARE THE TWO IS DUMB..... MARIAH IS WAAAY BEYOND KELLY, SO TRY AGAIN
PerrieEllis1 6 hours ago
yes she can
peeer12001 1 day ago
What is she doing? Saying "again and again and again" over and over? Or the yelling?
Ghaanji 2 days ago 3
As much as I truly love, love, LOVE and respectKel: that last note was plain screaming... -_- Mariah owns.
nefsy09 2 days ago
Mariah is a prerecorded bitch and has been caught many times lipsynching.
yugijane 2 days ago
Kelly can sing but she don't want Mariah on her worst day she still sits Kells down lol Stop pushing your idol farther then you think she is lol.
dondidit 3 days ago
sample song- if its over..mariah carey... and the question is kelly can do mariah songs? like fly like a bird.......
johnylify 3 days ago
@johnylify right lol but i have to say i do see Kelly sound a little like mariha
maxday1000 3 days ago
It's just the same music as before, she even can't whistle like Mariah Carey. She whistle not like Mariah Carey whistle or i must said ' Worst '. Why don't you try your vocals, and show us?
PeaceSpeaker100 4 days ago 2
I love Kelly, but Mariah SLAYS her.
emilee494 5 days ago 5
Mariah don't need to do it, and if she could she wouldn't. Her musicianship is to high to do it.
RomuloVideos2 6 days ago 5
Well of course Mariah can, anyone can because Kelly is practically screaming.
Missycandylips 1 week ago
yes, easily of course
justandreas889 1 week ago
No comments
moidebrito 1 week ago
No she can't do that!She can do something a million times better!!!!P.S.:Kelly sounds like she's being killed while singing Respect!
TheJasonland 1 week ago
Mariah Carey is a LEGEND. She has one of the most beautiful, POWERFUL voices I've ever heard! She has sold over 200 million albums worldwide, and been showered with lots of musical awards. Kelly Clarkson will never come CLOSE neither to her level of musicianship nor to her level of success. This video is a JOKE.
zucchini2007 1 week ago
bad like that OFc mariah cant scream ...trololol
MarcoBaetaCh 1 week ago
Mariah use to be better but not in 2012
db200508 1 week ago
of course Mariah can, and more beautifully
dmobrien82 1 week ago
umm yes she can...
deps21 1 week ago
if ill go choose between mc and kel..ill go for mimi! sorry but i do also love kel! just saying!
ruinahrt07 1 week ago
No, she can't do that beacuse she is Mariah Carey and not Kelly Clakson, and both have different voices and different vocal techniques.
humor78 1 week ago
Yes i was wondering tthe same with bith pecehemelba and blindwatch. Is this video for real? kelly that i like 2 is good, but mariah is the best and she can do better than just screaming again and again and again, see how mariah sings in wave and her voice is so strong. Obviously some stupid person who like kely do not know about music and post this video lol, its like looking at a kindergarden shool, how can you campare a magical voice with a regular voice?
Ihendera1 1 week ago
Kelly is the FIRST and best American idol she will NEVER be forgotten. Mariah is already dissapearing
seilagirl09 1 week ago
Mariah Carey has a good voice but she SCREAMS and Kelly Clarkson SINGS...Mariah
Carey was a Light Lyric soprano and Kelly Clarkson was a Soprano leggero!!!
ziggylennox2012 2 weeks ago
Comment removed
ziggylennox2012 2 weeks ago
Mariah Carey's 5 Octave Vocal Range ,she can do more then Kelly that right!!! ,WHAT!? did you say "NO" STUPID :(
nannieZD 2 weeks ago
ARE YOU FUKIN SERIOUS?!! what kind of a question is that!?? MARIAHS VOICE IS GOLDEN! WHAT AN INSULT TO EVEN COMPARE THE TWO!!
h311ra1zah 2 weeks ago
Kelly > Mariah!!
StevayPeePay 2 weeks ago
Yes, a lot of people can scream.
myNSproductions 2 weeks ago
K is just screaming...
stevenzder 2 weeks ago
Lol KELLY IS A WAYYYYYYYYYYYYY BETTER VOCALIST THAN MARIAH! Pple mariah is boring and her notes are dull just bcz she can whistle dsn't mean that she's better! DO NOT HATE ON ME THAT'S MY OPINION! KElly can outsing her ANYTIME :)
JZ311995 2 weeks ago
Mariah is like billions, trillions time better, not because of the whistle, mariah has hundred times better voice texture, melisma, range and TONE TONE TONE!! she writes stuff and is one of the best female singers of alltimes!!, Kelly isnt even half talented, good soundin or succesful, idol flop who tries hard to be mariah/whitney hahahaha with rock, please stop makin laugh. Kelly is such an irrelvant singer!!!
zanoases 2 weeks ago
@JZ311995 omg you are so stupid. The only song i like from kelly is because of you, and that is because of the song not the voice, yes its true it it an insulf even trying to compare the 2,
Ihendera1 1 week ago
@JZ311995 After whitney passiing we are in mourning, even back then whitney can not sing with strong beatiful waves like mariah, listen to the song my all and try to compare it to because of you.
Ihendera1 1 week ago
@JZ311995 I can scream 2, a lot of people do,kelly deosnot write her songs, while mariah does!! all her lyric or as you said note is so smart and never run out of idea while beacuse of you basically about what?
Ihendera1 1 week ago
@JZ311995 when simon cowel said people have to give her credit because out 0f 15 number 1 songs she had, she wrote them except for1 : i ll be there, which was never a part of her albums, but people like it so much, sony realese unpluged album and cd single for that song, people relate 2 jackson five, that unpluged was legendary people from coast 2 coast want to hear it watch it so mtv play that again and again and finallyrealising a video dollars
Ihendera1 1 week ago
LMAO THAT WAS AN EPIC FAIL OF MASS PROPORTIONS!!!!
MDB2770 2 weeks ago
Oh come on... hang yourself! This video is shit! Kelly is not bad but you never can compare her to Mariah, NEVER!
enderarias 2 weeks ago
@enderarias agree, this video is shit, and yes we can sream 2 and stop hating and comparing. Mariahs voice by far is the most magical and you can not compare, especially with kelly, whoever post this vid obv do not like mimi
Ihendera1 1 week ago
Umm... Yes.
J2Cam85 2 weeks ago
Mariah can do and do it better !!
Mariah Carey is worldwide known Kelly isn't !
Trying to compare Mariah to this bitch is like a blasphema cuz Mariah is a godess and her music a religion ;)
underworld91200 2 weeks ago
Of course Mariah can do this and much more effortless than her and sounds more great = ="
It's not singing but screaming .....God ...horrible sound ......
BTW, Mariah Carey is incomparable , because she's the BEST !!!
terrywind826 2 weeks ago
take this stupid video down... only an idiot would try and compare two different types of talent and instead of enjoy both decide to debate which is better.... have some respect or just all together grow the fuck up.
TwistedRoots1 3 weeks ago
yes she can... ... and she can do much much more than this, and better than this...
davidchubo 3 weeks ago
Oh. Yes she can. And can do better ;P
ILoveFirst 3 weeks ago
Kelly can sang though
jonniboi212 3 weeks ago
She can hit that note, it would just sound better
jonniboi212 3 weeks ago
Can Kelly do Whistle technique? hahahha NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO..NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO..NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO..NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO..NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO.. NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO..NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO..NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO..
coupe1416 3 weeks ago
Okay...No i LOVE kelly she without a DOUBT is an AMAZING VOICE...but come on...
javarie19 3 weeks ago
its MARIAH thats on top this video is stupid lmao. Jessie J's voice has more control than kell lmao
thetoddstah 3 weeks ago
Anyone know what song she's singing at 1:28?
iRonta13 3 weeks ago
Kelly is copy paste Christina Aguilera style..
U are so stupid to compare Kelly with MC..
Why U don't compare Kelly with the original Style Christina Aguilera.
So people can see who is the best. Of course CA
Kelly must to make her own style don't copy paste other singer style..
So people can respect to Her..
mangajoentax 3 weeks ago
Mariah faz melhor :D
vandremzz 3 weeks ago
Mariah can hit and sing each of these notes. Kelly tends to sustain them longer but she also gets shouty. Overall I prefer Mariah.
ksionc100 4 weeks ago
@ksionc100 she also doesn't have mariah's power and resonance to her belts... mariah is just perfect. in my opinion her voice and tone sound like honey :) so sweet! why kelly tends to get shouty, like you said, and unsupported when she belts high notes.
iiAmitx3 3 weeks ago
@iiAmitx3 if we are talking about upper belts, Kelly does have decent resonance up there. Some of her notes are perfectly fine. The thing is she also has many shouty, throaty notes - something Mariah disciplines herself not to do. Like you, I appreciate Mariah's singing much more than Kelly's however keep in mind that her flawless portfolio comes partly due to dubbed DVDs and lipsynching so she's not perfect
ksionc100 3 weeks ago
@ksionc100 i agree but i judge the voice not only by live performances, but also studio work. especially mariah who is more of a studio artist. (but also a stunning live performer when she wants to)
iiAmitx3 3 weeks ago
@iiAmitx3 uhm, when she wants to? Mariah's LIVE performances has made her known for who she is 2day.
99heartbreaker99 3 weeks ago
@99heartbreaker99 yea but now mariah doesn't always give the best peformance she can. in the beginning though she was one of the best! :)
iiAmitx3 3 weeks ago
@iiAmitx3 You r comparing Mariah with Kelly...Kelly has just started her career but Mariah has gone through many years.. You would see if Kelly is able to sing like this at 40s... Mariah was even way too better than Kelly during Kellly's age..
coupe1416 3 weeks ago
@iiAmitx3 2 YOU she cant give her best..& it's bcuz she's already given her best 4 over TWENTY years..so unappreciative. We'll see if Kelly can do this in 20 yrs..However, Kelly loves AND respects MC so hey, it is what it is ;)
99heartbreaker99 3 weeks ago
@99heartbreaker99 @coupe1416 omg you guys don't understand me! im on mariah's side! LOL... L4L!
iiAmitx3 3 weeks ago
@iiAmitx3 agree :)
Ihendera1 1 week ago
@carshe209 First of all I love Kelly and did not degrade her. I said she screamed her SUBG G5's along with the Walk Away G5's and a few others. Some were great and nice here but those sucked and Mariah has never screamed like that ever. I stated the facts. Kelly is great in her own right but she is not on Mariah's level.
musicguy713 4 weeks ago
LOL. Mariah shits on this screamer even on her WORST performance.
Stefano94x 1 month ago
@Stefano94x yes mariah is hell better than kelly specially on her prime.. a FACT. but kelly screamer? stop hateing.. kelly tends to belt those notes with roughness to make her genre pop/rock sounds more effective.. and besides there where tons of kelly clarkson better g5's..
carshe209 4 weeks ago
@carshe209 Yes, she is a screamer. Flawed technique and bad intonation. Deal.
Leave now.
Stefano94x 4 weeks ago
@Stefano94x bad intonation your ass.. kelly clarkson is a pop rock singer.. the rise and fall of her voice and smooth shift and transition are not necessary on her genre.. but when kelly sang chain of fools, standing infront of you.. my man cover from barbra streisand.. and the 2 song she sang in tony bennet.. her intonation was faultless.. it just dpends on genre she is singing..
carshe209 4 weeks ago
@Stefano94x talking to you in civilized way is impossible.. coz you are jerk.. now shove your computer in your stinky foreskin.. uncircumcised italian cunt!.. block user.. bwahahahahah
carshe209 4 weeks ago
Comment removed
Stefano94x 4 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@carshe209 You're a moron lol. The fact you insult me won't erase that Kelly is a screamer who can barely support the sound over 6 notes, and Mariah shits on her on every note in every register :)
Stefano94x 4 weeks ago
foolish she could never compare to the queen silly silly video. mariah is always effortless! cigarette smoker and all and still sings like a goddess! #FAIL
misfit11288 1 month ago
Kelly screams better than Mariah. Mariah sings better than Kelly. Point made.
LeInevitable 1 month ago
@LeInevitable agree
fulpis 4 weeks ago
LOL i love kelly and she slays but her SUBG G5's were screamed. Mariah has never screamed like that ever. Stay pressed! Mariah will always be better than kelly. Lamb 4 Life <3
musicguy713 1 month ago
@musicguy713 this video was made by retarded christina stan.. because kelly fans always defends mariah.. on why she is better and superior compare to christina.. and sad to see that a lamb is degrading kelly.. knowing that kelly clarkson herself is a lamb.. and so is her fans..
carshe209 4 weeks ago
no she does better
calipsoflo 1 month ago
Why do you continue to embarrass all Kelly fans like this? Kelly is an amazing singer but Mariah is in a completely different league.
lawlinat0r 1 month ago
This shit is awful!!! It doesn't even do Kelly justice cause she's a good singer and it's like you put all her bad sounding performances together.. the audio is horrible. Kelly is a great singer but Mariah in her prime and even now will always be a better vocalist than Kelly!!!! Awful video total dislike!!!
kevgonzal85 1 month ago
can kelly still do this? I watched a performances of hers 2011, long shot, and her voice was extremally weak, she wasn't singing it the way it's supposed to be sang, mariah uses lip syinch to preserve her voice, and everytime she is really singing live she is awesome
lucaschermontsantos 1 month ago
@lucaschermontsantos Lol, yes... her voice has been better in the past few years then it ever has been.
lawlinat0r 1 month ago
wtf is this kelly is good but MARIAH CAREY IS THE BEST #1 BEST FEMALE SELLING ARTIST, OCTAVE VOCAL RANGE
itspophoe 1 month ago
Well , sorry to break it to you , but 144 people think otherwise , DUMB ASS .
Nobody can touch the REAL QUEEN of music ! Mariah SLAYS everyone .
I love Kelly , but she doesn't come close. . . sorry dahling
trybeeMUSIC 1 month ago
Come on!! Don´t compare this to Mariah,please!! Don´t do that to yourself!
felo4444 1 month ago
Again? what a f...
viny2511 1 month ago
@viny2511 what the name ?the right name :(
LiinouTec 1 month ago
MARIAH IS THE BEST VOICE OF ALL TIME. I'M SO SORRY
viny2511 1 month ago
again? haha
uprainbow 1 month ago
mariah can hold high notes for much more time than her
lucaschermontsantos 1 month ago
np puedes COmparar es imposible comparar a mimi! I love U mariah desde Peru!!
aleshitop16 1 month ago
This is so funny she's just another xtina!!! Mariah at least sounds good when belting and also looks hot doing it... Kelly looks like a cow and answering your vid NO Mariah cannot do that because Mariah sings not squeals like a pig
luisboricua9 1 month ago
merda
jeffinhodiscarado 1 month ago
Mariah DOESN'T scream.
ChariceBillboard 1 month ago
a lot of singer can do this.. so pls dun compare this to mariah..
qiqi5277 1 month ago
pig squeeling? why..... ?
shakeitoff22 1 month ago
Is this video for real..? The answer is, Mariah can do that, and so much more, not to mention make it sound a lot better in the process. lol
BlindWatchMakers 1 month ago 6
No she can't. She can't sing bad like that!
lambicous 1 month ago 2
LISTEN. These girls are both great. But look at Kelly, shes at least 10yrs younger! Look at mariah 10yrs ago. Impressive too! they both are great!
samofficial1 1 month ago
Mariah CAN do this, even more than this.
Kelly wouldn't have existed without Mariah.
See you in 20 years mate, Kelly will be forgotten while everybody will remember Mariah.
PecheMelba113 1 month ago 30
what? are u serious w/ that question...mariah is incomparable...!
rubriklitanea 1 month ago 2
YES SHE CAN YOU ARE STUPID
MinhPhuongoctopus 1 month ago 2
How to compare an alto to a soprano...
TagPop 1 month ago
Mariah is much better, this girl always is screaming -.-
JesusDonaldoOFICIAL 1 month ago 2
@JesusDonaldoOFICIAL - Shes done pretty well out of 'screaming'... how many world tours has she sold out? How many albums has she released and how many fans does she have?
adamc260 1 month ago
I PREFER KELLY ALL THE WAY!!!
willKCFAN 1 month ago
I mean Kelly can sing great and all but don't compare this to Mariah Carey for frying out loud, you make Kelly look bad.
angelit161 1 month ago
Haha omg Kelly is good but she isn't in Mariah's league!
999xander999 1 month ago
What? Scream like a sick cat? I don't think so..
lase2312 2 months ago
Why you comparing Mariah and Kelly ? Both are great but also they are different.
MrKadirbey 2 months ago
*Face palm* Mariahs farts sound better than this shit.
cat3542fc 2 months ago 27
@cat3542fc haha
minyawakoypusa 1 month ago
@cat3542fc jajajajajaj thats true!!
kirkian 1 month ago
i think mariah fans attack kelly because they are afraid, because kelly is more popular on todays music, i think she one of the best things that breakout las decade!!!
willKCFAN 2 months ago
I THINK KELLY IS WAY BETTER, LOVE HER, HATES CAN HATE, BUT SHE WILL STAY HERE!!!
willKCFAN 2 months ago
I am glad that Mariah cant to this because for me this is not singing is Kelly screaming her head off so she can hit the higher notes that she wouldn't normally achieve. This is awful, poor quality and rubbish.If you can't hear that I am sorry but you are hearing impaired.
thecamil10 2 months ago
yes mariah can do that,and on key
MrLiamantonyhoughton 2 months ago
Please Don't Compare an Artist with 20 years of career Like Mariah Carey with an Amateur Singer like Kelly she is Good But Mariah use to sing too hihg and she still Can Belt High Notes Easier for example "Subtle Invitation" She hit G5 Tho times and F#5 like 3 times She has Showed that she is a Great Singer So please don't be ridiculous!!
ivennein 2 months ago
i love that mariah is the barometer for evert single stanwar. u all myst know she was and still is the shit at the core
shaunmike 2 months ago
Funny how all the comments agree: Mariah CAN do better and she did it before Kelly.
radiorecord1 2 months ago
dont compare kelly to mariah ....
keneth3493 2 months ago
of course mariah can do that and much better!
guilleramosdamas 2 months ago
CAN MARIAH DO THIS? SHE DID DO THIS BEFIRE KELLY TIME AND TIME AGAIN!
icantdothisbymyself 2 months ago
all this SCREAMIN
jak30341 2 months ago
Mariah in her day when she was the age of Kelly here, PULLLLEASE, Mariah would have blown Kelly to smithereens, and Kelly would be the first to admit it, SERIOUSLY, you need to listen to Mariah's first two CD's from the early 90's then GET BACK
jak30341 2 months ago
Mariah can~ a little respect please~ lol
kyo1223 2 months ago
If I hear her say again, again I promise!!
dattboi19 2 months ago
Mariah Can do WAYYYYY BETERR!!!! Shes BELTED Way Higher notes Than This... OBVIOUSLY shes tryna IMMITATE MARIAH
jameld55 2 months ago
No, she can do much better.
MariahIsTheQueen 2 months ago
this is funny :))
vcassfamily 2 months ago
@Blanersucks Please. I really like Kelly but stacking her up against Mariah is pure foolishness.
Can't nobody touch Mariah...
BlackLightning20101 2 months ago
Mariah is one hell of a singer, but she sings with no emotion.
vatonolan 2 months ago
@vatonolan That's simply not true...you need to take a better look at Mariah's discography...
BlackLightning20101 2 months ago
I really hope this was a joke.
xxPowderSnowxx 2 months ago
Really? Clearly Mariah is better than her and more successful.
piscesgirl98 2 months ago
Comparing anyone to Mariah is a FAIL.
myNSproductions 2 months ago 45
@myNSproductions Lolz thank you.
iLolz19 2 months ago
Q merda'
jeaancarlloslf 2 months ago
Are you seriously comparing a girl who won american idol with one of the best selling artist of all time? please.
FrostMan92 2 months ago 3
Kelly Clarkson isnt only an american idol winner, shes the best singer of them also. Although I think this video is pretty dumb, the truth is Mariah can't hit that note (G5) better than Kelly. Infact, no one can hit that note as well as Kelly Clarkson can. As far as who the better singer is, Mariah, in her prime of course, but don't let the idea of her being an Idol winner blind you of how phenominal a singer she is, 'cause theres a reason she won AI. She's one hell of a singer, don't forget it.
lightningshock12 2 months ago
Come On Mariah Carey Will Slay Her!! Kelly is a great singer, come one Mariah is a legend!!
dontayemc3 2 months ago
obviously mariah cant do this hahaha because she can do better.. hehehe
amythest1982 2 months ago 2
In fact she can do and much better ;)
Myoneandonly2011 2 months ago
No, Mimi can do better. :)
aliyaahbaby 2 months ago
wow you're so stupid haa
louismendee 3 months ago
comeon kelly is good i think
but why r u putting her into such a question
mc's kinda legend. with no doubt
and the new comers need not defeat mc to be the one who stands out
so please dont upload this kinda video
u r just doing nth but making ppl hate kelly
murejigent 3 months ago
@murejigent they used kelly.. kelly fans admire maria.. and the one who make this video is christina fans.. :)
carshe209 3 months ago
who cant scream,LOL
lathanregintree 3 months ago
This is shouting.. Nariah is singing.. if shouting is the deal Mariah can shout and roar at kelly out of the water..
iLLusion625 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
G5 of Mariah is beautiful! It's not like screaming! but to make a loud melodic! Mariah is better!
HackerOscarBytes 3 months ago 2
Comment removed
HackerOscarBytes 3 months ago
look Kelly is a great singer and I get that you like her and everything but you just can't compare her to Mariah. Yes, Mariah can do everything in the video. that's the truth. listen to anytime you need a friend by mariah and listen to her hit 3 G5's
mariahphilmrazem 3 months ago
Mariah can do Much much better than Her!!
can Kelly do Mariah Carey songs??? Duuuuhhh!! no! she cant bet Mariah! why comparing Kelly to a legend?? well i Love Kelly,but this Video is Insane!!
GhenMariahyonce1995 3 months ago
I wish her voice lasts for 10 years.
IzumoD 3 months ago
yeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeees she can do it so mcuh better and i love kelly!
adany83 3 months ago
What Song Is The One Where She Sings Again And Again And Again And AGGAAINNNNN ? :) <3
buffboipete 3 months ago
No, she can't, she just can do it a million times BETTER!
MrMarkithuz 3 months ago
mariah is a hundred times better! has 5 octaves, Kelly is not even 4! her whistle notes are just squeaking!
rihannafam 3 months ago
FAIL
MissJayG 3 months ago
No..Mariah doesn't scream! LOL! :D
iamblueneptune 3 months ago 29
Yeah she can but im glad kelly covered fantasia omg... I cannot stand her voice
shaunmike 3 months ago
they have different styles. pls dont compare they are both great. kelly can't outdo mariah's song Forever.. and mariah cant do that rock thing going on with Kelly. dont compare oranges and apples lol.
ami7mina 3 months ago
@ami7mina Listen to Mariah's You Need Me if you think she doesn't have a rock voice. watch?v=skLD3M5n7FU
razzp 3 months ago
@razzp OK im convinced! :D
ami7mina 3 months ago
u r jus no point showing this
SamyYap 3 months ago
can kelly loose weight?, can kelly get 18 number ones?, can kelly be worth 500 million, can kelly wear a bikini, can kelly write her own songs?....comparing kelly to mariah is like comparing a cubic zirconia to a diamond...
TheXwatts 3 months ago 3
@TheXwatts EXACTLY,LOL
lathanregintree 3 months ago
@TheXwatts You're being ridiculous. Everyone has the ability to lose weight and Kelly DOES write her own material and with all the other things you said,only time can tell whether Kelly can accomplish them. In a year of so, for all we know Kelly may be one of the biggest international stars like she was in 2005-2006. Stop being disrespectful to Kelly because BOTH Mariah and Kelly are amazing artists. This video was made by an Xtincta stan posing as a Kelly Clarkson stan so you don't need to bash
Snookiiiii 3 months ago
those are unhealthy belt.. it can damage her chords.
vocalphenomenon 3 months ago
@vocalphenomenon no they arent sorry
KellyFan4Lyfe08 3 months ago
ahahahahah xDDD !! LOL Maria's note ARE HIGHER !!!!!! FOR MUCH XD
kozocitow 3 months ago
@kozocitow LOL actually mariah has not belted anything higher then this maybe one G#5 these are all G5s and kelly sustains hers mariah has never sustained a G5 or G#5 kelly has sustained G5 G#5 hit A5s Bb5 B5 and sustained C6 belt
KellyFan4Lyfe08 3 months ago