Added: 3 years ago
From: HSMRocksMedia
Views: 116,379
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (293)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • what have i done....added this to my nightmare before christmas (covers) playlist

  • I love this albulm, the artist had the same intent as Jack, to bring a new fun twist to stuff we like XD Oh irony :3

  • @Fluteplayingbandgeek Probably has something to do with the sort of evil laugh necessary here isn't generally achieved by females. We tend to go more for the screechy cackle, where men, even if they do get cackly, manage something a bit deeper and more throaty.

  • @goldmegaman1000 haha same here

  • Fantastic cover of my fave song from this whole damn film...But I have to admit, the evil laugh is a little pathetic.

  • @MoonGalleon22 haha "a little pathetic" doesn't quite cut it.....more like sadly pitifully wimpy....i can do a better man evil laugh and im a girl. xD but no hate intended.....i ADORE PWT'S!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @Fluteplayingbandgeek what does you being a girl have to do with anything?

  • Halloween playlist I'm adding the nightmare register songs XD well most of them

  • now i want to go trick or treating(: 

  • im in the halloween mood :)

  • @amber1richardson Bah, listen to leif011; fuck off. -___- tribute, and it's good.

  • Comment removed

  • I like it

  • O love how they got Plain White Ts AND All American Rejects on this album <3

  • @zemyx96renhei

    agreed (: I love how they got Korn and Rise Against<3

  • wheres the original one? this is really good but i like the original better.

  • Brilliant.

  • "And I, JACK, the pumpkin king- That's right I AM the pumpkin king!" Is my favorite part <3 :D

  • i actually think this is a pretty good cover of the song! He really made me feel the emotion, however, jack will always be better. but this is great too

  • i wish i was as positive as jack

  • i really wish Panic! at the Disco's version of This is Halloween would be on Nightmare Revised. But still I love that they did this <3 all the songs were still done good. I would have never thought The Plain White T's would have been a good fit at all for the album but they pulled it off!

  • I was a little dissapointed about All American Reject's tribute, but it wasen't all bad. I feel a little better about this one ^^ It's not all good but not bad either! Both bands did better in the Alice in Wonderland CD though <//<

  • You know what, I thought this was actually really, really good. Not to be compared to the original of course, but hell, the lead singer really put a good bit of feeling into singing this song, at least I thought so! I like this cover, but that's just me. <3

  • @PlotMasterX Err, let me correct my self, he put a good bit of feeling into the last half of it. ^.^; (After listening to it over)

  • just because it doesn't match your opinion, doesn't mean it is negative. if people like the original better we're allowed to voice that. this is bad and the singer sounds like the last one i listened to...they are different people. that is NOT a good thing.

    danny elfman sounds like a man, these "men" sounds like little boys. bleh awful and they have no feeling no emotion just reading lines it sounds like.

  • can you send me a copy of this song plz?

  • cool :D

  • That was awesome!!!! :D

  • this is good :)

  • Pretty good... I think... :/ But NOBODY can beat Danny Elfman's voice!!! >:C

  • they did a pretty good i think

  • i sang along. with feeling. and my friend staring.

    but i dont care! LONG LIVE THE PUMPKIN KING!

  • For a second i thought he said "i weted my bed" when he said, "All i ever wanted was to bring them something great" O_O is that normal?

  • @ForkandNumNum lolz XD no...

  • the pumpkin king 4 ever

  • Yay I liked it :D 

  • O-MAZINGG!!

  • AWESOME! xD

  • @OhMyRawrItsMCR ikr :D hahaha XD

  • I think his singing sounds too happy to be jack skelington<3

  • no.. just no..

  • hmm i wonder where the american rejects were when they made this they should hav originally sung this

  • Good song

  • everyone is so negative, do you people forget it's not meant to be a replacement for the original but a tribute?

    you should celebrate you fools.

  • @leif011 Exactly, it's the various artists paying homage to the beautiful, twisted wonderland that is The Nightmare before Christmas~

  • I'm sorry, but Danny Elfman owned this song. This is a pathetic remake of something beautiful. It's like remaking the Mona Lisa with a crayon.

  • God this is just terrible compared to the original.

    Its not bad, but Elfman trounces these poor fools.

  • @TheFreakDownStreet trounces MOST i agree but korn kicked some ass

  • Jack has a boner.

  • @asianwanabe1

    I didnt know that was possible. O.o

  • korn and panick at the disco's songs were the best (:

  • Nightmare Before Christmas = Win.

    no matter whos singing it.

  • eu amei!!!!!

    i love!!!

  • lol the top comments contradict each other so much. xD

  • "Gasp! Sandy Clause!" lol, for some reason it seems rather funny.

  • It sounds like they don't know what they are doing...very odd.

  • I think there is more energy in this revisited version than the original version, although I much prefer the first version ^ ^

  • this is better than other revisited ones....

    but not as good as like amy lee's so...

  • hey woah whats wrong with flyleafs whats this????

  • @1takethislife It just doesn't show the same emotions Jack was feeling, but still a great song!

  • Oh, love it.

  • at some points it sounds like Jack is singing in the background... am I the only one who hears it? or is it SUPPOSED to be that way??

  • @Gothchick657 I think it is supposed to be like that so it sounds like him

  • Well I don't know about you guys, but I like this version and the movie version because I absolutely love jack's voice, such a fine singing voice

  • I prefer this to Sparklehorse's song. They use Sparklehorse's version for torture. I swear.

  • The 20 who disliked this version prefers the shitty ass, ear bleeding, horrible than hell, torture of Sparklehorse's version.....

  • awsome they do sound like jack. O.O

  • nice 

  • they do sound like jack.

  • sounds like Jack O_o luv it! Hey to the fags complaining about this song try watching Nightmare Revisited Jack's Obsession by Sparklehorse THEN complain about a shitty song! till then shut the fxck up.

  • LOL I LIKE IT WEN HE SAYS NEVER! m wen they say WHAT THE HECK AND FOR A MOMENT WHY I EVEN TOUCHED THE SKY

  • wow this song sounds like shit, original is way better, this song shoulda been done by pink floyd, this part always sounded like it could fit into the wall album

  • the 17 people are only dust.

  • my only complaint is at the end he sounds pouty instead of like he's considering the possibilities like in the movie

  • And why the heck I went to did my best! Lol I like that part

  • The 17 people that dislike this have done wrong.

  • super.

  • 3 favs on this cd. hands down #1 is sallys song. #2 is flyleaf and #3 is this one. he just captures the way jack felt at this part in the movie so well. its amazing. i love TNBC. best movie ever directed. no competition.

  • Thumbs up for the Scilent Hill theme in the begining

  • Comment removed

  • It does kinda sound like Jack

  • This is great, fully capturing the mood of Jack :D

    Also I didn't really like Flyleaf's cover, but that's my opinion.

  • @h4y4bu54

    Flyleaf version was awesome. Hands down.

    It does capture the mood of Jack on this one!

  • i like it when he says ''dust..'' :D

  • flyleaf v fall out boy for their versions of what's this? and.. go.

  • nice. this, Sally's song, and flyleaf's version of Whats This are the best on the album.

  • i agree with deathrider217 and CavemanAmadeus ..... but i havent heard/seen the move in a long time and i dont think it sounds like jack...not at all

  • I need this CD and fall out boy needs to be on it.

  • @TeJap2 they are

  • @ThreeDaysGraceCrazy not on itunes they're not... are they? maybe i read wrong. i hope so...

  • @TeJap2 LMAO. xD Fall Out Boy IS on it. xD

  • yeah, I agree with deathrider, the origional had more emotion in it, and it must have been a while since you heard the original if you think that he sounds at all like jack

  • i remember there being more emotion behind it

  • I LOVE IT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • uuugggghhhh i really dont like the plain white tees, the original is one hundred percent better

  • @imnotcrazy15 i agree with you on that the original rocks this one sounds like they sang it while they were drunk

  • wow i was reeeally impressed with this! A totally new side to plain white t's ..how unexpected D:

  • lol i felt like my own boney self again just kidding i'm not like that

  • I diden't think I was going to like this but I reallyyy like this ^_^

  • Mk,everyone,it sounds like Danny but you can tell its Plain White tees because the low pitched parts is wrong and you can hear their teen-like voice.Got the "why does nothing work out like it should" part wrong Danny's was more of a growl,now people,shut the fuck up and listen.

  • i think brazilians versions better

  • not better than rise again. but good ^w^

  • Well, what the heck,

    I went and did my best

    and by God I really tasted something swell!

    That's right!

    and why for a moment, why,

    I even touched the sky! and at least I left some stories they can tell!

    :)

  • "Why does nothing ever turn out like it should?! Well what the heck! I went and did my best! And my god I really tasted something swell! And for a moment why I even touched the sky! And at least I left some stories they can tell! I did! And for the first time since I don't remember when I felt just like my old buddy self again..." I love that.

  • where's the HQ??? hahaha

  • This is... really really good....

    ever since i saw Plain White T's i wanted them to have a duet with P!ATD

  • ...Not bad. Could have put more emotion to it. But maybe it's just not enough background music to it. But nothing can replace Danny Elfman.

  • I love this movie and he sounds close to Jack.

  • Awesome!

  • Great match!

  • what is this

  • wooo one more reason to love plain white t's!!

  • plain white ts are awsome!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! <3

  • I don't know this band's style or anything, but they should have added more to it from 1:27. It gets really dull. And the hahaha was the lamest evil laugh ever...

    But this is my fav song from the movie so nothing but the original will be good enough for me :p

  • I agree, I'm not saying these remakes are bad but... the original versions are BETTER. MUCH BETTER.

  • @RedGhoulProductions what do you expect? it was one of the best movies of the century. i dont think theres any possible way that movie could have been any better, which means any recreation would just dull in comparison. i think they did a decent job though

  • I think the only remakes that I liked was Amy Lee's version or Sally's Song, and Tiger Army's version of Oogie Boogie's Song

  • @RedGhoulProductions agreed the old ones where brilliant but these new ones are really good and i love both (exscluding the new whats this?)

  • @RedGhoulProductions i claim thats your opinion. they are good but people may think that these are better

  • @RedGhoulProductions The originals are ALWAYS better. :)

  • @RedGhoulProductions well the original were created with the towns people, jack and sallys emotions =] thats why i hate the marlyn manson version of this is halloween, he takes away all the emotion in the towns people =]

  • @RedGhoulProductions Dude im sorry some of the remakes are just to amazing, however comparing these are not what we are really suppose to do.

  • @RedGhoulProductions I think the Marilyn Manson, Korn, Yoshida Brothers, and Rodrigo Y Gabriela did amazing.. but the rest was mediocre.

  • @commentableuser Amy wasn't bad > . >

  • @commentableuser Or mediocre, rather.

  • the "but i never intendet all this madness, never" part almost sounds almost as if he has fun Oo

  • @z3r0u lol he sounds hilarious at that part...

  • Good job, but his voice isn't deep enough, their style isn't dark enough.

  • again, I said this in another vid, it's their style. their not suposed to change. just redo the song, but, your right, it's kind of.. strange.. love the band, but... yup....

  • where can i find MP3's to all these songs?

  • um. iTunes? LOL

  • @JoshKegley ...free?

  • My mom knows the singer of the Plain White T's. She does! I showed this to her and she said "You know, I knew the singer of this band" I looked at her and said "YOU DO?!" She said "Yeah. He helped me take care of you when your were a baby" I thought "COOL!"

  • @IJFan123 my mom's friend babysat Joel and Benji Madden when they were little. Lol

  • yeah right

  • @IJFan123 Her name isn't Delilah, is it? haha

  • This song is amazing as well! :D

  • WOW This is my absolute favorite song I sing it all the time Ive done it for solos and I really gotta give it to Plain White Tee's they did a really good job at it. Of course nobody could ever beat Mr. Danny Elfman. But they did a really good job!

  • The originals are so awesome!!! It must have been super hard trying to come up with a remake that has a twist AND sounds good!!!! People need to stop hatin!

  • I think all the songs are amazing but nothing is better then originals out of all korn did the best job :)

  • Comment removed

  • You're crazy ... Marlyn Manson, Korn, Amy Lee, Shiny Toy Guns, and Rise Against's covers were all great

  • sucks, needede to be morre brutal

  • Wow, that was really awesome XD Great cover!

  • i hate hannah shittanah

  • Plain White T's keep surprising me... I hate most of their songs but I love 'Figure It Out', they do a nice job of being in 'Greek' and this is a really respectable cover. Good on them =)

  • Nice job plain whites T's :D

  • I think it's awesome how well the Plain White Tee's pulled this off.

  • It's pretty good. I like the original better, though. There really should've been a build up when Jack's mood improves and he starts ranting, like in the original. Without that increase in the power of the melody to accompany that of the lyrics, it just falls flat.

  • I love it!!! :D

    so much emotion put into it! :DDD

    EEEEEEEEEEEEEP!

  • it aint half bad...better than sparklehorse...

  • what ISN'T better than sparklehorse? honestly?

  • hannah sluttanna

  • touche

  • : D

  • but yeah that sparkle thingie was creepy *shudders*

  • @demonicchild13 justin beiber and owl city they suck as well

  • @demonicchild13 everything 

  • mmm... I don't know. I thought they were all supposed to bring something new to the songs... I think he's trying too hard here to sound like Jack. He should have just made it sound original. Still it is good, but definitly should try to bring more originality to it.

  • I agree. It needs a balance of sounding recognizable to the original, so it brings that feeling of recognition/nostalgia to the listener, while still bringing something original and new to the song, to make it worth listening to over the original in the first place.

    I think if they had just added a little more to the music, and left the vocals, it would have been better.

  • He even got that slight tremor when he says "moment" there, really well done.

  • damn this doesn't even sound like them! sounds just like jack!!!!

  • Nice

  • wow, was that even the plain white tees singing? it sounded a LOT like Jack..

  • I agree!!

  • @EmoTheElephant ikr it doesent even sound like them

  • @EmoTheElephant i agree man heck when i first watched this i didnt c the plain white T's part of the title so i seriously thought it was jack

  • @EmoTheElephant

    Do you not know Danny Elfman's voice at all?!

  • @Destinatious

    Well, in EmoTheElepnant's defense, it does sound somewhat Danny's voice. Not exactly, but you can still hear some of the similarites.

  • @EmoTheElephant ditto

  • @EmoTheElephant Hell no it doesn't.

  • Halfway through the song it gets real better!

  • this sounds alot more diffrent than the original