I'm a life-long White Sox fan, and I feel obligated to mention Dwayne Wise's catch in the top of the 9th inning that preserved a perfect game for Mark Buehrle while potentially saving a home run, but I even I think that Endy Chavez's NLCS game 7 play from 2006 beats them all. He had to range to his left, make a snow cone catch over the wall that saved a 2R homer, and then he doubled up Edmonds.
i am sorry...willie was a great player but this catch is just over rated. i have been watching jim edmunds do this once a month for like 15 straight years. I may be prejudice but i think endy chavez's catch in game 7 of the 2006 nlcs was better than this and my have been the best ive ever seen. i honestly think jim edmunds might have 10 or 15 catches on his own better than this one...sorry willie
Unfortunately, what is missing in this video is the effort to get to the ball. Mays was playing somewhat in and this park is freaking huge. It's amazing that he got within 10 feet of the ball before it landed.
Neither did Mays. "580 feet"? Good lord, how much weed have you been smoking. You need to subtract about a hundred feet off that before you even begin to be accurate. This is the most overrated catch ever.
I was in the park for the one you're talking about: off Bobby Tolan of the Reds, right? Mays crashed into the fence and rightfielder Bonds simultaneously, was knocked out, and still held on to the ball. Sheer beauty.
he catches its at like 480 feet deep in straight center over the head (and if u c his glove in the HOF, u can see that its only like an 11 inch glove a most, compared to like 14 inch the players have now) and then he ends up doubling the guy off, f*cking amazing
willie mays is one of the greatest ball players in history, u cant possibly disagree
good catch. not great. i wudnt even have that in my top 20 plays of all time. That catch by endy chavez in the nlcs in 2006 ws serious sht. it was 2 feet over the wall and he stillaught it!!!!!!
yea, uhhh, overrated catch, jim edmonds makes catches equal or better to this at least once a season. "But he threw it back into the infield!! thats insane!!!!"
What else was he gonna do with it, stick it up his ass?
Anyone who has played or knows baseball well also knows that this catch is overrated and does not belong in the top 5 or 10 plays in a highlight reel where it is usually found.
while ill give u that edmonds catch might have been better consider this.....
the situation he was in.... the world series
also the park was 500 to straight away center and that ball was only 30 feet(give or take 10 feet) away from the fence and he had to run a good 100 feet to reach it
also, the time was an important factor. that catch was the firs of its kind, as was the tallent of mays
actually willie admitted this was not his best catch. his best catch was a robbed home run in which he collided with another player and both were knocked unconscious - and he held on to the ball. still an amazing catch, no doubt.
@toolagit5 One thing you don't see is how shallow he was playing. Thats what truly made the catch remarkable .
I saw Willie play at the stick for the first time in 64 he played so shallow he was a threat to throw a guy out at first on a grounder up the middle. The only player I ever saw until this day play that shallow was Paul Blair. Both had an amazing ability to know where the ball was going as soon as it left the bat. He was the one to say the catch was ok the throw kept runners from moving
Most overrated catch in sports history.
uricehe4 1 year ago
I'm a life-long White Sox fan, and I feel obligated to mention Dwayne Wise's catch in the top of the 9th inning that preserved a perfect game for Mark Buehrle while potentially saving a home run, but I even I think that Endy Chavez's NLCS game 7 play from 2006 beats them all. He had to range to his left, make a snow cone catch over the wall that saved a 2R homer, and then he doubled up Edmonds.
dataslul 1 year ago
i am sorry...willie was a great player but this catch is just over rated. i have been watching jim edmunds do this once a month for like 15 straight years. I may be prejudice but i think endy chavez's catch in game 7 of the 2006 nlcs was better than this and my have been the best ive ever seen. i honestly think jim edmunds might have 10 or 15 catches on his own better than this one...sorry willie
jets495 1 year ago
David Wright's barehanded, the best one ever!
elmontro16 2 years ago
You jealous ignorant people and I expect most of you are racist are so full of hatred you make me sick to my stomach!!!!
NiagaraFalls4424 2 years ago
willie mays is my great uncle he lives in california :)
puyaboy2712 2 years ago
@puyaboy2712 I know this is kinda old, but my great uncle pitched that ball. ;)
thevshi 9 months ago
Unfortunately, what is missing in this video is the effort to get to the ball. Mays was playing somewhat in and this park is freaking huge. It's amazing that he got within 10 feet of the ball before it landed.
zappa2496 2 years ago
jim edmonds catch was better
idunnobella 2 years ago
It wasn't in the World Series. This was...makes all the difference.
Spartan9299 2 years ago
Wertz's ball was hit much further - Mays had a longer run to make the catch
willt65 2 years ago 3
And about 30-40 feet more shallow.
crixxxxxxxxx 2 years ago
Jim Edmonds did not have to get up and throw the ball from 580 ft away from the plate. this also was in the world series.
JohnnyMac496 2 years ago
so now its 580 feet? wow
idunnobella 2 years ago
@JohnnyMac496
Neither did Mays. "580 feet"? Good lord, how much weed have you been smoking. You need to subtract about a hundred feet off that before you even begin to be accurate. This is the most overrated catch ever.
uricehe4 1 year ago
mays wouldn't have had to dive for the ball that edmonds caught.
JohnnyMac496 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
It was LUCKY!
bracaa01 3 years ago
Actually, that's not even his best catch. He did one better when he flew into the fence at Candlestick Park to rob a guy of a home run.
bondurango 3 years ago
I was in the park for the one you're talking about: off Bobby Tolan of the Reds, right? Mays crashed into the fence and rightfielder Bonds simultaneously, was knocked out, and still held on to the ball. Sheer beauty.
dharmabums320 3 years ago
That's the one. Willie Mays making like an Air Jordan spread eagle slam dunk before Jordan.
bondurango 3 years ago
in my opinion, thats #1 right there
he catches its at like 480 feet deep in straight center over the head (and if u c his glove in the HOF, u can see that its only like an 11 inch glove a most, compared to like 14 inch the players have now) and then he ends up doubling the guy off, f*cking amazing
willie mays is one of the greatest ball players in history, u cant possibly disagree
if u do then Fuck You, u dont kno baseball
EDoug35 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
what a good catch
even though some of ichiro's stuff is wayy better
Froboy12345678 3 years ago
good catch. not great. i wudnt even have that in my top 20 plays of all time. That catch by endy chavez in the nlcs in 2006 ws serious sht. it was 2 feet over the wall and he stillaught it!!!!!!
dawndeath117 3 years ago
How is it #5...
jmarino200 3 years ago
one of the most famous catches EVER
yet it really isnt anything amazing
there is like 10 a yeal in mlb and some of them r alot better
tbradyne 3 years ago
I have always wondered why this catch is so popular, I see a play like this a couple times a year on TV and even in my local softball leagues.
LukeL007 3 years ago
how come they never show the greatest part of that play, when he doulbles off the guy? He did that from dead center almost
fredrico0012 3 years ago
yea, uhhh, overrated catch, jim edmonds makes catches equal or better to this at least once a season. "But he threw it back into the infield!! thats insane!!!!"
What else was he gonna do with it, stick it up his ass?
Anyone who has played or knows baseball well also knows that this catch is overrated and does not belong in the top 5 or 10 plays in a highlight reel where it is usually found.
toolagit5 3 years ago
while ill give u that edmonds catch might have been better consider this.....
the situation he was in.... the world series
also the park was 500 to straight away center and that ball was only 30 feet(give or take 10 feet) away from the fence and he had to run a good 100 feet to reach it
also, the time was an important factor. that catch was the firs of its kind, as was the tallent of mays
redsox4home 3 years ago
actually willie admitted this was not his best catch. his best catch was a robbed home run in which he collided with another player and both were knocked unconscious - and he held on to the ball. still an amazing catch, no doubt.
losingallmyfriends 3 years ago
@toolagit5 totally agreed thank god someone unerstands
heightssurfer 1 year ago
@toolagit5 One thing you don't see is how shallow he was playing. Thats what truly made the catch remarkable .
I saw Willie play at the stick for the first time in 64 he played so shallow he was a threat to throw a guy out at first on a grounder up the middle. The only player I ever saw until this day play that shallow was Paul Blair. Both had an amazing ability to know where the ball was going as soon as it left the bat. He was the one to say the catch was ok the throw kept runners from moving
tellthetruthg 3 months ago
not that great of a catch
irishkid27 3 years ago
kellen tht makes no sense
Tripod181 3 years ago
lckscjax jjasnfjsancsa amfmsa
kelleno 3 years ago