@axel4clover1 Of course that Layne sings this song way better, his vocals are perfect for man in the box. But that doesn't mean that David is less of a great vocalist, his vocals aren't just made for this song, his vocals belong to a different style of music. Layne would probably not sing Disturbed's songs as well as David. You can't compare them, they're both great in their domain. None of them is better then the other.
@Krow83 I don't think Layne is overrated, He has some of the most amazing and original vocals ever. And I know that David can sing better, I've seen him live and it was amazing. I think that it's David that is underrated.
I love Disturbed. I am 14. I love Led Zeppelin and Alice In Chains as well as much as Disturbed. I think that you are an idiot comparing thoses 3 bands, they have completely different music styles. Why can't you just admit that both Layne Staley and David Draiman are both great singers ? And you first discovered Led Zeppelin at the age of 16 ? That is sad dude.....
@CesarDyrbergTv now listen to man in the box live with layne staley, in seattle 1990 it just shows how much less of a great vocalist david is, but robert plants a fucking beast
You are wrong about Layne Staley being overrated. I love David Draiman's vocals, he is amazing there is no doubt about that. Disturbed is one of my favorite band. But I do admit, this song is not meant to be singed by Draiman, especialy after his surgery. Why can't you just admit that both Layne Staley and David Draiman are both really good singers ? You can't compare them, the music style they play are so different.
@Krow83 Overrated? Are you serious? You think that Layne Staley is overrated? Did you forget that Kurt Cobain suffered heroin addiction and then offed himself and became a "legend" Layne Staley was by far the most talented singer of the 90's and when he died he got swept right under the carpet. They didn't even listen him in the celebrities that died at the grammies of that year. And you're calling him overrated? You sir, are sadly mistaken.
Love David... Not the best rendition of Man In the Box though. Definitely should have waited a little while longer after that surgery before doing this.
Get off David. He's just out of surgery on this video, and this isn't about being awesome. This is a tribute to Layne Staley; one of the greatest metal/grunge vocalists of all time. If either of them heard this shit going down here they'd personally kick your asses.
yeah its a shame whats happened to David's voice over the years, but still not as big a shame as what has happened to James Hetfield's. both great vocalists... not so much anymore :/
@MrScottCarr no dude. like ok James' is a much more serious case. James i feel no longer has a singing career really. David can still sing quite well, but dude on The Sickness his voice was pure fucking power, rage, and psychoticness all mixed into one demon. he is not nearly as good as he was. no....
Dudes, the video is not about who is better, it's about honoring a colleague singer and this shit comments about who's better would probably make Layne and David feel ashamed. And David would be pissed off.
Draiman is a beast i saw them in March with Korn i got in a fight when i was in the moshpit...good times good times.anyways to say Draiman is better than Layne what the fuck. This just proves it he doesnt have the range Layne had.I dont means just hitting certain notes but singing different types of vocal styles. Layne could sing 80's high vocal style all the way to acoustic.Hes one of the greatest ever. If he just had surgery he shouldnt be singing at all. Both own but come on.
They say that the originals are allways better than the originals but they can suck me because with David's voice any cover sounds better than the original hands down.
@Ditak NO, THAT IS TOTAL BULLSHIT, LISTEN TO THE ORIGINAL, YOU DO NOT UNDERSTAND THE VOICE THAT IS LAYNE FUCKING STALEY...JUST DONT EVEN FUCKING THINK FOR A MINUTE THIS GUY CAN SING BETTER
@AwesomeSauceLimited Dude i like ALice in chains and stuff but the voice of David Draiman just kills Layne Staley hands down, but hey its just my opinion. :D
I have always been a huge Disturbed and Alice In Chains fan. Yes, Both David and Layne are great singers, but to say that David is as good or even better than Layne is UTTER BULLSHIT.
Hell no. Layne's overrated as hell. Dave has way more fucking range. Between the pot, countless surgeries, 3 broken noses, acid reflux and much more, Dave is still an excellent singer. What does that tell you?
@Krow83 THIS GUY. Layne Staley overrated WTF! is wrong with you. You like Disturbed so im guessing your like 14. I liked them whe i was 16 also then my music knowledge grew and I Discovered AIC, Zeppelin. in other words i discovered greatness. and realized WTF was i listening too. Soon it will hit you to. Theres gonna be a day were you go "now i know what people are talking about" I saw disturbed in march. Draimans voice cracked like 3 timesHes good but Layne is Greatness. Plant, Staley> draiman
Lol, dude. I'm 18 and I play bass, regular guitar. I've also played baritone, violin, trumpet and clarinet and have experimented slightly on the piano.
And if you discovered Led Zeppelin when you were 16.... Wow, I think we're done here.
18 buddy; that's why I can spell correctly, use proper grammar and know what capitals are.
And hell no. Alice in Chains is practically KNOWN for Layne Staley. That doesn't make him a bad singer, in fact I actually like him; as AiC and STP tend to be the only grunge bands that I like.
However, saying he's a better singer than Dave is just blasphemous. Check out Warhammer's vid of 10,000 Fists live at Uproar.
Anyone who says this is horrible should go suck one. Obviously this is not davids type of vocals but he pulled them off a lot better than anyone else could. Hardly any remakes are better than the originals. Rock on David!!!!!!!!! WE ARE DISTURBED!!!
It's a cover, and you have people playing that aren't in the band Disturbed. Soooooo of course it isn't Disturbed. It's not supposed to be. I think we should have all known what to expect. No??
O_o
But anyway... honestly, I like Disturbed, but I love Alice in Chains. And I'm not moved by this at all. Dave Navarro is beast though, I must say.
Yeah, this wasnt too good. I mean the parts that he let his voice flow deeply was good, but whe he tried to throw his voice in overdrive he should have just made his voice deeper in some way. David is still the man. I am a die hard disturbed fan, dont get me wrong.
you say lady gaga - i say bullet for my valentine
you say emenem - i say system of down
you say hannah montana - i scream heavy metal
92% of teenagers have turned to hip-hop and pop, if ur part of the 8%, copy this message and past it to an other video. DONT LET THE SPIRIT OF ROCK DIE!!!!
Broken glass man. Whenever i here anything about dave all i can think about is when there was a tour that wanted godsmack and disturbed together and dave wanted godsmack to open for them. HELLO! Godsmack=Platinum Disturbed=Gold at the time. EGOS!!!!!! Not to mention Sully rips Dave apart vocally on this song. He sounds like a diing pig.
good god... david shouldve rested his voice after the surgery lol this was awful lol. but dont get me wrong. he sings goldy now but he shouldve waited to sing something as awsum as man in the box that soon after his surgery. no offence all my fellow Disturbed brothers
It sounds weird because their playing it to the pitch the Alice in Chains guy would sing to, David was just trying to match the pitch, but the low notes of the song he nailed perfectly.
when the solo kicked in i thought "nice job!"
then Jerry appeared on the screen and i thought "oh, so that's the reason"
Mor4is 3 days ago
@axel4clover1 Of course that Layne sings this song way better, his vocals are perfect for man in the box. But that doesn't mean that David is less of a great vocalist, his vocals aren't just made for this song, his vocals belong to a different style of music. Layne would probably not sing Disturbed's songs as well as David. You can't compare them, they're both great in their domain. None of them is better then the other.
CesarDyrbergTv 2 weeks ago
@Krow83 I don't think Layne is overrated, He has some of the most amazing and original vocals ever. And I know that David can sing better, I've seen him live and it was amazing. I think that it's David that is underrated.
CesarDyrbergTv 2 weeks ago
when he start to sing first chorus I thought someone stomp on his eggs))))))) he is far not AIC great coverman)))
NEWMESSIAH2000 4 weeks ago
@notavailableisnotava
I love Disturbed. I am 14. I love Led Zeppelin and Alice In Chains as well as much as Disturbed. I think that you are an idiot comparing thoses 3 bands, they have completely different music styles. Why can't you just admit that both Layne Staley and David Draiman are both great singers ? And you first discovered Led Zeppelin at the age of 16 ? That is sad dude.....
CesarDyrbergTv 1 month ago
@CesarDyrbergTv now listen to man in the box live with layne staley, in seattle 1990 it just shows how much less of a great vocalist david is, but robert plants a fucking beast
axel4clover1 2 weeks ago
@Krow83
You are wrong about Layne Staley being overrated. I love David Draiman's vocals, he is amazing there is no doubt about that. Disturbed is one of my favorite band. But I do admit, this song is not meant to be singed by Draiman, especialy after his surgery. Why can't you just admit that both Layne Staley and David Draiman are both really good singers ? You can't compare them, the music style they play are so different.
CesarDyrbergTv 1 month ago
@CesarDyrbergTv
I didn't say Layne's a bad singer. I said he's overrated; there's a different.
If you notice in the vid, that's not all Dave's fault. The sound crew is a bit off for whatever reason.
Krow83 4 weeks ago
@Krow83 Overrated? Are you serious? You think that Layne Staley is overrated? Did you forget that Kurt Cobain suffered heroin addiction and then offed himself and became a "legend" Layne Staley was by far the most talented singer of the 90's and when he died he got swept right under the carpet. They didn't even listen him in the celebrities that died at the grammies of that year. And you're calling him overrated? You sir, are sadly mistaken.
AzhiaziamL 3 weeks ago
@AzhiaziamL
Yes, as far as grunge singers go, I'd say he's overrated. Then again, I don't listen to much grunge.
I just prefer Scott Weiland over all grunge.
Krow83 3 weeks ago
@Krow83 *list
AzhiaziamL 3 weeks ago
Love David... Not the best rendition of Man In the Box though. Definitely should have waited a little while longer after that surgery before doing this.
FroggieGirl92 1 month ago
Surgery's one issue; the other issue is the sound crew. The mic sounds way too flat. Some of that's the voice, but not all of it.
Krow83 1 month ago
david :/ my idol... dude.... your awsome but this song wasnt ment for you :/ srry
ianbg72 1 month ago
Get off David. He's just out of surgery on this video, and this isn't about being awesome. This is a tribute to Layne Staley; one of the greatest metal/grunge vocalists of all time. If either of them heard this shit going down here they'd personally kick your asses.
Linuxgeek3124 2 months ago
Horrible.
MatiBorkBorek 3 months ago
I like David, but this is awful.
pip1764 3 months ago
yeah its a shame whats happened to David's voice over the years, but still not as big a shame as what has happened to James Hetfield's. both great vocalists... not so much anymore :/
redgibson1 4 months ago
@redgibson1 this was 3 years ago, his voice has recovered from surgery, listen to asylum, hes still got it!
MrScottCarr 3 months ago
@MrScottCarr no dude. like ok James' is a much more serious case. James i feel no longer has a singing career really. David can still sing quite well, but dude on The Sickness his voice was pure fucking power, rage, and psychoticness all mixed into one demon. he is not nearly as good as he was. no....
redgibson1 3 months ago
@redgibson1 i agree, but the band also said that they wanted more emotion in thier music, instead of anger like the sickness
MrScottCarr 3 months ago
Dudes, the video is not about who is better, it's about honoring a colleague singer and this shit comments about who's better would probably make Layne and David feel ashamed. And David would be pissed off.
niamdevil 4 months ago
wow sounds like scott stapp. just complete shit.
maurin 4 months ago
dude, relax...I love Disturbed but you can't say that his voice doesn't suck here
rockstarr469 4 months ago
Wow. The vocals suck
rockstarr469 4 months ago
@rockstarr469 LOL fuck off cunt, you couldnt do what David is doing even if it took you 100 lifetimes
PureHayabusa 4 months ago 2
Layne Kills This Guy!!!!!
ThEmB0nEz 4 months ago
is david in 2 bands?
funeralfighter97 4 months ago
david does it better just saying
Sl3yer1o7 6 months ago
why do people think anyone gives a shit about what they think?
MEPHISTOPHELESw 6 months ago
man in the box covered by disturbed? ORGASM
CSDGames 6 months ago 2
Not Good. Couldn't Even Watch the Whole Video.Miss Layne.
ThEmB0nEz 6 months ago
@ThEmB0nEz your retarded david is beast
PS360DDW2009 5 months ago
Draiman is a beast i saw them in March with Korn i got in a fight when i was in the moshpit...good times good times.anyways to say Draiman is better than Layne what the fuck. This just proves it he doesnt have the range Layne had.I dont means just hitting certain notes but singing different types of vocal styles. Layne could sing 80's high vocal style all the way to acoustic.Hes one of the greatest ever. If he just had surgery he shouldnt be singing at all. Both own but come on.
notavailableisnotava 6 months ago
Both Layne And David are amazung vocalists, byt david is not fit for a song like this -.-
pivotgod1111 7 months ago 3
Hell yeah Ditak, that show was badass.
alexandria4915 8 months ago
They say that the originals are allways better than the originals but they can suck me because with David's voice any cover sounds better than the original hands down.
Ditak 8 months ago
@Ditak NO, THAT IS TOTAL BULLSHIT, LISTEN TO THE ORIGINAL, YOU DO NOT UNDERSTAND THE VOICE THAT IS LAYNE FUCKING STALEY...JUST DONT EVEN FUCKING THINK FOR A MINUTE THIS GUY CAN SING BETTER
AwesomeSauceLimited 8 months ago
@AwesomeSauceLimited Dude i like ALice in chains and stuff but the voice of David Draiman just kills Layne Staley hands down, but hey its just my opinion. :D
Ditak 8 months ago
@Ditak i cant believe you! xD listen to Love Hate Love live and...well... if you can show me david top that then... well i'll jizz! lol
AwesomeSauceLimited 8 months ago
@AwesomeSauceLimited @Ditak Amazing indeed. :D
But check this out. Disturbed - Ten thousand fist live at rock am ring. :D
Ditak 8 months ago
@AwesomeSauceLimited
he can sing better just not here cuz he had surgery dumbass chill out
666DISTURBIFIEDable 8 months ago
@666DISTURBIFIEDable meh...compared to layne hes average, even when he's at his peak
AwesomeSauceLimited 8 months ago
@AwesomeSauceLimited layne is a great singer but to say david is average compared to him is bull shit hes as good if not better
jsephc1 7 months ago
I have always been a huge Disturbed and Alice In Chains fan. Yes, Both David and Layne are great singers, but to say that David is as good or even better than Layne is UTTER BULLSHIT.
EternalLies 7 months ago 2
@EternalLies
Hell no. Layne's overrated as hell. Dave has way more fucking range. Between the pot, countless surgeries, 3 broken noses, acid reflux and much more, Dave is still an excellent singer. What does that tell you?
Krow83 1 month ago
@Krow83 THIS GUY. Layne Staley overrated WTF! is wrong with you. You like Disturbed so im guessing your like 14. I liked them whe i was 16 also then my music knowledge grew and I Discovered AIC, Zeppelin. in other words i discovered greatness. and realized WTF was i listening too. Soon it will hit you to. Theres gonna be a day were you go "now i know what people are talking about" I saw disturbed in march. Draimans voice cracked like 3 timesHes good but Layne is Greatness. Plant, Staley> draiman
notavailableisnotava 1 month ago
@notavailableisnotava
Lol, dude. I'm 18 and I play bass, regular guitar. I've also played baritone, violin, trumpet and clarinet and have experimented slightly on the piano.
And if you discovered Led Zeppelin when you were 16.... Wow, I think we're done here.
Krow83 1 month ago
@Krow83 laynes overrated? how old r u like 12?layne staley is the most underrated singer/songwriter of all time
MsJilsephonie 1 month ago
@MsJilsephonie
18 buddy; that's why I can spell correctly, use proper grammar and know what capitals are.
And hell no. Alice in Chains is practically KNOWN for Layne Staley. That doesn't make him a bad singer, in fact I actually like him; as AiC and STP tend to be the only grunge bands that I like.
However, saying he's a better singer than Dave is just blasphemous. Check out Warhammer's vid of 10,000 Fists live at Uproar.
Krow83 1 month ago
@MsJilsephonie
watch?v=_cKjIo80mKE
Different uploader; same vid.
Krow83 1 month ago
Anyone who says this is horrible should go suck one. Obviously this is not davids type of vocals but he pulled them off a lot better than anyone else could. Hardly any remakes are better than the originals. Rock on David!!!!!!!!! WE ARE DISTURBED!!!
alexandria4915 9 months ago
oh gawd.
AwesomeSauceLimited 1 year ago
he did this good good remake but this is not disturbed .....srry.
lateraider 1 year ago
@lateraider
who said it was disturbed?
It's a cover, and you have people playing that aren't in the band Disturbed. Soooooo of course it isn't Disturbed. It's not supposed to be. I think we should have all known what to expect. No??
O_o
But anyway... honestly, I like Disturbed, but I love Alice in Chains. And I'm not moved by this at all. Dave Navarro is beast though, I must say.
musicmytruelove 1 year ago
He shouldn't be singing like that after he just had his surgery
groovyrascal 1 year ago 20
i doubt he cares lol
NedFalco 7 months ago
he is the best at what he does.....but he does not pull this off.
his voice is unique and has a distinct style that does not transfer well here.
but that happens to nearly all great singers.
listen to halford cover paranoid by sabbath - same thing- it doesnt work, but still an incredible vocalist.
southperth22 1 year ago 2
Yeah, this wasnt too good. I mean the parts that he let his voice flow deeply was good, but whe he tried to throw his voice in overdrive he should have just made his voice deeper in some way. David is still the man. I am a die hard disturbed fan, dont get me wrong.
StitchedDead1O 1 year ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
you say soulja boy- i say linkin park
you say rihanna - i say metallica
you say hip-hop - i say three days grace
you say lady gaga - i say bullet for my valentine
you say emenem - i say system of down
you say hannah montana - i scream heavy metal
92% of teenagers have turned to hip-hop and pop, if ur part of the 8%, copy this message and past it to an other video. DONT LET THE SPIRIT OF ROCK DIE!!!!
fenderstrat707 1 year ago
Is he having a heart attack at :48 seconds.
bigboss25262 1 year ago
i love disturbed. i love AiC even more. but Dave killed this song....layne staley would be ashamed
GanjikaAranyaka 1 year ago
Jesus Christ this sucks. He sounds like Scott Stapp.
libertyfalls 1 year ago
Broken glass man. Whenever i here anything about dave all i can think about is when there was a tour that wanted godsmack and disturbed together and dave wanted godsmack to open for them. HELLO! Godsmack=Platinum Disturbed=Gold at the time. EGOS!!!!!! Not to mention Sully rips Dave apart vocally on this song. He sounds like a diing pig.
Stimos 1 year ago
jERRY cANTRELL SHOULD OF SMACKED David FOR THAT PERFOMANCE... Jerry Should Have Just Taken Over..!!
BUDWEISERNFL123 2 years ago
good god... david shouldve rested his voice after the surgery lol this was awful lol. but dont get me wrong. he sings goldy now but he shouldve waited to sing something as awsum as man in the box that soon after his surgery. no offence all my fellow Disturbed brothers
oatmealj 2 years ago
Low notes are alright.But high notes sound like a catin heat.Layne staliy forever
heavy379 2 years ago
this was cool...he is good at all he does..rock on David! love you!
babygirlpj2008 2 years ago
you know nothing
babbracer 1 year ago
It sounds weird because their playing it to the pitch the Alice in Chains guy would sing to, David was just trying to match the pitch, but the low notes of the song he nailed perfectly.
TheOneYouForsaken 2 years ago
fuckin awesome. david draiman is really good at alot of songs.
zackattatck 2 years ago
kickass man
Manoffire959 2 years ago
the surgey was to literaly open up his nose, he broke it too many times. so i dont think that would haf to do anything with his voice
deadwalkingman1 2 years ago
david had surgery shortly before this show but his voice still sounds awesome
sonicsykes08 2 years ago 17
@sonicsykes08 Surgery or not it isn't good. Draiman has a good voice but Alice in Chains isn't for him.
KingVerdo 1 year ago 4
@KingVerdo now your comment should be the top rated one.
phoenixforce22 1 year ago
his voice is obviously off, probably due to the surgery or need of...still sounds sick tho
artiepoore 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
please read this because it actually works!!!!!!!!!!!!
1.put both of your hands on your chest
2.think of the person you like......
3.tomorrow that person will ask you out or say i love you
4.heres the catch send this to 5 videos
salvad0r229 2 years ago
great
MrBoggersterla 2 years ago
wow it sounded like David just had he's throat surgury
tubelake15 2 years ago
man, david is awesome, i mean... his voice is fucking versatile
icemaster13 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
FUCKING AWFUL! Why would Jerry play with this HACK!!!!! DAVIS IS GOD-AWFUL!
NOfatCHIX87 3 years ago
shut up it was fucking awesome
mumme22 2 years ago 2
keep dreaming man
cass273 2 years ago 2
put a chode in it cock sucker
Manoffire959 2 years ago