Butchering one of the greatest songs ever written. Even if it is Wakeman's band. The shredding Guitar is terrible and shouldn't have been allowed anywhere near this. The vocals are all out of sync and equally sucked.
Sorry for the confusion I seem to have caused here... this is NOT Yes but is instead Rick Wakeman from his "The Ultimate Rick Wakeman Experience" solo CD. It is not Jon Anderson singing neither is it Steve Howe on guitar. The musicians on the CD are not credited so I have no way of knowing who they are but an enlightened guess would be some of his friends from The English Rock Ensemble. I hope this will clear up some of the confusion!
Not a patch on the original. When the vocals came in I had to stop the video. This song is supposed to be melodic and comforting to the ears. Those vocals were like a razor blade on glass - they hurt my ears.
Hang about - it's yes music, it's not Yes playing!! Who is this doing lead vocals?? Also who's that on guitar?? Certainly not Jon Anderson or Steve Howe!!
Sounds like Wakeman keyboards though....can anyone enlighten me?
The track is taken from "The Ultimate Rick Wakeman Experience" CD which is a wierd collection of Ricks solo work but alas all the musicians are uncredited... maybe some friends from The English Rock Ensemble but that would just be me guessing.
sorry i dont know what the film i used here is and i dont remember where i got it from although i think it maybe footage from one of david attenborough's life on earth things... i just thought the music and film went so well and thought i would share
Dave - sorry to have to tell you this, but it's not Yes playing! It may well be Wakeman but the guitars and vocals are all wrong - definitely not Jon Anderson or Steve Howe. The Orchestration is different too. Is this lifted from a solo Wakeman work? Where did you get this from?
No it's not from Going for the One - because it isn't Jon, Steve or Chris playing!! It isn't Yes, but I'll grant you whoever it is has done a fair job -
This has been flagged as spam show
I thought it was great.
progbob1 3 months ago
Great stuff - thanks for posting
bubblabu 4 months ago
I shared this faux to my friends you little man.No Jon NO Yes!
TheTherese3 6 months ago
Yes's sound is too unique. Especially the singing. such a unique voice cannot be duplicated
RRgoalie37 2 years ago
Butchering one of the greatest songs ever written. Even if it is Wakeman's band. The shredding Guitar is terrible and shouldn't have been allowed anywhere near this. The vocals are all out of sync and equally sucked.
Don't try this at home folks.
escomments 2 years ago
um...that is Jon Anderson singing - and this track is of "Going for the One" album - sometime in mid-later 70's.
duggandeep 2 years ago
@duggandeep
It is most certainly not at all Jon Anderson ... in fact it is not YES>
Since when did Jon Anderson sing like a Dream Theater?
ChordCluster 1 year ago
@ChordCluster sounds like bruce dickinson out of iron maiden singing !!!
tokaicarl 1 year ago
@duggandeep jeeze, what dungeon did you crawl out of? My 83 year old Mother could tell this isn't YES.
kennywowie 6 months ago
Espectacular Gracias YES por existir !!!
Mak9163 2 years ago
Comment removed
TheTube1970 2 years ago
Past a mortal as we, here we can be
rodrico50 2 years ago 3
Well ,at least it is Rick playing!!!No harp,no Jon,but it is credible
carrietide 2 years ago
I can't believe where they ended this Song....Crazy.
nignog87 2 years ago
Sorry, this is one song that can't be duplicated by others.
Only the original can work for this. Good effort though.
CrystalVision7 3 years ago 3
@CrystalVision7 Strongly agree
RRgoalie37 2 years ago
Sorry for the confusion I seem to have caused here... this is NOT Yes but is instead Rick Wakeman from his "The Ultimate Rick Wakeman Experience" solo CD. It is not Jon Anderson singing neither is it Steve Howe on guitar. The musicians on the CD are not credited so I have no way of knowing who they are but an enlightened guess would be some of his friends from The English Rock Ensemble. I hope this will clear up some of the confusion!
daveoxton 3 years ago
Not a patch on the original. When the vocals came in I had to stop the video. This song is supposed to be melodic and comforting to the ears. Those vocals were like a razor blade on glass - they hurt my ears.
Signaltonoise 1 year ago
Hang about - it's yes music, it's not Yes playing!! Who is this doing lead vocals?? Also who's that on guitar?? Certainly not Jon Anderson or Steve Howe!!
Sounds like Wakeman keyboards though....can anyone enlighten me?
stiltskin1 3 years ago
The track is taken from "The Ultimate Rick Wakeman Experience" CD which is a wierd collection of Ricks solo work but alas all the musicians are uncredited... maybe some friends from The English Rock Ensemble but that would just be me guessing.
daveoxton 3 years ago
YES....Great video.. tastefully done, thanx
Samadhijunkie 3 years ago
Thank you very much! I'm glad I've found it!
kautokeine
kautokeine 3 years ago
Thanks for your answer ! David Attenborough's reference is very useful. You have made a beautiful clip.
yestopographic73 3 years ago
agreed, my friend!
1nessism 3 years ago
Does anybody know title of the movie used for this clip ? Thanks
yestopographic73 3 years ago
sorry i dont know what the film i used here is and i dont remember where i got it from although i think it maybe footage from one of david attenborough's life on earth things... i just thought the music and film went so well and thought i would share
daveoxton 3 years ago
Dave - sorry to have to tell you this, but it's not Yes playing! It may well be Wakeman but the guitars and vocals are all wrong - definitely not Jon Anderson or Steve Howe. The Orchestration is different too. Is this lifted from a solo Wakeman work? Where did you get this from?
stiltskin1 3 years ago
Yes I know it isn't Yes ... it is Rick Wakeman from his "The Ultimate Rick Wakeman Experience" solo compilation CD.
daveoxton 3 years ago
The music is Yes with Awaken from their album Going for the One (1977).
stamatis53 3 years ago
No it's not from Going for the One - because it isn't Jon, Steve or Chris playing!! It isn't Yes, but I'll grant you whoever it is has done a fair job -
stiltskin1 3 years ago