@calvingmail Yeah we lost 58000 soldiers and killed over 2 million, which is a lowball estimate, and NEVER lost one ground engagement with strategical importance in Vietnam. Yeah we really "got our ass kicked." Learn history before you spout off ignorant bullshit. The U.S. having one hand tied the entire time by politics, and leaving because of political reasons does not constitute the NVA winning anything militarily.
@THEKINGOFMETROPOLIS Yeah, right, North Vietnam with China & USSR backing fought against South Vietnam with the US and its allies. So if you want to compare 2 million North Vietnamese (actually it was 1.1 million), compare that to 300,000 South Vietnamese on the other side. And if you want to compare 58000 Americans, compare that number to the 1500 Chinese or maybe 16 Soviet soldiers. Think, use your brain instead of listening blindly to propaganda from your own government.
@lt2hieu2004 Use my brain? Yeah we didn't fight the chinese or russians in a full scale land battle you retard so of course their casualties are lower, no shit. Like I said we never lost a single engagement of actual strategic value. Thats no "propaganda" thats pure fact. 1.1 million dead North Vietnamese is a mid level estimate. No matter which way you want to spin it the U.S. in no way lost the war militarily, it lost because it was a shit storm politically. FACT.
@THEKINGOFMETROPOLIS Seriously, can you guys argue in a more civilized manner? Calling people name doesn't make you better or your argument any more valid. To put things into perspective, yeah sure, because the Soviet or Chinese never enter any full scale battle with any side during that conflict, their casualties are much lower. The same reason why American casualties are much lower, most of the fightings on the field were between North & South Vietnam troops.
@THEKINGOFMETROPOLIS And btw, which sourcce did you use that says 1.1m North Vietnamese is a mid level estimate? This is exactly why I call the U.S sources nowadays mostly propaganda. They all says there are approx. 2.1m Vietnamese casualties but they don't say how many percent of that number from the North & how many from the South. Same for civilian casualties. And what was that about you guys never lost a single battle? Colonel David Hackworth on your side would disagree. Look up his book.
@lt2hieu2004 Jesus christ its where you got your source of 1500 dead chinese and the 16 soviets, wikipedia. Those are combatants not civilians. Did I say never lost a a battle? I said never lost a battle with actual strategic importance. Yeah we got ambushed now and again and took casualties and had to pull back, but none of this actually affected any real military objectives in the actual campaigns. We never had a firebase overrun or pulled back because we were facing superior forces.
@THEKINGOFMETROPOLIS Now I know where it all goes wrong. If you source is Wikipedia then I am really speechless. Use real sources mate. Did you know you can edit anonymously almost all pages in Wikipedia? Maybe just for fun you should change the number of American dead to 10 soldiers. Even if you take Wikipedia as a valid source and I'm assuming the English version here, there it also says the North Vietnamese dead is 1.176m (highest estimate), so which source did you use that says 2m really?
@THEKINGOFMETROPOLIS And I'm also talking about "battle with actual strategic importance" here. If you have done as I recommended - i.e. looking up Hackworth's book and actually skim through it very quickly you would not have said so. And what's better is that he's not the only one. Btw, again, which source did you use here that says "the US never lost a battle with actual strategic importance"? American source? Have you ever read anything written from a non U.S perspective?
@calvingmail - Total ignorance or, worse, pure racism. Please open a book on history (drop down your comics, Wikipedia or light-sourced material) and revise a bit. From the gallic era (against Cesar's legions) all the way to the 60's (in Algeria) or during 1991's Gulf War , France's got loads of military victory, not the least under King Louis IX ("Saint Louis"), Francois 1st, Louis XIV, Napoleon, WW1 (France actually WON the war). Appalling lack of knowledge...
As far as I'm concerned anyone supporting Marx is an enemy of Civilization! Look at everything the French & the Europeans did for the medieval world AND THIS was how those ingrates repaid us?! We would have been better off just killing the natives & colonising these places with our OWN PEOPLE instead of attempting to modernize them!
If Hitler had crushed the Soviet Union as should have happened modern weapons would never have gotten to these people & the European empires would still exist!
Dang CS phai giai the. Da Dang se tieng hanh ngay sao khi co cuoc bau cu toan quoc.QDND phai dung ve hang ngu cua dan toc VN de bao ve lanh tho va quyen loi cua dong bao vi tu do, doc lap va dan chu. Ke tu gio phuc nay QDND phai vi dong bao dan toc VN va lanh tho VN ma moi nguoi con dan VN trong hang ngu cua QDND phai bao ve tai san cua quoc gia, tung mang song cua dong bao va lanh tho VN.
Halfway up the mountain lake Once you join me. Between heaven and earth immense. Hu called Pakhoang As the situation three. The same water Why not partner together. Has called a couple. How could three people. Why do you love me But also business people. Current situation as Pakhoang. Lying still on the mountain. ( gift of Dien Bien and He)
Để biết con đường cứu quốc và để lại hãnh diện làm con dân đất Việt kiêu hùng:
Xin mở xem ngay:
VĂN MINH ĐẠI VIỆT Phim mới VN Đạo hết sức vĩ đại - 4 phần - Mỗi phần một giờ:
War and Peace, Past and Future of Vietnam. (1) Quá Khứ Hùng Anh (2) Tang Thương Cận Đại (3) Đại Bác Đã Ngưng (4) Tương Lai Ngời Sáng. Đất Việt tiến lên, chẳng chi cản nổi!
@PierreBraquemard I think that you have never been in any war or Army service. Every war is f.cking shit. And if You´re thinking that your french country was doing great think to take somebody´s land....than You are peace of shit. What France needs ? Is it a small country and without everything needed? Why you french always wanted to take colonies and to colonize world ? Colonized Pacific, Indochina and other places...You fucking french fried bastards !!!
@matsuo07 It was the same for Spain, UK, Portugal and some others countries (including Japan). Why do they felt like colonize everyhting? For power as always, it was easier than to fight wars with strong neighbors.
Oh and when a country decide something it doesn't mean the people wanted it or even agree, most of the french were against the war in Vietnam.
You know, it's just sad that people take time out of their day to argue about a war that ended over 30 years ago. There is nothing we can do about it, so why argue? Also, for you fucking hippies, please don't hate ANY soldiers, wether it be Chinese or American, past or present. A soldier is simply following orders. Message if you agrre
Thats is Bull crap VietNam wanted the Frence out of south east asia,it ask America for support frist,but they refused!!!!Vietnam wanted to unite its brother to the south but the more powerful country's may object to the actions,so it asked american for support ,they refused so it then they turned to China and Russia.All Vietnam wanted was to unite its people into one country,Vietnam could not fight the frence alone it needed help.
@MerguezFurtive Asshole! Why you whites always seriously consider dick sizes? Not confident with yours & compare others? Know what your race is like? Dogs in rut - exactly! Why? Because your white - males like sucking their dicks longer & female like to blow-up their skirts for anyone who just buy them a bread or drink!
seriously, 'youstinky', you need to grow the fuck up. nobody is 'swayed' by your childish arguements and laughably lousy revisionist history.
the french were outnumber at dien bien phu, but it was a LOUSY place to set up defense; if you were ever in the military, it takes at least a 3:1 ratio of attackers to defenders.
bottom line:saying the Americans WON the war in Vietnam. at least THEY never lost a battle in that war; the French can't say that, can they?
@neoconsnightmare3 you are the child claiming you can teach me france history about things you dont know, Suez Crisis 1956, Bizerte Crisis 1961, i bet you never heard about that. actually there's no need for me to waste time with stupid kids.
@YouSmellyReds revisionism? the british LOST the battle of france in 1940, their escape at dunkirk is regarded as a great victory by their propaganda, ha! :) but they runaway to save their troops, FACT is they lost with the french because the germans were the best at this time.
@YouSmellyReds the US had 50,000 dead in vietnam how can you claim they NEVER LOST a battle? you are ridiculous. you don't have a clue about france, about the governments betraying the army, abandoning conquered territories. the coup d'état of 1958? the coup d'état of 1961? the assassination attempts of de Gaulle ? byebye kid. :D
@YouSmellyReds you've NEVER been in the military, have you? nor can you understand history. japan beat russia in the russo-japanese war, and had WAY MORE DEAD than russia.
in america's case, the u.s. had 58,000 dead versus northvietnamese/viet cong dead of 1.8 million, and the u.s. LOST the war.
battles are tactical, and the u.s. never lost a battle in that war, but n. vietnam won the war.
@wachaufeuropa i dig. but the u.s. created the viet minh/viet cong because when ho chi minh begged truman to acknowledge vietnamese freedom, truman couldnt. the french threatened not to join NATO if the u.s. did that.
don't get me wrong, the u.s. fucked up by doing that. but yousmelly has a pretty delusional image of the french military might the last 130 years.
at dien bien phu the FRENCH UNION had 1 division while the communist viet minh had 5 divisions, however the outnumbered and outgunned FRENCH UNION fighters inflicted more losses to the reds, killing much more of these fags; check the DEATH TOLL kids, DEATH TOLL can't lie ! but reds can ! thats the matter with the REDtards. :|
vntiger is a red monkey trying to block my account so he can spread his propaanda and lies :D but you can't get kid ! you just can't ! i come and leave here as i like. ;) good night ladies.
@hoilungly83 Pierre here. your BF vnmonkey tried to block me for the 2nd time :D yes indeed history is made just like fagg0ts like you were done. nobody gives a fvck about your miserable life so stay at home and don't post here. i teach history to REDtards. you don't even write a correct french so forget about it you stinky swine.
@YouSmellyReds des lâches ne sont pas en guerre de 1939 à 62 tête de noeud et ne conquièrent pas un empire mondial DUC0N, canadian army er? :D you stupid canadians have a territory populated by reindeers and thats all. that being said i unscrew your head and sh1t on your neck.
maybe you just cant cut it kidd. maybe you can. maybe youre slow....or SUPER fast in other areas. who cares
in THIS area.......you have no clue.
USA invaded South Vietnam in the early to mid 60's for the sole and direct intent on procuring RUBBER for american car tire manufacture's. 58000 americans are STILL DEAD over the decisions made by amoral greedy white american "higher ups"
@MrHarry46 why are you telling shit about usa if you live there er? why did the france and the us have hosted antired indochinese refugees if they fougt for rubber? why did the french and us made the operation Passage to Freedom if they were there only for money? you have fed up with lies called communist propaganda.
this is an absolute propaghanda. it wasnt communism the generals were afraid of. it was the loss of the sweat shops with cheap labor. kids who toil their lives away making clothes for rich americans AND the rubber tree plantations were of course threatened. Ford GM and Chrysler would have been devastated with no tires for their cars
I cannot count the # of times Ive heard my fellow americans ask "why were we over there anyway?" or .."why did we go to vietnam?" or "what were we doing there?" or "what are were we fighting for?". even songs of the era asked...what are we fighting for?....dont ask me I dont give a damn, next stop is vietnam! and its one two three..etc. now you know. the answer is RUBBER....good day
@MrHarry46 shut up and get off with your rubber dildo stupid smartass. the french and the us fought the vietnam to defend it from the communists assholes like mrharry46. the domino theory proved right with laos and cambodia becoming communist dictatorship. as a result the whole former french indochina turned into a red territory. in the end thousands of vietnamese moved from the communist area to reach the free area though Operation Passage to Freedom. many eventually moved to france and the us.
@PierreBraquemard as we speak the red vietnamese and laotian armies are hunting the remaining hmong people living in the laos mountains. these hmong fought the communists with the french secret services then the us and that's why the reds are doing a genocide. voila. now there are still puppets like mrsilly46 to make false claims and support ridiculous conspiracy theories. by the time of dien bien phu laos and cambodia were fully independent though the french defend them.
@MrHarry46 not only rubber but they also wanted viet nam to be their colony like the philippines, korea and japan. it was also a strategic settlement to contain china from all directions. america was so bitter that they could not win the war so they bombard the country to rubble.
@PierreBraquemard check again because American has around 49 army base sitting in Germany. Germany oppose Iraq but insist on staying in Afghanistan, isn't that what America is doing right now? but wait. they still haven't left Iraq... Actually they're sending 30,000 more troops into Iraq to "fight for freedom". Millions of Iraqi civilians already dead as America entered Iraq. Who's the communist invading who now?
yes the germans have us bases because they were not allowed by others (eg de gaulle) to raise a true army. as a consequence they are kind of protectorate of the us. the french are in afghanistan but opposed the iraq war. iraq war was us bullshit to control oil but afghanistan is the craddle of terrorism. the communists have invaded georgia last year do you remember and the vietnamese and lao armies are making a genocide over the montagnard hmongs do you know that?
@PierreBraquemard says the propaganda machine. actually Russia is a democratic federation not communist, maybe your knowledge is too poor to debate about politics. you cannot oppose a war and then enter it, then you'd be a hypocrite. you want to talk about genocide talk about America genocide in Japan, Viet Nam, Korea, Philippines, Laos, Cambodia, Iraq, Afghanistan, Cuba etc. first then we can talk about Viet Nam and Hmong.
@vntiger its you who don"t have a clue aboutr calling poilitics. calling germany an us colony and claiming the us did a genocide in japan shows you are pretty limited.
@PierreBraquemard get that big rubber dildo out of your flaming liberal butt and grow some balls man!. its not like you have abrain or anything. I think your brains have oozed out of you pock marked face pores. its lost whackbags such as yourself that make this world a weaker more unstable place
@PierreBraquemard woa! woa! there big gay horsie! get that rubber boner out of your butt gayboi! you ugly pock marked frenchie fag!! its too bad you dont get pussy fagboi, but...you dont like girls anyways. NOW youre trying to act like you know something! LOGODDAMNEDMOTHERFUCKING L. as your gay world turns you STILL, as in STILL MISSED MY ENTIRE POINT, why?...you got rubber boners up your ass and you cant see the trees for the rubber boners!!LOL USA was in vietnam because OF RUBBER S2UPID!!
sut you you son of prostitute get off of this video already you fat bastard. you are a piece of shit i don't want to waste my time with with traitors like you. go to hell and stick your rubber dildo in your ass. all the deads of utah beach shit on your head.
@PierreBraquemard hahaha poor little dildo licker. poor frenchie. I beat your ass fair and square now ya got a little attitude problem huh....poor little baby. ya just cant get that rubber dildo out of your mind can ya ..HA HA HA HA. whatever kidd. if it werent for the deads at omaha beach youd be speaking german right now FAG FACE
@vntiger i'm laughing because idiots like both of you are still fed up with red propaganda. it wasn't the french army but only an expeditionary corps and it didn't fought alone but with the vietnamese national army, laos army and cambodia army against stinky communists. the french union army made a joke of the viet minh at na san and other battles.
@PierreBraquemard at dien bien phu there was 1 vs 5 ratio from french union versus vietminh, that demonstrates the viet minh was a joke. the vietnamese communist army is actually only good for making a genocide over the hmong people.
@PierreBraquemard you're saying that the French savior for the Vietnamese, Cambodian and Laos from the communist? you filthy pest. you animals tortured those people for over 50 years and in the end when they beat your ass you claim that you came to save them? it's so funny because after WW2, you animals came into Viet Nam exported all the rice back to France and starved millions of people to death. everything to you is communist propaganda, maybe the only truth is that you're a dumb ass.
@vntiger red propaganda that's exactly what you are doing, calling germany an us colony and us genocide in japan shows it all. you don't know what those terms are. what red pigs like you don't mention is the french created the state of vietnam and that there were more vietnamese fighting with the french than with the viet minh. and don't you dare mention torture the viet minh torture the french union POWs and killed 3/4 of them from dien ben phu. you animal blocked pierrebraquemard's account.
@vntiger that's fact idiot compare the numbers and compare the DEATH TOLL between the FRENCH UNION and the silly VIET MINH. murder by numbers you monkey! :D
@chrisbreizh29 we never wanted to fight anyone, fightng came to us. has viet nam ever invaded america, france or china? they all came to our home and harassed our people. what would you do if someone came into your home and hurt your family? we were not fighting for capitalism or communism, we were fighting to keep our home and today we stop fighting and even forgave american, chinese and french for their unforgivable deeds in our homeland, because that's the true face of the vietnamese people.
Shame it had to happen like this, but history likes to repeat herself. The pacifist people get invaded by the strongest ones. Other pacific nations turn out aggressive to avoid being invaded themselves etc
@vntiger How come that the north attacked the south if the only wanted to protect their country?! thats pretty dumb to me if you are saying that you only protected your country.
@vntiger i love how you keep talking has if you were tehre when you probably werent even born during the war. and im sorry but everything you have been told has been propaganda since birth. and im not saying its unique to your country. every country does that to make itself seem better or more right to each new generation. now stop it with your self righteous rant, you werent there so stfu.
@Kingdoc1976 fuck you bastard. your corrupted country was kicked at suez in 1956, those sweety egyptians were fighting for freedom blablabla truth is it was the french who devised and made the canal of suez thanks to ferdinand de lesseps while you english bitches tried to prevent the french from doing it you bastards. now fuck off you roastbeef. the vietcong bastards were fighting for communism while south vietnam was fighting for freedom with the french. vietnamese refugees came to france.
@Kingdoc1976 i'm glad your dirty country was kicked in afganistan two time before even the soviets get there. look at you bastard the english who killed the australian natives to establish a colony giving lessons to the others. you are a funny guy.
@FabuleuxFab6 i have to simplify things for these delusion minded. if people actually watched this video before they make up stories and theories then i wouldnt be so angry and vietnam war/history isn't so complicated. basically viet minh vs french puppet... viet cong vs american puppet. simple as that. all 3 million lives at the cost of separatist following their master's trail to "independence" where the french's defeat should've solved the entire situation of Vietnamese independence.
Westerners always like to style themselves as saviors of the world when they are really history's greatest robbers. For over 500 years, they steal from the world. They displaced the people the Americas and Australia. They carved up Africa, conquered India and parts of China. They divided up Southeast Asia amongst themselves. They enslaved and killed millions, committing the greatest global genocide in history. And these people want us to think of them as saviors? Sorry, you're out of luck.
@RoniCMaster well, the backwardness of most part of the world then had caused these things to be inevitable. If the world could make a change like japs did quick enough, these would have been avoided. For time and tide waits for no man. In the survival of the fittest, change is required for failing, would render you marginalised and eventually extinct. Harsh reality, but true in life as a whole.
@PierreBraquemard uh, the French were successful the early part of the war, but the latter half of the war, they pretty much had their asses handed to them by the Viet Minh. These are FACTS, Pierre.
The 'stinky communists' were able to whip the hell out of the French, and went on to outlast (if not out fight) the Americans. What did the French go on to do? Oh yeah, the got their asses kicked out of Algeria as well.
No 'red propoganda'...it's a FACT the French lost their empire.
pierre here, our good communist friend blocked my other account :) THAT IS COWARDICE like hoilungly answering to only "Pierre" so i don't get his answer. well, don't you, an american, dare teach me the history of france please and especially this part, how could you understand what's the algerian war was about? about indochina you've only heard of dien bien phu and that's all (without knowing 37 CIA pilots flew there with 2 KIA!). in fact you're all wrong. i've sent an argumented answer. :)
@PierreBraquemard This was more than 50 years ago, dude ! Now everyone has his jobs to do in a very normal life ! It's non-sense if you'll still seat here in this topic and suck your own dick to make clear who went right or wrong ! Hehehe...
Perhaps, you still need to know if your French shit is still in VN, huh ? Yeah, it's still there and smells to bad
@annpbtma what are you talking about you asshole. fact is our good friend vntiger blocked my accounts so i can't answer him. fuck you asshole, its been 50 years blablabla why are you here on this video posting BS you idiot?! forget about it.
@MerguezFurtive Did I said to you, shit mouth ? Maybe shit is your favourite & you like everyone gives it to you ? Trying to perfect English, huh ? It's better to you moron to give your mom a blowjob! Mother fucker
@MerguezFurtive How childish you are ! Your mother could have not enough dicks to suck before giving birth to you, boy ? Give me your mon's address. I can go to teach her a real fuck. It's better to her to give better education to other births, not a shit like you anymore. Remember sucking a French dicks 1 hundred times to show your admirability, dickhead
@annpbtma i fuck you in the ass you gay retard. the french shitted in your viet mouth from 1881 to 1956. things are hard i know but that's life, your country is populated with cowards and your ancestries were dogs that were ruled by rhe french. now jusr look at vietnam all women ther are prostitutes, just like your mother and even you.
@MerguezFurtive it's stupid if I again waste my minutes of life to talk to a shit like you. You're even not a shit in your white race.You just need to find a wall and fuck yourself on it and say VIVAS MY DICKHEAD FRANCE !!! HEHEHE, LMAO
@annpbtma one last word for you, shit ! Your France is only a chicken-hearted sturdy country. Humiliated in 2 WWs. Sniff behind the asses of Britain & US to regain your power. Even in DBP, De Castries was even kicked in his ass by Vietminh. Wonder if this general had orders to clean Giap's toilets ?? Asshole, next time, don't shit your bravo France by a fake name. It's not French at all. Or you're just a son of a French dickhead and a Latin whore ?
@annpbtma if you think france was humiliated in world war 1 then you know absolutely nothing about world war 1. we would not have won if not for france.
@MerguezFurtive lol you're pathetic, it's so sad that you have to make fake accounts to talk bullshit here and spread your hate instead of using your current account to do that in another video. why do I block you? because you're a dumb ass, with no education. this video is too much information for you to interpret.
@vntiger I agree with half your statement. the USA wanted rubber. no imperialist country, such as the USA is....wants any country for any other reason than MONEY. Comodities. Its been going on since the dawn of time. one group of apes invade anothers colony. classic, classic ape doctrine. and americans, along with poor little mrPeirreBoneLicker think theyre so above it all!!..LOL
@vntiger visit ANRPC's website. vietnam is one of the top ten natural rubber producing countries on the planet. rubber is a 150 billion dollar a year industry.
58000 americans and over 3 million vietnamese are still dead. PierreBonelicker is a fucking whackbag brainwashed retard.
@MrHarry46 who brought the rubber in vietnam stupid dick? without the french settlers work, the vietnam would had remain in the stone age. actually you have the limited sense of a caveman yourself.
@50poiuyt bragging? bragging is all of you communist vietnamese are doing being you vntiger or this mrstinky46. at dien bien phu the french union fighters had the equivalent of 1 division when the viet minh had 5 divisions, although the french union killed much more viet minh, the latter killed 3/4 of the french union POWs which is more than at the siege. it says much about whos bragging and whos brave. all 3 of you are red assholes.
PierreBonelicker: your face is pockmarked like a fucking rubber loving dildo sucking drug addict. too bad youre too weak and broken to defeat me. I AM the king here not you. you cant get pussy so you suck cock.whatever its your life gayboi
@MrHarry46 you talk trash because your skull is full of shit. all you deserve is to get your ass kicked. you don't have a clue about vietnam and you are a useless piece of shit so get off this video, stop your nonsense comments now and put your rubberdick in your ass it wall calm you down. you are an idiot.
the vietnam war was all about lies, cover-ups, deceptions, death. once the major rubber players(Goodyear Firestone Cooper Michellin) realized that the american people arent very smart NOR do they have the guts to hold their government accountable,they were HELL bent on capitalizing on that fact. christ...its open season on dumbfucks!!....WOOOOO!!!. THERES MONEY TO BE MADE!!! thats how it works in this world. sorry kidds. greed kills. americans are so very stupid
@ChipBeo the US supported the Vietminh against the french in 1946 because they wanted to do business with indochina. in 1950 the communist chinese defeated the republic, recognized hochiminh and started to massively supply the viet minh. against this the US started to support the french by paying 80% of the indochina war fee and supplying them with aircrafts, carriers, tanks, weapons etc. they invented the domino theory to justify the french support vis a vis their domestic opposition.
@PierreBraquemard in 1949 france gave independence to vietnam, laos and cambodia. the state of vietnam fought with the french against the viet minh. the us and uk recognize bao dai's state of vietnam in 1950. mrharry46 believes the us invaded normandy for rubber. he's an idiot.
exactly. the "domino theory" and "THE RED SCARE" were tactics the US gov propaghanda machine use to "convince" americans to go to another country and kill any human being they decided to. fact is, Secretary of Defense at the time, and former Ford Motor Company exec Robert McNamara, upon his death, appologized to all the vets families and all the men who served in vietnam for lieing about the Gulf of Tonkin incident that catapulted USA into "war" with vietnam.(it never happened)
@ChipBeo the true sorce of the "domino theory" is that if USA lost vietnam...GoodYear Firestone Cooper and Michellin, would not have enough rubber to make car tires. Ford Chrysler and GM would fall like "dominos" because they would have NO RUBBER car tires to put on their cars. take 6 months and think about this. 58000 americans and over 3 million vietnamese are still dead over RUBBER.
PierreBonelicker.....youre about as ignorant and as your good buddy FreeChicken101rst. youre obviously a paid gov schill (FR) continuing the propaganda campaign. fact is, Vietnam is one of the top ten producers of natural rubber in the world. google ANRPC. youll see. cant bullshit me kidd. 58000 americans are still dead over rubber and shitsuckers like you are still trying to cover up WHY. its asslicks like you who keep the uninformed, uninformed. youre a waste of life. goodbye
@MrHarry46 shut up you stinky piece of shit. the only thing about rubber is you use to stick it in your red ass. when the french conquered indochina no one cared about rubber you piece of shit. the thing about indochina was laos's opium now shut the fuck off and go into the jungle to hunt the only remaining hmong that your stinky dictatorship called vietnam is exterminating. hmong genocide thats what red laos and vietnam are doing you assholes.
@PierreBraquemard dont tell me to shut up you gay assloving dicksniffer! youre as queer as queer gets stinky fag!!
if you cant handle the truth TOO BADD. stinky fags like you dont matter anyways.
dont even think of telling me what to do STINKY FAG. why get so upset when I expose the truth STINKY FAG? what have you got to lose?.STINKY FAG!!.youre agay little boy who is still trying to cover up the truth STINKY FAG.58000 americans are STILL DEAD, STINKY FAG
@MrHarry46 your problem with rubber is you don't want to share it with the other nations because you want it all to make rubberdicks and stick them in your arse.
FreeChicken101rst.....you cant prove me wrong. 1rst.....youre too chickenshit.... 2nd youre not intelligent enough to know anything about vietnam at all except what your gov brainwashed you to believe. grow up kid....then get fucked
@uatwmf you cant change the human heart, if he wants something he will do anything to get it, but im not saying I hate humans im just saying, it would a great wait amazing place if it was just peace, but theres none what so ever in this world, we have gangs war terrorist jihadist revolotionist, its just like we will always have wars till the end hate to break it to you
pure propaganda. USA was in vietnam for RUBBER. in the 1800's France invaded/colonized vietnam and by 1960 Michellin(FR) had VAST rubber tree plantations growing there. US tire makers depend on natural rubber to make car tires. if vietnam fell to the "commies" the entire US auto industry would have been devastated. USA would have NEVER spent the trillions it spent on vietnam JUST TO STOP THE SPREAD OF COMMUNISM. remember: its vietnam for RUBBER Iraq for OIL. americans NEVER fight for freedom
youre not intelligent enough to tell me what to do dicklick. its obvious since you havent done the research. the reason you havent done the research is because youre a chickenshit with no brains who CANT HANDLE THE TRUTH. goodbye asshole
@MrHarry46 and you're not even in vietnam you live in the us while you are peacocking about communist vietnam.... you are the biggest piece of shit ever!!
HOW DO YOU CALL A DEAD FRENCH? A FRENCH FRIED!
colt35 1 month ago
Điện Biên Phủ
webmasterforumviet 2 months ago
I miss really miss this show.
Mamboro17 5 months ago
it dont matter now
troytblevins 5 months ago
America got its ass kicked in Vietnam...the truth
calvingmail 6 months ago
@calvingmail Yeah we lost 58000 soldiers and killed over 2 million, which is a lowball estimate, and NEVER lost one ground engagement with strategical importance in Vietnam. Yeah we really "got our ass kicked." Learn history before you spout off ignorant bullshit. The U.S. having one hand tied the entire time by politics, and leaving because of political reasons does not constitute the NVA winning anything militarily.
THEKINGOFMETROPOLIS 6 months ago
@THEKINGOFMETROPOLIS Yeah, right, North Vietnam with China & USSR backing fought against South Vietnam with the US and its allies. So if you want to compare 2 million North Vietnamese (actually it was 1.1 million), compare that to 300,000 South Vietnamese on the other side. And if you want to compare 58000 Americans, compare that number to the 1500 Chinese or maybe 16 Soviet soldiers. Think, use your brain instead of listening blindly to propaganda from your own government.
lt2hieu2004 6 months ago
@lt2hieu2004 Use my brain? Yeah we didn't fight the chinese or russians in a full scale land battle you retard so of course their casualties are lower, no shit. Like I said we never lost a single engagement of actual strategic value. Thats no "propaganda" thats pure fact. 1.1 million dead North Vietnamese is a mid level estimate. No matter which way you want to spin it the U.S. in no way lost the war militarily, it lost because it was a shit storm politically. FACT.
THEKINGOFMETROPOLIS 6 months ago
@THEKINGOFMETROPOLIS Seriously, can you guys argue in a more civilized manner? Calling people name doesn't make you better or your argument any more valid. To put things into perspective, yeah sure, because the Soviet or Chinese never enter any full scale battle with any side during that conflict, their casualties are much lower. The same reason why American casualties are much lower, most of the fightings on the field were between North & South Vietnam troops.
lt2hieu2004 6 months ago
@THEKINGOFMETROPOLIS And btw, which sourcce did you use that says 1.1m North Vietnamese is a mid level estimate? This is exactly why I call the U.S sources nowadays mostly propaganda. They all says there are approx. 2.1m Vietnamese casualties but they don't say how many percent of that number from the North & how many from the South. Same for civilian casualties. And what was that about you guys never lost a single battle? Colonel David Hackworth on your side would disagree. Look up his book.
lt2hieu2004 6 months ago
@lt2hieu2004 Jesus christ its where you got your source of 1500 dead chinese and the 16 soviets, wikipedia. Those are combatants not civilians. Did I say never lost a a battle? I said never lost a battle with actual strategic importance. Yeah we got ambushed now and again and took casualties and had to pull back, but none of this actually affected any real military objectives in the actual campaigns. We never had a firebase overrun or pulled back because we were facing superior forces.
THEKINGOFMETROPOLIS 6 months ago
@THEKINGOFMETROPOLIS Now I know where it all goes wrong. If you source is Wikipedia then I am really speechless. Use real sources mate. Did you know you can edit anonymously almost all pages in Wikipedia? Maybe just for fun you should change the number of American dead to 10 soldiers. Even if you take Wikipedia as a valid source and I'm assuming the English version here, there it also says the North Vietnamese dead is 1.176m (highest estimate), so which source did you use that says 2m really?
lt2hieu2004 6 months ago
@THEKINGOFMETROPOLIS And I'm also talking about "battle with actual strategic importance" here. If you have done as I recommended - i.e. looking up Hackworth's book and actually skim through it very quickly you would not have said so. And what's better is that he's not the only one. Btw, again, which source did you use here that says "the US never lost a battle with actual strategic importance"? American source? Have you ever read anything written from a non U.S perspective?
lt2hieu2004 6 months ago
France always got hammered by others....
calvingmail 6 months ago
@calvingmail - Total ignorance or, worse, pure racism. Please open a book on history (drop down your comics, Wikipedia or light-sourced material) and revise a bit. From the gallic era (against Cesar's legions) all the way to the 60's (in Algeria) or during 1991's Gulf War , France's got loads of military victory, not the least under King Louis IX ("Saint Louis"), Francois 1st, Louis XIV, Napoleon, WW1 (France actually WON the war). Appalling lack of knowledge...
SupersonicFlight 5 months ago 4
Rip for all the vietnamese and french soldiers, waste of lifes
bullshit7128 6 months ago
Vietnam was a senseless waste of life. America should've told Frenchy to suck it
JackMeadeIsACunt 6 months ago
Fuck the French.
Glamoramaful 7 months ago
Imperialist dogma breeds only dissidence.
liveecarbme 7 months ago
Comment removed
handsomehoang 7 months ago
Does anyone know the music for this documentary?
I really like it alot!
Thanks
(also thanks to vntiger for uploading this, it's very interesting!)
(bad grammar - I'm Dutch)
HeroSpiderman 8 months ago
The best battle of the 20th century!
MultiO2010 9 months ago
Thanks uncle Ho chin minh for expel the white man to go home
tojtaug 9 months ago
As far as I'm concerned anyone supporting Marx is an enemy of Civilization! Look at everything the French & the Europeans did for the medieval world AND THIS was how those ingrates repaid us?! We would have been better off just killing the natives & colonising these places with our OWN PEOPLE instead of attempting to modernize them!
If Hitler had crushed the Soviet Union as should have happened modern weapons would never have gotten to these people & the European empires would still exist!
Apollo40315 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Dang CS phai giai the. Da Dang se tieng hanh ngay sao khi co cuoc bau cu toan quoc.QDND phai dung ve hang ngu cua dan toc VN de bao ve lanh tho va quyen loi cua dong bao vi tu do, doc lap va dan chu. Ke tu gio phuc nay QDND phai vi dong bao dan toc VN va lanh tho VN ma moi nguoi con dan VN trong hang ngu cua QDND phai bao ve tai san cua quoc gia, tung mang song cua dong bao va lanh tho VN.
Lequyenphuong 1 year ago
tranquanghiep2006 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
HOÀNG SA TRƯỜNG SA TRUNG CỘNG CHIẾM
THẾ ĐÔ NƯỚC VIỆT GIẢI CỨU THÁI BÌNH.
Để biết con đường cứu quốc và để lại hãnh diện làm con dân đất Việt kiêu hùng:
Xin mở xem ngay:
VĂN MINH ĐẠI VIỆT Phim mới VN Đạo hết sức vĩ đại - 4 phần - Mỗi phần một giờ:
War and Peace, Past and Future of Vietnam. (1) Quá Khứ Hùng Anh (2) Tang Thương Cận Đại (3) Đại Bác Đã Ngưng (4) Tương Lai Ngời Sáng. Đất Việt tiến lên, chẳng chi cản nổi!
Để xem xin vô YouTube đánh bốn chữ:
VAN MINH DAI VIET
DMTGOD3 1 year ago
ahh.....a good documentary for saturday night
couldnt be better
Sturmmann 1 year ago
cant wait for bad comapy 2 vitname!!! yeeee!
happygamestvfun1 1 year ago
@PierreBraquemard I think that you have never been in any war or Army service. Every war is f.cking shit. And if You´re thinking that your french country was doing great think to take somebody´s land....than You are peace of shit. What France needs ? Is it a small country and without everything needed? Why you french always wanted to take colonies and to colonize world ? Colonized Pacific, Indochina and other places...You fucking french fried bastards !!!
matsuo07 1 year ago
@matsuo07 It was the same for Spain, UK, Portugal and some others countries (including Japan). Why do they felt like colonize everyhting? For power as always, it was easier than to fight wars with strong neighbors.
Oh and when a country decide something it doesn't mean the people wanted it or even agree, most of the french were against the war in Vietnam.
Infernalis792 1 year ago
who say France lose to Vietnam, they are winning first at the Battle Of Hai-Phong. congrat France.
colt35 1 year ago
I like this little yellow mens, strong as hell !!!
MrTheEvilgerman 1 year ago
Oops agree
NBMGamer 1 year ago
You know, it's just sad that people take time out of their day to argue about a war that ended over 30 years ago. There is nothing we can do about it, so why argue? Also, for you fucking hippies, please don't hate ANY soldiers, wether it be Chinese or American, past or present. A soldier is simply following orders. Message if you agrre
NBMGamer 1 year ago
Darn, I thought it was a demo of the BF Vietnam Video game. Too bad, might as well watch anyway. Serendipity all the way.
P.S: I have rarely happened upon a utube video with so much kindergarten insults on the comment section that this one...
P.S.2: are there any Vietnam documentaries from a Vietnamese perspective?
Gargantua606 1 year ago
Just because the cold war the make so many war happens. Vietnam, Middle East, Korea,...
hienhao 1 year ago
Thats is Bull crap VietNam wanted the Frence out of south east asia,it ask America for support frist,but they refused!!!!Vietnam wanted to unite its brother to the south but the more powerful country's may object to the actions,so it asked american for support ,they refused so it then they turned to China and Russia.All Vietnam wanted was to unite its people into one country,Vietnam could not fight the frence alone it needed help.
utubb100 1 year ago
I Love Việt Nam
keomayman 1 year ago
Việt Nam muôn năm !
vanchuong8x 1 year ago
@annpbtma you vietnamese have a small dick that's why you are jealous.
MerguezFurtive 1 year ago
@MerguezFurtive Asshole! Why you whites always seriously consider dick sizes? Not confident with yours & compare others? Know what your race is like? Dogs in rut - exactly! Why? Because your white - males like sucking their dicks longer & female like to blow-up their skirts for anyone who just buy them a bread or drink!
annpbtma 1 year ago
i love VN
YeuConNguoiVietNam 1 year ago
last time i checked the sweet red vietnamise were doing a genocide over the hmong people of laos. this is happening right now. fuck you vnbastard. :)
MerguezFurtive 1 year ago
without HCM VN won't win with foreigner war.
hoangtvu 1 year ago
seriously, 'youstinky', you need to grow the fuck up. nobody is 'swayed' by your childish arguements and laughably lousy revisionist history.
the french were outnumber at dien bien phu, but it was a LOUSY place to set up defense; if you were ever in the military, it takes at least a 3:1 ratio of attackers to defenders.
bottom line:saying the Americans WON the war in Vietnam. at least THEY never lost a battle in that war; the French can't say that, can they?
neoconsnightmare3 1 year ago
@neoconsnightmare3 you are the child claiming you can teach me france history about things you dont know, Suez Crisis 1956, Bizerte Crisis 1961, i bet you never heard about that. actually there's no need for me to waste time with stupid kids.
YouSmellyReds 1 year ago
@YouSmellyReds revisionism? the british LOST the battle of france in 1940, their escape at dunkirk is regarded as a great victory by their propaganda, ha! :) but they runaway to save their troops, FACT is they lost with the french because the germans were the best at this time.
YouSmellyReds 1 year ago
@YouSmellyReds the US had 50,000 dead in vietnam how can you claim they NEVER LOST a battle? you are ridiculous. you don't have a clue about france, about the governments betraying the army, abandoning conquered territories. the coup d'état of 1958? the coup d'état of 1961? the assassination attempts of de Gaulle ? byebye kid. :D
YouSmellyReds 1 year ago
@YouSmellyReds you've NEVER been in the military, have you? nor can you understand history. japan beat russia in the russo-japanese war, and had WAY MORE DEAD than russia.
in america's case, the u.s. had 58,000 dead versus northvietnamese/viet cong dead of 1.8 million, and the u.s. LOST the war.
battles are tactical, and the u.s. never lost a battle in that war, but n. vietnam won the war.
neoconsnightmare3 1 year ago
@neoconsnightmare3
What you say is true. But let's not forget the USA created the Viet Minh in the first place, because they did not want the French to stay in Vietnam
wachaufeuropa 1 year ago
@wachaufeuropa i dig. but the u.s. created the viet minh/viet cong because when ho chi minh begged truman to acknowledge vietnamese freedom, truman couldnt. the french threatened not to join NATO if the u.s. did that.
don't get me wrong, the u.s. fucked up by doing that. but yousmelly has a pretty delusional image of the french military might the last 130 years.
neoconsnightmare3 1 year ago
@YouSmellyReds you are an idiot with way too much time on his hands.
neoconsnightmare3 1 year ago
at dien bien phu the FRENCH UNION had 1 division while the communist viet minh had 5 divisions, however the outnumbered and outgunned FRENCH UNION fighters inflicted more losses to the reds, killing much more of these fags; check the DEATH TOLL kids, DEATH TOLL can't lie ! but reds can ! thats the matter with the REDtards. :|
YouSmellyReds 1 year ago
vntiger is a red monkey trying to block my account so he can spread his propaanda and lies :D but you can't get kid ! you just can't ! i come and leave here as i like. ;) good night ladies.
YouSmellyReds 1 year ago
@hoilungly83 Pierre here. your BF vnmonkey tried to block me for the 2nd time :D yes indeed history is made just like fagg0ts like you were done. nobody gives a fvck about your miserable life so stay at home and don't post here. i teach history to REDtards. you don't even write a correct french so forget about it you stinky swine.
YouSmellyReds 1 year ago
@YouSmellyReds des lâches ne sont pas en guerre de 1939 à 62 tête de noeud et ne conquièrent pas un empire mondial DUC0N, canadian army er? :D you stupid canadians have a territory populated by reindeers and thats all. that being said i unscrew your head and sh1t on your neck.
YouSmellyReds 1 year ago
PierreBraqueWHATTHEFUCKEVER. maybe youre gay .......maybe...........not
maybe you just cant cut it kidd. maybe you can. maybe youre slow....or SUPER fast in other areas. who cares
in THIS area.......you have no clue.
USA invaded South Vietnam in the early to mid 60's for the sole and direct intent on procuring RUBBER for american car tire manufacture's. 58000 americans are STILL DEAD over the decisions made by amoral greedy white american "higher ups"
MrHarry46 1 year ago
@MrHarry46 why are you telling shit about usa if you live there er? why did the france and the us have hosted antired indochinese refugees if they fougt for rubber? why did the french and us made the operation Passage to Freedom if they were there only for money? you have fed up with lies called communist propaganda.
YouStinkyReds 1 year ago
@YouStinkyReds if you have to ask such a retarded question, you certainly wont understand the answer.
you wouldnt know what "propaganda" was if it was shoved up your ass sideways
MrHarry46 1 year ago
this is an absolute propaghanda. it wasnt communism the generals were afraid of. it was the loss of the sweat shops with cheap labor. kids who toil their lives away making clothes for rich americans AND the rubber tree plantations were of course threatened. Ford GM and Chrysler would have been devastated with no tires for their cars
MrHarry46 1 year ago
I cannot count the # of times Ive heard my fellow americans ask "why were we over there anyway?" or .."why did we go to vietnam?" or "what were we doing there?" or "what are were we fighting for?". even songs of the era asked...what are we fighting for?....dont ask me I dont give a damn, next stop is vietnam! and its one two three..etc. now you know. the answer is RUBBER....good day
MrHarry46 1 year ago
@MrHarry46 shut up and get off with your rubber dildo stupid smartass. the french and the us fought the vietnam to defend it from the communists assholes like mrharry46. the domino theory proved right with laos and cambodia becoming communist dictatorship. as a result the whole former french indochina turned into a red territory. in the end thousands of vietnamese moved from the communist area to reach the free area though Operation Passage to Freedom. many eventually moved to france and the us.
PierreBraquemard 1 year ago
@PierreBraquemard as we speak the red vietnamese and laotian armies are hunting the remaining hmong people living in the laos mountains. these hmong fought the communists with the french secret services then the us and that's why the reds are doing a genocide. voila. now there are still puppets like mrsilly46 to make false claims and support ridiculous conspiracy theories. by the time of dien bien phu laos and cambodia were fully independent though the french defend them.
PierreBraquemard 1 year ago
@MrHarry46 not only rubber but they also wanted viet nam to be their colony like the philippines, korea and japan. it was also a strategic settlement to contain china from all directions. america was so bitter that they could not win the war so they bombard the country to rubble.
vntiger 1 year ago
@vntiger did the us made a colony out of west germany...
PierreBraquemard 1 year ago
@PierreBraquemard not only west germany but entire germany.
vntiger 1 year ago
@vntiger last time i checked germany was a free country who copposed the us in the irak war, and communist viet nam invaded laos.
PierreBraquemard 1 year ago
@PierreBraquemard check again because American has around 49 army base sitting in Germany. Germany oppose Iraq but insist on staying in Afghanistan, isn't that what America is doing right now? but wait. they still haven't left Iraq... Actually they're sending 30,000 more troops into Iraq to "fight for freedom". Millions of Iraqi civilians already dead as America entered Iraq. Who's the communist invading who now?
vntiger 1 year ago
yes the germans have us bases because they were not allowed by others (eg de gaulle) to raise a true army. as a consequence they are kind of protectorate of the us. the french are in afghanistan but opposed the iraq war. iraq war was us bullshit to control oil but afghanistan is the craddle of terrorism. the communists have invaded georgia last year do you remember and the vietnamese and lao armies are making a genocide over the montagnard hmongs do you know that?
PierreBraquemard 1 year ago
@PierreBraquemard says the propaganda machine. actually Russia is a democratic federation not communist, maybe your knowledge is too poor to debate about politics. you cannot oppose a war and then enter it, then you'd be a hypocrite. you want to talk about genocide talk about America genocide in Japan, Viet Nam, Korea, Philippines, Laos, Cambodia, Iraq, Afghanistan, Cuba etc. first then we can talk about Viet Nam and Hmong.
vntiger 1 year ago
@vntiger its you who don"t have a clue aboutr calling poilitics. calling germany an us colony and claiming the us did a genocide in japan shows you are pretty limited.
PierreBraquemard 1 year ago
@PierreBraquemard get that big rubber dildo out of your flaming liberal butt and grow some balls man!. its not like you have abrain or anything. I think your brains have oozed out of you pock marked face pores. its lost whackbags such as yourself that make this world a weaker more unstable place
MrHarry46 1 year ago
@PierreBraquemard we love people our and neiborhood, now get your ass back to france. or your french fried.
colt35 1 year ago
@PierreBraquemard woa! woa! there big gay horsie! get that rubber boner out of your butt gayboi! you ugly pock marked frenchie fag!! its too bad you dont get pussy fagboi, but...you dont like girls anyways. NOW youre trying to act like you know something! LOGODDAMNEDMOTHERFUCKING L. as your gay world turns you STILL, as in STILL MISSED MY ENTIRE POINT, why?...you got rubber boners up your ass and you cant see the trees for the rubber boners!!LOL USA was in vietnam because OF RUBBER S2UPID!!
MrHarry46 1 year ago
sut you you son of prostitute get off of this video already you fat bastard. you are a piece of shit i don't want to waste my time with with traitors like you. go to hell and stick your rubber dildo in your ass. all the deads of utah beach shit on your head.
PierreBraquemard 1 year ago
@PierreBraquemard hahaha poor little dildo licker. poor frenchie. I beat your ass fair and square now ya got a little attitude problem huh....poor little baby. ya just cant get that rubber dildo out of your mind can ya ..HA HA HA HA. whatever kidd. if it werent for the deads at omaha beach youd be speaking german right now FAG FACE
MrHarry46 1 year ago
@MrHarry46 he's just mad because the Vietnamese made a joke out of his army.
vntiger 1 year ago
@vntiger i'm laughing because idiots like both of you are still fed up with red propaganda. it wasn't the french army but only an expeditionary corps and it didn't fought alone but with the vietnamese national army, laos army and cambodia army against stinky communists. the french union army made a joke of the viet minh at na san and other battles.
PierreBraquemard 1 year ago
@PierreBraquemard at dien bien phu there was 1 vs 5 ratio from french union versus vietminh, that demonstrates the viet minh was a joke. the vietnamese communist army is actually only good for making a genocide over the hmong people.
PierreBraquemard 1 year ago
@PierreBraquemard you're saying that the French savior for the Vietnamese, Cambodian and Laos from the communist? you filthy pest. you animals tortured those people for over 50 years and in the end when they beat your ass you claim that you came to save them? it's so funny because after WW2, you animals came into Viet Nam exported all the rice back to France and starved millions of people to death. everything to you is communist propaganda, maybe the only truth is that you're a dumb ass.
vntiger 1 year ago 31
@vntiger red propaganda that's exactly what you are doing, calling germany an us colony and us genocide in japan shows it all. you don't know what those terms are. what red pigs like you don't mention is the french created the state of vietnam and that there were more vietnamese fighting with the french than with the viet minh. and don't you dare mention torture the viet minh torture the french union POWs and killed 3/4 of them from dien ben phu. you animal blocked pierrebraquemard's account.
YouStinkyReds 1 year ago
@YouStinkyReds lol more viet fight for the french then the viet minh? then maybe the french should've won. you dumb ass.
vntiger 1 year ago 3
@vntiger that's fact idiot compare the numbers and compare the DEATH TOLL between the FRENCH UNION and the silly VIET MINH. murder by numbers you monkey! :D
YouSmellyReds 1 year ago
@vntiger FINALLY china russia and u are more capitalist than american. why fighting?
chrisbreizh29 1 year ago
@chrisbreizh29 we never wanted to fight anyone, fightng came to us. has viet nam ever invaded america, france or china? they all came to our home and harassed our people. what would you do if someone came into your home and hurt your family? we were not fighting for capitalism or communism, we were fighting to keep our home and today we stop fighting and even forgave american, chinese and french for their unforgivable deeds in our homeland, because that's the true face of the vietnamese people.
vntiger 1 year ago 44
@vntiger dude i know how u feel.
hienhao 1 year ago
@vntiger
Shame it had to happen like this, but history likes to repeat herself. The pacifist people get invaded by the strongest ones. Other pacific nations turn out aggressive to avoid being invaded themselves etc
Kamfrenchie 1 year ago
@vntiger How come that the north attacked the south if the only wanted to protect their country?! thats pretty dumb to me if you are saying that you only protected your country.
7thcavalary 8 months ago
@7thcavalary: the first step to answer this question is to think of Vietnam as one whole country, no north, no south. Cheers!
handsomehoang 7 months ago
@handsomehoang Yes but you couldn't see Vietnam as a "whole" country during the war -.-
7thcavalary 7 months ago
@vntiger i love how you keep talking has if you were tehre when you probably werent even born during the war. and im sorry but everything you have been told has been propaganda since birth. and im not saying its unique to your country. every country does that to make itself seem better or more right to each new generation. now stop it with your self righteous rant, you werent there so stfu.
KevFil 7 months ago
@KevFil
STFU bitch
warfwar91 7 months ago
@warfwar91 if thats your best argument then taht just proves me right. go back to your mom you little shit.
KevFil 6 months ago
@KevFil
LOLOLOLOLOLOLOSER!!!
:D :D :D
FAIL, just utter fail
warfwar91 6 months ago
@warfwar91 yep. you are retarded. we all know it, you can stop showing it off now.
KevFil 6 months ago
@KevFil
HAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAAHA!
(you're hilarious)
p.s.
STFU bitch
warfwar91 6 months ago
@vntiger US should have nuked Hanoi and prevent the entire of Vietnam falling to communism. How is the Ho Chi Minh's doctrine working for ya?
fxnooodle 4 months ago
@fxnooodle ,the USA was poor and sick at that time, because the American people againsted this dirty war; the GI must came back to their home
PetainPhilippe 2 months ago
@vntiger 5 dollar humpy humpy?
firebirdcas 2 months ago
Your country is a dirty bastard,Good on the viet cong for kicking you corrupt shower of fuckers right out,They were fighting for there freedom.
Kingdoc1976 1 year ago
@Kingdoc1976 fuck you bastard. your corrupted country was kicked at suez in 1956, those sweety egyptians were fighting for freedom blablabla truth is it was the french who devised and made the canal of suez thanks to ferdinand de lesseps while you english bitches tried to prevent the french from doing it you bastards. now fuck off you roastbeef. the vietcong bastards were fighting for communism while south vietnam was fighting for freedom with the french. vietnamese refugees came to france.
MerguezFurtive 1 year ago
@Kingdoc1976 i'm glad your dirty country was kicked in afganistan two time before even the soviets get there. look at you bastard the english who killed the australian natives to establish a colony giving lessons to the others. you are a funny guy.
MerguezFurtive 1 year ago
@YouStinkyReds the brazenness is typical trait of white invaders from France and America
50poiuyt 1 year ago
@vntiger amen
bloodazn 1 year ago
@vntiger don't be so angry, these things are too complicated for people like you, you simplify everything
FabuleuxFab6 1 year ago
@FabuleuxFab6 i have to simplify things for these delusion minded. if people actually watched this video before they make up stories and theories then i wouldnt be so angry and vietnam war/history isn't so complicated. basically viet minh vs french puppet... viet cong vs american puppet. simple as that. all 3 million lives at the cost of separatist following their master's trail to "independence" where the french's defeat should've solved the entire situation of Vietnamese independence.
vntiger 1 year ago
Westerners always like to style themselves as saviors of the world when they are really history's greatest robbers. For over 500 years, they steal from the world. They displaced the people the Americas and Australia. They carved up Africa, conquered India and parts of China. They divided up Southeast Asia amongst themselves. They enslaved and killed millions, committing the greatest global genocide in history. And these people want us to think of them as saviors? Sorry, you're out of luck.
RoniCMaster 1 year ago 16
@RoniCMaster GREAT HISTORIAN
colt35 1 year ago
@RoniCMaster well, the backwardness of most part of the world then had caused these things to be inevitable. If the world could make a change like japs did quick enough, these would have been avoided. For time and tide waits for no man. In the survival of the fittest, change is required for failing, would render you marginalised and eventually extinct. Harsh reality, but true in life as a whole.
y2kenag 1 year ago
@vntiger
How did thing go after France and USA left? In term of conditions of life, rights etc?
Kamfrenchie 1 year ago
@vntiger
Stop your preaching. You might have won the war, but you certainly lost the peace. Period. End of discussion.
BillyBoy2071 1 year ago
Comment removed
BillyBoy2071 1 year ago
@PierreBraquemard uh, the French were successful the early part of the war, but the latter half of the war, they pretty much had their asses handed to them by the Viet Minh. These are FACTS, Pierre.
The 'stinky communists' were able to whip the hell out of the French, and went on to outlast (if not out fight) the Americans. What did the French go on to do? Oh yeah, the got their asses kicked out of Algeria as well.
No 'red propoganda'...it's a FACT the French lost their empire.
neoconsnightmare3 1 year ago
pierre here, our good communist friend blocked my other account :) THAT IS COWARDICE like hoilungly answering to only "Pierre" so i don't get his answer. well, don't you, an american, dare teach me the history of france please and especially this part, how could you understand what's the algerian war was about? about indochina you've only heard of dien bien phu and that's all (without knowing 37 CIA pilots flew there with 2 KIA!). in fact you're all wrong. i've sent an argumented answer. :)
YouSmellyReds 1 year ago
@PierreBraquemard This was more than 50 years ago, dude ! Now everyone has his jobs to do in a very normal life ! It's non-sense if you'll still seat here in this topic and suck your own dick to make clear who went right or wrong ! Hehehe...
Perhaps, you still need to know if your French shit is still in VN, huh ? Yeah, it's still there and smells to bad
annpbtma 1 year ago
@annpbtma what are you talking about you asshole. fact is our good friend vntiger blocked my accounts so i can't answer him. fuck you asshole, its been 50 years blablabla why are you here on this video posting BS you idiot?! forget about it.
MerguezFurtive 1 year ago
@MerguezFurtive Did I said to you, shit mouth ? Maybe shit is your favourite & you like everyone gives it to you ? Trying to perfect English, huh ? It's better to you moron to give your mom a blowjob! Mother fucker
annpbtma 1 year ago
@annpbtma i shit in your mouth, in yours and in your mommy too you short dick boy.
MerguezFurtive 1 year ago
@MerguezFurtive How childish you are ! Your mother could have not enough dicks to suck before giving birth to you, boy ? Give me your mon's address. I can go to teach her a real fuck. It's better to her to give better education to other births, not a shit like you anymore. Remember sucking a French dicks 1 hundred times to show your admirability, dickhead
annpbtma 1 year ago
@annpbtma i fuck you in the ass you gay retard. the french shitted in your viet mouth from 1881 to 1956. things are hard i know but that's life, your country is populated with cowards and your ancestries were dogs that were ruled by rhe french. now jusr look at vietnam all women ther are prostitutes, just like your mother and even you.
MerguezFurtive 1 year ago
@MerguezFurtive it's stupid if I again waste my minutes of life to talk to a shit like you. You're even not a shit in your white race.You just need to find a wall and fuck yourself on it and say VIVAS MY DICKHEAD FRANCE !!! HEHEHE, LMAO
annpbtma 1 year ago
@annpbtma one last word for you, shit ! Your France is only a chicken-hearted sturdy country. Humiliated in 2 WWs. Sniff behind the asses of Britain & US to regain your power. Even in DBP, De Castries was even kicked in his ass by Vietminh. Wonder if this general had orders to clean Giap's toilets ?? Asshole, next time, don't shit your bravo France by a fake name. It's not French at all. Or you're just a son of a French dickhead and a Latin whore ?
annpbtma 1 year ago
@annpbtma if you think france was humiliated in world war 1 then you know absolutely nothing about world war 1. we would not have won if not for france.
grandpathong 1 year ago
@MerguezFurtive The Image of the French waved white flags to Vietnamese in Dien Bien Phu do not be less shameful by your dumb comment,idiot
50poiuyt 1 year ago
@MerguezFurtive I fart in your general direction. Your mother was a hamster and your father smelt of elderberries.
Now go away or I shall taunt you a second time.
freeasthewinds 1 year ago 4
@MerguezFurtive lol you're pathetic, it's so sad that you have to make fake accounts to talk bullshit here and spread your hate instead of using your current account to do that in another video. why do I block you? because you're a dumb ass, with no education. this video is too much information for you to interpret.
vntiger 1 year ago
@MrHarry46 shut up you piecve of shiy
PierreBraquemard 1 year ago
@vntiger I agree with half your statement. the USA wanted rubber. no imperialist country, such as the USA is....wants any country for any other reason than MONEY. Comodities. Its been going on since the dawn of time. one group of apes invade anothers colony. classic, classic ape doctrine. and americans, along with poor little mrPeirreBoneLicker think theyre so above it all!!..LOL
MrHarry46 1 year ago
@MrHarry46 actually. I forgot to mention that Viet Nam is also a oil rich at sea. this information many people don't know about.
vntiger 1 year ago
@MrHarry46 you're right about the rubber though, Viet Nam had a huge plantation for rubber.
vntiger 1 year ago
@vntiger visit ANRPC's website. vietnam is one of the top ten natural rubber producing countries on the planet. rubber is a 150 billion dollar a year industry.
58000 americans and over 3 million vietnamese are still dead. PierreBonelicker is a fucking whackbag brainwashed retard.
MrHarry46 1 year ago
@vntiger vietnam had a large number of assholes thats why the french conquered it and stayed there so many time.
PierreBraquemard 1 year ago
@MrHarry46 who brought the rubber in vietnam stupid dick? without the french settlers work, the vietnam would had remain in the stone age. actually you have the limited sense of a caveman yourself.
PierreBraquemard 1 year ago
@PierreBraquemard The war do not be won by bragging,but by braveness,brightness,that you didn't have ,moron
50poiuyt 1 year ago
@50poiuyt bragging? bragging is all of you communist vietnamese are doing being you vntiger or this mrstinky46. at dien bien phu the french union fighters had the equivalent of 1 division when the viet minh had 5 divisions, although the french union killed much more viet minh, the latter killed 3/4 of the french union POWs which is more than at the siege. it says much about whos bragging and whos brave. all 3 of you are red assholes.
YouStinkyReds 1 year ago
PierreBonelicker: your face is pockmarked like a fucking rubber loving dildo sucking drug addict. too bad youre too weak and broken to defeat me. I AM the king here not you. you cant get pussy so you suck cock.whatever its your life gayboi
MrHarry46 1 year ago
@MrHarry46 you talk trash because your skull is full of shit. all you deserve is to get your ass kicked. you don't have a clue about vietnam and you are a useless piece of shit so get off this video, stop your nonsense comments now and put your rubberdick in your ass it wall calm you down. you are an idiot.
PierreBraquemard 1 year ago
the vietnam war was all about lies, cover-ups, deceptions, death. once the major rubber players(Goodyear Firestone Cooper Michellin) realized that the american people arent very smart NOR do they have the guts to hold their government accountable,they were HELL bent on capitalizing on that fact. christ...its open season on dumbfucks!!....WOOOOO!!!. THERES MONEY TO BE MADE!!! thats how it works in this world. sorry kidds. greed kills. americans are so very stupid
MrHarry46 1 year ago
@ Harry: US came to VN to contain the spread of the Red wave according to the Domino Theory ~_~
ChipBeo 1 year ago
@ChipBeo the US supported the Vietminh against the french in 1946 because they wanted to do business with indochina. in 1950 the communist chinese defeated the republic, recognized hochiminh and started to massively supply the viet minh. against this the US started to support the french by paying 80% of the indochina war fee and supplying them with aircrafts, carriers, tanks, weapons etc. they invented the domino theory to justify the french support vis a vis their domestic opposition.
PierreBraquemard 1 year ago
@PierreBraquemard in 1949 france gave independence to vietnam, laos and cambodia. the state of vietnam fought with the french against the viet minh. the us and uk recognize bao dai's state of vietnam in 1950. mrharry46 believes the us invaded normandy for rubber. he's an idiot.
PierreBraquemard 1 year ago
exactly. the "domino theory" and "THE RED SCARE" were tactics the US gov propaghanda machine use to "convince" americans to go to another country and kill any human being they decided to. fact is, Secretary of Defense at the time, and former Ford Motor Company exec Robert McNamara, upon his death, appologized to all the vets families and all the men who served in vietnam for lieing about the Gulf of Tonkin incident that catapulted USA into "war" with vietnam.(it never happened)
MrHarry46 1 year ago
@MrHarry46 in your case itsTHE TARD SCARE. all you need is to be clubbed to death with a rubberdick.
PierreBraquemard 1 year ago
@ChipBeo the true sorce of the "domino theory" is that if USA lost vietnam...GoodYear Firestone Cooper and Michellin, would not have enough rubber to make car tires. Ford Chrysler and GM would fall like "dominos" because they would have NO RUBBER car tires to put on their cars. take 6 months and think about this. 58000 americans and over 3 million vietnamese are still dead over RUBBER.
MrHarry46 1 year ago
@MrHarry46 you are an idiot. the us landed at utah beach for rubber is it? you piece of shit want rubber for your ass.
PierreBraquemard 1 year ago
@PierreBraquemard no no no stupid. thats an entirely DIFFERENT war GAYBOI
MrHarry46 1 year ago
PierreBonelicker.....youre about as ignorant and as your good buddy FreeChicken101rst. youre obviously a paid gov schill (FR) continuing the propaganda campaign. fact is, Vietnam is one of the top ten producers of natural rubber in the world. google ANRPC. youll see. cant bullshit me kidd. 58000 americans are still dead over rubber and shitsuckers like you are still trying to cover up WHY. its asslicks like you who keep the uninformed, uninformed. youre a waste of life. goodbye
MrHarry46 1 year ago
@MrHarry46 shut up you stinky piece of shit. the only thing about rubber is you use to stick it in your red ass. when the french conquered indochina no one cared about rubber you piece of shit. the thing about indochina was laos's opium now shut the fuck off and go into the jungle to hunt the only remaining hmong that your stinky dictatorship called vietnam is exterminating. hmong genocide thats what red laos and vietnam are doing you assholes.
PierreBraquemard 1 year ago
@PierreBraquemard dont tell me to shut up you gay assloving dicksniffer! youre as queer as queer gets stinky fag!!
if you cant handle the truth TOO BADD. stinky fags like you dont matter anyways.
dont even think of telling me what to do STINKY FAG. why get so upset when I expose the truth STINKY FAG? what have you got to lose?.STINKY FAG!!.youre agay little boy who is still trying to cover up the truth STINKY FAG.58000 americans are STILL DEAD, STINKY FAG
MrHarry46 1 year ago
@MrHarry46 your problem with rubber is you don't want to share it with the other nations because you want it all to make rubberdicks and stick them in your arse.
PierreBraquemard 1 year ago
Comment removed
MrHarry46 1 year ago
Comment removed
MrHarry46 1 year ago
FreeChicken101rst.....you cant prove me wrong. 1rst.....youre too chickenshit.... 2nd youre not intelligent enough to know anything about vietnam at all except what your gov brainwashed you to believe. grow up kid....then get fucked
MrHarry46 1 year ago
why did you always force us give weapon ?
50poiuyt 1 year ago
HOWARD STERN'S PENIS
nigger nigger nigger
MegaGewehr 1 year ago
hahah HAHAHAHA
TheStrawberryLolicon 1 year ago
@uatwmf Oh and haha no john wayne doesnt have the last word its either chuck norris or rambo =)
trojanhorse1994 2 years ago
@uatwmf you cant change the human heart, if he wants something he will do anything to get it, but im not saying I hate humans im just saying, it would a great wait amazing place if it was just peace, but theres none what so ever in this world, we have gangs war terrorist jihadist revolotionist, its just like we will always have wars till the end hate to break it to you
trojanhorse1994 2 years ago
very good documentary
lucirz 2 years ago
pure propaganda. USA was in vietnam for RUBBER. in the 1800's France invaded/colonized vietnam and by 1960 Michellin(FR) had VAST rubber tree plantations growing there. US tire makers depend on natural rubber to make car tires. if vietnam fell to the "commies" the entire US auto industry would have been devastated. USA would have NEVER spent the trillions it spent on vietnam JUST TO STOP THE SPREAD OF COMMUNISM. remember: its vietnam for RUBBER Iraq for OIL. americans NEVER fight for freedom
MrHarry46 2 years ago
shut your mouth u IGNORANT fuckface
rubber ?? hahahahaahaha x'D
Freebird101st 2 years ago
yeah yeah ...I KNOW it REALLY sucks when a person finaly finds out the REAL TRUTH about a matter
heartbreaking.....whatever
IF YOU CANT HANDLE THE TRUTH GET THE FUCK OUT OF MY COUNTRY
"freebird101st" is just another broken,weak, redneck with no brains
MrHarry46 2 years ago
LOL im not from the USA
faggot
Freebird101st 2 years ago
the real truth about vietnam : rubber HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAahahahhaha x'D
Freebird101st 2 years ago
Comment removed
MrHarry46 2 years ago
fail. im from europa
Freebird101st 2 years ago
@MrHarry46 HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH rubbbberrrr xD
we got here a true polpot suporter
Freebird101st 1 year ago
youre not intelligent enough to tell me what to do dicklick. its obvious since you havent done the research. the reason you havent done the research is because youre a chickenshit with no brains who CANT HANDLE THE TRUTH. goodbye asshole
MrHarry46 1 year ago
@MrHarry46 and you're not even in vietnam you live in the us while you are peacocking about communist vietnam.... you are the biggest piece of shit ever!!
PierreBraquemard 1 year ago
@MrHarry46 fuck you asshole!
PierreBraquemard 1 year ago
@Freebird101st
the worst is this piece of shit lives in the us not in vietnam. rubber? wtf?! he must smoke rubber. :)
PierreBraquemard 1 year ago