Added: 2 years ago
From: PianoKidElaine369
Views: 2,688
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (48)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • What actual grade is this piece?

  • very beautiful playing, Elaine.

  • Elaine you are very good

  • sehr gut gespielt. Es hat mir sehr gefallen. Weiter so. Du kannst viel erreichen.

  • Good, but there are some a bit akward tempo changes. Of course you are suppost to go a little faster during the 5ths/16ths (I dont know what notes those are) You speed up a little, more than is needed.

  • By the "5ths/16ths" do you mean the B section of this piece?

  • around 00:34 are some wrong notes :( but other than that it's great.

  • Omgsh! you did amazing! =)

    may I ask what level is this song?

  • This is a level/grade 9 piece. I've seemed to have improved even more since I posted this up on youtube, so I will post a final version of it in Nov./Dec. Thanks for watching!

  • when you're on about grade 9, are you talking about diploma level?

  • Well done. 5*.

  • thanks!

  • Well played. Lots of good work on it. A little rough here and there though. I think this piece will sound great if you come back to it a couple of years. You'll be much more at ease with the piano and can focus on the expression.

    Your piano could use some tuning.

  • Nice job, Elaine! Great to see as a teenager you keep enjoying playing piano in addition to your other hobbies. Keep up with the good work!

  • Very nice, Elaine!

    Good luck and hope you will be able to play it at your Chinese School Talent Show!

  • Thank you!

  • Well done :) 5*

    Thomas

  • Thank you!

  • Really nice job!

  • thanks!

  • Wow. You are a very talented and well-rounded girl. Way to go!!!

  • Thank you for your kind words:)!

  • Great job Elaine!

  • Good job Elaine!

  • thanks

  • Hi Elaine, you played it so well. I really like it.

  • Thanks Chester!

  • Wonderful!You are very talented!

  • Thank you so much!!!

  • It is beautiful!

  • Thanks!

  • Hi Elaine,

    You did it awesome

  • Thanks Ben!

  • Wonderful, Elaine! Great job! 5*

  • Thanks!

  • Hi Elaine! That was really fine playing. I like how you've really improved it. It's great. *****

  • Thanks Magnus!

  • I love Chopin, Elaine. Thank you for playing it so well!

  • Thanks Ben and Gabriel!

  • Excellent!

  • Thank you Eric!

  • that video was great elaine

  • Thanks Aidan, I'm glad you liked it!

  • What a big improvement you made in a month in terms of speed, phrasing, and artistry. It sounds like a pretty hard piece to me and you played it so effortlessly.

    You go girl!

  • Thank you so much for your encouraging comment!!!!!!

  • WOW!!  You're fast!

  • Beautifully played, Elaine! And I love this piece too. Great Job!!!

  • Thanks Tiffany!

  • This is beautiful Elaine. You play beautifully in any setting!

  • Thanks for your kind comment!

  • Wonderful, Elaine! (*^^*)

  • Thank you!

  • Very nice, Elaine! Great practice!

  • Thanks!

  • Terrific effort Elaine.. Keep at it, you're doing very well. I didn't know you were learning so many instruments at the same time. That certainly must keep you pretty busy.

    Reach for the stars.

    In tune

    Lalita

  • Thank you Lalita!

  • Hi Elaine, good job. Some suggestions for improvement: Your notes in the Piu mosso are not uniformly clear. If you play the run at the end of the piu mosso louder in volume as you go up in pitch, I think it will sound better. Your Lento needs more rubato. That will bring out the emotion more. I love this waltz and it was a pleasure watching. Abhik.

  • Thanks for the advice Abhik!

  • Hi Elaine !

    I'm working on this piece too. I think you still need just a little more work to be excellent =)

    There are some parts where I loved the nuances, like in the beginnig, and others where I found it a little bit rough.

    And at the part that biggins at 0:44 , you miss some notes. It's a quite difficult part, so try to play it slower first. And at 0:56 , it should be pianossimo.

    But overall, you did a good job ! Keep it up ;)

  • Thanks for your advice, I agree on the "pp" to be played but I didn't miss out any notes, I think it's because I played the left hand too loud, that covered the right hand melody, I'm still trying to work out how to play the left hand softer.

  • Absolutely Wonderful playing, 5 *****. Sry to say but i disagree with u! I'm learning this song too but on my sheet is doen't show pianisimo at that part. Also why r u critisizing a kid that's just turned 12, it's talented to even attempt this at that age!

  • I'm not critikising her at all !

    I love her playing ! I just thought she'll appreciate some advices just to be more professional, and I don't mean that she's not a great pianist !

    Cause If I post a video, I'll be very glad to recieve advices too !

  • I totaly agree with you! I know that you weren't critisising me and the advice you gave me was very useful!

  • Elaine, give you 5 stars :)

  • Thanks for the rating!

  • Excellent, very well played... Gaby is just really enjoying Chopin, he is praxticing his second chopin but he really enjoys this one. David & Gaby!

  • Thanks for the comment, When Gaby is ready with his second Chopin post it on youtube. I will be looking forward to it!

  • you are so good cuz ... you get 5 stars!!

  • Thanks!

  • Really beautiful song! Five Stars!

  • Thank you!

  • Yes I study guitar, violin and harmonica. That was the guitar but I don't have a teacher for all those instruments except for piano.

  • Thanks Bill!

  • Great job!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Thank you very much Hannah!

  • I really like it :D

    ***** Stars for you .

  • Thank you!

  • WOW!!! THAT WAS AMAZING!!!!

  • Thank you for the BIG COMPLIMENT!

  • Good improvement, Elaine!

  • Thanks Arthur & Angeni!

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more