Added: 4 years ago
From: JackMcConnell
Views: 150,186
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (430)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Damn, she looks so fucking awkwark, making all of these faces and shit.

  • she only won cos she's very alpha compared to the other girls... but the other girls (chelsea an melissa) are way more talented

  • everything's anoying! she overemphasizes the line "i dont need a ring around my finger" she says "i dont need a ring around myyyyyyyyy finger". and another, her fingers suck! its moving too much!!!

  • LOL omg her voice... it sounds like shes takin a shit.

  • she was wack

  • if you pay attention you can hear at 0:35 that is edited , just listen her voice, it changes. haha she totally didn't deserve w

  • Her voice annoys me. It's like she's forcing it out.

  • Asia only won because they were afraid Melissa Reyes was too good and thought that she would be more popular than Nicole Scherzinger (since they were both filipino). SO Asia only won because they thought she wouldn't outshine Nicole ever. I think it's kinda stupid. Melissa.R should've won. And plus Asia wanted to go solo.

  • why is she so jerky? :S

  • Melissa R should've won

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • chelsea is accually in a girl group right now

    paradiso girls there pretty good!!

  • @darylovleynewaccount I think Chelsea not trying hard was the reason she didn't make it...

    Her dancing, for instance.

  • Asia won because the judges knew that whoever made the group wouldn't sing one note anyway so the decision was mostly based off of stage presence....which I still think Melissa R had over Asia also

  • i probably commented on this a million times cause i watched it a million times lol but now looking back these performances from that night..I think they based the winner from the performance of lady marmalade and weather you like it or not Asia was the best there

    it wouldnt make since and it's unfair for them to base it off the solo's cause Asia had an upbeat song while Melissa and Chelsea had ballads..

  • Melissa R should have won! :-/ Chelsea was amazing aswell... so why did Asia win?!

  • Chelsea is the best

  • I thinnk she was the best out of akk the girls. Why does everyone hate on her?

  • OMG READ!!!

    im happy she one cause she sang the u know nice

    songs and the others sang slow quiet songs

    i hate those and that proves she was to be a pussycat doll!!

    THUMPS UP!!

  • i hate the way she stand it just makes her look weirddd

    and melissa r was soo much better

  • I don't care what anyone else says, Asia KILLED it! She owned the stage & had a great voice. But most of all you could tell she had fun, it wasn't fake ♥

  • Ive always loved her since the start :)

  • asia killed it. dont hate.

  • I feel that Asia had a slight advantage over Melissa and Chelsea. She was given a much more upbeat and faster song compared to melissa and chelsea who both had slow songs. Asia had more opportunities to show the power in her voice and with faster songs it's easier to cover up a mistake in pitch without making the song sound horrible.

  • she's shit

  • i hate robins hair -.-

  • :-s.. it's the first time I hear about this competition.. I'm not a fan of PCD... but I really prefer asia to melisa or chelsea (I just watched their singing).... melissa looks better.. and maybe chelsea too... but asia sings better... melissa/chelsea's voice can be weak sometimes.... asia controls it better....

    but again, I am not a fan of these ladies... I have other standards in terms of music, range, tone...

  • Chelsea and Melissa R. were better to me!

  • Okay...asia can dance...I'll admit that...but I'm not a fan of her singing. =/

  • naw Asia dha shit dnt Hate

  • Why do you so hate her?

  • Honestly I think any of the 3 girls would have quit anyway. Just like most of the actual pussycat dolls did. I would hope if you actually have talent you would think you're better than standing in the background going "ohh ohh" and mimicking nicole's words.

  • i love asia wanted and now she was gna win was so upset wen she never became a pcd

  • ahh boooo

  • u rock

  • SUUUCH a fake audience insertion at 1:26~ 1:28... -___-;;

  • YOU KILLED IT ASIAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA­AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA­AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA­AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA­AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA­AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA­AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA­AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA

  • YAY ASIA SHE DESERVED TO WIN...HER VOICE IS SOOO DIFFERENT FROM EVRYONE ELSE...POINT BLANK...IM GLAD SHE WON GO ASIA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! DOIN YOUR THANGGG...

  • CHELSEA OR MELIZZAA R . BESTTT !!!!

  • ugh, her smile at the end was so ackward looking..

  • She had a very nasal voice...eeek...but she ain't bad.

  • This performance was awesome when i saw this performance for the first time i knew she was gonna win

  • honestly, everyone knows that melissa or Chelsea should've won. but I'm sure Robin and the rest chose Asia because she won't stand out and make Nicole look bad. Melissa and Chelsea on the other hand would. Hope you get my drift lol

  • What was the point of these girls joining PCD when they'll probably have no chance of singing other than just dancing on the background

  • Lei canta con il naso -.-"

  • Lmao yahh need to stfu , i bett all yahh whitee too . smh' pettyy ascell ! Yahh couldd do bettaa ?

  • she singing from her nose

  • this girrl sings with her nose!! she cant sing!

  • i didnt like asia, i was rooting for other people, but she had talent, and she owned this song. so stop hating.

  • they didnt do the ending 3 songs right they gave chelsea and melissa r slow songs that dont require as much energy they gave asia this fast fun song that everyone got into and stuff i just always thought it was unfair the way they did that

  • I think the resluts of this comptetion would have been different if one of the other Dolls had judged the girls instead of Lil Kim. I don't have anything against Lil kim but what does she have to do with the Pussycat Dolls?

  • Well, Asia is certainly not Céline, but she rocked that tune! So WHATEVER! I enjoyed it. Alot.

  • Asia just sucks.

  • @Ronsley I agree. I think she's just trying too hard.

  • @Ronsley Can you do better ?? :P 

  • im sorry but asia can't really sing. good dancer but cant sing for shit

  • well after the show they all became famous people found malissa r and chelsea and asia has been on victoria secret modle shows and modles for diddy also. and for the ppl who think she cant sing. she gave up singing

  • LOL the question is why people are still hating on a girl that doesnt even know y'all exist? like. the show ended like a year ago. give it a rest. damn.

    ppl on youtube.

  • chelsea . cheslea . chelsea .

  • i love asia :--D

  • I have no idea why Asia won and not Melissa R. fuck.

  • LOOK, they did on purpose to give Asia an upbeat song, and Chelsea and Melissa a low-tempo song so Asia would "possibly" have a better performance because they did on purpose for her to win! See, Chelsea and Melissa would outshine Nicole, who is the main doll, and that's not what they wanted. They wanted someone "okay"-ish. And that's what they got.. sorta.. until Asia pulled a hissy fit and quit because she said she'd be better off as a solo artist. Look how great that turned out... XD

  • whatever!!! they saw something in her!!!!

  • Why do ppl put her done she a realy good singer like why don't you go up there and sing actually

  • ahwa shit! compasred to chealsea and melissa r!

  • More like she doesnt need to sound like a man . LOL

  • She isn't that great, and her voice makes me cringe =/ what's with the way she danced? she kept bouncing around like she needed to use the restroom

  • Nobody could be as bitchy as much as her :// sry

  • Her gestures and facial expressions like at 1:05 is what Robin loved about her so much.

  • kay. from my point of view.

    she wasn't good.

    they could of at least picked melissa r.

    i love chelsea, she's my favorite, but she couldn't dance the best.

    they should of picked melissa r. and gave chelsea a record deal as a soloist or something.

  • @emmajade25

    I agree, Asia was horrible, but I think that Melissa R was too good to be a background dancer for the Pussycat Dolls, she looks much like Nichole and she could be competition for her. Chelsea is now one of the three lead singers of the Paradiso Girls. But still...Asia was a bad singer and a very good dancer! 'Perfect' for the Pussycat Dolls.

  • Horrible!

  • Ohh my god, i hated her, she had a TERRIBLE voice, i cant understand how she won :/

  • terrible voice!

  • she's good even though i like chelsea waaaaaaaaaaayyyyyyyy betteer than her i know she's the deserving winner but what she did was totally wrong because it makes other people think that the search for the etc.... made a pretty big waste because of her!

    if she wants to quit she should've w8 a bit longer !!

  • she suuuucks, melissa reyes was way better vocally, and much prettier.

  • I like her a lot... she kind of has to work on her phrasing (this song was probably a bit too fast), but she has great stage presence, and her voice itself has a nice tone and range.

  • this performance was hott. people are just hating because they cant take that her voice is hgih pitched but tbh asia cant help it, thats just her natural singing voice - high pitched. and if your not hating over that then your hating that she left pcd but tbh who wouldnt ? she wouldnt even get to sing anyway so hush with ya negativity.

  • she is a great performer she just sounds nasaly

  • the best person one...shame we couldn't c her in PCD

  • no I think she should have won because would she really sing much in pcd? It's mostly nicole, and everyonce in a while melody, everyone else is really backup, and so really she just needs to be a good performer

  • Yeah it's true, Asia captured the audience more.. She know how to performance. Melissa looked like a Nicole's twin too much? But she should have won cuz she really wanted to win but Asia just left??

  • @DiamondedOne just because melissa wanted to win doesnt mean she should have. all of them wanted to win. even melissa r but she was jus boring and a bitch on the sly.

  • someone's jealous of melissa

  • why would i be jealous of melissa?? you dont even know me LOL

  • because she's talented and pretty

    your right i don't know you but jealous people will right comments about melissa calling her a bitch and hey your one of them

  • @xXxS4BZxXx lol there are loads of talented and pretty people out there. i dont have to be jealous of anyone for that because everyone is unique, and if you know what a jealous person would right then maybe your one of em. im a fan of both melissa's but neither are perfect, so what have i got to be jealous of ? gosh, i really dont care for your opinon, unless you know me in real life, your chattin internet trash which means nothing to me.

  • @FabulosityCANDY if your a fan of both

    why did you call melissa sly and all that and it aint me who's jealous love

    likewise

  • how the hell did she win . lol

  • LMFAO. I was watching this and my older brother came into the living room. and asked the same thing.

  • Melissa R or Chelsea had to win!!!

  • @mopmopgrapgrap chelsea!

  • @mopmopgrapgrap who won? xD

  • asia

    

  • @helena7773 Asia, but she left the Pussycat Dolls after a few weeks or months!

  • her voice gets kinda anyyoing

  • het voice doesn't sound pleasant at all

  • yeah. melissa shoulda won, but asia was amazing, but i hate how she like twitches her hand on the microphone when she's singing. :l

  • Its her natural verbrata and its really high and annoying.

  • @LOUISABABES ron fair hates it too lol. christina aguilera twitches her hand on her mic when shes singing aswell and asia said chrstina is idol so i wonder where she got the twitching hand thing from .. lol

  • I know everyone thinks that Melissa Reyes should have won the competition, but based on the finale, I say Asia deserved to win. Not saying Melissa did horrible, but Asia captured the audience more. But after Asia just quit, I definitely agree that Melissa should have won.

  • @MsCindyVo i agree. melissa's performance was okay. but a pussycat dolls performance cant just be okay it needs to be memorable and really capture the crowd.

  • yeah'! if she wanna quit she should've w8ed a lil bit longer! more a year of less i think!

  • you guys are are just hating especially you stadance..... she cann sing betta denn u so hushh and wayy prettier den u!!!

  • she's ugly&she sing like a man&look like one too.

  • you can't even get a man pleas ha ha

  • Melissa R was better""""

  • she quit tho

  • Asia was not the best!

  • absoluty truee!

  • you are all freaks she totaly deserved to win so shut up:)that smile si not for any of yous

  • Wouahhh =O i love it

  • she messes up at :35 n :36

  • she stays on tune at least...

    as Ron said the tune was good, but I do agree that in some parts she sounds like drowning!

    She sings with her nose so much!

    1:10 is the worst.

    But you have to admit she was the one with the largest belted vocal range! She did higher notes than Chelsea from the beginning.

  • i hate it how she like tap's like the mick ever 2 sec's.u suck bitch

  • I don't like Asia and I think she didn't deserve to win, but this perform was very great!

    (sorry for my English)

  • but she's not the bad, the BEST  is RELISSAR.

  • you ,, ooo ,, ooooeeee ! it sounds so weird

  • Asia is a good singing but in this song she sounded like she was drowning in so many of the notes.

    And what's with the nose noise at 1:06!!!

  • now that she is in the PCD, she will compete with melody with the "piercing voice"

  • she isn't in PCD. She quit after a week, or the next day or something because she wanted a solo career.

  • Everyone Is Lyk Omg She Has Not Got A Good Enuf Voice- Thats Ur Choice To Say That But Think Logically If She Was That Crap She Wuldnt Get This Far In The Show, Yuu Know!! I Think She Has A Great Voice But I Do Think There Are Others With A More Better Voice And A More Better Chance Than Winning But Dont Gt Me Rong I Do Think Shes Bloody Talented!!  Lots Of Luv Megz x

  • i loveeeee her she has an amazing voice i wish i could sing like her

  • Her voice isn't NATURAL,it's actually like she's copying the style of the way a singer sings. [IMITATION]

    but she's not that bad, but the BEST is MELISSA R.

  • i don't like the way asia sang

  • Oh cmon you think youd let a voice like that just be a "backup" for the pcd.

    Who the hell wouldn't wanna pursue a solo career after that?

  • WHY IS EVERYBODY DISAGREEING WITH SEIXEIR0's comment it soo true..

    asia has a great voice

  • she isn;t that good and shes not even a pussycat doll nemore?!?

  • SHE SUX!!!

    SHES NOT EVEN iiN THE FUCKiiN GROUP ANYMORE!!!

  • She is the best. I like her a lot ! :) Well done, Asia !

  • you know i dont like some parts of this song its like really weird some parts like when she sings For You but hey she still won

  • Where is she???I like her

  • Elle elle a de la voix !

  • I look at almost evry song she sang and i rlly still cant see y she won she cant sing well sum girls sing better them her.

  • I think too,she was better them Chelsea and Melissa r,for sure

  • asia... a singer? no...a dancer? no... a performer? maybe,mmm... no! Why was she One of the dolls??

    asia? une chanteuse? non...une danceuse? non, une interprète?? peut-etre,mmm... non! Pourquoi était-elle une des Doll?

  • i think asia's performance was hott:) it was great! but a lot of people just hate asia because melissa is prettier. and asia black. but i loveed melissa and i wanted her to win. but i thought asia deserved to win.

  • She's saying

    "I DUN NEED A MUN TO MAKE IT HEPUNNNNNN"

  • lol that's really funni

  • Essa menina não canta nada

  • i hav to admit this was awesome - her best

  • Asia killed this song. She may not be the best singer but she is decent. She is an awesome performer, and can dance her butt off. Go ASIA!!!!!!!

  • ahahah moi jparle FRENCH pis j'adoree Asia;)

    Cé la meilleure pis elle au moin a bitch pas le monde !!!!!!! =)

  • I LOVE YOU ASIA !! <3<3

  • Shes singing good but she looks..not must beutiful

  • She don't know how to sing SHE'S REALLY NOT GOOD!! SHE'S UGLY!!

  • I think Girlicious sings better than them.

  • Stop Making bad comments about Asia!How would it feel if you though you did something so good and you had bad comments?!It's not nice making fun of Asia.If you didn't like it then why did you watch it?!I loved her singing.

  • i agree with u. im a Asia fan. she sings better than anybody there in the competition.well, i like Melissa R. too but Asia N. is the best one

  • Are you on crack? She was the worst singer of the final three and if you talk to any professional they will agree. It has been emphasized that her talent is her performance in general. Chelsea had THE best voice, Melissa had great dancing and great singing, and Asia's dancing and performance were much stronger than the other two.

    Asia isn't a good singer.

  • are you on crack ?

    because asia is a good singer which is why she won ... robin is pretty dam professional and soo is ron fair and they were the ones who pick her to win so that would mean she is a good singer . Melissa R is not a very good singer look at her new song shes sounds horrible but she is an amazing dancer and is gogerouss just cant sing very well .

  • Obviously you didn't pay attention to what the judges, especially Ron, were saying. He mentioned several times that she was the least experienced singer on the show but her amazing dancing and over all appearance and performance is what kept her on the show. PCD has plenty of good singers, they didn't need someone like Chelsea who had great vocals but below par dancing. Melissa was a great dancer, and a good singer, but Asia was BETTER at dancing and performing.

  • (continued)

    Vocals weren't as important during the search, they needed someone to blend in well with the group who could present and perform like they do.

    Chelsea is a solo singer, Melissa is also someone fit more for a solo career. Asia is someone who needs to be in a group in order for her to succeed the way she could have.

    If you plan on telling me off, try spelling properly and use correct grammar. Also, get a grasp on what you're arguing because you sounded ridiculously stupid just then.

  • people need to stop hating because theres a reason she won cuz she the best so why is u looking at her stuff if u dont like her

  • Asia is so freakin awesome! Screw all u haterz. I knew from the moment i laid eyes on her she was gonna win. She's so awesome. and i dnt care wat any1 thinkz or says. She did this 4 her and her baby and i think she deserved it. so **** all u haterz. she won get ovr it! Asia ROCKS!

  • SHE SUCKS

  • i love this girl she is good

  • asia has a flat nose no offence...

  • she sounds good

  • In the words of Chelsea- She looks like she's suffering.

    Kind of sounds like it too. She's not the most horrific singer in the world, but this most definately wasn't the song for her.

  • OMG she's like bouncing and jerking all over the place..FREAK!!

  • mellisa should have won

  • she made a mess of it

  • Honestly, she sounds like a chicken :| should not have won, and she made vocal mistakes too

  • wow , so you know how a fucking chicken sounds , chicken dont talk letalone sing so what you just said was something at the top of your head to make your self sound like a fucking fool , cleary she can sing because she was the one that one , SHE STILL WON :). shes amamzing and cleary roibn though so to .

  • thxz bout time sum1 actually gave asia tha credit she deserves!

  • haha of coursee she does , shes an amazming singer and cleary they though so to because she won . lol everyone is just stuipd ass people that have noting better to do with there life .

  • i kno right!!!???