Added: 2 years ago
From: MariahCareyVEVO
Views: 19,139,693
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (9,452)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • i miss my aunty clara she was like my mother i miss her soo much she was killed one of the friend of families gave her a pill that killed her i also lost my uncle kevin i miss him and my grandma and my dad and my god mom i miss them all

  • R.I.P Aizan Roslan.... (1992 - 2012) Only 20 years old and so many problems. Took his own life away for good because the world was becoming unbearable. It's a pity for a young man to have so much at one point and losing it all at once.

  • bye bye My Hamster:( my Hamster had 2 tumors and i put her down today;"(

  • unen tas

  • i cried cuz i lost my dad at 9 year old he married so1 else and left me all alone in da corner by myself so i hav is my mom and i luv her so MUCH!!!

  • R.I.P JUSTIN A. ISSACS

  • i really appreciate mariah carey for making this song cuz all these other rappers and singers are talking about getting money or bitches and hoes or how famous they are and she is singing about some real shit and that takes true courage

  • this song is amazing and emotional. too great combo

  • Comment removed

  • This remided me of my best friend baby brother he died when he was born cause he couldn't breathe <3 i miss you baby boi takecare in heaven :(

  • This Remaieded me of my best friend baby brother he only died when he was born cause he couldn't breathe i miss him <3 take care in heaven my little angel

  • this iis for my mom love u

  • i cry every time i sit and hear this song, it makes me think back to the times my grandmother & i shared and the times i wish we had.

    i miss my abuelita, Alpha & i will always luv you

  • This is for my grandpa, never had the chance to say a proper Goodbye. Take care in heaven! I love you! Mahal kita.

  • Thinking about you, Grandpa (1933 - 2011). The promise I made to you is the promise I will keep forever.

  • love you Mommy ....R.I.P. 1/29/04 GONE NEVER FORGOTTEN G.C.N.

  • gudbye lilian........lord knowz i lavd u...

  • Make me feel sad just by reading u guys comments... T.T...

    make me remembering those that already gone and

    think about all that are still with me....

  • you only have 326 day left to listen to this song :)

  • Daddy I want you so bad, it hurts I don't know if I could finish living without you Happy Birthday daddy I thought you a be here forever it doesn't seem real seems like yesterday we were watching movies and if I knew the next day you would be gone I would have made that movie last forever. Daddy I'll never ever ever forget you. January 29,1956 - August 19, 2011 /3

  • My friend Remy died last night & she was only 15.. R.I.P Remy. We'll miss you so much, I'll never forget you ); i love you );

  • My Grandmother passed away 3 days after this songs was released as a single. This was our funeral song. :'( Miss her so much<3

  • everytime i listen to this song... i end up crying :_(

  • Aww :( my grandfather died just today :(( im going to miss him,such an accident for him :(

  • and my grandma

  • RIP Lennoxx You were my first and my only true love...I miss you. I know you in heaven lookin down but I see you every day in our daughters eyes. And to my daddy...I know we didnt always have the best relationship but I know you loved me. And I miss you terribly. To the two men in my life I loved the most this songs for you. RIP

  • Mariah Carey and Beyonce should Make a song together

  • @zandala12 no.

  • R.i.P. Nakia "boi" Ernest Reggie Robinson jr. its so hard to accept the fact tht ur gone. </3 nthin will ever be the same. ur son looks just like u. all i c is u in him. i just wish u were here 2 hold him nd love him. bt i know ur lovin him from above and ur always watchin down on all of us. & dont worry we gon tell ya son all about u. ima call him bby boi <3 i still have our old convos from myspace i bet u no one would understand them lOl. i love u boi dnt ever forget tht. rest easy i miss u

  • @ChristyBabii420- Omg that's soo horrible I'm sorry for loss I read you're comment and started crying instantly :'( stuff like that gets to me, R.I.P girl

  • this song make me cry i miss my grandma

  • This song is my favorite song in the world ~~~~ always

  • R.I.P. Dan, zach, scott, shaunia, judy, mike, marvin, and all the loved ones lost among the years. You are all greatly missed.

  • harvy i miss you so much son i know th.i love you nak

    is was your fvrite song.so sad he died i was not on his side but in singapore.died nov.2008

  • r.i.p pawpaw ily nd miss u i wish i cld see u 1 last time

  • This one goes out to the one true love of my life Danny RIP. It's been a year and yet the tears still come when I remember how silly in love we were. I'll see you again my love.

  • 265 ppl dont have a heart

  • this reminds me of my grandma

    i wanna sing this at her funeral but I'm to scared granny plz give me the strength i think you would really love this <3 R.I.P. grandma love-you

  • This reminds me of my brother.

    he passed away from cancer and he was 10 R.I.P <3

  • Comment removed

  • this brought me to tears.every one who lost a love one like for them

  •  Heavenly Love

  • this song reminds me of my grandma right now she is in the hospital an doesnt look good juat scared an hope she ok soon :'(

  • i still cry every time i hear this song.. <3

  • It's awesome!!!

  • you rode a plane but it sounded like a train for me

  • My bestie got murder in may 2011 she was just 19 years old just had a baby that was only 4 months old her husband abused her so she was trying to leave him and she went to go get her stuff with her friend and her husband came home and shot them both.....i miss her everyday.....cant believe its almost a year R.I.P M.N.C O3/15/11 you will forever be in my heart i <3 you babygirl

  • @ChristyBabii420 damn thats crazy! so sorry to hear! R.I.P girl

  • its never a "goodbye", more like a "see you later" . . i love you grandma n i miss you soo much!!<3

  • Amazing song & video ,,<3 MC

  • I miss ma godmother, LoveYou!!!

  • I miss you grandma but this isnt bye

  • R.I.P ZOCOYIA EVERYDAY I CRY AND HOPE THAT I CAN SEE U ONE LAST TIME

  • love u mariah so much , thank you for this song

  • R.i.p Ella. god took the most adorable angle from earth to heaven. We all know you will always take care of us from above. You are going to die if no one thinks about you. But I promise we all are going to think about you day and night because you left so many tracks in our hearts. God took his best angle but he also took a big part of our world. In love ♥

  • Thumbs up if you watch this on 2012

  • @eric6439 yess we're watching this in 2012 and we're going to be watching this in 2013,2014,2015 and we gone watch it until we cant watch it no more

  • RIP Raccine Frank ; <3

  • rip elizabeth rae teal ily gramma 1-4-1944 to 1-24-2012

  • R.I.P Megaupload T^T

  • R.I.P. KEYONAH died at 2 months ~sniff~ i <3 you mc

  • I like very much the music

  • This remind me of my grandpop. its been almost a year.

    He gave me the world and much more. but when i got older his true colors came out.

    He was cold hearted and evil.i shouldnt even waste my tears on him. but i do :'(

    but i still miss him alittl. the only grandpop i had.

  • R.I.P KENNETH! FUCK YOU

  • the first time i heard this song, was 3 years ago. when my grandma died. i think this song really made me feel better. but i still cried when i listened to this yesterday. because it was the day my grandma died. i really loved her. she lived all the way in canada. and i was sad i didn't get to see her one last time because i didn't know my last goodbye meant bye forever, not see you next year. i didn't even get to go to her funeral.

  • R.I.P JUSTIN A. ISAACS I MISS YOU I KNOW U IN A BETTER PLACE SEE YOU WHEN I GET THERE~ LOVE YOU BROVA GONE BUT NEVER FORGOTTEN!

  • This so is so touching... being a 14yr old I know good music when I hear it and it IS most defiantly Mariah Carey

  • thumbs up for who are watching in 2012

  • Comment removed

  • @coolzoner9 Screw you.! you might as well say that to all of the 9,385 people saying the EXACT same thing ,i didnt asked to be top comment so....:D go fuck yourself <3

  • I think about My Best Friend Sometime because she live in Providence Rhode Island, I think and wonder how she's doing? Because it's been so many ages since I havn't seen her.=) 2010 is when I went to my hometown because that's where I also was born at too with her. By the time I got there my aunt told me the most saddest stry ever that it was so hard to believe, she got sick and passed away at a very young age after I moved from Providence to South Carolina! I cried and cried

  • rip to my grandpa in september 2011 i love u :'(

  • R.I.P to my grann Maria :((( xxx

  • That is so sad sry for lost keep ur head up

  • Song Makes Me Cry. My Mother Died At 23. I Was 5, My Brothers Wer 3 & 11 Months Old. I Grad In 2008, Graduatin This Year (22yrs old), The 2nd Oldest In Starting College (20yrs old) & The Youngest Grads Next Year (17 now). ....... @ 1:44 "you never got to see the good WE have done" .... @ 2:10 "its soo hard to except the fact your gone FOREVER." R.I.P Eliza Marie Walden :(

  • this makes me mad because how does this song have 262 dislikes, obviously those people dont have hearts. Thank you MIMI :D for making songs like this that inspire everyone too never forget those loved one's. <3

  • I love u cuz never say u love some one ps francisto iz a dick

  • A friend of my studio partner died today right while they were talking on the phone...they got hit by a car while changing their tire...the very tire that was getting ready to be delivered...they crazy thing about this story is that right before she called ans told us that she has a flat...we almost hit a car that stranded on the side of the road with a flat tire...we stopped and asked if they needed help and then she called with the same situation but this time someone hit her and she died!

  • r.I.p 2 my brother jermaine luv u althought we never really saw each other n both of my grandmas luv u forever

  • Rest in Peace, my bestfriend. 1995-2007. "I thought you were so strong you'd make it through whatever, it's so hard to accept the fact you're gone forever". I have no idea how life can go on after loosing you, my soul sister, but I'll forever honour you and aspire to be more like you were, more beautiful, more humble, more generous, more human. I love you and will miss you eternally.. untill we meet in Heaven. "Bye Bye" beautiful!

  • eu dedico ao meu filho,um anjo da minha vida,que ta com deus me ajudando,vitor rafael pereira.

  • Bye To My Auntie Ava We will miss ya 1-22-12

  • R.I.P for everyone Who holds a special place in somone's Heart.

  • Miss you Everyday papa and my uncle. my heart still aches everyday..

  • R.I.P to my lil sister i love u even no i never new u i love u so much!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • R.I.P RIGO LUNA MY BEST CUZIN IN THE WROLD:(

  • this song means a lot to us people. epic song, Mimi. :)

  • Comment removed

  • NICK, ENJOY HER!!!

  • nice , enjoy her!

  • I never thought I could hurt this much.I'll love you 4ever+always <3 R.I.P Cous

  • Comment removed

  • BYE BYE and rest in peace, dislike bar...hahaha

  • Rest in Paradise, Daddy. <3 Your memory forever stays alive.

  • You will be forever loved my dear Tricia, my dear, my love, my best friend forever.

  • RIP to my dog named chacha! :'( mariah is very amazing she wrote song's marked to our hearts T.T

  • Rest in peace Dad, I will forever & always love and miss you!

  • R.I.P to my great paw paw I miss you so i'd give anything to see your face again and to my great helen i love you too so much but i know you are in a better place so i think god

  • R.I.P TO EVERYBODY WHO DIES. XOXO

  • R.I.P Ny'Quara my handsome son maybe gone but neve 4gotten spent 16 months together thn lost u love u son love from mummy xoxox

  • RIP AUNCLE ISMAEL MEZA

  • RIP Etta James

  • R.I.P to my mother Celina Bradly I love u &u miss u .

  • RIP DAD (DENNIS) I LOVE YOU SOO MUCH AND MISS YOU ALWAYS BE IN MY HEART

    LOVE YOUR

    GORDA <3

    EVALEE

  • r.i.p to my ex i'll always love you x

  • R.I.P TO KEII 

  • RIP Rannetta Doorman <3

  • i love abah , mak , ateh n opah... u left me me with so much of memorise that i can't forget about it... R.I.P...

  • i lost my baby sis when she was 6 weeks old

  • did any1 see nick canon

  • RIP to one of my friend's mother and my other friend's grandpa.. i know a new life in a brighter place is just beginning now..

  • Comment removed

  • Rest in Peace Uncle Dapo

  • 260 people do not know how to say bye.

    R.I.P Etta James true legend.

    Bye bye :'(

  • this song makes me cry so hard thinkin of my boo who got shot and my nephew and my cousinss love and miss you all so much

  • Man I cry when I her thiz song cuz it macke me thank of my pass man love u gandpa n gandma love yall so much :'(

  • This song goes out to my cousin Joey he died when I was 3 and he was my bestfriend..... R.I.P Joey I love you soo much bubba!!!!

  • R.I.P ETTA JAMES. Amazing soul + voice

  • This song for my grandpaw he died when I was 9 its been 5 years hes been gone he had cancer me and my mom fell to the grown when he died I will alway loveu

  • R.I.P ETTA JAMES <3

  • BYE BYE ETTA JAMES

  • RIP LIL MIKE LOVE U CUDDY ;(

  • @jun2dakay : be strong ! hottest 'll support U forever !

  • this is fo u @Jun2daKAY hyung!!

  • My grandma:( my x

  • rip shirley virgina more aka grandma everytime i listen to this i start balling like a baby. i miss you grandma

  • May God Have mercy on all your loved ones. I hope everyone is resting in peace :) in a much better place

  • RIP great grandma you have helped me through so much in life you believed me when others didnt and always stood by my side. please look over me and protect me i love you so much!

  • love this song when it came out was the time i lost my baby girl. she was 6months old... but i know god has his reasons... i love you baby girl!!!! we'll see each other again one day

  • too my neice Patrice , my grandparents Eli n Rose, my Tio Elifas , Sammy , Jimmy, my primo Amos my homie n ex Raul and so, so many more !

  • R.I.P Megaupload 1-19-12... killed by SOPA... -manly tears-

  • RIP grandpa, he died when I was only 2 years old. Wish I had a chance to get to know him better... ;(

  • RIP to my nan u was all nutty nanny we called u love u lots and miss u can u come bk plz i miss u so much!!!!!!!!

  • RIP to my mother who i lost when i was only 1yr and 4months old, even-though i never got a chance to know you or say goodbye! i know your in a better place!

  • thumbs up if you searched up bye

  • rip of my father who left me all alone with out care or a father to love i cry every night wondering why he left us my mother had hard time being a mother when she only ahd me at 16 it was hard for her dis song makes me cry an wonder thumps up if u understand

  • @tyty3269 thanks for the thumps up but ever night i cry an never will stop when i listen to dis song

  • @tyty3269 why do ppl have to die why can't they live for ever when they die its like u lost ur heart u lost the way to find the path u can't go back to the days u was with them i really wish he was hea with me most ppl lucky they have a father to love them i'm only 13 still dont' have a father an i need one to love me an to play with an to have a big smile on my face an to cry out my tears when i need them most

  • Rip ;

    Ying, Roman, Yang, Bella.

    The Wonderful Siblings , Gone . :c

  • Love u grandma n gandpa :'(

  • R.i.p

  • R.I.P. Grandma I love you! 1~13~12

  • R.I.P to my sister. She was born early and the doctor said My mom can take her home, four days later she never woke up :( I Wish i saw her atleast, but i know she will always be in my heart. I'm gonna see her in Hevan and tell her about myself and we ill hopefully get along

  • Comment removed

  • R.I.P Daddy I Never Got To Know You........................I Still Don't Died When I Was 1 Years Old Its been 12 Years I Miss You And Love You I'm Glad Your In A Better Place :'D

  • i miss my kitty....it's only been a few months since he died, but it feel like an eternity....

  • this is for my best friend Dajon its only been a year but fills like forever man i miss you soooo much:'( and its for my grandma its been almost 6 years i love yall both plz watch over me and along with every body that sees this video and everybody after them i love yall both miss yall and i cnt ait till i can see yall face to face again

  • R.I.P. to my son Malachi. mama luvs u. i lost u just as i had gotten u and i miss dat chance to hold u again in my arms. i love u lil daddy

  • wow she has a perfect nose....sorry off topic

  • this is to my big bruv gone 5 years but not fogotten xx

  • RIP lil D i miss you and mamii's thinkn about you

  • RIP Grandma Cora 10/31/07 i miss yhu ndd i love yhu

  • we had not spend alot of time together,Im sorry and I miss you!!

  • R.I.P cuz i will miss and love you always!!

  • Seeing all the comments on here makes me realise how short life is!!! So glad I have my grandmother still here present on Earth. I curse the day I lose her. I'm not strong enough.

  • I just auditioned for CANADA'S GOT TALENT- so please check out my audition video on my page & U may hear me singing some songs by Mariah on TV in March! Thanks. People say I sound similar to her.

    MC COVERS: ALL I WANT FOR CHRISTMAS IS YOU, OH SANTA, Lovin you Long Time, Love Takes Time, Forever, Open Arms, My all, Angels cry, When I saw you, Vision of Love, Without you, Emotions, Cruise Control, I stay in love, Touch my body, Shake it off, I'll be there, I don't wanna cry, etc

  • rip ma lisa 1-10-10

  • R.I.P Grandma ...

    Gone but Never forgotten

  • RIP aunt Guylaine. I miss you so much! It was too soon :(. I will never forget you and everything you taught me! xxx 15/01/2012

  • adrian castillo.. my best friend. i miss and love you more than anyone knows! 1-13-2012

  • Comment removed

  • R.I.P Papa Don Finley Haslam!!! I love and miss you sooo much papa!!! 2/7/28-5/1/09

  • RIP, my grandfathers. Miss you both so much.

  • im not hatin cuz i love this song.... but seriously, she manages to make herself look like a whore even in a sad song?? wow...

  • @marytheeawesomest13 ever watch a rihanna or beyonce video? mariah is a nun compared to most artists lol

  • @vyperdash22 and that's a great thing!!!:)

  • R.I.P Joseph Elliott A.K.A Joeker 1/7/12 =(

  • her hair relly matches her complexion :) i love this video she is looking gud too like alwayz