Evanescence-Heart Shaped Box(Live Acoustic)

[PalmerianDream]

Great job. It does exactly what a cover is supposed to do: Sound different.

[XxxSnowWhitexX]

Of course she can't scream and sing this like Kurt, because she's a woman. But she did a good job. Of course this isn't better than the original, but it's not bad.

[devilgoth1]

I love Nirvana and Kurt is God for me but this cover is perfect! Amy lee is such a talented girl

[medicoize]

QUE GENIAL BANDA, AMI LEE UNA VOZ INIGUALABLE, ME ENCANTA

[MrHeidiHigh]

ach amy your so sweet :*

[grannybenson]

good version and it almost compares to nirvana but no one can beat kurt in my opinion

[Spondoo]

When most artists try to cover a Nirvana song they either try to sound exactly like Kurt which annoys me to no end. Amy on the other hand did an amazing cover of Heart Shaped Box, I prefer Kurt ofc, but Amy's version is much clearer and her voice is beautiful when she cries out in any of her songs i.e. 'Going Under live acoustic'.

[MultiTata80]

i liked the way she sang the heart shaped box.. she gives a melancolic tone to the song and make it almost mysterious...

[1ryanoconnor]

fuck you its great

[kryptokrow]

AMAZING, how many people dont get it,duh, she not a dude with a scratchy vioce strung out on heroine, and duh, its acoustic not grunge..but its ok..if any of you millionaire recording artist actually had a vioce or a real band,,i would make sure to tell you, you sucked 2 for doing a cover song in youre own vioce, or trying to sound like someone youre not..if you wanna hear Kurt sing it again click it, over on the right..he's not on tour, but happy sum1 is still doing his work and keeping it real

[isorivolta]

I love this version. I love the original too. I can't pick a favorite, but I bet that Kurt would've loved this one as well.

[mileymontana95]

I Love evanescence and Nirvana. How can I choose between them? xD

[FullMetalDeathNote44]

good cover but nothing compares to the original

[TheAdorabelle]

It's nothing like Nirvana, but I still like it. :)

[LacrymosaPrincess]

You shouldn't criticize Amy because she sang this to show her admiration to Nirvana. She's a fan and BOTH bands are great. She wouldn't sound nice if she screamed like Kurt. Kurt is a guy and screaming fits better to him.

LOVE TO EV AND NIRVANA

[NillaWafer88]

Look, I'm not taking anything away from Nirvana, because there's no denying they were great. But Amy Lee does have a way better voice than Kurt Cobain. You've got to give her some credit, because when she did this song, you knew people were going to rip into her not being Nirvana in the first place.

[ricochetfuzzy]

sounds like shit

[Lazewski]

This dumb bitch needs to stick to Emo music. Nirvana is the best thing to hit the shelf of Music History.

[aga170594]

Shit!

Nirvana is so much better...

[ajmdrummer]

i like this but the two versions are uncomparable because they're almost two different songs. nirvana was def the grunge version this version has the soft ballad kind of sound. you can't really say one's better than the other

[surfzombie2]

I like this better than nirvana

[JeanineMooiwark]

Nirvana was beter duuh

[AnpilogovIlya1992]

Nirvana is besser

[BfmVandSilverstein]

richtig.

[WagnerPrA]

just take a look at this picture. Surely my will-to-life has chosen this perfect woman to be my kids' mother. Pity she's already taken....

[kathie015]

Amy is AMAZING!!!! beautiful and an amazig voice!!!! just mesmerizing!!!!!!!!!!

[Tarni64]

Amy Lee has one of the most amazing voices out there and has really set the mark for others to follow, I am a huge fan of her music and of Evanescence, but I must say, Nobody does this song like Kurt... rip

[bandsturtle317]

i like nirvana, and most people couldn't cover them to save their life. but this does them a good bit of justice. good job evanescence! amy rocks!

[bajee123]

shit cover can never do like nirvana

[pr0dud3]

Can you asshole do better than Evanescence?!!

[InnocentzRaptor]

Meh, leave him be. While I personally think this is better than the original [you heard me] it's his own opinion...a rather narrow-minded opinion. He'll never know how awesome Ev truly is until he expands his horizons.

[BonnieMasacre]

i love this

but nothing

like the original

[GameOverXbox]

Nobody can sing like kurt but damm I just got chills.

[xLoonyLunax]

This is great!

And it's live too... wowza, it sounds like it's in studio!

[breezee0622]

she did an outstanding job on this!!

[DieBlutroteKurenai]

very cool!

sounds like nirvana and i like nirvana!

[Sunzu49]

This is how "Heart-Shaped Box" would have sounded like if Nirvana performed it in their (last and) acoustic concert "MTV Unplugged in New York."

[chvll101]

most people that cover this should fuckin shoot themselves.but this is 1 cover i think kurt would be proud of

[Audtodd90]

absoultely lovely. :)

[XiXhateXmeXmoreX]

i like nirvana and luv amy lee!

i like this version

[kontimongo]

nirvana ia awesome hands down, but i love her voice especially her acoustic songs

[linkdarkw]

nirvana did it great m not saying her version isnt good i just think the original is better lets just leave the singing of kurts song to kurt

[johnLecompt]

She's wonderful. What the hell are you saying?

She's much better than nirvana.

Nirvana is good but evanescence is wonderful

[dawn12935]

What has more brains than Kurt Cobain? The wall behind him

[muncy1006]

she is the best female to ever sing

[manospitsis]

@muncy1006 !!!!!!AGREE!!!!!!!............­!!!!

[punkextrodinere]

I do agree, i like it better when Nirvana sings it but i do like evanescence

[kuchenmonster90]

DAMN GOOOD =)

[dawn12935]

She is really good. It sounded awesome

[hobil9]

FUCK, leave it to nirvana. DAMN FUCKFUCKFUCKFUCKFUCKFUCKFUCKFU­CKFUCKFUCKFUCKFUCKFUKCUFKCFUCK­FUCKFUCKFUCKFUCKFUCKFUCKFUCKFU­CKFUCKFUCKFUCKFUCKFUCKFUFUCKFU­CKFUCKFUCKFUCKFUCKFUCK

[Omgitsville]

agreed

[Bsbaby]

she looks so pretty in that pic

[qazplmwscokn]

her voice is good but it sucks when she sings it cause' shes not like metal and stuff

[synyster54]

it was an amazing song when nirvana came up with it. amy just sucks

[franxta]

god her voice is so beautiful, i dont care what anyone says,

shes amazing.

even if it is a nirvana song...get over it

[allpimpsnohoes]

okay, Alilina, yes Nirvana is rad... but you didn't even spell it right and umm... amy is seriously the best singer in the fucking universe. she's the raddest person EVER! you're shit. you shitfuck

[CroftWorld]

Please don't swear this song is beautiful!

[J0NNO]

@CroftWorld

there's nothing not beautiful about swearing :)

[Alilina]

nirana forever and amy lee is SHIT

[blackandredcookie666]

well...she shouldnt do nirvana, but she isnt shit