Added: 9 months ago
From: SamBOWSSBeauge
Views: 157,988
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (730)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • all u durbin haters can get fucked! why the fuck are you watching this if u dont like him! he is amazing and a true performer this is an amazing performance as were all his performances

  • i still wear the james tail

    

  • He just fucked up a great song.

  • I love this song ..

  • @vincet2009 That's exactly what I was trying to say! I think the judges actually hurt James chances by not telling him what he could do to improve.

  • @ross121670 The judges are paid to hype the contestants for the audience. There hasn't been a truthful judge since Simon Cowell left Idol. The judges didn't do James any favors by not giving him the constructive criticism that he needed. He might have lasted longer had they told him what he needed to hear instead of blowing smoke up his ass.

  • @MrBrockilus James can show restraint? Hahahahah LMAO! The guy doesn't know when to keep his mouth shut.

  • IM SINGING THIS SONG ON MY MUSICAL!!!! :DDDD SMOKEY JOES CAFE!!! :DDD

  • oh wtf is this? the guy just murdered a classic...

  • James Durbin Shoulda Won It All.

  • better than the original

  • my mom and i cried when he lost :'(

  • massacre de la chanson! :@

    et tu feras gaffe c'est nineteen fifty six

  • omfg , he's so amazing ! :o

  • how do i screw a number up. i think like this

  • i love him i wanted him 2 win not scotty mc. creery : ( he came 4th

  • He did not have any bad perfomances whatsoever! This, I think, is his best! He is amazing and he should have won! But like he said, Daughtry came in 4th as well and look at how good they did! :)

  • he should hav won or lauren i hate scotty he is really bad

  • How the hell did he get voted off for this performance?! The finale should've been James and Casey. And Haley should've gone home a looong time ago.

  • @11gothicprincess Perhaps because this performance was a lot more sizzle than steak. Fanciness over vocal substance, so to speak. The fact that this came after that karaoke Glee rendition and he had a big off-week the week before didn't help him either.

    Oh, and BTW, Haley deserved to go as far as she went and perhaps even further.

  • @jpad319 Actually there was substance given the vocals were all there, pitch perfect and flawless. I don't see how it was fancy either. He did a rock version of an old song. He took it and made it his like the judges keep telling everyone to do.

    Haley is the most overrated contestant of season 10. I was even shocked when she made the top 13. If she had made the finale this would've been my first and last season watching Idol.

  • @11gothicprincess Nope. Enjoyable as it was, if the theatrics were more memorable than the vocals itself, then the performance is flawed. Arrangement aside, this was a typical Durbin performance: very high on theatrics with compromised vocal quality.

    Besides, ever heard his Top 5 week performances? Demonstrated pitch problems and a wobbly lower register.

    With all due respect to Haley, it took a while for her to gain her footing. But when she did, she kicked major butt. Overrated my ass!

  • James should have won!!!!

  • Damn, he didn't have a single bad performance. I guess that's why he was never in the bottom 3 until he got eliminated while Haley was in the bottom 3 five times.

  • @metallica708 Wrong. He had a terrible week the week before that time. And with a popular singer, fans are gonna go on overdrive to save him. But since he followed it up with a mediocre week, that won't work the next time around.

  • James: Talented out ofthis world

    Should have won

    Got a CD anyway dont that prove somthing you stupid tone death haters

  • he shouldve won.

  • DAME SCOTTY U DIDNT DESERVE TO WIN JAMES SHOULD OF WHOA JAMES SORRY JAMES SCOTTY U SUCK

  • @shainann15 yeah right... james rock!!!!

  • @shainann15 Scotty doesnt suck, James i think should won, but Scotty has just as much talent as James only in a diffrent style music, so stop.

  • Casey shoulda been second

  • Comment removed

  • James DOES have a record deal with ''Windup records'' & cd coming out in November!!! He will show everyone WHO James Durbin is!!!!...The best ever to walk on that Idol stage,THATS FORSURE!!! :) \m/

  • DAMN YOU DURBIN!  your the only one that gets my heart racing my blood pumping and the chills down my spine..THUMBS UP FOR DURBIN!!!

  • Wrong orange, he is the 5th one to get signed. Haley got signed more than a month ago. James behind Haley, remember that. jk those two are the best, I hope they become the biggest stars of this group. But yeah, this could turn out to be one of the most succesful season ever, 5 recording artists already. Probably Casey should get signed too. And Paul already make his own music even before Idol.

  • This was an awesome, hot! performance. James had soooo many fantastic performances on AI and showed himself as a true artist from day 1. He's got a great future ahead of him.

  • I'm pretty sure he got a record deal. I forget where I heard it but I think it was Scotty, Lauren, James, and Pia who got signed...

  • I can't believe this guy didn't win.

  • Comment removed

  • @XxlipstickloverxX he can't announce until the finishing of Idol's deal, only if he's signed with Interscope (who only do pop). James got signed with Wind Up records, who does rock albums.

  • i loved this performance but i really also loved haley singing i who have nothing or whatever!

  • America just isn't rock anymore. What a fu*kin shame.

  • @XxlipstickloverxX pretty sure he got one.

  • AWESOME JAMES!! ... Perfect Pitch!!! ... Pure Showmanship!!!

    Blazingly talented ROCKER who connects with the audience...

  • i would have loved to see him do a song with Steven Tyler T^T

  • This wasn't his best performance or even a good night for him. James if he wanted to stay should have outsang Lauren and Haley and he most definitely didn't. Almost everybody could outsing Scotty, but beat him in votes is impossible. James is great but he ended up being the weakest link altogether. I mean, he never would have won, neither could Lauren or Haley. This was impossible to lose for Scotty, little it has to do with music. Just girls fangirling for him but he is not good at all.

  • America obviously just didn't realize it was witnessing the next truly GREAT Amercian rock star. Can't wait for your music,James!

  • James Durbin IS so freakin entertaining what a talent . James won the hearts of millions so in my eyes james is the real winner. i wish him all the success in the world and cant wait for his album JAMES DURBIN ROCKS!

  • James and Pia should been in finale!

  • I love the studio version of this song. He is a great story teller.

  • We all know the American Idol voting system is completely broken. We know who the real winners are.

  • @GasCityGuy I agree with you if you're saying James should have won...check out ....votefair.org...American Idol section...producers know there are many problems with the broken AI voting system, but will not acknowledge...James should have won...but I think he is much better off @ top 4...

  • 37 people took dumb potion #9

  • How can he have been voted off AFTER this?????

  • James Durbin reigns supreme - he rocks our world - great performance!!

  • Amazing performance and probably most under-rated performance. Totally love it. Total James. Hot!

  • Hmmm... How about Sex Potion or Fap Potion No. 9?

  • I meant "paraphrase' (not paragraph) Bono, fyi.

  • To respond to arrogance claim, let me paragraph Bono (U2). Performers like him (Bono) do what they do 'cause they love music, art, connecting with people, but mostly because it feeds their ego.' So, if you think James ego is bigger than any of the other top 11 (maybe except for Thia, who needs more ego) think again. They wouldn't be up there ( & probably coudln't be) if they didn't love the applause & attention. James is just honest about it & personally,I love that about him.

  • @maxelca I agree with you regarding ego & yes all entertainers have to have large egos in order to be in the business...some are better at hiding them than others and I do so admire James honesty also. But when it comes to some people saying he is arrogant....conceited, haughty, etc. I just do not see it. IMO I think he is a brilliant artist & entertainer & his honesty is refreshing. I really like that about James...

  • @elsinep4  I'm with you all the way!

  • That ending was both hilarious and epic.

  • James took a song that was boring and ROCKED IT!!!!! I would buy it!

  • @stupidzhangjiayi  Arrogance only works for the hottest of the hot; Jim Morrison, Madonna..but not James Durbin. He'd be better off humble.

  • @elsinep4 I think James Morrison or Madonna could get away with arrogance but not James Durbin; he just isn't hot enough. Hey, just my opinion bro

  • @LitZena no problelm at all!!! IMHO you're entitled to your opinion---we just disagree!!!

  • @elsinep4 I disagree, I think James is VERY INTO James; and that style turns me off. He is a great singer, just not into it.

  • Judge: Tell us Mrs.Replay where did Mr. Arrow click you?

    Mrs.Replay: Here *gesturing towards entire body*

    Judge: And how many times did he click you

    Mrs.Replay: Over 100 times

    Mr.Arrow: What I only clicked her 10 times

    Judge: Order! You have now been sentenced to Internet Prison for 1 year

    Mr.Arrow: Oh come on now how am I suppose to do my f*ckin job

    Me: *Gets on laptop* Where the f*ck is my arrow?!?!

  • JAMES DURBIN IS THE BEST PERFORMER EVER ! 

  • James Durbin is totally amazing!!

  • i love it all he is ammaaazzinngg!!!!!!!! but my most favorite part is from 1:40 - 2:10 :D i love how high he can go!

  • This was the best of the night for me. It still floors me, this is the week he got voted off. Top 5 week, I could understand if James was voted off, it was not a good week. Top 4, it was just wrong that this was his last week.

  • @sajinokami you got it right there. He should've been in the bottom 2 (honestly) at the top 5 night. So he wasn't called out, Lauren was and her fans voted their ass off at the top 4 week for her. And James ended up receiving the least amount of votes in top 4 week. In where honestly Scotty was the worst, but he never was in danger so he can do whatever he wants. Meanwhile James wasn't the worst but he wasn't better than Haley and Lauren that night, he gets screwed then. It's all true.

  • i cant beleve he lost

  • You're great! Don't worry about not winning. You are a winner. You rocked OKC tonight. Best performances of the night!

  • @Glamrma Absolutely amazing!!

  • this man will change modern music. make it known that rock takes tallent. modern rap just takes autotune and a black guy.

  • This is an incredibly self-indulgent performance..check out where James stops and puts his arms out like am I awesome or what just wanting everybody to take his greatness in. James has a great voice but he was arrogant; when he was eliminated he said he did so much that nobody else ever did, that just isn't true. I think James is a recycled Adam and that Adam was more polished and better than James. And he cried to leave his family for where: TO BUILD HIS CAREER ON THE TOP RATED SHOW!

  • @LitZena

    if someone can sing like James.. I personally don't have ANY problem with him being arrogant.. and he can be as arrogant as he wants cause he CAN.

  • @LitZena of course you are entitled to your opinion but I do disagree...IMO First.. that move is known as a false ending ...it is the performer (James) being a tease...& connecting with the audience....also, don't confuse the fact.... that James is enthusiastic, animated , very spirited, and in the moment...loves to connect with the audience, & they love him, a showman .Don't confuse with arrogance. JAMES is the "real deal" ....

  • @elsinep4 I'm with you here. Self indulgent? I think it's called "entertainment!" It's so funny to me how some people get upset at James 'over' performing. Uhhhh, what are we staring at our computers and tvs for..if not to Be Entertained! LMAO. I'll drink this potion anytime! I like having fun!

  • I voted for him 500 times that night.. I can not believe he went home. He should of won. He can sing anything.

  • @MrsRandyOrtonfan1 i did to it just wasnt fair....its all riged on looks.

  • Forever bitter. This performance was crazy good.

  • JD can sing any song of any genre and make it his own... I still can't believe he wasn't standing on that stage as a finalist... little 12 old girls should be in bed when this is on and keep the cells off!

  • best performance of this song EVER!

  • God he sux!!!

  • James..I see your Highlights EP debuted at #7 on Billboard Top Rock Albums Chart!!!...& #31 on Billboard 200...fans ..show our support by buying James Highlights EP ..only @ Walmart!! //Congrats!

  • Love it! James take a somewhat cheesy ol' 60s/70s song and turns into fun, sexy rock n roll. Gotta love it. Hot!

  • James Durbin...sensitive, soulful & passionate ROCKER!!!

    James Durbin...a rare & unique musician/artist...NOTHING ordinary about this HOT HOT performer!!!

  • Well, all I heard from this video was screaming. And that doesn't fit with the tone and merit of the song.

    A good singer knows how to bring out the soul of the song, not scream the hell out of it... 

  • It's good that he got voted off. Now he doesn't have to be constricted with what Idol would have wanted him to write. Now he can bring out some real hard rock/ metal!

  • We love you James Durbin - rock on - reach for the stars!!

  • It's a nice imitation of Love Potion No.9 - Tygers Of Pan Tang (1982)

    But that take was then a sure move outside the box of the covers of that song. This is more a replica of TOPT that surprises and wows people who are unfamiliar with the original version from Tygers of Pan Tang.

  • I was straight...Then I heard James sing this...now I'm seduced.

  • 32 people took dumb potion number 9

  • how can he go home after this performance

  • American Idol Guitarist Tony Pulizzi nearly outshines James Durbin as the the two perform a blistering version of Love potion Number 9.

  • James is my idol hands down!!

  • The final should have been between James & Haley

  • I still don't know how Scotty (Maybe WORST Winner of AI ever) beat James in votes. Heck, I'm suprised he GOT votes -.-

  • @rich2war Scotty is one of the best singers EVER. Don't get me wrong I like James, he's a singer but Scotty's better.

  • @ShineyShadowKnight ..............................­.... YOU DON'T KNOW TALENT! Yes, Scotty was really good, but James had that touch of uniqueness that not a lot of other singers have. JAMES DURBIN ALL THE WAY!

  • @rich2war *cough* Worst winner? Taylor Hicks and Lee DeWyze are probably relieved to hear you say that.

  • somebody sign that dude.

  • He has a voice like a trombone and looks like an angel , what more do you want ???

  • when he got voted off i was preety mad at lady gaga

  • I guess the reason that James didn't get enough votes for top 3 was that "everyone" thought he was so good that he was there allready, and started to vote for Haley so they could meet in the final

  • AMAZING Performance! Rock legend in the making!

  • @xxFLIPPIFERxx i dont like the bandana but skinnier and mowhawk r awesome

  • james durbin is the ROCK AND ROLL MAN!

  • In my opinion this performance was better than any of the others that night...why the hell he got voted off I don't know. In a way though, I'm happy that he got 4th place because it seems like people that get that spot can go off and do their own thing like Chris Daughtry did. I think the winner and runner-up immediately get signed to Interscope and I think James will be able to sign with whoever. I'm gonna bet that James will be big. :)

  • @Crystasorrow

    exactly right. He will get to join whomever he wants now. Idol pics the songs he should play that suit the winner. Now he has a shot at the big times. A side note: There are websites that promote others to vote for the worse performances on idol. Why they listen i've no freakin' clue.

  • @Crystasorrow Perhaps because both his performances that night were a lot more sizzle than steak: High on theatrics but pretty low on vocal quality. And don't get me started with that ultimate karaoke Journey song, either. Raised the bar my ass! More like threw a pipe on the floor, if you ask me.

  • @jpad319 of course you are entitled to your opinion...However I wonder why you and a couple of other people come back on a regular basis to view James videos & leave negative comments.....if I REALLY thought an artist was lacking talent I would not be wasting my time by returning to view his videos...you do have a choice...

  • @elsinep4 Oh, believe me, I am a fan. I like a few of his songs, the ones during the few starting weeks. But truth be told, his last two weeks in the show were a letdown.

  • @elsinep4 Obviously because they REALLY DO like him and think he is AWESOME......they can't get enough of his wonderful, amazing, super talented voice ......lol......shhhh.....it's ok we won't tell anyone ..............THEY ARE CLOSET FANS ....lmao !!!

  • @TheRenegadewoman  I agree... James is electrifying!!!

  • @Crystasorrow yeah im happy casey and james left when they did. And, at this point, looking back, I'll bet they are too.

  • @Crystasorrow Roadrunner Records *crosses fingers*

  • @Crystasorrow He didnt win because Majority of people in the States, are infact country fans.....

    so there for lauren and scotty got second and first.....

    If people up here in Canada could vote...He would have gone on.

    but I Totally agree with you...

    someone will see him, and want to sign him right away,

    Hes purreeeee Talent. :)

  • @Crystasorrow yeah I'm always thrilled when my favorite doesn't win this show, but gets really far. Just means they get a good starting fan base, and can do their own thing without the record companies controlling him.

  • This song is perfect for James! How could people not have voted for him?!?!?!?! I guess people couldn't find their way to their cell phone or computer! ; )

  • My thoughts exactly - he had the pimp spot and sang like a god  ---- how could it happen -- it says something about who is and isn't mass voting!!! James will rise higher & faster than a shooting star!!! He leaves me speechless after every performance!!

  • Awesome Performance!! Who gets eliminated after a performance like that?!?! no seriously??!!?!

  • cant wait to see james durbin at the american idol live tour this summer! so excited <3 anyone else going?

  • I LOVE HIM!!!! hes amazing. And so pissed off that he didnt win. :(

  • Anyone else confused when to clap?

    

  • @moneymoneymoney1092 Nobody that has ever been to a rock concert.

  • @nrrgellegani You ask him to be humble yet you're saying that your 7 year old cousin can sing better? Damn hypocrite...

  • WHY did you tag JUSTIN BIEBER and NEVER SAY NEVER here?

  • Hot, hot performance. Totally awesome rendition, turning a cheesy song into a hot, bluesy number, sliding into those flat notes perfectly, just amazing. Don't get how more people didn't get how good this performance was. Frkn rock star. Oh well. At least I GET IT !! :) :)

  • @maxelca TOTALLY AGREE!!! James is so amazing!! My brother has been a voice teacher/coach for 30 years, his words were "James has a PHENOMENAL VOICE, PERFECT PITCH ..can reach a high F or high G & HOLD IT which is very difficult to do". Some singers may be able to hit a high note but not able to sustain it. His advise to James would be to take some of the money he won & invest in a great voice teacher to learn how to take care of his incredible voice & work on lower register....JAMES ROCKS!!!

  • the idol voting should be 18 + cuz look what happened with damn scotty.. the bastard won

  • The love potion number nine failed for twenty Eight people.

  • James - you WON Idol..........forget the ending. YOU won! Love your talent, ability, singing.

  • @C0017A your right!!!!

  • @C0017A i second, third, and fourth that.

  • Why is every James Durbin video i look at there is a suggetion of scotty mccreery singin!

  • fucking amazing<3

  • any time I think there is going to be a "do do do do do do do do do do do do do do do!", except on the Yell parts

    For who doesn't get it, it's from Hungry Like the Wolf, by Duran Duran

  • damn i was hoping to hear him sing some dookie

  • Durbin, YOU ARE A FREAKIN' ROCKSTAR MY FRIEND!!!!!!!!!

  • holy fuck.. this guy can actually sing, while the rest only knows how to hold the microphone. how the fuck didnt this guy win?

  • thumbs up if jmz shouldve won

  • AMERICA ...

    Y U NO RECOGNIZE REAL TALENT?

  • @tooawesome2bereal I know what real talent is. And that is the sole reason why I do not like James Durbin. I would have been a fan but God gave me a tone perfectionist ear.

  • @nrrgellegani, Quit fooling yourself. If James has no talent, then 8 of the 10 Idol winners don't either because he is legitimately better than 8 of the 10 winners, including this season.

  • @coltcub64 i disagree he is better than everyone else

  • @coltcub64 I am not fooling around man. I am just being honest. I know that my God does not want me to lie. I don't know yours. And as a person with no hearing disability, I can clearly hear him miss those good notes. both in upper and lower register. Either he make it sharp or flat. My 7 year old cousin can definitely bring it so much better than James. And lastly, he should learn to be humble and stop being so arrogant if he really wants to stay long in his chosen career.

  • @nrrgellegani dude noone cares if he was a little flat!! he sings better than youll ever hope to be. his stage performing ability is awesome!! he sings amazing. LONG LIVE ROCK AND ROLL!!

  • y didnt he win????

  • He would be a great Jesus in Jesus Christ Superstar Rock Opra!!!!!!

  • I absolutely love every single thing about this performance. What he did with this old, tired song was simply amazing! Love you James...can't wait for your first CD!!!

  • the show had no character and escitment after he left

  • @TheAlienSisters <3 He's the next big thing. Hell yeah.

  • i have a crush on him thumbs up if u do 2

  • Can you put the lyrics too !!! With James singing !!!!