Added: 2 years ago
From: RyanMcNutt
Views: 11,325
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (80)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Why would you do that to such a good song? Poor Modest Mouse.

    

  • only good song by her because it sounds so much like float on

  • I'm not the only one who had this idea I guess.... nice job!

    AmDrag

  • When I was younger I used to love Miley Cyrus and now I love Modest Mouse. Having been a fan of both songs for a long time, I find myself enjoying this XD

    Good job :P

  • It makes me think that sometimes it can because they were at the place when they can be there and miley sounds like smiley face which sounds like yyyyyoooooouuuuuu.🏈🔫🚬🚬🚬🚬🚬🚬💣💣💣💣­💰💰💰💰💰PENIS

  • guys guys guys calm down miley cyrus didn't steal form modest mouse, the person that writes all of her songs did

  • This is kickbutt :)

  • Download available?

  • contrast kicks ass :)

  • Difference: Isaac Brock, Eric Judy, and Jeremiah Green write their music. Miley Cyrus shows up to the studio to sing over a track a team of producers created.

    Although, your statement that the two are the same song just shows your lack of understanding surrounding the basics of music creation.

  • I had the same thought. It is the same song on a basic level, but MM is 10000 better than Smiley.

  • Gonna double post... but @ the people getting their uterus tied in a knot over this: Stop being music nazis. It's not an insult to anyone. Music is freedom. Who are you to say what is good music and what isn't? I like BOTH of them. The Lonsome Crowded West is one of my top 10 most fav. albums of all time, and Miley Cyrus has really good pop songs. Stop being so close-minded and open yourself up to new experiences, and music.

  • Awesome job on syncing the songs and pointing it out. I never would have noticed this before. It's now my duty to point this out to as many people as possible.

  • This is amazing, yes Miley is horrible, and Brock is a god, but damn this sounds kewl.

  • I don't usually comment on YouTube videos, but seriously, fuck all the people that are hating on this. This isn't about the talent, style, or whatever of either of the involved tracks/artists, just like moneydude said. Good show, man, I think I you did a commendable job on this track.

  • This really, really upset me.

  • you need to just stop sir. you need to stop this RIGHT FUCKING NOW.

  • i've lost faith in the world...

  • Why watch it if you have a fricken issue with it? Damn it, get over it and move on.

  • fuck miley, what an insult to Isaac

  • OH SHIT!

  • You people are overreacting. There's nothing wrong with the video. It's just pointing out the similarity of the songs, which is there whether you like it or not. Nobody is comparing the artists or saying that the songs would make a good mashup so stop complaining.

  • What the fuck is wrong with you!

    Who does this to Modest Mouse?

    Isaac Brock is going to send you to hell.

  • this................sucks.

  • this......sucks.

  • WAH WAH WAH MY BEAUTIFUL MODEST MOUSE IS BEING RUINED BY THIS GUY!

    Seriously, calm your asses down. I (of course) like modest mouse more than Miley Cyrus, but the user just wanted to show that the songs are using the same chord structure.

  • "They're practically the same song."

    Are you shitting me?

  • This is shit

  • whoever made this is a fucking retard

  • this hurts my heart... because miley cyrus doesn't even deserve to be in the same sentence as... well you know.

  • This is so hilariously horrible! God awful!

  • Kill yourself.

  • DUDE MODEST MOUSE AND ISAAC BROCK ARE MUSICAL GENIUSES, Miley cyrus is not! You cant possibly even begin to compare the two.

  • TERRIBLE!!!!! NEVER AGAIN ATTEMPT< YOU ARE AN IDIOT!!!!!!

  • Dude. This is musical blasphemy. What the fuck is this? Can you not hear all the improper notes? Not only is the key of these two songs off, but so is the time signature. Also, Miley Cyrus should never be associated with a god. Ever. Don't ever insult Isaac Brock again. His fan club isn't a large population of teenage females. We will hunt you down and murder you.

  • Too jumbled. Check out spookboy0's mash-up.

  • HATE.

  • Ooooh, try to get some a Capella versions of these two songs so you can cut out the dissonant chords that happen in the beginning. I thought of doing this mash-up the other day, but you've got a good start here, very nice!

  • this makes my ears bleed. off to the doctor now, thanks youtube.

  • I might get slapped but this is good

  • pretty damn good

  • Why is everyone busting on this dude? hes just trying to show you how much miley stole this song...

  • Miley doesn't deserve to be on the same webpage as modest. this SUCKS!

  • what software did you use?

  • this is horrible

  • i liked it.both vocals fit over the other riff.there basically the same song.i was going to make this but my system crashed :(

  • yes i caught this first time i heard mileys song.its so alike its ridiculous

  • whoever made this needs to kill themselves immediately. before i do it for you =/

  • why would you do this to modest mouse i frown on you

  • You are a horrible excuse for a human being..

  • it sorta matches ._.

  • this sounds like shit it dosent go together at ALLL

  • So much fail condensed in 3m11 of bad singing...

  • Find a fire. Die in it. Now.

  • what the fuck is this shit ???? typical shite american that cant sing or write

    ....

    please leave modest mouse stuff alone freak

  • hey float on fans..i have a mash up of float on vs intergalactic check out ppl i want to kno what you guys think.

  • This sounds pretty cool.

  • I wonder if the jury will accept this as legitimate murder reason..?

  • i knew it ever since her music video came out!

  • It's hilarious that as soon as I figured this out myself (thanks to Rock Band), I typed in "float on m" and the search finished the sentence for me.

  • haahhaha me too. I wanted to hear a remix of float on. So I thought, and sang the intro to float on in my head, and it turned into miley cyrus. so I typed in "float on mi" and it finished it lol.

  • i have another one on my page its called intergalactic vs float on check it out tell me what you think

  • chill out bmm good mix

  • Modest Mouse and Miley Cirus are complete opposites and it's insulting to Modest Mouse to put them together.

    Those songs are nothing alike and Miley Cirus doesn't have one tenth of one percent of the talent that Isaac Brock has. Miley is mainly a good voice and sex appeal. Issac Brock doesn't have either sex appeal or a good voice but he makes the best sounding music I've ever heard. He's the true artist, not Miley.

  • @BeautifulModestMouse The guitar riffs are pretty much the same but yeah other than that they are nothing alike

  • well hey man thought this was preety bad check out my mash up i did with float on..its called float on vs intergalactic you can get to it either by typing my name in the search bar or just clicking my name and going to my profile.not trying to spam or nothing bro just trying to get out there..tell me what you think about it :)

  • @BeautifulModestMouse mileys voice isnt even that good.

  • @BeautifulModestMouse the reason these songs go so well together is the chord progression is basically the same...but i dont think is a could "mash up"

  • @BeautifulModestMouse i think the idea is that miley's song is ripped off of modest mouse.

  • @BeautifulModestMouse Are you in Modest Mouse? If not, who are you to know what is offensive and insulting to Modest Mouse? This is a mash-up, not a talent competition or "true artist" competition. If you don't like the mash-up, just say so. I can't understand getting worked up about a mash-up when the band you like probably could give two fucks.

  • @BeautifulModestMouse I dont think the point of the video was to compare the artists, it was to point out that the instrumentals are practically the same and that the songs fit together perfectly

  • @BeautifulModestMouse I agree that Modest Mouse is worlds better than Miley Cyrus, but you can't deny that, even though Float On is a better song, they have very similar instrumentation and chord progressions, which make them similar songs.

  • @BeautifulModestMouse I totally agree!

  • Oh cool. :) Thumbs up.

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more