Dream Theater overrated??? Queensryche Masterpiece??? Okay DT is influenced by Queensryche, but honestly DT has taken Prog to a whole new level. Queensryche
shadow gallery is even better than D.T. and Aspera too by the way....D.T doesnt create anything...is only a mix between rush and yes with another sound...pains of salvation is more interesting...to hear...and even some records of angra...bands like twinspirits....Atmosfear...Ark...etc. im with you DT is SOOO overrated...people think that petrucci is god ...what about michael harris?
I love Dream Theater. I know a lot of people have a problem with James Labrie's voice but personally I'd take his voice over most of these dungeon-dragon vocals. No offense, it just gets old if it's every single band like most of these.
i wouldnt call dt overrated. they definitely deserve the credit they get. but i would agree than they've kinda become the stereotypical prog metal band. i mean, if you mention prog metal the first band people think of is dt. THERE'S A LOT MORE OUT THERE!!!
You see, that's very subjective and called "taste".
I like PoS more than any of the above bands, and I'd place Cynic at about the same level as DT, and that only because DT used to release quality albums a long long time ago.
And quite a few other bands are somewhere around "there" atm; not to mention I&W and Awake are the only albums from the above mentioned bands that would perhaps just make it into my top 10 metal albums.
But like I said, this is something called "taste".
I personally would put Metropolis part 2 up there. Even though it's obvious, I think it belongs in there. Not so much the other albums.
...But I'm talking about Pagan's Mind, Queensryche and Mindflow in terms of musicianship. It's a bit hard to say "Pagan's Mind's 'Enigmatic: Calling' blows Opeth's 'BWP/Still life/Deliverance' out of the water". Of course there are different tastes, I'm just personally talking in terms of melody, which is my taste.
I already knew all these bands lol. I think CM are good but over-rated, and Shadow Gallery have some mind-blowing instrumentals but their lyrics are cheesy as hell. I really like Dreamscape though.
I wouldn't call BTBAM emocore, they sounded like deathcore. Either way I don't like it. it's sad because they ARE a talented band, but they choose to sound like crap instead...
And my friends and I have a running joke about Opeth being naptime music, haha!
I personally think that Dream Theater is an incredible band, but my main frustration is their fanbase - how they think they've seen it all once they reach DT. Every band brings something new to the table, and progressive metal has so many other promising artists.
Yes, it's probably because a lot of Dream Theater fans are just metal fans, so when they hear Dream Theater, they probably just assume they are just a crazy metal band or something.
@Keyboardzrock I do think DT is a phenomenal band but as a DT fan I recognise there are many great bands out there who are on a par as musicians - love Vanden Plas, Symphony X, Porcupine Tree, Threshold and more recently Haken whose debut Aquarius is frankly phenomenal so us DT fans are open to other music - I don't think DT are overrated! The problem is that some of the other bands are UNDERRATED!- I only discovered Threshold and Vanden Plas last year - they've been around 20 years or so!!
I love this series, and it helped me discover one or two great metal bands out there that I wouldn't really have thought of listening to... here are some ideas you might consider if you plan on expanding this series
Disillusion, Back to Times of Splendor (prog/melodic death; I personally don't like death metal, but this album is simply too good)
Oblivion Awaits (watch?v=dzp8isg48yA ; mostly neoclassical, found it by accident lol)
To the person who posted this video. Dream theater is not over rated, i dont think you understand what that means lol. They are the kings of progressive rock/metal.. i cant even pin them on a specific genre because there so universal.
i think the reason why they are so popular is because no one really leasons to prog metal, it basically had its chance in the 80s and no one really tried it. dream theater may not be the gods of all prog metal, but they have done the most out of all of them, so, yeah they are close
He has a point. They ARE good; I mean they're still my 2nd favorite metal band (next to PoS) but a lot of DT fans act like DT are the be all and end all of prog metal, which is simply not true. There is a lot more to prog metal than DT, you just have to look for it.
Well acctually theres alot of good progressive bands out there my self dreamtheater is my favorite:P got a dreamtheater tattoo all over my back:D but got sevral other bands i like too like Circus maximus,Opeth,symphony x,Pagans mind shadow gallery so keep looking and you find the band so fit your personal tast of prog exact:)
Some nice choice cuts, like Osiris' Eyes by PM best. I notice you have Dreamscape's trance-like state as you avi, if you have that album I'd be eternally grateful If you'd put it up beacuse I haven't been able to buy it anywhere. Cheers.
I didnt said DT sucks or anything similar. They are an awesome band. Ive seen em live like 4 times and they are awesome. The problem is when thier fanboys talk about them thinking that they are the one and only prog band in the galaxy. They think that no prog band can stand beside them. People lets get things straight......that people arent the same after Awake......and since that....there have been hundreds of bands with better music that DT.
Great vids. I make progressive videos too so watching yours give me ideas. And there are a lot more bands than Dream Theater but that doesn't mean Dream Theater aren't good
Mindflow is the great brazilian band.
Saudem o mindflow.
DonVittoMontana 3 months ago
Dream Theater overrated??? Queensryche Masterpiece??? Okay DT is influenced by Queensryche, but honestly DT has taken Prog to a whole new level. Queensryche
termite98th 5 months ago
the only reason i like this video is the description. DT sucks ass.
haanbhyee 6 months ago
check out Cynic omg i just discovered them. like experiental, progressive, jazz metal
GuitarFreak70000 7 months ago
Comment removed
crocodilesmiles74 8 months ago
You say DT are overrated.
A lot of these bands emulate DT (not Queensryche, Pain of Salvation and the like) and so you call those bands overrated too.
crocodilesmiles74 8 months ago
shadow gallery is even better than D.T. and Aspera too by the way....D.T doesnt create anything...is only a mix between rush and yes with another sound...pains of salvation is more interesting...to hear...and even some records of angra...bands like twinspirits....Atmosfear...Ark...etc. im with you DT is SOOO overrated...people think that petrucci is god ...what about michael harris?
francheski 8 months ago
What is the name of the Porcupine Tree song? Thanks for the music, I'm buyin a lot of it soon.
blaklodge 9 months ago
DT is musical masturbation.
PissedFechtmeister 1 year ago
Thanks to your videos I know a lot of new prog metal bands, something i was searching for, great job with this videos, keep on Proggin :P
PowerRushFlame 1 year ago
CYNIC is an amazing band. Saw them live recently. BRILLIANT!!!!!
aguahoja 1 year ago
I love Dream Theater. I know a lot of people have a problem with James Labrie's voice but personally I'd take his voice over most of these dungeon-dragon vocals. No offense, it just gets old if it's every single band like most of these.
vinthebeast 1 year ago
i wouldnt call dt overrated. they definitely deserve the credit they get. but i would agree than they've kinda become the stereotypical prog metal band. i mean, if you mention prog metal the first band people think of is dt. THERE'S A LOT MORE OUT THERE!!!
middlenut3 1 year ago
Nice Ryche pick!
Definitely not enough appreciation out there for SiD
pygmyprawn 2 years ago
DT can be overrated for you... but has influenced 9 of 10 Prog metal bands....
hpinbr 2 years ago
Comment removed
J0000OOOO 2 years ago
Opeth, Porcupine Tree and DT are amazing. The others aren't quite there yet.
eviltube1111 2 years ago
You see, that's very subjective and called "taste".
I like PoS more than any of the above bands, and I'd place Cynic at about the same level as DT, and that only because DT used to release quality albums a long long time ago.
And quite a few other bands are somewhere around "there" atm; not to mention I&W and Awake are the only albums from the above mentioned bands that would perhaps just make it into my top 10 metal albums.
But like I said, this is something called "taste".
moneymail002 2 years ago 2
Pain of Salvation is just plain amazing.
I personally would put Metropolis part 2 up there. Even though it's obvious, I think it belongs in there. Not so much the other albums.
...But I'm talking about Pagan's Mind, Queensryche and Mindflow in terms of musicianship. It's a bit hard to say "Pagan's Mind's 'Enigmatic: Calling' blows Opeth's 'BWP/Still life/Deliverance' out of the water". Of course there are different tastes, I'm just personally talking in terms of melody, which is my taste.
eviltube1111 2 years ago 4
Saw your post. If you haven't, check out Shadow Gallery, Circus Maximus and DreamScape. Thank me later. ;)
metalweenis 2 years ago
I already knew all these bands lol. I think CM are good but over-rated, and Shadow Gallery have some mind-blowing instrumentals but their lyrics are cheesy as hell. I really like Dreamscape though.
moneymail002 2 years ago
Okay, just checking, lol. I really like CM though. Do you like the song End of Light by Dreamscape? I think there's a few parts that are just SICK.
metalweenis 2 years ago
Yeah, End of Light is what got me listening to them, it used to play on some internet radio from live365.
moneymail002 2 years ago
New Video coming Up!
adrian30020 2 years ago
nice.. adding queensryche.. major influence for alot of the prog bands today
fireguye4 2 years ago
Hail Pagan's Mind and Porcupine Tree!
DeathToNewbie 2 years ago
DT's New Album kicks major ass.
jerradcwilliams 2 years ago
i just watched all 9 of these lol
i have been baffled
if you're into new prog, check out between the buried and me
and Opeth (though i'm sure you've heard them)
jackamomo630 2 years ago
between the buried and me is a stupid emocore band, opeth is ok and all these bands are amazing
resilenthill 2 years ago
I wouldn't call BTBAM emocore, they sounded like deathcore. Either way I don't like it. it's sad because they ARE a talented band, but they choose to sound like crap instead...
And my friends and I have a running joke about Opeth being naptime music, haha!
wonderfoam 2 years ago
Comment removed
TacoDip2009 2 years ago
I laugh at anyone who calls BTBAM emocore. Yet, I still frown, because it shows there are still idiots out there.
TacoDip2009 2 years ago 3
Have you even heard colors?
ilikeeggs666 2 years ago
I personally think that Dream Theater is an incredible band, but my main frustration is their fanbase - how they think they've seen it all once they reach DT. Every band brings something new to the table, and progressive metal has so many other promising artists.
Keyboardzrock 2 years ago 16
@Keyboardzrock
Yes, it's probably because a lot of Dream Theater fans are just metal fans, so when they hear Dream Theater, they probably just assume they are just a crazy metal band or something.
Mordain607 1 year ago
@Keyboardzrock I do think DT is a phenomenal band but as a DT fan I recognise there are many great bands out there who are on a par as musicians - love Vanden Plas, Symphony X, Porcupine Tree, Threshold and more recently Haken whose debut Aquarius is frankly phenomenal so us DT fans are open to other music - I don't think DT are overrated! The problem is that some of the other bands are UNDERRATED!- I only discovered Threshold and Vanden Plas last year - they've been around 20 years or so!!
dreamwarriorphil 5 months ago
Got the name of the Porcupine Tree song
grassyknol 2 years ago
With all the many prog metal masterpieces you have, you've missed one band (unless I've missed it) Circus Maximus should get some recognition
wawwwaaa 2 years ago 4
They are in # 1 or # 2 I Think
adrian30020 2 years ago
i've looked, but they aren't there
wawwwaaa 2 years ago
heil, man. whats the name of the queensryche's song ?
micistan 2 years ago
Screaming in Digital
adrian30020 2 years ago
tnx.:) good vid
micistan 2 years ago
sos un capo
cesarpagua 2 years ago
I love this series, and it helped me discover one or two great metal bands out there that I wouldn't really have thought of listening to... here are some ideas you might consider if you plan on expanding this series
Disillusion, Back to Times of Splendor (prog/melodic death; I personally don't like death metal, but this album is simply too good)
Oblivion Awaits (watch?v=dzp8isg48yA ; mostly neoclassical, found it by accident lol)
moneymail002 2 years ago
You're so fucking right about Disillusion dude, I wish I stumbled upon more albums like BTTOS.
HooligannSTR 2 years ago
To the person who posted this video. Dream theater is not over rated, i dont think you understand what that means lol. They are the kings of progressive rock/metal.. i cant even pin them on a specific genre because there so universal.
evereddie 3 years ago
People like you and comments like that is what makes them the kings of the overated
adrian30020 3 years ago
i think the reason why they are so popular is because no one really leasons to prog metal, it basically had its chance in the 80s and no one really tried it. dream theater may not be the gods of all prog metal, but they have done the most out of all of them, so, yeah they are close
REAVEY 2 years ago
He has a point. They ARE good; I mean they're still my 2nd favorite metal band (next to PoS) but a lot of DT fans act like DT are the be all and end all of prog metal, which is simply not true. There is a lot more to prog metal than DT, you just have to look for it.
moneymail002 2 years ago 3
Well acctually theres alot of good progressive bands out there my self dreamtheater is my favorite:P got a dreamtheater tattoo all over my back:D but got sevral other bands i like too like Circus maximus,Opeth,symphony x,Pagans mind shadow gallery so keep looking and you find the band so fit your personal tast of prog exact:)
dreamtheater2k 3 years ago
Some nice choice cuts, like Osiris' Eyes by PM best. I notice you have Dreamscape's trance-like state as you avi, if you have that album I'd be eternally grateful If you'd put it up beacuse I haven't been able to buy it anywhere. Cheers.
alzico 3 years ago
I didnt said DT sucks or anything similar. They are an awesome band. Ive seen em live like 4 times and they are awesome. The problem is when thier fanboys talk about them thinking that they are the one and only prog band in the galaxy. They think that no prog band can stand beside them. People lets get things straight......that people arent the same after Awake......and since that....there have been hundreds of bands with better music that DT.
adrian30020 3 years ago
I like Dream Theater. They introduced me to prog. They may be overrated, but they are a gateway into the genre.
Also, what are the songs, in order, in this video?
FarazR2 3 years ago
Great vids. I make progressive videos too so watching yours give me ideas. And there are a lot more bands than Dream Theater but that doesn't mean Dream Theater aren't good
DTkeysplayer16 3 years ago