Wonderful playing. She doesn't quite excite me as much as Evgeny Kissin on this piece. I think Kissin may be playing on a bit better piano though. This is a Yamaha. She does give her own own female touch to the piece. To me Kissin puts a little fantasy into the piece. I enjoy her playing very much also.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
zzzSukSukSuxzzzzSukSuckSuckszzz istz suhc ape hitty yo espelign shudennly ymrpoved Wsa lout moor etnertainting beef ore yous tarted geitign twos hairyarse abuot tit all in sukhtc aan anal y tick all manerr. Glucklich Fahrt!
Strange to find almost NO MUSIC in this girl's rendings,sketchy skimpy tone,no real body of sound or nuance,all fart oof arsed like she snot interestd &got another competition to get to.Stravinsky sounded as anaemic as her ShowPan.Depressing.I zapped out beef ore the yendddd.
I think she is a phenomenal pianist. But the most artistic musicians know that beauty in music can't be accomplished when notes are so fast that you can't feel the music anymore. Express don't impress. This is about technique, not artistry. Which is alot of what the music scene is about, showmanship. I would rather hear this piece a tad slower.
uhmmm tisilisls when somebody plasy fast but thinks at the speed of his (her) playing is not probelm.
This superb pianist thinks the same or faster than the speed she plays. For that reason it sounds so fluent.........her pianism.
Not about artistry? Did you listen her prhasings, dynamics, balances, nuances?
She is just perfect. SOme pieces are not so good played in her hands, aS an example the Mozart Fantasie in C minor, BUT NOBODY `PALYS EVERYTHING PERFECT.
Huangci only chose to perform the TECHNICALLY HARDEST PIECES!!! I couldn't name a single pianist who liked to show off more bravura; she even surpasses Liszt in showing off bravura.
continuing.....a guy with a terrible technique so stiff. he played not mistakes almost, but his complete playing was a mistake..........so blurry, unclear, terrible use of pedals, clampling the floor with his foot, etc. just terrible, but he got the first place......Well in my opinion the third place should be assigned to Wang Shijun. and the last one to Sederenko or Yuan Jye.
continuing....Well, that´s the life. Anyway my sincere congratulations.
Unfortunately competitions are not the real indicator about how is your playing. The real imprtant think is improve yoour playing..specially since the musical side.
So..is good when you get advise from somebody about your "Bussines". also try to get advise to a different person to get a wider idea aboout how your "Bussines" is going. I am a person who believe in ture talent, and i believe you have it, But a little changing of attitude, could be very positive for you. Also avoid some unnecesary "Expressions" you made sometimes(fortunately are few), to establish a difference between a mere "Emotive"... to continue....
No1asskiker is right. Farteramadeus is ytpiano7 and it's also roberto barvo. Doesn't take a rocket scientist to figure it out. Thousands of u tubers know it too. Same style of writing.
continuing... in terms of a mechanic monster, but not as a real musician. I know that´s not true. But a thing who is true, owed to your amazing technique (i don´t know if it do you learned from a superlative teacher, or if it is a natural born gift)is the fact you don´t worry too much about to go deep into hte music itself, and a kind of arrogant attitude towards it. I really don´t know if thta is true, but at least thta is the opinion i got from mostly people who i was ...to continue...
Well. Dear Claire: If you are reading this comments about you... Take a note of this: I was invited for a person "X" to "Observe" the Hamamatsu "Piano Academy". I went Saturday afternoon and i remain until this evening. I was watching all the 6 finalists.
The best of all 6 were by far: You and the amazing 11 year old "Alice Burla". Alice Burla played a beautiful incredible 1st Chopin concerto under any point of view...technically and musically...
continuing.... you played an amazing 2nd Prokofieff concerto, but a question to you: ¿Why do you choose that concerto?...well, despite i really don´t like too much that work, it shows from you only (or mostly) you technique, but not some of the nice things you make( as an example) in the Chopin etude Op10 No2, or Feux Follets, or Bach-Busoni Chaconne. I make this observation, because many people(included some of the jury and not only from this competition) who i know, think of you..to continue..
My friend who belong to a group interested in improve the level of comments on youtube is now on vacation fron youtube. He will no make any comment for a while. I am speaking about ytpiano7. The principal difference between us is: I don´t get involved in dicussions with people like the guys who use garbage language.
They can post any of their grabage comments. They will have not any answer from me. frateramadeus
Senti froscio "Cherygarcia" come fai la finta di quell che non pui fare, peazzo di deficente encefalitico.Forse la tua mama te fa un pompino per farti cappire , ma come voui scribere quel cue voui........allora andatene a fan´culo en andatene a gonfiare assini per il cazzo. Figlio di sifilitica troia. Y por eso so reconcha de tu madre, dile a al granputa de la malparida de tu madre que te vaya a lamer el culo. Luego te lo lavas y te tomas el agua. RECONCHADETUMADRE.
Dear Cherrygarcia concha tu madre. Aprende a escribir el Italiano. Se voui scribere in italiano pezzo d´stronzo lo fai bene o non lo fai ¿Capito? figlio di putana? . per quello: Andatene a fan´culo o a la REPUTA DE TU MADRE QUE TE PARIÓ POR EL OJETE.
No jorgebachelrt TU MADRE ES EL ROBOT LAME PINGAS.
Tu,el mierda del cherybananagarcia el ytpino9y el kseto88 pueden irse toditos juntos de puntitas en zapatillas de ballet a la mierda y a la rechucha de su madre.Sigan jodiendo y ya verán como continua esto.Mientras tanto váyanse a inflar burros o mulas por la pinga o la pija, o la trola, o el pollón o como mierda le digan pero chúpensela todos juntos a la vez al burro.que eso es vuestro deporte favorito so cagados de nacimiento. GAYS.
"BNestimmterdas" is one more of the group of homosexuals whose nicknames are: " Lagrettabarreto" " cherygarcia" "Kseto88" and now the last one "Jorgebachelet" a gay too. who come here to SPAM some great pianists as Arrau, Rubinstein, and in special the young Claire Huangci. All of them hate women (very big homosexuals)and are fan of the Pycho pianist Lang Lang.
Read piece of crap ( nerd..thisk343498 ) i am not South American ( by born ) but one of my nationalities is from a Country of South America. My main nationality is Italian becuase i was born in Italy if that makes you happy imbecil
But ...so which is the problem with born in South America, or in any other country? bastard? From where is Martha Argerich? Baremboim? Arrau? Nelson Freire? Cristina Ortiz? Giomar novaes? Roberto Szydon?
You are a mentally retarded ans probably a big homosexual...
Ummmm muy osada para atreverse con este, pero bueno tan poco le ha quedado tan mal, aunque todavía tiene mucho que mejorar en lo que ha bueno se refiere, ah por Dios... y utilizar el legato, que es lo verdaderamente importante para que este te deje en buen lugar como pianista...^_^
Naturalmente que no es la Lang Lang pero pobre chica.. que no lo ha hecho tan mal.. está bastante bien.. si no llega a ser por el legatto que se le ha dejado olvidado..
Only an intelectual donkey can compare a 17 years old outstanding pianist with Argerich, Horowitz,...unbelievable, BUT MOST unbelievable is when that intelectual donkey put in the same bag Horowitz, Argerich and ¿Mitsuko Uchida the maniac pianist? but at least correct musician...BUT the mediocre Yundi Li with his stiff technique, and plntey of false accents ?? My God the ignorance and lack of people involved professionaly in music who make comments here is just Beyond any imagination
1)Clarie Huangci is already a great pianist despite her young age.
2)Horowitz and Argerich belong to the history already as a great pianists of all times.
3)Mitsuko Uchida is just a very correct pianist(no more)with a tons of lack of self control..argh.
3)Yundi Li is just a clean notes player with bad technic and very media musical level. He needs urgently to search for a good teacher. Win a competition in these days is not neccesary "The true".
i will never run out of words and new account name if i will. The words of revenge and vengeance against claire who will never have media support, no talent, no feelings, no dexterity.....
She does not rate in comparison to the living -- mistuko uchida, martha argerich or even yundi li - and the dead -- friedrich gulda, horowitz etc.... This is due to her lack of physical and emotional strength - demonstrated by her relatively weak tones in the piano, even in pieces such as the prokofiev, which require power. She uses a lot of pretentious elegance, producing light and weak tones, lacking in depth. nuances doesn't matter when u got someone with no feelings as claire
the physical strength required to play the piano is not of the big-muscle sort that claire lacks. Furthermore, Claire is always weak. also her tone is the weakest out there... it is a little heavy in some repertoire because she doesn't modify it.
she may play some of the difficult pieces but continue to worsen her techniques. she often has trouble with nuances. there's plenty of pretension and self-consciousness in her playing like what she does with this piece. it shows how many takes she had to do during this recital. Perhaps she almost had begun her so-called career in piano but throughout her life, she is only average pianist in general.
So wonderful. Great technique, Completely relaxed. Very even nuances. Great prahsing and use of dynamics. Only an ignorant amateur can make complaints against this already great pianist in his 16-17 years old.
She doesn't love playing the piano and it is obvious that she is only force to study by her teacher. She doesn't take this seriously. She doesn't smile. people would be longing for other things when they see this or even just after listening to this robotic pianist.
she plays this piece worse than any one else but better than she plays with her other already worse pieces and she plays a lot of out of out of tune notes because she don't memorize her piece
she doesn't show the real essence of the music. she is just a mime artist like in a silent film. just a mimic show of playing the piano. it surprise me how she can convey little playing through the piano
She uses her lack of memory to excuse her from having maturity and expression in her piece. Forget the faults, this kid's lack of soul is an ordinary pattern in her playing. She can't channel such subtly of mood, expression, emotion - to say of her technical ability
I want to go shoot the person who says that a woman can't move their fingers as rapidly as a man(though it had absolutely nothing to do with the piano).
that shows lack of practice already that she stoop down to the keyboards. i tink she needs some eye glasses because she has a trouble to see the piano.
i saw claire last night at a bar. she ordered margarita and cosmopolitan. that was cool. i did not know pianoist could drink at the bar. i thought they are like playing
Ia a moderator here or a persons who can block the "Kseto88" comments?
One thing is to make comments against somebody, and a differnet one is to come here with that kind of language who belongs more to a prostitues context maybe, but not to a place like this. What a pitty to have to read people with mental problems and with so low behavior-Probably that "Kseto88" born and growht in a neigborhood like Harlem or similar.
ytpiano7 should be removed. His comments are very insulting people. He likes to call a chinese person a chinese monkey or pigs. Is that what you call a high behaviour? Anyone agree with me?
The sick "Kseto88" and his sick friend "ytpiano9" not myself...i am "ytpiano7".
Those two fanatics of lang lang, hate me soo musch becasues my comments against their pig GOD (lang lAng), and they came here just to SPAM. Is good you to know this to understand the reason we have the comments of these two sick persons.
Where is the music? She might have a good technique of playing piano but without passion and personal style. It's very robotic. Any computerized grand piano can play the same thing.
Of course you are not invloved professionaly in music. That´s maybe the reason you make angry commnets agaisnt this already great pianist Claire Huangci. Becuase i criticize very strong your God "La Bestia" or Lang Lang (the same thing) is no reason to be so ridicoulus to copy in a 99% my nickname, and come here to write nonsense, and worst since you are completely a diletant in music.
Hey listen fucker, you write your OWM opinion and I write mine, understand? . They are both monkey piano players. As the matter of fact all asian piano players are all monkeys. But this bitch should'nt play piano at all. The reasons is she is a woman. Kitchen is where they belongs. They should stay home to cook, do the landery, clean the house and be ready to be fucked by their husband any time he wants to.
Absolutely awesome,I do not play but I have been listening to classical music since I was a kid.Let's just say for MANY years.Her performance was brilliant..BRAVA !!
Sometimes i think whether it's really possible to achieve a technique like that together with the ability to put one's soul too... i am giving up believing in this !!
about 40 years ago i heard a pirated recording of feux follets. it was a mature richter in bulgaria sometime around 1959-60. this is the closest thing to it i've heard since. she's wonderful.....it's so nice to sit back and hear someone else play it so effortlessly, as it should be. franz would be proud of this recording.
The talent out there nowadays is truly awesome. I'm new to Liszt, but I've figured out by now that the Etude No. 5 'Feux Follets' (second piece here) is one of the most devilishly difficult piano pieces, which many famous pianists declined to attempt. I agree with someone who says she plays it cleaner and with more spirit than Kissin - at least to my inexperienced ears. If one can do this at 16, where does one go? It's frightening.
Incidentally, she played the Liszt Etude No.5 and Don Juan in the 2006 Minnesota piano-e-competition also. If you have a digital piano and your computer has MIDI connection, you can download the MIDI files and play her performances on your piano. Too bad that she did not play Chopin's Andante Spianato there.
Who is this Bassman911? Did you start learning how to play the piano yesterday? It is terrible that someone who can't tell the difference between a 'song' and a 'piece', and who can't identify Chopin's Andante Spianato would think he is in possesion of a genius that towers over this very talented girl. She is very young, but if you think she lacks ability, you lack humility. And a brain.
My goodness! May I ask what competition this is? She's fabulous! In only one recital, she played such demanding works? What are the works she played in the other rounds?
that fourth song sounds like an embellished version of the raindrop prelude by chopin. very pretty, crazy strong technique but I feel her musical ability is a bit lacking.
unfortunately the Stravinsky is not as good as the other etudes. She didn't have as much control and hit many wrong notes, which seems quite uncharacteristic considering the technique she displayed in the previous two etudes.
Amazing!
monicapianista 1 year ago
mmm thats good feux follets!
verystacy 1 year ago
I saw her at the National Chopin Competition :D
Laureeeen1995 2 years ago
OMG!
she's so amazing!:P
I wanna see her in concerT!
:P
by the way, what was her place after the competition?
:P
great vid!
salamence47 2 years ago
Wonderful playing. She doesn't quite excite me as much as Evgeny Kissin on this piece. I think Kissin may be playing on a bit better piano though. This is a Yamaha. She does give her own own female touch to the piece. To me Kissin puts a little fantasy into the piece. I enjoy her playing very much also.
robertslistening 2 years ago
@robertslistening I think I would agree with you there. Kissin certainly has more power but I really do enjoy this performance.
chobeethaninov 7 months ago
She is genial is true but please only fingers...
manuelfernandezkrk 2 years ago
I enjoyed this very much; an excellent effeminate program and accurate performance for such like!
pobz100 3 years ago
this girl is incredible...she' s not normal!!!!!she's the best of all!!!!
syzi1857 3 years ago 8
Program played here:
Chopin: Etude op.10/2
Liszt: Etude d'excécution transcendante n. 5 "Feux follets", S139
Stravinsky: Etude op.7/4
Chopin: Andante spianato e Grande Polacca brillante, op.22
Liszt: Réminiscences de Don Juan, S418
Tokuyama: Musica Nara
IMHO, this IS NOT human!! And she was only 16 here! "Breathtaking performance" is not enough!
DesAbends 3 years ago 9
This is just so amazing! I haven't ever heard so wonderful version of 10 2. So wonderful music!
Aul1kki 3 years ago 2
Amazing . Only comparable to Pollini´s version.
666
z666z666z 3 years ago
This is great!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Pianoloverok 3 years ago 4
Wonderful pianist.
666
z666z666z 3 years ago
what dp u mean by '666' ??!
jockolong 3 years ago
What i meant?. jockolong?.
Just 3 consecutives 6.
or is something rare in writing numbers?
z666z666z 3 years ago
I shat myself
djvbb12 3 years ago
Amazing!
It's so fast,and my eyes are running out!:)
masherlenys 3 years ago
Amazing!
It's so fast,and my eyes are running out!:)
masherlenys 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
zzzSukSukSuxzzzzSukSuckSuckszzz istz suhc ape hitty yo espelign shudennly ymrpoved Wsa lout moor etnertainting beef ore yous tarted geitign twos hairyarse abuot tit all in sukhtc aan anal y tick all manerr. Glucklich Fahrt!
fartlestucks 3 years ago
Are you still with farts ??? farttlestruchs?
Some probelm with your asshole?.
Just take many Ex-Lax tablets, and you will trow away all your fucking farts.
Just don´t disturb the beutiful playing of this nice girl with your fucking farts.
And please. don´t go to any of her recitals, becuase all people will abandon the concert hall becuase your dirty farts.
666
z666z666z 3 years ago
Oh please, just stop it.
beaver7756 3 years ago
What´s the matter with you beaver77756?
i will stop it when i want. Capito?
666
z666z666z 3 years ago
Comment removed
D0g63rt 3 years ago
Strange to find almost NO MUSIC in this girl's rendings,sketchy skimpy tone,no real body of sound or nuance,all fart oof arsed like she snot interestd &got another competition to get to.Stravinsky sounded as anaemic as her ShowPan.Depressing.I zapped out beef ore the yendddd.
fartlestucks 3 years ago
fartstklestucks...youshould have a nickname ""FART" which is closer to your fucking ignornace.
When you want to write or speak about something what you have no even the smallest idea, is better to take your tongue, and put in into your asshole.
Retarded.
666
z666z666z 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Read carefully fucking fartslestrusjedikejd...s..
You don´t find anything in this girl playing becuase you are:
Deaf , or sick, or with not any musical trainig, or a jelous girl, or gay, or something related to all those posibilities.
If you don´t like her playing is a different story, but in MUSIC, are things which are objetive:
Technique, Understanding of the score, individuality into the rendition of that music
---->
z666z666z 3 years ago
----> or personality, sense of musical architecture, tone quality, and of course PHRASING.
All this elements are perfectly harmonized by this over-talented pianist.
So : Just say i dont´like, or if is not the case , explain scientifically the reasons for your comments.
666
z666z666z 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
she does act like a freak when she plays... but what more can you expect from an asian
davidweiner23 3 years ago
In general terms you can not expect too much form Asian pianists.
BUT this pianist is the exception. She is a great pianist already.
You are a kind of ignorant. Go to learn something about music before.
666
z666z666z 3 years ago
@z666z666z what a stupid thing to say. In general terms you cannot expect too much from any pianist these days-Asian or not.
verystacy 1 year ago
I think she is a phenomenal pianist. But the most artistic musicians know that beauty in music can't be accomplished when notes are so fast that you can't feel the music anymore. Express don't impress. This is about technique, not artistry. Which is alot of what the music scene is about, showmanship. I would rather hear this piece a tad slower.
tisisils 3 years ago
uhmmm tisilisls when somebody plasy fast but thinks at the speed of his (her) playing is not probelm.
This superb pianist thinks the same or faster than the speed she plays. For that reason it sounds so fluent.........her pianism.
Not about artistry? Did you listen her prhasings, dynamics, balances, nuances?
She is just perfect. SOme pieces are not so good played in her hands, aS an example the Mozart Fantasie in C minor, BUT NOBODY `PALYS EVERYTHING PERFECT.
666
z666z666z 3 years ago 3
Some of the songs are written to be as fast as she plays
djvbb12 3 years ago
BRava Hungaci
666
z666z666z 3 years ago
Ohh yeahh..............what a place . the beauty and the beasts?
No at all.
Superman?..........Wonder woman? Bachelet? Kakasetto? Cheeta? Tarzan?
so cool......yeahh...all assholes. In this place the only brained are mathpianist, frater, and zongora.
Just an amazing pianist. Ototoi.....Wang tang.
sugoi.
fuck fuck and fuck. What a moment.bananas ¡¡
666
z666z666z 3 years ago
This is NOT funny.
Huangci only chose to perform the TECHNICALLY HARDEST PIECES!!! I couldn't name a single pianist who liked to show off more bravura; she even surpasses Liszt in showing off bravura.
mathpianist93 4 years ago
Hello.
Is somebody the moderator of this link?
Please make know it, becuause i would like to send him (her) a very important private post.
Thanks in advance.
zongorarichter
zongorarichter 3 years ago
And Liszt WAS JUSTIFIED TO BE showing off bravura!!!
mathpianist93 3 years ago
continuing.....a guy with a terrible technique so stiff. he played not mistakes almost, but his complete playing was a mistake..........so blurry, unclear, terrible use of pedals, clampling the floor with his foot, etc. just terrible, but he got the first place......Well in my opinion the third place should be assigned to Wang Shijun. and the last one to Sederenko or Yuan Jye.
Well, that´s the life. ...to continue.....
frateramadeus 4 years ago
continuing....Well, that´s the life. Anyway my sincere congratulations.
Unfortunately competitions are not the real indicator about how is your playing. The real imprtant think is improve yoour playing..specially since the musical side.
frateramadeus 4 years ago
continuing.....talking about you.
So..is good when you get advise from somebody about your "Bussines". also try to get advise to a different person to get a wider idea aboout how your "Bussines" is going. I am a person who believe in ture talent, and i believe you have it, But a little changing of attitude, could be very positive for you. Also avoid some unnecesary "Expressions" you made sometimes(fortunately are few), to establish a difference between a mere "Emotive"... to continue....
frateramadeus 4 years ago
You are ytpiano7!
no1asskiker 4 years ago 2
Read carefully "no1Asskisser". I am not ytpiano7, but if you don´t believe it, sorry i can´t do nothing for it.
Bye dear
frateramadeus 4 years ago
you are right no1asskikker
jorgebachelet 4 years ago
No1asskiker is right. Farteramadeus is ytpiano7 and it's also roberto barvo. Doesn't take a rocket scientist to figure it out. Thousands of u tubers know it too. Same style of writing.
kseto88 4 years ago
continuing... in terms of a mechanic monster, but not as a real musician. I know that´s not true. But a thing who is true, owed to your amazing technique (i don´t know if it do you learned from a superlative teacher, or if it is a natural born gift)is the fact you don´t worry too much about to go deep into hte music itself, and a kind of arrogant attitude towards it. I really don´t know if thta is true, but at least thta is the opinion i got from mostly people who i was ...to continue...
frateramadeus 4 years ago
Well. Dear Claire: If you are reading this comments about you... Take a note of this: I was invited for a person "X" to "Observe" the Hamamatsu "Piano Academy". I went Saturday afternoon and i remain until this evening. I was watching all the 6 finalists.
The best of all 6 were by far: You and the amazing 11 year old "Alice Burla". Alice Burla played a beautiful incredible 1st Chopin concerto under any point of view...technically and musically...
to continue..
frateramadeus 4 years ago
continuing.... you played an amazing 2nd Prokofieff concerto, but a question to you: ¿Why do you choose that concerto?...well, despite i really don´t like too much that work, it shows from you only (or mostly) you technique, but not some of the nice things you make( as an example) in the Chopin etude Op10 No2, or Feux Follets, or Bach-Busoni Chaconne. I make this observation, because many people(included some of the jury and not only from this competition) who i know, think of you..to continue..
frateramadeus 4 years ago
My friend who belong to a group interested in improve the level of comments on youtube is now on vacation fron youtube. He will no make any comment for a while. I am speaking about ytpiano7. The principal difference between us is: I don´t get involved in dicussions with people like the guys who use garbage language.
They can post any of their grabage comments. They will have not any answer from me. frateramadeus
frateramadeus 4 years ago
how can it be possible :O
waldoelchulo 4 years ago
Finally they post again the Prokofieff Toccata Op.11 again, WONDERFUL.
ytpiano7
ytpiano7 4 years ago
Come one guys, I don't think she's like a robot. She's so musical and talented for such age!
strider881 4 years ago
Ji nv, cao ni zu zong shi ba dai claire
jorgebachelet 4 years ago
ytpiano7
this is not about italian grammar. i write what i wish to write capito roberto?
cherygarciah 4 years ago
Senti froscio "Cherygarcia" come fai la finta di quell che non pui fare, peazzo di deficente encefalitico.Forse la tua mama te fa un pompino per farti cappire , ma come voui scribere quel cue voui........allora andatene a fan´culo en andatene a gonfiare assini per il cazzo. Figlio di sifilitica troia. Y por eso so reconcha de tu madre, dile a al granputa de la malparida de tu madre que te vaya a lamer el culo. Luego te lo lavas y te tomas el agua. RECONCHADETUMADRE.
ytpiano7 4 years ago
non capito tu vecchio garbage gay.
cherygarciah 4 years ago
ytpiano7
tu vecchio, your mama what?
cherygarciah 4 years ago
Dear Cherrygarcia concha tu madre. Aprende a escribir el Italiano. Se voui scribere in italiano pezzo d´stronzo lo fai bene o non lo fai ¿Capito? figlio di putana? . per quello: Andatene a fan´culo o a la REPUTA DE TU MADRE QUE TE PARIÓ POR EL OJETE.
Chau MARICÓN.
Addio froscio.
ytpiano7 4 years ago
Kseto88: Concha tu madre
ytpiano7 4 years ago
Ytpiano: bagayelo!
kseto88 4 years ago
ytpianosiete: anciano sewer rat. vete a la verga, vales verga pianista retardino bravo!
cherygarciah 4 years ago
La verga es lo que te gusta como loca. CONCHA DE TU MADRE
ytpiano7 4 years ago
A robot!
kseto88 4 years ago
Si Kesto85 la concha tu madre is a robot
ytpiano7 4 years ago
a defective robot is claire.
jorgebachelet 4 years ago
No jorgebachelrt TU MADRE ES EL ROBOT LAME PINGAS.
Tu,el mierda del cherybananagarcia el ytpino9y el kseto88 pueden irse toditos juntos de puntitas en zapatillas de ballet a la mierda y a la rechucha de su madre.Sigan jodiendo y ya verán como continua esto.Mientras tanto váyanse a inflar burros o mulas por la pinga o la pija, o la trola, o el pollón o como mierda le digan pero chúpensela todos juntos a la vez al burro.que eso es vuestro deporte favorito so cagados de nacimiento. GAYS.
ytpiano7 4 years ago
jorge bachelte the only defective here is your mom
ytpiano7 4 years ago
ytpiano, let's get off of mothers, I just got off of yours
davidweiner23 4 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
agreed
davidweiner23 4 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
"BNestimmterdas" is one more of the group of homosexuals whose nicknames are: " Lagrettabarreto" " cherygarcia" "Kseto88" and now the last one "Jorgebachelet" a gay too. who come here to SPAM some great pianists as Arrau, Rubinstein, and in special the young Claire Huangci. All of them hate women (very big homosexuals)and are fan of the Pycho pianist Lang Lang.
ytpiano7
ytpiano7 4 years ago
ytpiano7 is south american idot!
nerthzib 4 years ago
Hello "nerd thsib" i didn´t understand ..Your mom what?
ytpiano7
ytpiano7 4 years ago
Read piece of crap ( nerd..thisk343498 ) i am not South American ( by born ) but one of my nationalities is from a Country of South America. My main nationality is Italian becuase i was born in Italy if that makes you happy imbecil
Hai Capito stronzo ?
ytpiano7
ytpiano7 4 years ago
But ...so which is the problem with born in South America, or in any other country? bastard? From where is Martha Argerich? Baremboim? Arrau? Nelson Freire? Cristina Ortiz? Giomar novaes? Roberto Szydon?
You are a mentally retarded ans probably a big homosexual...
ytpiano7
ytpiano7 4 years ago
Ytpiano7 is not a south american. It, I have to use "IT" is a sewer rat.
kseto88 4 years ago
Hola kaseto067 concha tu madre.
ytpiano7 4 years ago
Cierto kasetto547 no soy sudamericano concha tu madre
ytpiano7 4 years ago
ytpiano7 sewer rat: BAGAYELO!
kseto88 4 years ago
Ummmm muy osada para atreverse con este, pero bueno tan poco le ha quedado tan mal, aunque todavía tiene mucho que mejorar en lo que ha bueno se refiere, ah por Dios... y utilizar el legato, que es lo verdaderamente importante para que este te deje en buen lugar como pianista...^_^
jorgebachelet 4 years ago
Naturalmente que no es la Lang Lang pero pobre chica.. que no lo ha hecho tan mal.. está bastante bien.. si no llega a ser por el legatto que se le ha dejado olvidado..
Que no está mal no seais malos^^
jorgebachelet 4 years ago
Of course she is not the monkey pig chinese lang Lang.
You are comparing a first class person with a Chines "Culi" ( la Bestia ) lang Lang.
De que legato estás hablando? Ni tienes idea de lo que hablas. A ver te espero para que sustentes lo que escribes.
ytpiano7
ytpiano7 4 years ago
If you just watch her, you realize that her playing is not as as exciting as it seems. Bad posture, bad body movements.
jorgebachelet 4 years ago
Bad posture, Bad body movements?
Really?
Well explain why if you can.
I will waiting for it.
ytpiano7
ytpiano7 4 years ago
"BNestimmterdas" is one more of the group of homosexuals who come here to SPAM Claire Huangci.
ytpiano7
ytpiano7 4 years ago
CLAIRE is Cheap Whore! Claire is
a Monkey! Bad Playing Piano.
bestimmterdas 4 years ago
I totoaal agree with you.
kseto88 4 years ago
Only an intelectual donkey can compare a 17 years old outstanding pianist with Argerich, Horowitz,...unbelievable, BUT MOST unbelievable is when that intelectual donkey put in the same bag Horowitz, Argerich and ¿Mitsuko Uchida the maniac pianist? but at least correct musician...BUT the mediocre Yundi Li with his stiff technique, and plntey of false accents ?? My God the ignorance and lack of people involved professionaly in music who make comments here is just Beyond any imagination
ytpiano7
ytpiano7 4 years ago
And to be clear:
What i wanted to say is:
1)Clarie Huangci is already a great pianist despite her young age.
2)Horowitz and Argerich belong to the history already as a great pianists of all times.
3)Mitsuko Uchida is just a very correct pianist(no more)with a tons of lack of self control..argh.
3)Yundi Li is just a clean notes player with bad technic and very media musical level. He needs urgently to search for a good teacher. Win a competition in these days is not neccesary "The true".
ytpiano7 4 years ago
interesting. she seems ok. all things considered. could you please the complete video?
thetroutrex 4 years ago
i will never run out of words and new account name if i will. The words of revenge and vengeance against claire who will never have media support, no talent, no feelings, no dexterity.....
DG
cherygarciah 4 years ago
She does not rate in comparison to the living -- mistuko uchida, martha argerich or even yundi li - and the dead -- friedrich gulda, horowitz etc.... This is due to her lack of physical and emotional strength - demonstrated by her relatively weak tones in the piano, even in pieces such as the prokofiev, which require power. She uses a lot of pretentious elegance, producing light and weak tones, lacking in depth. nuances doesn't matter when u got someone with no feelings as claire
cherygarciah 4 years ago
the physical strength required to play the piano is not of the big-muscle sort that claire lacks. Furthermore, Claire is always weak. also her tone is the weakest out there... it is a little heavy in some repertoire because she doesn't modify it.
cherygarciah 4 years ago
she may play some of the difficult pieces but continue to worsen her techniques. she often has trouble with nuances. there's plenty of pretension and self-consciousness in her playing like what she does with this piece. it shows how many takes she had to do during this recital. Perhaps she almost had begun her so-called career in piano but throughout her life, she is only average pianist in general.
cherygarciah 4 years ago
So wonderful. Great technique, Completely relaxed. Very even nuances. Great prahsing and use of dynamics. Only an ignorant amateur can make complaints against this already great pianist in his 16-17 years old.
ytpiano7
ytpiano7 4 years ago
She doesn't love playing the piano and it is obvious that she is only force to study by her teacher. She doesn't take this seriously. She doesn't smile. people would be longing for other things when they see this or even just after listening to this robotic pianist.
cherygarciah 4 years ago
she plays this piece worse than any one else but better than she plays with her other already worse pieces and she plays a lot of out of out of tune notes because she don't memorize her piece
cherygarciah 4 years ago
she doesn't show the real essence of the music. she is just a mime artist like in a silent film. just a mimic show of playing the piano. it surprise me how she can convey little playing through the piano
cherygarciah 4 years ago
Is this Etude Op. 10 No. 2?
GrandPatzer 4 years ago
Yes it is.
4313112hamamatsu 4 years ago
She uses her lack of memory to excuse her from having maturity and expression in her piece. Forget the faults, this kid's lack of soul is an ordinary pattern in her playing. She can't channel such subtly of mood, expression, emotion - to say of her technical ability
cherygarciah 4 years ago
she has no potential and does not show a large technical skill. she plays with the maturity of a confident 2 year old.
cherygarciah 4 years ago
I want to go shoot the person who says that a woman can't move their fingers as rapidly as a man(though it had absolutely nothing to do with the piano).
hellomate639 4 years ago
I can tell there is a lot of talent beyond the technical ability.
However, as for the piece itself, I'm not terribly fond if it...
hellomate639 4 years ago
You don't respect people, people won,t respect you. A very simple formula.
kseto88 4 years ago 3
that shows lack of practice already that she stoop down to the keyboards. i tink she needs some eye glasses because she has a trouble to see the piano.
cherygarciah 4 years ago
why is she sway like there's a hurricane. she is a sway robot. why couldn't she see the keyboards? why does she have to stoop down.
cherygarciah 4 years ago
claire's mama is imbecil. i saw it on the other youtube. i don't know what she is if she is a pianoist or a imbecil. cannot decide please help me.
lagretabarretto 4 years ago
Ask ytpiano7. That thing is a professional.
kseto88 4 years ago
what is this that she is playing on the keyboards?
lagretabarretto 4 years ago
i saw claire last night at a bar. she ordered margarita and cosmopolitan. that was cool. i did not know pianoist could drink at the bar. i thought they are like playing
lagretabarretto 4 years ago
You are 18 years old.
Why were you at a bar, last night?
4313112hamamatsu 4 years ago
You believe he is 18? In the world of cyberspace everything are fake.
kseto88 4 years ago
Yes, you are.
I can't say he writes the fact or not.
But, at least he writes so at his page.
4313112hamamatsu 4 years ago
Now, I can understand what you say, kseto88.
Thank you foy your comment.
So, we are in a cyberspace.
But..., there is a big problem.
The problem is I ofen forget it.
4313112hamamatsu 4 years ago
No, they're not loosers. Far from it, just an upper class type.
hellomate639 4 years ago
Ia a moderator here or a persons who can block the "Kseto88" comments?
One thing is to make comments against somebody, and a differnet one is to come here with that kind of language who belongs more to a prostitues context maybe, but not to a place like this. What a pitty to have to read people with mental problems and with so low behavior-Probably that "Kseto88" born and growht in a neigborhood like Harlem or similar.
ytpiano7
ytpiano7 4 years ago
ytpiano7 should be removed. His comments are very insulting people. He likes to call a chinese person a chinese monkey or pigs. Is that what you call a high behaviour? Anyone agree with me?
kseto88 4 years ago 3
What a coincidence
The sick "Kseto88" and his sick friend "ytpiano9" not myself...i am "ytpiano7".
Those two fanatics of lang lang, hate me soo musch becasues my comments against their pig GOD (lang lAng), and they came here just to SPAM. Is good you to know this to understand the reason we have the comments of these two sick persons.
ytpiano7
ytpiano7 4 years ago
Excellent!
katsura999 4 years ago
Where is the music? She might have a good technique of playing piano but without passion and personal style. It's very robotic. Any computerized grand piano can play the same thing.
ytpiano9 4 years ago
Where is the music?
Listen and write piece of deaf.
Of course you are not invloved professionaly in music. That´s maybe the reason you make angry commnets agaisnt this already great pianist Claire Huangci. Becuase i criticize very strong your God "La Bestia" or Lang Lang (the same thing) is no reason to be so ridicoulus to copy in a 99% my nickname, and come here to write nonsense, and worst since you are completely a diletant in music.
Be more intelligent.
ytpiano7 (the original one)
ytpiano7 4 years ago
Hey listen fucker, you write your OWM opinion and I write mine, understand? . They are both monkey piano players. As the matter of fact all asian piano players are all monkeys. But this bitch should'nt play piano at all. The reasons is she is a woman. Kitchen is where they belongs. They should stay home to cook, do the landery, clean the house and be ready to be fucked by their husband any time he wants to.
kseto88 4 years ago
Hay son. Your mama was great last night.
kseto88 4 years ago
you are so childish, or was your mother underpressed by your father?
xXwaveXxdat 4 years ago
What a pitty the exsistence of people like you
ytpiano7
ytpiano7 4 years ago
Absolutely awesome,I do not play but I have been listening to classical music since I was a kid.Let's just say for MANY years.Her performance was brilliant..BRAVA !!
TSEG72351 4 years ago
Great
ytpiano7 4 years ago
She is just another chinese monkey.
ytpiano9 4 years ago
does anyone know what the third piece's name is? I couldn't recognize it at all.
Hiro5508 4 years ago
Sometimes i think whether it's really possible to achieve a technique like that together with the ability to put one's soul too... i am giving up believing in this !!
kristmist 4 years ago
daim, she pwns
suremate 4 years ago
Does anybody know what is a name of the third work?
tlbhp 4 years ago
Stravinsky Etudes 4
dobo50 4 years ago
Tu est envoutante!
crazyboi1949 4 years ago
shit...........she is really a piano, Not pianist..men
vinnymatrix 4 years ago
Comment removed
Wazzup132435465768 4 years ago
Comment removed
Wazzup132435465768 4 years ago
Excellent!!!!!
Pianoloverok 4 years ago
about 40 years ago i heard a pirated recording of feux follets. it was a mature richter in bulgaria sometime around 1959-60. this is the closest thing to it i've heard since. she's wonderful.....it's so nice to sit back and hear someone else play it so effortlessly, as it should be. franz would be proud of this recording.
hothairybtm4u 4 years ago
She plays at a furious tempo, and her passage work is clean. Her "Feux Follet" is the best I've heard. Bravissimo!
ArmchairPundit 4 years ago
For only 16 years old, that's fucking INCREDIBLE!!
TheTradge 4 years ago
Wow- thanks for this video! Nadyart, the third and last piece is Chopin's barcarole (boat song).
mason104 4 years ago
My mistake- it's not barcarole.
mason104 4 years ago
It's Andante Spianato et Grande Polonaise, Op.22.
mason104 4 years ago
Her performance is truly excellent. I don't know why she is not famous.
chanwcom 4 years ago
Well to be fair she's only 16 years old, she's bound to come to fame some day soon!
TheTradge 4 years ago
Excellent!!!!!!!!
Pianoloverok 4 years ago
Esta pianista tiene una técnica impresionante. Bravo!
tigrankalevian 4 years ago
What is there to say! Amazing girl! I´ve never seen such a young pianist with such ease and elegant technique! Brilliant!!
JoenEik 4 years ago
The talent out there nowadays is truly awesome. I'm new to Liszt, but I've figured out by now that the Etude No. 5 'Feux Follets' (second piece here) is one of the most devilishly difficult piano pieces, which many famous pianists declined to attempt. I agree with someone who says she plays it cleaner and with more spirit than Kissin - at least to my inexperienced ears. If one can do this at 16, where does one go? It's frightening.
orion777ben 4 years ago
And she seems charming, graceful and pleasant, without any ego. Why aren't the major labels fighting over her?
orion777ben 4 years ago
she's probably one of my favourite young pianists! Her feux follets is fantastic!!
TheTradge 4 years ago
What is the name of the third piece?
nadyart 4 years ago
It's Stravinsky's Etude in F sharp major, Op. 7 No. 4 - a piece which doesn't get heard much.
BrucknerEnthusiast 4 years ago
Yeah, I love the rendition of Stravinsky's 7/4 by Jon Nakamatsu during Cliburn '97.
Nalsii 4 years ago
WOW. 10/2 amazing
elevateme 4 years ago
Incidentally, she played the Liszt Etude No.5 and Don Juan in the 2006 Minnesota piano-e-competition also. If you have a digital piano and your computer has MIDI connection, you can download the MIDI files and play her performances on your piano. Too bad that she did not play Chopin's Andante Spianato there.
kykong 4 years ago
Who is this Bassman911? Did you start learning how to play the piano yesterday? It is terrible that someone who can't tell the difference between a 'song' and a 'piece', and who can't identify Chopin's Andante Spianato would think he is in possesion of a genius that towers over this very talented girl. She is very young, but if you think she lacks ability, you lack humility. And a brain.
qwertyproulx 4 years ago
My goodness! May I ask what competition this is? She's fabulous! In only one recital, she played such demanding works? What are the works she played in the other rounds?
thriving21yo 4 years ago
this is some of the most gorgeous playing I ve ever heard.believe me people this is special!
chad410 4 years ago
that's hot shit...
AdaOsi 4 years ago
Does anyone know where I can get sheet music for the last piece she played, Musica Nara?
pianogirl714 4 years ago
that fourth song sounds like an embellished version of the raindrop prelude by chopin. very pretty, crazy strong technique but I feel her musical ability is a bit lacking.
Bassman911 4 years ago
unfortunately the Stravinsky is not as good as the other etudes. She didn't have as much control and hit many wrong notes, which seems quite uncharacteristic considering the technique she displayed in the previous two etudes.
tlin741332 4 years ago
which competition is this?
elevateme 4 years ago
Thanks, houseofblackleaves!
PianoDabbler 4 years ago
Awesome! What are pieces 3&4?
PianoDabbler 4 years ago
In this round she played:
-Chopin: Etude op.10/2
-Liszt: Feux Follets
-Stravinsky: etude op.7/4
-Chopin: Andante Spianato et Grande Polonaise Brilliante
-Liszt: Reminiscenses de Don Juan
-Tokuyama: Musica nara
This was my favorite recital in the whole competition. Pity for her third round... she could have done really well if it was as good as this one!
houseofblackleaves 4 years ago
Wow she was wonderful... The etude set seems based upon Sa Chen's choice @ her amazing 1st round recital at the Van Cliburn in 2005...
beethoven op.110
Chopin Etude Op.25 no.6
Liszt Feux Follets
Stravinsky Etude Op.7 no.3.... Actually this was the one that Claire played too, not no.4.
lostinfugue 4 years ago
Yeah, I just realized that two weeks ago when I was going through the archived videos on the Van Cliburn website.
You can see the similarities from that competition in Huangci's interpretation, like her Don Juan and Joyce Yang (brilliant pianist also)'s Don Juan.
And I'm pretty sure that this is no.4, unless the edition of this etude I have is numbered incorrectly (which may be.)
houseofblackleaves 4 years ago
Did she win the competition? If she didn't, there ought to be an investigation!
xalamac 5 years ago