This sounds like a pop song. The eeriness and emotions that this song transmits when Tarja sings it is lost when you hear it from Annette. I am not saying she doesn't sing good, all I am saying is that the song feels very different, somewhat without power and losses most of its appeal- except if you plan to hear it in a club, I guess.
THIS IS TERRIBLE!!! :o TARJA WAS SO SO SO MUCH BETTER!!!! <3 THIS ANETTE, WHATEVER.... TOTAL BITCH!!!! PLAYS IN A FINISH BAND AND CAN'T EVEN SPEAK FINNISH!!!!! LIKE WTF???!!!
i support hellBoy133333, tarja was a cunt who thought she was better then the band, well guess what.. there doing better then when she was around and i beleive anette's voice is better.
Wow, Anette got way better at this song. Hmm, she isn't so bad after all! I thought that Nightwish had been almost ruined by a new singer, but hey, she is getting MUCH better.
not bad annette! You go girl. I didn't expect her to do so well on one of Tarja's old song, but she sounds sweet and innocent on it and gave the song a new kind of mood to it. Its beautiful.
this is really good! its nothing like tarja bus still its great how anette could do just as good job as anyone else who joined nightwish could possilbe do. She pulled it off as best to her abilities..kudos to you Anette! you filled Tarja's shoes pretty well <3
i like them both...very inspirative song ...luv it (cry)...remind me about the old days...the childhood was so great...okay peace&love guys...luv u too annete...very nice voice
STOP!!! JUST STOP!!!stop....Taria WAS a perfet singer,she was my favourite singer..But I realise Taria have a perfect voice,but she is..a......Assh...
Anette is a pretty good singer. it's not that easy too sing this song. tarja was just able to sing this song cuz she has a opera voice. and in case u guys haven't heard 'byebye beautiful' , it was tarja's fault that she got kicked out of the band. so keep ur smart ass comments to urself.
She ruined Tarja Turunens lovely version with some new shit version. This version sounded much better when Tarja Turunen sang it. Now it sounds like crap.
Tarja ain't coming back, guys. ;D No matter how much you whine about how she was better. She makes her own albums now; go listen to those and buy them. She's also moved on. You should, too.
Of course Tarja is more "appropriate" for this song; it was written for her. But if Anette never preformed the older Nightwish songs, people would doubt her ability even more, and I'm sure show after show with the same songs would get tiring. She does the best she can; it isn't her fault Tarja got fired.
I hated Anette when she first came to the band, but now I actually prfer her over Tarja. Her voice is much sweeter and more pleasant to listen to, and she has a better stage presence. She actually talks to the crowd, whereas Taja didn't. It's also nicer to have a fresher voice to listen to, as personally Tarja's voice was getting a little "off".
if you notice how tarja didnt talk to the fans at all, it shows one of the reasons y she got kicked off. i miss her music just as much as the next fan but i love nightwish so much that i dont care anymore that tarja got kicked off because i Love anette's voice. she is a true singer she actually shows that she loves performing.
hate to burst your bubble, but i fell in love with Nightwish when i found it after annette came, and i personally like her better. ive listened to both, and i just dont like tarja as much
OMG OMG OMG! At first when I listened to the first thirty seconds I thought it was Tarja! When Anette sings this song she sounds actually SOMEWHAT similar to Tarja! It's just Anette is more soprano and Tarja seems more alto and operatic on the original version. I LOVE NIGHTWISH, I like both Anette and Tarja! They both bring different sounds to the group. People are so stubborn these days, they don't even give Anette A CHANCE! Just because NW has a new lead singer it doesn't mean they-
Reading some of these comments, I'm wondering. How can a song look like something??? Also, not bad, but it doesn't sound like Anette. Which may be a good thing... but not really for me...
where do U guys find this stuff?! Itunes or rhapsody don't have it and going to a retailer sucks, these guys don't know crap! I am a Nightwish fan regardless who sings! I like both versions, btw- great post and thank U for sharing.
They would need access to the master tracks in order to make changes to the vocals specificly which won't happen so no its not sped up, it is Anette, and she's done a good job with this. You can't say she's trying to sound like Tarja because its the style of the song and the rhythm just she has a different voice.
This sounds like a pop song. The eeriness and emotions that this song transmits when Tarja sings it is lost when you hear it from Annette. I am not saying she doesn't sing good, all I am saying is that the song feels very different, somewhat without power and losses most of its appeal- except if you plan to hear it in a club, I guess.
DreamlessSky 7 months ago 27
a little speedy considering the original wasn't very fast at all, thats the only criticism i have though.
93homard 7 months ago 8
left to right: Thor, Zoro, Girl from underworld, Bad guy in die hard, one of captain jack's mates haha
robyrob78 7 months ago 16
It's Tarjas song and it should be her song forever!
But i think they would sound perfect if they would sing together.
Khornflakesftw 7 months ago 3
Anette is much better than Tarja
3Stiffy 9 months ago
Anette is much better than Tarja :)
3Stiffy 9 months ago
I respect both Anette and Tarja but I perdonally think that Tarja's version was better, this version is kind of popish and fast.
lileu982715 9 months ago 60
Anette have a soft and clearly voice... I Love you Anette!
126bisefsanesi 9 months ago 24
=)))))))) :((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((
zsoltibanto 1 year ago 3
my god.... its great!
Iwan2007 1 year ago 40
This version almost made me cry... 'Cause Anette is really great!
dpchiko17 1 year ago 60
Anette´s voice is beautiful, but only on recordings. When she sings live, it´s horrible.
happykecgirl 2 years ago 171
is this live??? if not where i can find this song??
SaccoN2 2 years ago
This is so much better than Tarjas version. Also, Tarja couldn't sing live since she had absolute crap pronunciation.
90hamg15 2 years ago
THIS IS TERRIBLE!!! :o TARJA WAS SO SO SO MUCH BETTER!!!! <3 THIS ANETTE, WHATEVER.... TOTAL BITCH!!!! PLAYS IN A FINISH BAND AND CAN'T EVEN SPEAK FINNISH!!!!! LIKE WTF???!!!
Sopu90 2 years ago
Anette Olzon is the best!
tarja was a bitch so thets wy she kicked out the band!
alexveldin 2 years ago
I really liked Tarja, but her voice quickly became annoying. Hearing the same songs but with Anette's voice, is making me like Nightwish again.
kevlevin 2 years ago 262
Tarja have a great voice and she sings better then annette this song is ruined because of her
PwnManpower 2 years ago
Tarja come back i beg of yoouuuu D=
Kokett0s 2 years ago 66
I thing Anette has very, very good voice, but this is Tarja song. Because Tarja in Whoevery brings the night? No...
SheLovesDrinkPoison 2 years ago 574
i support hellBoy133333, tarja was a cunt who thought she was better then the band, well guess what.. there doing better then when she was around and i beleive anette's voice is better.
dragonpsn3 2 years ago 57
hate this voice. /pf
bitch. i prefer tarja's version.
LalaHiromi 2 years ago
Tarja is best! Gth Anette!
mauti451 2 years ago
this is like a pop song without Tarja... this version is much, much poorer. I think everybody who really likes rock agrees
atllantiss 2 years ago
Wow, Anette got way better at this song. Hmm, she isn't so bad after all! I thought that Nightwish had been almost ruined by a new singer, but hey, she is getting MUCH better.
jibber102 2 years ago 69
i dont miss tarja... and this verison i so perfect [:
love ya anette
HellBoy133333 2 years ago 30
not bad annette! You go girl. I didn't expect her to do so well on one of Tarja's old song, but she sounds sweet and innocent on it and gave the song a new kind of mood to it. Its beautiful.
AutumnTwilight06 2 years ago 58
this is really good! its nothing like tarja bus still its great how anette could do just as good job as anyone else who joined nightwish could possilbe do. She pulled it off as best to her abilities..kudos to you Anette! you filled Tarja's shoes pretty well <3
18Shadowfox 2 years ago 60
i like them both...very inspirative song ...luv it (cry)...remind me about the old days...the childhood was so great...okay peace&love guys...luv u too annete...very nice voice
rQuiWi 2 years ago 16
Comment removed
Tinwelir 2 years ago 2
OMG!!!!Nettie,THAT'S MUUUCH BETTER than the nemo you used to sing at the beggining!!!!
congratulations!!
Love Nightwish!!!
Tinwelir 2 years ago 13
does anyone know where I can download this version of nemo? I cant find it anywhere
plz help!
lillykun 2 years ago 9
this version is ok but it sounds like they have forgotten the meaning of the song,I do prefer Tarja's version!!
101BurtonFan101 2 years ago 34
this would've been called the "Annete Olzon Remix"
cutepotop2 2 years ago 3
tarja sing this song bether :(
anette is pretty but....she can´t sing so good like tarja
...sry anette :\
Dimehy666 2 years ago 14
well anette can sing better live XD
nateplaysguitar15 2 years ago 30
STOP!!! JUST STOP!!!stop....Taria WAS a perfet singer,she was my favourite singer..But I realise Taria have a perfect voice,but she is..a......Assh...
Anett is PERFECT!!!!!!!!!!noone is like her...
LoveNightwish81 2 years ago 10
its actually pretty good i thaugt it would suck but i was wrong, but still i think tarja has a better voice. they are both very good singers tho
lolzzXxx 2 years ago
their voices are different, but i think they're both just as good. this song is beautiful no matter who sings it.
LadyLuria 2 years ago 10
anette havent got a good voices but tarjas is better beautifull :D tarja i miss you:(
Kahn2580 2 years ago
Anette is a pretty good singer. it's not that easy too sing this song. tarja was just able to sing this song cuz she has a opera voice. and in case u guys haven't heard 'byebye beautiful' , it was tarja's fault that she got kicked out of the band. so keep ur smart ass comments to urself.
ayamehanachi 2 years ago 9
thank god someone els can see it you 1005 right x
rockinlis 2 years ago 2
She ruined Tarja Turunens lovely version with some new shit version. This version sounded much better when Tarja Turunen sang it. Now it sounds like crap.
Bob1nah 2 years ago
Both of them are good. I prefer Tarja, but I respect Anette, she's very good too.
Btw.. I don't like so much how the keyboard sounds at the beginning and almost at the end with this speed up.. my opinion :P
cofuser 2 years ago 5
Tarja ain't coming back, guys. ;D No matter how much you whine about how she was better. She makes her own albums now; go listen to those and buy them. She's also moved on. You should, too.
Of course Tarja is more "appropriate" for this song; it was written for her. But if Anette never preformed the older Nightwish songs, people would doubt her ability even more, and I'm sure show after show with the same songs would get tiring. She does the best she can; it isn't her fault Tarja got fired.
SirensAfterMidnight 2 years ago 11
Aaaah, I like it alot more than I thought I would. SHe sounds very young and fresh (I dont know her real age, but whatever) .
Both Tarja and Anette have very different, yet distinct voices. I think they both did really well on this song :)
lillykun 2 years ago 3
Tarja was a bitch and she will not come back because everybody want her insted of Anette.
Tochinden 2 years ago
she must not sing tarja's songs...i miss her... annette seems a spice girls' singer .-.
lucylovesrammstein 2 years ago
just Tarja can singing this song...:(
vidamkislany 2 years ago 18
lol nightwish aint a band eny more just a group of peps ho sings but with Tarja they would been a great metal band
Amongru 2 years ago
Anette SUCKS!!!
Tarja ROCKS:) !!
:x
bloodybuterfly 2 years ago
I prefer tarja and i think Anette does a great job but the older songs of Nightwish do not sound very good with Anette
tzonki 2 years ago 9
both singers are good stfu lmao
etl54321111 2 years ago 22
Tarja!!!!
omodeo17 2 years ago 5
tarja has a deeper voice than annette so i like annette better
XxCHRISchaosxX 2 years ago 5
I hated Anette when she first came to the band, but now I actually prfer her over Tarja. Her voice is much sweeter and more pleasant to listen to, and she has a better stage presence. She actually talks to the crowd, whereas Taja didn't. It's also nicer to have a fresher voice to listen to, as personally Tarja's voice was getting a little "off".
DemonicaDark 2 years ago 11
if you notice how tarja didnt talk to the fans at all, it shows one of the reasons y she got kicked off. i miss her music just as much as the next fan but i love nightwish so much that i dont care anymore that tarja got kicked off because i Love anette's voice. she is a true singer she actually shows that she loves performing.
Nelli915 2 years ago 16
Of both Tarja and Annette, my preference falls towards Tarja.
xDDD
But I do admit, Annette does have a good voice.
However, this song is much better suited for Tarja than Annette in my opinion.
taintedxsilence 2 years ago 9
she sings well but... nothing like Tarja...
her voice is a little too sweet for this song.... this is a Tarja's song!!
sweetegirl135 2 years ago
actually its Nightwish's song if it was tarja's song then nightwish would have to ask permission for anette to do a cover of the song....-_-
Nelli915 2 years ago 7
Wow! Annette does an amazing job with nemo! I was honestly really surprised at how good she was. But lets face it, Annette will never replace Tarja!
lordphoenix82 2 years ago 8
Heh, this sounds very good in studio!! Even as good as Tarja, but live Tarja is like 100000000 times better. :)
snuffe8 2 years ago
The live version with anette sucked. This one owns!
frobank 2 years ago
Anette has a very sweet voice but I think this song is more suitable for Tarja.
animatopiababy101 2 years ago 18
I really love nightwish but sorry anette you r not the correct female for this band, i think tarja is much better!!!!!!
Katoru31 2 years ago 2
i like anette more bu tarja still sounds better in the old songs
mashamane 2 years ago 7
Anette has rapped this song this was like 1000 times better when Tarja was a singer
AndDeathForAll 2 years ago 8
tarja controled her voice MUCH better, even on this song ... nice try anette but not good enough, i mean shes obviosly an average singer
nathaniell84 2 years ago 9
i can't choose between the two
they both sound amazing
and no matter who sings this song, i absolutely love it!
battousaiblade 2 years ago 7
hate to burst your bubble, but i fell in love with Nightwish when i found it after annette came, and i personally like her better. ive listened to both, and i just dont like tarja as much
feyabarin 2 years ago 2
aggree i didn't like nightwish until anette starts to sing in this amazin band ;)
Flatcher94 2 years ago 7
much much better than live version .
Sure , Annette is not tarja , but she sing well
thegod8000 2 years ago 4
OMG!!! this is amazing i love nemo thanks for upoading
AnetteOlzonFanPage 2 years ago
is not bad...annette is nice but tarja's beeter for nightwish:)
dafoc95 2 years ago 2
I agree with Byakyualovelornsoul. anette's voice is very good, but tarjs is the reason I started to like nightwish in the first place
BleedingPhantom829 2 years ago 3
Wow! So much better then live <3
moonIight93 2 years ago 30
yeah.. the miracles of studio recordings.
Tarja however, sounded much better and stronger in her voice live.
volvo145 2 years ago 13
I don't prefer one of the vocalists, but I think that this song's written for tarja, and her voice sounds better in this song.
they both rock, but you shouldn't try to let them sing the style of the other one.
wolfjeanne 2 years ago 54
Personally I don't like this version at all. I love the old version only.
Nightwish + Nemo + Tarja = perfection
Otherwise -.-
lushdimple 2 years ago 7
Tarja is better.
Of course, Anette's not bad...but Tarjas voice better fits Nightwish. So cold and arw <3
Anette's not a bad singer but too warm for Nightwish, if you ask me =)
nicecatz 2 years ago 59
I dont think annette's 'warm' she sings of blood and death.
sytheruchiha 2 years ago
fucking annette!
YaMUz09 2 years ago
I like both versions=]
starrygal07 2 years ago 26
I really like this version!!!
But I prefer it when Tarja sings this song xD
Nightwish For Ever!! <3
luvitxxx 2 years ago 27
beautiful :)
DieGo93cs 2 years ago 15
OMG OMG OMG! At first when I listened to the first thirty seconds I thought it was Tarja! When Anette sings this song she sounds actually SOMEWHAT similar to Tarja! It's just Anette is more soprano and Tarja seems more alto and operatic on the original version. I LOVE NIGHTWISH, I like both Anette and Tarja! They both bring different sounds to the group. People are so stubborn these days, they don't even give Anette A CHANCE! Just because NW has a new lead singer it doesn't mean they-
Byakuyalovelornsoul 2 years ago 38
I know what you mean. I like both but I do prefer Tarja. But Annete's voice is easier for me to match.
CynthiaLestrange 2 years ago 4
it sounds like she is trying to be tarja..
ragejens 2 years ago 3
i just love both of them =)
JaderGater2 3 years ago 317
annete is really good
tarja was to melancolic
sjuninho911 3 years ago
NIGHTWISH RULES
meniinaines 3 years ago
Where can I download the song? I love itt!! *___*
lizziethspain 3 years ago
she sing more swetly
bigalrei 3 years ago
She is gorgeous, and this version is actually better.
oceanborn05 3 years ago
it's all about the song, not the performer. nemo is an awesome song, and both annette and tarja did it justice
GoldenEye333 3 years ago
they look like shit fucking creeps but they make some good shit so it's OK with me
mamba1234567890 3 years ago
Reading some of these comments, I'm wondering. How can a song look like something??? Also, not bad, but it doesn't sound like Anette. Which may be a good thing... but not really for me...
wonebutuoynomi 3 years ago
Both are great, but I like Tarja =)
Sandberg121693 3 years ago 71
i dont want to choose since they have different styles
Riranor 3 years ago
just one thing:
anette is here now so dont keep talking about tarja
loontjuhhh13 3 years ago
i love her
DaRkSymphoniCa 3 years ago 42
lol the version is most better:X i miss you tarja....
dea7hkn1gh7 3 years ago 51
I really like it!
DaRkSymphoniCa 3 years ago 31
AneTte!!! <3
DaRkSymphoniCa 3 years ago 8
better than dark chest of wonders,
but anette's voice doesn't suit to this kind of music
i miss tarja :(
Marco3129 3 years ago 9
I like both versions. It's an awsome song, reguardless who sings it.
SeeMeInTheShadows 3 years ago 16
Brilliant, but I still love Tarja's version
Jweg55 3 years ago 17
The piano guy wrote it Tarja fcking betrayed you all its a NIGHTWISH song
LAKEAXEL 3 years ago 8
that Piano guy wrote it m8 TARJA HAS FUCKING BETRAYED THE FANS its an Nightwish song
LAKEAXEL 3 years ago 4
both versions are great, but i slightly prefer the anthemic nature of tarja's version
GoldenEye333 3 years ago 5
where do U guys find this stuff?! Itunes or rhapsody don't have it and going to a retailer sucks, these guys don't know crap! I am a Nightwish fan regardless who sings! I like both versions, btw- great post and thank U for sharing.
rodimaxus 3 years ago 5
i like annettes version
but this song suits tarja +
DaRkSymphoniCa 3 years ago 8
this song was made for tarja not for annette to sing it.. but i really love it!
im trying not to compare both singers, both are amazing!!
but i really like annette´s version
DaRkSymphoniCa 3 years ago 2
thats what i was thinking. I tried to match it up wit a version of tarja and it sounds like it was sped up.
i dont like annette at all so i kinda figured it was tarja's a bit
ToxMarshmallow 3 years ago 11
tbh shes sort of copyed tarja. trying to sound the sound like her. i think someones just sped up tarjas voice
its not annettte
x
PETEYHEYHEYHEY 3 years ago 10
They would need access to the master tracks in order to make changes to the vocals specificly which won't happen so no its not sped up, it is Anette, and she's done a good job with this. You can't say she's trying to sound like Tarja because its the style of the song and the rhythm just she has a different voice.
the1vancha 2 years ago
LOVE ANNETTE!!!
Thassae 3 years ago 2
I reckon this WAS accelerated a bit, but nah, 'tis not of Tarja's version. They're quite noticably different.
dustd3mon 3 years ago 5
The singer may have changed, but the meaning of the song lives on
StarWarsMedia 3 years ago 3
I like both versons
StarWarsMedia 3 years ago 2
na boa. acabou com a musica (y)
SillyXLux 3 years ago
naum gostei dessa versão... Tarja, voce é insubstituiveeelll!!!! TARJA S2 S2 S2 S2 S2 S2 S2 S2 S2... anette boquette estragou nemo ¬¬
nubencio 3 years ago 2
Tarja, NightWish miss you!
AndrehChamber 3 years ago
Well done!
Flodu67FMA 3 years ago 2
saudades da TARJA x.x
icetails 3 years ago
wow. Where did you get this? Sound quality is awesom!
k10edd 3 years ago