The phantom is so much better than that stupid Raoul ): Why'd everyone love stupid Christine? she's such a bitch D: I can't believe he did that to her.
The phantom looks so adorable when he's smiling at his monkey (:
haha, i agree. I mean, i don't dislike Roul and all (I'm more of an Erik fan) But, really, how many times was he told to keep his hand at the level of his eyes? He didn't listen, and look where that got him XD
well hes been alone too long and hes gone crazy but GEEZ hes taken it to far!!!! my god if she dosnt like you then get over it!!!!! geez some guys just dont know when to quit!!!
the guy was named by a fortune teller, got shipped to Turkey and back,isolated for ten years, then snubbed by the only person he thought cared about him. I'd be pretty pissed, and I bet you would too.
I think though that that may be a part of the problem-- in some dark, twisted part of her soul, she DOES love the Phantom, except that most of her, the part she lives with day-to-day, loves Raoul -- Phantom can't stand this, he'd kill Raoul so that Christine would be his absolutely and completely (or so he thinks, anyway). But true, the Phantom truly does not know when to quit.
raoul is a wimp, he gets caught so easily! he has to be rescued by christine! omg that look of hope he had when christine came back, only to give him the ring. if i were her i would have stayed with erik from the beginning. HE'S THE BEST!!!
Who is Erik? There is no one by that name in the cast. Gerard Butler plays Phantom, and Patrick Wilson is Raoul. Maybe you were thinking of one of those?
I have a question, and I'm not trying to be rude or obnoxious here, but if she didn't love Erik but had to choose him to save Raoul, then what would stop her from, I don't know, killing him in his sleep? I mean, if she wanted to be with Raoul, but he was forcing her to marry him, wouldn't it just make sense in a sadistic sort of way?Again, I'm not dumping on Erik, I actually prefer him to Raoul, but I don't think much forthought went into his plans.
Well to put it simply Erik is a mad genius. From being under ground for most of his life and ridiculed for most of his life his reflexes and senses would be enhanced...so Christine trying to kill him in his sleep would be pointless. She is no match for his strength especially when he's angry. And besides at this point Erik had to think quickly to try and get Christine to stay so threatening her was the only way he could think of.
I love this scene. The passion is awesome! I have to be honest, I think I would have gone with the phantom. Yes, the character is creepy. Raoul loves her of course! I don't know what I would do in the situation, having to choose one just 1. but there is a huge connection with the Ghost!
hm, has anyone thought that maybe she turned out to be a very bad kisser and that made him change his mind about her after she agreed to stay with him. maybe he was crying of disappointment :))))))) just a thought :)))
Every time I watch this scene and get so frustrated! I would have made out with the phantom and I woulda ditched raoul. Argh!!!!!!!!
persiantee 4 months ago
belloooooooooooooooo
redberry0 6 months ago
@THEJ0KERJV Eric is the phantom's name in the book. It never mentions it in the alw version though.
OppositesEverything 1 year ago
@THEJ0KERJV
OppositesEverything 1 year ago
this is my favorite part i wathced this so many times it never fets old!
Lainatwin2 1 year ago
I LOVE this part of the movie (: <3
TheDreamerCola 1 year ago
This is the only scene where all three of them sing together.......
FaerieMom1 1 year ago
how can he sing gso good with a lose around his neck? thanks for the vid been looking for it forages but i didnt know what to look for. ty
AliceAmberConstance 2 years ago 3
The phantom is so much better than that stupid Raoul ): Why'd everyone love stupid Christine? she's such a bitch D: I can't believe he did that to her.
The phantom looks so adorable when he's smiling at his monkey (:
peanutbuttag3lliee 2 years ago 5
he ain't that ugly.
TechUnadept 3 years ago 21
i love this scene, except for one part. "i tried so hard to free you"... really? REALLY? that was trying hard?
like i said, this scene is good, except i wish there had been a little more of a fight to get a noose around raul's neck.
anyway, all thier voices sound AMAZING in this scene. i keep listeneing to it on the soundtrack.
phantomfever17 3 years ago 3
haha, i agree. I mean, i don't dislike Roul and all (I'm more of an Erik fan) But, really, how many times was he told to keep his hand at the level of his eyes? He didn't listen, and look where that got him XD
Majixe 2 years ago 2
I love the way Christine sings in this scene!
I can sing at her pitch. It took me forever to get it right though.
arroofx 3 years ago 3
luv this part!!!!!!
nickelpickel456 3 years ago
well hes been alone too long and hes gone crazy but GEEZ hes taken it to far!!!! my god if she dosnt like you then get over it!!!!! geez some guys just dont know when to quit!!!
IamZoeyIchigo 3 years ago
the guy was named by a fortune teller, got shipped to Turkey and back,isolated for ten years, then snubbed by the only person he thought cared about him. I'd be pretty pissed, and I bet you would too.
TechUnadept 3 years ago 4
I think though that that may be a part of the problem-- in some dark, twisted part of her soul, she DOES love the Phantom, except that most of her, the part she lives with day-to-day, loves Raoul -- Phantom can't stand this, he'd kill Raoul so that Christine would be his absolutely and completely (or so he thinks, anyway). But true, the Phantom truly does not know when to quit.
DorianMichaelsIII 2 years ago
raoul is a wimp, he gets caught so easily! he has to be rescued by christine! omg that look of hope he had when christine came back, only to give him the ring. if i were her i would have stayed with erik from the beginning. HE'S THE BEST!!!
cleversagg22 3 years ago
Who is Erik? There is no one by that name in the cast. Gerard Butler plays Phantom, and Patrick Wilson is Raoul. Maybe you were thinking of one of those?
augury010 3 years ago
erik is the phantom's real name
cleversagg22 3 years ago
Seriously? Nifty! I've been wondering what his name was. But where did you hear that from?
augury010 3 years ago
i read the book.
cleversagg22 3 years ago
funny when they're both singing while the Phantom is strangling Raoul.
rohiogerv22 3 years ago
I have a question, and I'm not trying to be rude or obnoxious here, but if she didn't love Erik but had to choose him to save Raoul, then what would stop her from, I don't know, killing him in his sleep? I mean, if she wanted to be with Raoul, but he was forcing her to marry him, wouldn't it just make sense in a sadistic sort of way?Again, I'm not dumping on Erik, I actually prefer him to Raoul, but I don't think much forthought went into his plans.
phoenixchick777 3 years ago
Well to put it simply Erik is a mad genius. From being under ground for most of his life and ridiculed for most of his life his reflexes and senses would be enhanced...so Christine trying to kill him in his sleep would be pointless. She is no match for his strength especially when he's angry. And besides at this point Erik had to think quickly to try and get Christine to stay so threatening her was the only way he could think of.
Svfan007 3 years ago
i really love raol he will die for her
proud2beone 3 years ago
i hate that man
proud2beone 3 years ago
I love this scene. The passion is awesome! I have to be honest, I think I would have gone with the phantom. Yes, the character is creepy. Raoul loves her of course! I don't know what I would do in the situation, having to choose one just 1. but there is a huge connection with the Ghost!
emmaglow 3 years ago 3
Beautiful scene and all... but isn't he like... twice her age???
0Shadowdragon 3 years ago
Stop Hating on Raoul...
Hes amazing =O
enemyZ 3 years ago
best part is 3:26-3:29
HELLL000 3 years ago
RAOUL!!!!!
SHUT!!!
UP!!!
HELLL000 3 years ago
SHAMONN
WATCH IT ALL
HELLL000 3 years ago
this is my favourite part.. it's so beautiful, i almost cry..
freddysthecoolest 3 years ago 5
thats so sad. it made me cry. definitely one of my favorite musicals. no doubt about it.
GlowEuh 4 years ago 5
Definatly I cried too
nugygiver14 3 years ago 3
I would have chosen Erik. He's a real man, Raul is a pinky girl's dreamknight.
lykky 4 years ago 4
Oh yea.
freddysthecoolest 3 years ago
but he has a better voice, unfortuantly.
freddysthecoolest 3 years ago 2
ahaha. BAD BREATH! good one :]
LoveMartina 4 years ago
hm, has anyone thought that maybe she turned out to be a very bad kisser and that made him change his mind about her after she agreed to stay with him. maybe he was crying of disappointment :))))))) just a thought :)))
avidita 4 years ago 2
that or her breath was worst than his face
LegendaryPyro 4 years ago
hahahahhahahhahahahhahahhha!!!!!!!!!!!!!
jyotij888 4 years ago
That's awesome. Thanks for that. lol
MommaFairy28 4 years ago
I love this scene!!! This scene made me cry!!!
IsabelaPatricia 4 years ago
I wish he would have hung him. She should have picked Erik.
MommaFairy28 4 years ago 17
@MommaFairy28 who's erik?
CountryBuff08 1 year ago
@MommaFairy28 there is no one called eric the phantom is played by gerard butler and christine is played by emmy rossum but no who the over dude is
THEJ0KERGV 1 year ago
oh my goodness, my favorite scene for sure!
xlalalisax 4 years ago
has anyone uploaded the last scene? where raoul is at christine's grave and sees the phantom's rose?
bettyk14 4 years ago