Just wanted to say that I wished Hamza Yusuf would of made the distinction between the scholars of Saudi Arabia that are against celebrating the birth of the Prophet (pbuh) like Sheikh Bin Othaimeen and Sheikh Bin Baaz and the rulers of Saudi Arabia celebrating their 100 year independence. The two are not synonymous on many different issues and hence Hamza Yusuf's remarks, I believe, are unwarrented.
Jazak Allah Khair and May Allah Reward us all for all our Knowledge
Bid'ah is anything in religious matters that has no basis from the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon them) and the rightly guided Caliphs.
Imam Malik said: Anyone who claims to have innovated a bidah hasanah (positive innovation) has claimed that the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) betrayed the trust and did not deliver the message. Then he recited the last verse [Chapter 5, verse 3] ever revealed to the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him).
@TheKap1an Thats where you are wrong brother. Your understanding of the term 'bidah' is incorrect. Bidáh means innovation in the dean. Technological innovations are not included in this. Innovation in ibadah (worship) is what bidah means.
Please brother forget about me but for yourself , go study the fundamentals of Sunnah
study this hadeeth for instance
عن العرباض بن سارية قال وعظنا رسول الله موعظة وجلت منها القلوب وذرفت منها العيون فقلنا يارسول الله كأنها موعظة مودع فاوصنا قال اوصيكم بتقوى الله ... الى ان قال انه من يعش منكم فسيرى اختلافا كثيرا فعليكم بسنتي وسنة الخلفاء الراشدين المهديين من بعدي عضوا عليها بالنواجذ واياكم ومحدثات الامور فان كل محدثة بدعة وكل بدعة ضلالة وكل ضلالة في النار
Dear brother Listen to your brother I sewer I understand you love the prophet. F U keep telling yr mother I love U but U do not buy her what she wants, y're helpless
The prophet gave instructions so that his deen would not be altered little by little along the time line. Strict adherence is the key. Just follow and he'll love u.
I fight bida so that everybody can see Islam as original as the prophet left it for us, untouched,complete, neat , and great.
If you do not know say so and stop suggesting things in the deen of Allah. It has been completed and save Muslims from your bid'az . Every one can be a philosopher and justify things . We have sahaba, Tabeen to follow not HAWA. Be ware you are playing with the most beloved person's Sunnah . He left us a huge heritage to adapt to and we leave the main solid road and choose the narrow zigzagged ones..
If you want to be honored at the Hawd stay clear and respect Sunnah. He taught it all
You picked up one point that was obvious "No one said the Prophet forgot things" ok
Please answer my questions
1 what was the exact birth date?
2 Who did it in the first 300yrs the best three centuries How was it mukhtalaf
3 In 40 nawawi hadeeth what is the meaning of who innovate in our religion is going to be rejected
The clock and others" innovations adapted to the times" you mentions is something we have answers for you but let it be later so we take first things first
1 how can wise people celebrate a birth date if it is not known?
2 Hamza said it is mukhtalaf ? Actually no one in the first 300yrs did it
3 It contradicts the hadeeth we only have two feasts
4 Hamza admitted it contains many wrong things and attributed the tahreem to that but that is not correct.The prophet PBUH said I did not leave any good thing (in terms of hasanat) exept I told you about. If this is hasanat then the prophet forgot it. Does he forget? The deen is complete
@umadkhan50 You're making it sound like he was part of Bush's administration! Subhan' Allah, he met with Bush in the days after September 11th and "advised" him that Islam had nothing to do with such an act of terrorism. He also gave him a copy of the Qur'an.
This is just stupid. There is no ikhtilaf in moulid. Did Abubaker or Omar do it? You tell us who did it. The only evidence Sufi use is when the prophet fasted on Mondays . Well fast on Mondays, as simple as that.No one even know that the prophet was born on that particular date because he was born as a normal child and who would take a note of that then.
The anniversary of the nation is done by the secular advisers, not the religious ppl who condemned it
As Isa ibn Maryam A.S said Everybody gives from what they have if The incapacitated one call name what does it decrease or increase they all know deep inside what is true what is not. expect there will be haters, and May Allah guide us all.
Lol stupid Wahabis! Calling him Shia and Sufi because hes someone opposion their thoughts! Everybody is Shia Sufi or Bida when he is not Wahabi like them Typical Sect thinking.
@markansole well said brother! We have become a pathetic nation! We have become lowest of the low. I guess they are not happy with the amount of divide between us so they want to devide us even more ( if that is even possible). They are not happy with splitting up the khalifa into countries so now they even want to split up the countries too. They won't rest until we are devided into tribes or even worse! May Allah help us! Allah (swt) is sending His punishment on us and rightly so.
@sightsandsoundsofpak What's with the name-calling? Take the emotion out of it & relax. Also realize that many Muslims do NOT believe as you believe, that "sufism is the soul of Islam", but instead believe that sufism is a bid'ah, or a complete deviation. Calling Sh. Hamza a sufi & saying "be careful of him" implies these things & that's backbiting & slander. These people must be called out so they will think twice next time. Otherwise shaitan will keep our hearts divided.
@sightsandsoundsofpak can i ask you what a wahabi is? you pakistanis are scum you come from a filthy country with shirk in the bucketloads with palm readers all across the country, your women are taking their clothes off for indians and posing nude in their magazines. you kalb un nar you say sufism is soul of islam? yea how in your country theres filthy sufi shrines like datta darbar where grave worship goes on and lal shahbaz qalandar where u dogs made it like the kaaba and circumambulate it.
@sightsandsoundsofpak in all your graveyards you filthy scum have graves which are made of cement going against the prophetic cmmandment. and you dare to say wahabi wahabi?
@ukzane .this is a Muslim country u are talking about.and before you start callingme a sufi.I am not.so shut up.If you have some kind of racism against Pakistanis ,dont bring religion in it.dont find excuses to show your bigotry.
@sightsandsoundsofpak u dirty rat wat in the world makes u say pakistan is a muslim country far from it ? britain is more of a muslim country than pakistan u grave worshipping dogs. your founder was an ismaili filthy shia and even the shia dont consider them to be muslim so how will you tell me tht pak is a muslim country go live in ur filth u scum
gosh u make it so simple for me its not fair :) really i don't like this at all you are so helpful and kind that u don't let me make effort to write so much against you. :) Everybody can see how extremist you are its so typical Wahabi like i rest my case. Once again thanks a lot brother. Very poetic language you have used and i am sure you will be rewarded by that by Allah (SWT). Osama will be proud of you.
@hendersoncnc Do you even know who were the original 'sufis' or what they did? Junaid al Baghdadi was a sufi so was Imam Ghazali and Abdul Qadir Galani. These people who had Zuhud. Are you going to warn us about them as well.
@going2sleep Exactly Sufisim isn't Bid'ah per say, it depends on what is being done with it like doing things that are not in Islamic law. Sufis do alot of Dhikr and it is mentioned in many hadiths which it is permissble and reward is granted for it. The whirling i guess is a way of doing it? Its more of an art actually, Like Arabic Qur'anic calligraphy isn't compulsory but it's part of the out look and beautifying God's names and Qur'anic verses same with whirling Dhikr :/
@TheQuranAndSunnah Warning you are slandering which is worst than backbiting and eating the flesh of your fellow Muslim. Funny how your user name is QuranandSunnah when you cannot even practice what you read.
@McHuZii Our Nabi s.a.w. is human & man - but most perfect being - but to say Nabi s.a.w. is man LIKE me,u,or anyone else isakin 2 shirk - Nabi s.a.w is beyond comparison 2 any man - hope we all understand that this greatest mercy to the worlds is unlike any other & this mercy & blessing on mankind is what is celebrated - may the ummah unite under the leadership of men who understand this mercy to mankind-
@WhoIsArRahmanALLAH No the most sacred place in the world is the Place that contains blessed body of the Prophet saaw and no one disagrees this. It reminds me a Hadith that Rasulullah saw while addressing Kaba said. O kaba you are a place of dignity but the blood of Momi'n is sacred than you.
@SunniMuslim2100 Yes, I remember that hadith too. That hadith is authentic, but what you mean by it is false. Allah called Makkah the mother of all towns so that's why it is the most sacred place. There is no authentic hadith which says the grave of Rasulullah (S) is more sacred than Makkah. What you are talking about here is ijtihad.
@MuslimVlogGuy salaam, technically knowledge itself can only come from Allah so let's not degrade it to something we can buy. However when striving for it I think we should not complain whether or not it costs money. Because how can we place value on the attainment of knowledge that will help us for the hereafter?
@MuslimVlogGuy Of course knowledge itself is free because only Allah can grant knowledge. I was talking about when seeking knowledge yet being wishy-washy about having to pay for classes or buying books etc. People are willing to pay for things related to worldly nafs but when it comes to the deen they get hesitant. Wallahualam.. And off topic akhi but when a fellow muslim gives salaam I think you know what one should do.
I'm not obligated to reply to "salaam." That is not the Islamic greeting. Anyway, your justification doesn't work. No reason someone should pay thousands of dollars for something they can learn in the masjid for free.
@MuslimVlogGuy Can you please point out to me where I said we should pay thousands of dollars somewhere instead of learning in the masjid? Nowhere did I say that, that was apparently your own interpretation. That said, I'm not about to go into a fruitless argument with you. I'll be on my way now. Assalamualaikum.
Wasn't arguing. Don't be soft. Walaikum Assalam (See if you had said "Assalamu Alaikum" I would have responded. That is the Islamic greeting. Not "salam.")
There's alot of people judging others simply from the sects they're in. At the end of the day, no one can actually judge the contents of one's heart, therefore we have no place to say what is right or what is wrong. If you feel that something is wrong, dialogue, don't argue! Sufi, Suni or Shia, any man or woman who has dedicated their life to studying Islam deserves to be heard. :)
It's really a shame that so many Arab nations worship their "leaders", there are Masjids in which is written the names of the "kings", in the schools they play pianos in the morning and then sing a "celebration" song for their "rulers". It's very, very bad thing and almost shirk. Not so much for the people in my opinion as it's the leaders who carve their names and wish to be worshiped. May Allah lead them to the truth.
@3822218 I have heard this ''Sufi'' first time in my life ... but didn't hear anything against Quran or Sunnah in this particular video .. did you? ... if yes, do assist me and let me know .... come with a solid argument and not with a taunt, ok? ... JazakAllah
I didn't listen to what he said, but I laughed when i saw Hamza Yusuf talking about Bid'ah !!
It's like a smoker advising non-smokers to not smoke XD
You don't know what Sufi & Sufism mean ? This is a disaster my brother...Yusuf is a Sufi ( A lot of Islamic scholars said that ), he didn't express his real beliefs.
Go search about Sufism & Hamza Yusuf, I'm afraid you're a Sufi & you don't even realize that.
@3822218 Now it was my turn to laugh (thanks for that) that you laughed on Hamza Yusuf WITHOUT listening to what he said in this particular clip.(Its sufficient for one to be a liar if he communicates something to others without making sure of its truthness; Hadith).But good thing is you now seem ready to come with SOLID arguments. Now, leave Hamza Yusuf alone, you tell me, What Sufism is (am hoping you have learnt from authoritative books and not merely from internet scattered suspecious info).
I won't argue about the first part of your reply because you apparently didn't search about Hamza Yusuf.
Why you ask me this question ? is it because you want to know what Sufism is ? or you're a Sufi ? or you think I'm a guy who is talking about something he doesn't know ?!
Sufism is a good way to worship Allah in its first appearance BUT now it's just an Islam version full of Bid'ah & Shirks.
Dancing front graves & shaking while reading Quran are examples.
@3822218 JazakAllah,so u beleive that 'Sufism' is good way to worship Allah.There is no argument then.If someone does something which is prohibited in Islam and associate it wrongly to Sufism then its neither Islam nor Sufism.So if someone actually does something AGAINST Quran and Sunnah then it is not permitted, no matter its u, me or Hamza. But it would be just prejudice to accuse Sufism in the first place.It'd be like non muslims accusing Islam b'coz Muslims are not good in character !!!
I said Sufism is a good way in its first appearance ( in 3th century Hijri )
NOW it's full of Shirks & Bid'ah.
Anyone call himself a Sufi isn't following the real correct Islam ( i don't have to look to what he does because i know what Sufism is ).
BUT i don't say Sufis aren't Muslims they're just in the wrong way, i can say about the Ayat & Mo'ammen of Shia ( the Twelvers ) that they're not Muslims BUT who follow them are just ignorant we can't blame them.
@3822218 I wish I could be a REAL SUFI.I repeat real Sufi can't go against Sharia. I'd hoped that you being an Arab will come up with concrete arguments from Quran & Sunna and make me learn somthing from you but you've jsut come up with wishy washy comments. وَاعْتَصِمُوا بِحَبْلِ اللَّـهِ جَمِيعًا وَلَا تَفَرَّقُوا ....
وَعِبَادُ الرَّحْمَـٰنِ الَّذِينَ يَمْشُونَ عَلَى الْأَرْضِ هَوْنًا وَإِذَا خَاطَبَهُمُ الْجَاهِلُونَ قَالُوا سَلَامًا (am not translating as u can understand arabic text)
There is nothing could a real Sufi NOW, ask any Shikh in UK or imam he will tell you what Sufism is, or do some research about it, or just go & look how they worship Allah & you will recognize if what they do is right or wrong by logic.
This verse doesn't fit here, i can't walk with someone think that the souls of humans are just the souls of animals that died !! sadly, I'm not good in English BUT watch these vids & ask yourself is this Islam ?
& finally, there is no difference between Arabs & other nationalities, maybe you know more than me...
Brother, don't let them fool you, maybe you heard them say that there are fake Sufism & real Sufism ( it's one sect, they all do crazy things & believe illogical stuff )
@3822218 Absolutely this is not Sufism, these people have hijacked this term..and yes you'll not find a real sufi NOW because a real Sufi doesn't advertise his piousness, but it doesn't mean a real sufi doesn't exist.As I said you haven't come up with solid arguments from Quran & Sunnah, there is no point discussing it further.Everyone who follows 'Ehsan' as described in Hadees-eJibreel is real Sufi. I'll narrate this hadees in next two texts as it may not fit in this text. PEACE UPON YOU.
Brother you think that Sunnis don't have Ehsan in their sect ( if we can call it sect, i think it's ISLAM ) ? this definition of Ehsan i studied it in school in KSA when i was 7 years old.
You seem you don't know Sunnis & Sunnah well.
Let's take it in this way, what is wrong with Ahl Al Sunnah Waljama'a ? what you found in Sufism that doesn't Sunnah have ?
Why you want to take a dark unclear way if you already have clear way ?
not supporting mawlid doesnt mean agree on celebrating of an anniversary of 'anything'. mawlid can only be justified if someone not use this act as one of legitimate islamic rites which has been codified by shariah. underline this....'celebaring mawlid (like today some people do) is not part of shariah' so if some muslims dont agree with it, they dot violate the shariah, but if some other groups of muslim like to do it, make sure they dont put it in corporating with shariah....
@zarf00 I can’t agree with Sh. Hamza this time...celebrating a national day is different..People know it doesn’t have anything to do with religion..But celebrations that are labelled "Islamic" is a problem because it is Bidaa in Islam..People start claiming this religious duty and it propagates to a bigger Bidaa, Shirk and so on...
@DSSNTC how can you say it's nothing to do with Islam. by saying this you are separating Dunya from Deen while for a Muslim whatever he/she does should not be out of the fold of religion. Its not bidah because Sahaba RadiALLAHu Anhum celebrated Maulid but there mehtod was a bit different from us. There are Ahadith that prove this. the difference we have now a days because of the difference of our circumstances with them and this is not only in Maulid but everything.
@SunniMuslim2100 No its not separating Dunya from deen, there is no problme if you celebrate passing exams, but the problme araise when you claim this is a religioues duty or sunnah while its not! i hope you get that. if yo claim that celebrating passing exams is part of the religion duties that becomes Bidaa (Bidda means attributing something to islam while its not - this is deangeroues and this why the prophet (pbuh) warned us from), tell me when did the prophet celebrate Maulid?? its Bidaa.
I think Pakistanis those who condemn Al Mawrid and its scholars should take a lesson from it, just coz one of them spoke against Tablighi literature, countless non scholarly self righteous muslims have detonated him, which is in bad taste, u dont agree, u want to be on the save side and abstain do that, and counsel the close ones who support him with a dialogue, but attacking n saying oh he has no sunnah on his face, common grow up, no one knows no ones state of imaan so relax , salam u alaikum
Salam Alaikom All,
Just wanted to say that I wished Hamza Yusuf would of made the distinction between the scholars of Saudi Arabia that are against celebrating the birth of the Prophet (pbuh) like Sheikh Bin Othaimeen and Sheikh Bin Baaz and the rulers of Saudi Arabia celebrating their 100 year independence. The two are not synonymous on many different issues and hence Hamza Yusuf's remarks, I believe, are unwarrented.
Jazak Allah Khair and May Allah Reward us all for all our Knowledge
haitham1984 1 week ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Bid'ah is anything in religious matters that has no basis from the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon them) and the rightly guided Caliphs.
Imam Malik said: Anyone who claims to have innovated a bidah hasanah (positive innovation) has claimed that the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) betrayed the trust and did not deliver the message. Then he recited the last verse [Chapter 5, verse 3] ever revealed to the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him).
RealFan 1 week ago
@TheKap1an Thats where you are wrong brother. Your understanding of the term 'bidah' is incorrect. Bidáh means innovation in the dean. Technological innovations are not included in this. Innovation in ibadah (worship) is what bidah means.
Madhofd 2 weeks ago
@TheKap1an
Yes let us stop here.
Please brother forget about me but for yourself , go study the fundamentals of Sunnah
study this hadeeth for instance
عن العرباض بن سارية قال وعظنا رسول الله موعظة وجلت منها القلوب وذرفت منها العيون فقلنا يارسول الله كأنها موعظة مودع فاوصنا قال اوصيكم بتقوى الله ... الى ان قال انه من يعش منكم فسيرى اختلافا كثيرا فعليكم بسنتي وسنة الخلفاء الراشدين المهديين من بعدي عضوا عليها بالنواجذ واياكم ومحدثات الامور فان كل محدثة بدعة وكل بدعة ضلالة وكل ضلالة في النار
brain2770 2 weeks ago
@TheKap1an
Dear brother Listen to your brother I sewer I understand you love the prophet. F U keep telling yr mother I love U but U do not buy her what she wants, y're helpless
The prophet gave instructions so that his deen would not be altered little by little along the time line. Strict adherence is the key. Just follow and he'll love u.
I fight bida so that everybody can see Islam as original as the prophet left it for us, untouched,complete, neat , and great.
Do u like it tampered with?
brain2770 2 weeks ago
@TheKap1an
If you do not know say so and stop suggesting things in the deen of Allah. It has been completed and save Muslims from your bid'az . Every one can be a philosopher and justify things . We have sahaba, Tabeen to follow not HAWA. Be ware you are playing with the most beloved person's Sunnah . He left us a huge heritage to adapt to and we leave the main solid road and choose the narrow zigzagged ones..
If you want to be honored at the Hawd stay clear and respect Sunnah. He taught it all
brain2770 2 weeks ago
@TheKap1an
You picked up one point that was obvious "No one said the Prophet forgot things" ok
Please answer my questions
1 what was the exact birth date?
2 Who did it in the first 300yrs the best three centuries How was it mukhtalaf
3 In 40 nawawi hadeeth what is the meaning of who innovate in our religion is going to be rejected
The clock and others" innovations adapted to the times" you mentions is something we have answers for you but let it be later so we take first things first
brain2770 2 weeks ago
@TheKap1an proof of the consideration that celebrating the mawlid is a good practise. Becuz im pretty sure its a bid'ah
Madhofd 2 weeks ago
@TheKap1an
Brother
1 how can wise people celebrate a birth date if it is not known?
2 Hamza said it is mukhtalaf ? Actually no one in the first 300yrs did it
3 It contradicts the hadeeth we only have two feasts
4 Hamza admitted it contains many wrong things and attributed the tahreem to that but that is not correct.The prophet PBUH said I did not leave any good thing (in terms of hasanat) exept I told you about. If this is hasanat then the prophet forgot it. Does he forget? The deen is complete
brain2770 2 weeks ago
@TheKap1an proof plz.. thx
Madhofd 2 weeks ago
Comment removed
thinker6236 2 weeks ago
I wouldn't listen to this guy. He was an advisor to Goerge Bush. The biggest mass murderer of our time.
umadkhan50 2 weeks ago
@umadkhan50 You're making it sound like he was part of Bush's administration! Subhan' Allah, he met with Bush in the days after September 11th and "advised" him that Islam had nothing to do with such an act of terrorism. He also gave him a copy of the Qur'an.
IslamOnDemand 2 weeks ago 8
@umadkhan50
well most Arab country leaders listened to BUSH dude.
sightsandsoundsofpak 2 weeks ago
This is just stupid. There is no ikhtilaf in moulid. Did Abubaker or Omar do it? You tell us who did it. The only evidence Sufi use is when the prophet fasted on Mondays . Well fast on Mondays, as simple as that.No one even know that the prophet was born on that particular date because he was born as a normal child and who would take a note of that then.
The anniversary of the nation is done by the secular advisers, not the religious ppl who condemned it
It's shame on you Hamza to mention that.
brain2770 3 weeks ago
As Isa ibn Maryam A.S said Everybody gives from what they have if The incapacitated one call name what does it decrease or increase they all know deep inside what is true what is not. expect there will be haters, and May Allah guide us all.
sumaya090804 1 month ago
Lol stupid Wahabis! Calling him Shia and Sufi because hes someone opposion their thoughts! Everybody is Shia Sufi or Bida when he is not Wahabi like them Typical Sect thinking.
PunisherLobo 1 month ago
Astagfirullah...this kind of venomous language and lack of concern for adab in these comments is the reason our Ummah is in disarray. Embarrassing.
markansole 1 month ago 5
@markansole well said brother! We have become a pathetic nation! We have become lowest of the low. I guess they are not happy with the amount of divide between us so they want to devide us even more ( if that is even possible). They are not happy with splitting up the khalifa into countries so now they even want to split up the countries too. They won't rest until we are devided into tribes or even worse! May Allah help us! Allah (swt) is sending His punishment on us and rightly so.
urbanguru 2 weeks ago
Comment removed
BlackAbdul1 1 month ago
Good video, thanks.
07sawyerr 1 month ago
dont be upset brothers he is who he is.
hendersoncnc 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
lol hamza is right..but all in all u must be careful of him cuz he is a sufi.
hendersoncnc 1 month ago
@hendersoncnc Are you 100% certain he is a sufi? If so, what is your proof?
IslamOnDemand 1 month ago
@IslamOnDemand
so WHAT? he is a MUSLIM and sufilm is soul of Islam
lolz u children
sightsandsoundsofpak 1 month ago 2
@sightsandsoundsofpak What's with the name-calling? Take the emotion out of it & relax. Also realize that many Muslims do NOT believe as you believe, that "sufism is the soul of Islam", but instead believe that sufism is a bid'ah, or a complete deviation. Calling Sh. Hamza a sufi & saying "be careful of him" implies these things & that's backbiting & slander. These people must be called out so they will think twice next time. Otherwise shaitan will keep our hearts divided.
IslamOnDemand 1 month ago 3
@sightsandsoundsofpak how is sufisim is "soul of Islam"?
naarakyuu 1 month ago
@naarakyuu
its like talking to the wall dude.
stick to wahabism
like Osama
sightsandsoundsofpak 1 month ago
@sightsandsoundsofpak ...doesn't answer my question. and what is wahabism?
naarakyuu 1 month ago
@IslamOnDemand He is a monotheïst.
LegendWalid 2 weeks ago
@hendersoncnc
as long as he is not a Wahabi i dont care.
And Sufism is soul of Islam.
sightsandsoundsofpak 1 month ago
@sightsandsoundsofpak can i ask you what a wahabi is? you pakistanis are scum you come from a filthy country with shirk in the bucketloads with palm readers all across the country, your women are taking their clothes off for indians and posing nude in their magazines. you kalb un nar you say sufism is soul of islam? yea how in your country theres filthy sufi shrines like datta darbar where grave worship goes on and lal shahbaz qalandar where u dogs made it like the kaaba and circumambulate it.
ukzane 1 month ago
@sightsandsoundsofpak in all your graveyards you filthy scum have graves which are made of cement going against the prophetic cmmandment. and you dare to say wahabi wahabi?
your just a brainwashed paki
hope your country destroys itself
ukzane 1 month ago
Comment removed
umerjavednisar 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@ukzane .this is a Muslim country u are talking about.and before you start callingme a sufi.I am not.so shut up.If you have some kind of racism against Pakistanis ,dont bring religion in it.dont find excuses to show your bigotry.
umerjavednisar 1 month ago
@sightsandsoundsofpak u dirty rat wat in the world makes u say pakistan is a muslim country far from it ? britain is more of a muslim country than pakistan u grave worshipping dogs. your founder was an ismaili filthy shia and even the shia dont consider them to be muslim so how will you tell me tht pak is a muslim country go live in ur filth u scum
generalzeedot 1 month ago
@generalzeedot
gosh u make it so simple for me its not fair :) really i don't like this at all you are so helpful and kind that u don't let me make effort to write so much against you. :) Everybody can see how extremist you are its so typical Wahabi like i rest my case. Once again thanks a lot brother. Very poetic language you have used and i am sure you will be rewarded by that by Allah (SWT). Osama will be proud of you.
sightsandsoundsofpak 1 month ago
@hendersoncnc Do you even know who were the original 'sufis' or what they did? Junaid al Baghdadi was a sufi so was Imam Ghazali and Abdul Qadir Galani. These people who had Zuhud. Are you going to warn us about them as well.
going2sleep 1 month ago 2
@going2sleep Exactly Sufisim isn't Bid'ah per say, it depends on what is being done with it like doing things that are not in Islamic law. Sufis do alot of Dhikr and it is mentioned in many hadiths which it is permissble and reward is granted for it. The whirling i guess is a way of doing it? Its more of an art actually, Like Arabic Qur'anic calligraphy isn't compulsory but it's part of the out look and beautifying God's names and Qur'anic verses same with whirling Dhikr :/
thekillerose 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
WARNING hamza yusuf is SHIA
TheQuranAndSunnah 1 month ago
@TheQuranAndSunnah And your proof is???
IslamOnDemand 1 month ago 6
@TheQuranAndSunnah Warning you are slandering which is worst than backbiting and eating the flesh of your fellow Muslim. Funny how your user name is QuranandSunnah when you cannot even practice what you read.
going2sleep 1 month ago
@TheQuranAndSunnah your told is wrong
TheThker1403 1 month ago
Comment removed
umerjavednisar 1 month ago
That's right Shaikh, the only great thing in modern Saudi Arabia is Islam. They should got the coordinate right.
TheSaffyone 1 month ago
I don't celebrate Mawlid in the sense of Brelvis etc...but as the Shaykh said its a matter of difference of opinion and I don't condemn it. :)
ASH786b8 1 month ago 2
@McHuZii Our Nabi s.a.w. is human & man - but most perfect being - but to say Nabi s.a.w. is man LIKE me,u,or anyone else isakin 2 shirk - Nabi s.a.w is beyond comparison 2 any man - hope we all understand that this greatest mercy to the worlds is unlike any other & this mercy & blessing on mankind is what is celebrated - may the ummah unite under the leadership of men who understand this mercy to mankind-
43balsam 1 month ago
The most sacred place in the world is the ka'ba not the grave of Rasulullah (S)
WhoIsArRahmanALLAH 2 months ago
@WhoIsArRahmanALLAH No the most sacred place in the world is the Place that contains blessed body of the Prophet saaw and no one disagrees this. It reminds me a Hadith that Rasulullah saw while addressing Kaba said. O kaba you are a place of dignity but the blood of Momi'n is sacred than you.
SunniMuslim2100 1 month ago
@SunniMuslim2100 Yes, I remember that hadith too. That hadith is authentic, but what you mean by it is false. Allah called Makkah the mother of all towns so that's why it is the most sacred place. There is no authentic hadith which says the grave of Rasulullah (S) is more sacred than Makkah. What you are talking about here is ijtihad.
WhoIsArRahmanALLAH 1 month ago
At 4:15 Shaykh Hamza mentioned a book/Scholar, can anyone tell me what Shaykh Hamza said, i find it hard to hear it, Jazakallah. :)
masrurahmed95 2 months ago 2
@masrurahmed95 Al-Shefaa by Qadi Ayyad
85loma 1 month ago
@85loma Jazakallah :D
masrurahmed95 1 month ago
@masrurahmed95 Al-Shefaa means the healing in Arabic
85loma 1 month ago
How is comparing a man to the prophet shirk? I think Sheikh Hamza made and accidental mistake,one which others use to accuse him of shirk.
McHuZii 2 months ago
@McHuZii Sh. Hamza said it's "as close as you get to shirk". So technically speaking he's not saying it's shirk.
IslamOnDemand 2 months ago
I love this man :) for this video
qtrvid 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
So my comment got deleted? Why?
1FUNDAMENTALIST1 3 months ago
I wish I could go to Zeytuna, but its too expensive! Knowledge costs money nowadays...
balancedmuslim 4 months ago
@balancedmuslim
if knowledge costs money, there is something severely wrong.. dont you think?
MuslimVlogGuy 3 months ago
@MuslimVlogGuy what do u mean by something wrong? do u know something!?
qtrvid 2 months ago
@qtrvid
loool. If knowledge costs a lot of money, then something is wrong. Al Maghrib institute does the same thing
MuslimVlogGuy 2 months ago
@MuslimVlogGuy salaam, technically knowledge itself can only come from Allah so let's not degrade it to something we can buy. However when striving for it I think we should not complain whether or not it costs money. Because how can we place value on the attainment of knowledge that will help us for the hereafter?
SpankyBurrito 2 months ago
@SpankyBurrito
knowledge is free. it takes hard work to attain, but it's free.
MuslimVlogGuy 2 months ago
@MuslimVlogGuy Of course knowledge itself is free because only Allah can grant knowledge. I was talking about when seeking knowledge yet being wishy-washy about having to pay for classes or buying books etc. People are willing to pay for things related to worldly nafs but when it comes to the deen they get hesitant. Wallahualam.. And off topic akhi but when a fellow muslim gives salaam I think you know what one should do.
SpankyBurrito 2 months ago
@SpankyBurrito
I'm not obligated to reply to "salaam." That is not the Islamic greeting. Anyway, your justification doesn't work. No reason someone should pay thousands of dollars for something they can learn in the masjid for free.
MuslimVlogGuy 2 months ago
@MuslimVlogGuy Can you please point out to me where I said we should pay thousands of dollars somewhere instead of learning in the masjid? Nowhere did I say that, that was apparently your own interpretation. That said, I'm not about to go into a fruitless argument with you. I'll be on my way now. Assalamualaikum.
SpankyBurrito 2 months ago
@SpankyBurrito
Wasn't arguing. Don't be soft. Walaikum Assalam (See if you had said "Assalamu Alaikum" I would have responded. That is the Islamic greeting. Not "salam.")
MuslimVlogGuy 2 months ago
This guy right here is simply AMAZING masha'Allah! :o <3
thatgirlhibaa 5 months ago
Subhan Allah.
ShanZeize 5 months ago
Islam is the only way to get Salvation.
Jazak Allah.
ShanZeize 5 months ago
I love Brother Hamza yusuf we should respect our Brothers in ISLAM we have no right say any nonsense to a MUSLIM brother.
Don't divide the Ummah.
ShanZeize 5 months ago
There's alot of people judging others simply from the sects they're in. At the end of the day, no one can actually judge the contents of one's heart, therefore we have no place to say what is right or what is wrong. If you feel that something is wrong, dialogue, don't argue! Sufi, Suni or Shia, any man or woman who has dedicated their life to studying Islam deserves to be heard. :)
shamil6793 5 months ago
Mashallah! lol 1.53
Maturidi333 5 months ago
It's really a shame that so many Arab nations worship their "leaders", there are Masjids in which is written the names of the "kings", in the schools they play pianos in the morning and then sing a "celebration" song for their "rulers". It's very, very bad thing and almost shirk. Not so much for the people in my opinion as it's the leaders who carve their names and wish to be worshiped. May Allah lead them to the truth.
ThePatientMuslim 5 months ago
Good job brother Hamza!!
ITHADchannel 5 months ago
Salaam, Im not familiar with some of the words the sheikh used, I was wondering if someone could explain..?
jamesbond1066 6 months ago
Kisses for you sheikh!!
zahirmalbari 6 months ago
Look who is talking about Bid'ah = a Sufi !! XD
3822218 6 months ago
@3822218 shut up
8soccer4life8 6 months ago
@3822218
LOL
alithelin1234 6 months ago
@3822218 I have heard this ''Sufi'' first time in my life ... but didn't hear anything against Quran or Sunnah in this particular video .. did you? ... if yes, do assist me and let me know .... come with a solid argument and not with a taunt, ok? ... JazakAllah
mmkashifbaig 6 months ago
@mmkashifbaig
I didn't listen to what he said, but I laughed when i saw Hamza Yusuf talking about Bid'ah !!
It's like a smoker advising non-smokers to not smoke XD
You don't know what Sufi & Sufism mean ? This is a disaster my brother...Yusuf is a Sufi ( A lot of Islamic scholars said that ), he didn't express his real beliefs.
Go search about Sufism & Hamza Yusuf, I'm afraid you're a Sufi & you don't even realize that.
3822218 6 months ago
@3822218 Now it was my turn to laugh (thanks for that) that you laughed on Hamza Yusuf WITHOUT listening to what he said in this particular clip.(Its sufficient for one to be a liar if he communicates something to others without making sure of its truthness; Hadith).But good thing is you now seem ready to come with SOLID arguments. Now, leave Hamza Yusuf alone, you tell me, What Sufism is (am hoping you have learnt from authoritative books and not merely from internet scattered suspecious info).
mmkashifbaig 6 months ago
@mmkashifbaig
I won't argue about the first part of your reply because you apparently didn't search about Hamza Yusuf.
Why you ask me this question ? is it because you want to know what Sufism is ? or you're a Sufi ? or you think I'm a guy who is talking about something he doesn't know ?!
Sufism is a good way to worship Allah in its first appearance BUT now it's just an Islam version full of Bid'ah & Shirks.
Dancing front graves & shaking while reading Quran are examples.
That's it.
3822218 6 months ago
@3822218 JazakAllah,so u beleive that 'Sufism' is good way to worship Allah.There is no argument then.If someone does something which is prohibited in Islam and associate it wrongly to Sufism then its neither Islam nor Sufism.So if someone actually does something AGAINST Quran and Sunnah then it is not permitted, no matter its u, me or Hamza. But it would be just prejudice to accuse Sufism in the first place.It'd be like non muslims accusing Islam b'coz Muslims are not good in character !!!
mmkashifbaig 6 months ago in playlist Liked
@mmkashifbaig
I said Sufism is a good way in its first appearance ( in 3th century Hijri )
NOW it's full of Shirks & Bid'ah.
Anyone call himself a Sufi isn't following the real correct Islam ( i don't have to look to what he does because i know what Sufism is ).
BUT i don't say Sufis aren't Muslims they're just in the wrong way, i can say about the Ayat & Mo'ammen of Shia ( the Twelvers ) that they're not Muslims BUT who follow them are just ignorant we can't blame them.
btw, are you Sufi ?
3822218 6 months ago
@3822218 I wish I could be a REAL SUFI.I repeat real Sufi can't go against Sharia. I'd hoped that you being an Arab will come up with concrete arguments from Quran & Sunna and make me learn somthing from you but you've jsut come up with wishy washy comments. وَاعْتَصِمُوا بِحَبْلِ اللَّـهِ جَمِيعًا وَلَا تَفَرَّقُوا ....
وَعِبَادُ الرَّحْمَـٰنِ الَّذِينَ يَمْشُونَ عَلَى الْأَرْضِ هَوْنًا وَإِذَا خَاطَبَهُمُ الْجَاهِلُونَ قَالُوا سَلَامًا (am not translating as u can understand arabic text)
mmkashifbaig 5 months ago
@
There is nothing could a real Sufi NOW, ask any Shikh in UK or imam he will tell you what Sufism is, or do some research about it, or just go & look how they worship Allah & you will recognize if what they do is right or wrong by logic.
This verse doesn't fit here, i can't walk with someone think that the souls of humans are just the souls of animals that died !! sadly, I'm not good in English BUT watch these vids & ask yourself is this Islam ?
watch?v=2U_PWmQ_LtI
watch?v=mtT5RfDfeIE
3822218 5 months ago
@mmkashifbaig
& finally, there is no difference between Arabs & other nationalities, maybe you know more than me...
Brother, don't let them fool you, maybe you heard them say that there are fake Sufism & real Sufism ( it's one sect, they all do crazy things & believe illogical stuff )
& As i said, ask any imam in UK you trust.
May Allah guide us to the right way.
3822218 5 months ago
@3822218 Absolutely this is not Sufism, these people have hijacked this term..and yes you'll not find a real sufi NOW because a real Sufi doesn't advertise his piousness, but it doesn't mean a real sufi doesn't exist.As I said you haven't come up with solid arguments from Quran & Sunnah, there is no point discussing it further.Everyone who follows 'Ehsan' as described in Hadees-eJibreel is real Sufi. I'll narrate this hadees in next two texts as it may not fit in this text. PEACE UPON YOU.
mmkashifbaig 5 months ago in playlist Liked
@mmkashifbaig
Okay, so ?
Brother you think that Sunnis don't have Ehsan in their sect ( if we can call it sect, i think it's ISLAM ) ? this definition of Ehsan i studied it in school in KSA when i was 7 years old.
You seem you don't know Sunnis & Sunnah well.
Let's take it in this way, what is wrong with Ahl Al Sunnah Waljama'a ? what you found in Sufism that doesn't Sunnah have ?
Why you want to take a dark unclear way if you already have clear way ?
3822218 5 months ago
بَيْنَمَا نَحْنُ جُلُوسٌ عِنْدَ رَسُولِ الله ص ذَاتَ يَوْمٍ، إذْ طَلَعَ عَلَيْنَا رَجُلٌ شَدِيدُ بَيَاضِ الثِّيَابِ، شَدِيدُ سَوَادِ الشَّعْرِ، لا يُرَى عَلَيْهِ أَثَرُ السَّفَرِ، وَلا يَعْرِفُهُ مِنَّا أحَدٌ، حَتَّى جَلَسَ إلَى النَّبِيِّ ص، فَأَسْنَدَ رُكْبَتَيْهِ إلَى رُكْبَتَيْهِ، وَوَضَعَ كَفَّيْهِ عَلَى فَخِذَيْهِ، وَقَالَ: يَا مُحَمَّدُ، أخْبِرْنِي عَنْ الإسْلاَمِ. فَقَالَ رَسُولُ اللهِ ص: الإِسْلاَمُ أَنْ تَشْهَدَ أَنْ لاَ إِلهَ إِلاَ اللهُ وَأَنَّ مُحَمَّداً رَسُولُ اللهِ،
mmkashifbaig 5 months ago in playlist Liked
وَتُقِيمَ الصَّلاَةَ، وَتُؤْتِيَ الزَّكَاةَ، وَتَصُومَ رَمَضَانَ، وَتَحُجَّ الْبَيتَ إِن اسْتَطَعْتَ إِلَيْهِ سَبِيلاً. قَالَ: صَدَقْتَ، فَعَجِبْنَا لَهُ يَسْأَلُهُ وَيُصَدِّقُهُ. قَالَ: فَأَخْبِرْنِي عَنِ الإِيْمَانِ، قَالَ: أَنْ تُؤْمِنَ بِاللهِ، وَمَلاَئِكَتِهِ، وَكُتُبِهِ، وَرُسُلِهِ، وَالْيَوْمِ الآخِرِ، وَتُؤْمِنَ بِالْقَدَرِ خَيْرِهِ وَشَرِّهِ. قَالَ: صَدَقْتَ، قَالَ: فَأَخْبِرْنِي عَنِ الإِحْسَانِ. قَالَ: أَنْ تَعْبُدَ اللهَ كَأَنَّكَ تَرَاهُ، فَإِنْ لَمْ تَكُنْ تَرَاهُ فَإِنَّهُ يَرَاكَ
mmkashifbaig 5 months ago in playlist Liked
قَالَ: فَأَخْبِرْنِي عَنِ السَّاعَةِ، قَالَ: مَا الْمَسْؤُولُ عَنْهَا بِأَعْلَمَ مِنَ السَّائِلِ. قَالَ: فَأَخْبِرْنِي عَنْ أَمَارَاتِهَا، قَالَ: أَنْ تَلِدَ الأَمَةُ رَبَّتَهَا، وَأَنْ تَرَى الْحُفَاةَ الْعُرَاةَ الْعَالَةَ رِعَاءَ الشَّاءِ يَتَطَاوَلُونَ فِي الْبُنْيَانِ. ثُمَّ انْطَلَقَ فَلَبِثْتُ مَلِيًّا ثُمَّ قَالَ: يَا عُمَرُ أَتَدْرِي مَنِ السَّائِلُ؟ قُلْتُ: اللهُ وَرَسُولُهُ أَعْلَمُ، قَالَ: فَإِنَّهُ جِبْرِيْلُ أَتَاكُمْ يُعَلِّمُكُمْ دِيْنَكُمْ
رَوَاهُ مُسْلِمٌ
mmkashifbaig 5 months ago in playlist Liked
not supporting mawlid doesnt mean agree on celebrating of an anniversary of 'anything'. mawlid can only be justified if someone not use this act as one of legitimate islamic rites which has been codified by shariah. underline this....'celebaring mawlid (like today some people do) is not part of shariah' so if some muslims dont agree with it, they dot violate the shariah, but if some other groups of muslim like to do it, make sure they dont put it in corporating with shariah....
sonvai 6 months ago
"A country that wages war on the maulid is celebrating 100 birthday of its birthday right now"...
I love all scholars of the Ummah including many salafi scholars, but what Sh. Hamza said is the truth.
zarf00 7 months ago 8
@zarf00 I can’t agree with Sh. Hamza this time...celebrating a national day is different..People know it doesn’t have anything to do with religion..But celebrations that are labelled "Islamic" is a problem because it is Bidaa in Islam..People start claiming this religious duty and it propagates to a bigger Bidaa, Shirk and so on...
DSSNTC 1 month ago
@DSSNTC how can you say it's nothing to do with Islam. by saying this you are separating Dunya from Deen while for a Muslim whatever he/she does should not be out of the fold of religion. Its not bidah because Sahaba RadiALLAHu Anhum celebrated Maulid but there mehtod was a bit different from us. There are Ahadith that prove this. the difference we have now a days because of the difference of our circumstances with them and this is not only in Maulid but everything.
SunniMuslim2100 1 month ago
@SunniMuslim2100 No its not separating Dunya from deen, there is no problme if you celebrate passing exams, but the problme araise when you claim this is a religioues duty or sunnah while its not! i hope you get that. if yo claim that celebrating passing exams is part of the religion duties that becomes Bidaa (Bidda means attributing something to islam while its not - this is deangeroues and this why the prophet (pbuh) warned us from), tell me when did the prophet celebrate Maulid?? its Bidaa.
DSSNTC 1 month ago
Loool!! when he was talking about the film "a man from the desert" i was also waiting to hear the Prophet of God (PBUH).
saidsule 7 months ago 2
I think Pakistanis those who condemn Al Mawrid and its scholars should take a lesson from it, just coz one of them spoke against Tablighi literature, countless non scholarly self righteous muslims have detonated him, which is in bad taste, u dont agree, u want to be on the save side and abstain do that, and counsel the close ones who support him with a dialogue, but attacking n saying oh he has no sunnah on his face, common grow up, no one knows no ones state of imaan so relax , salam u alaikum
MrRuggedboy27 7 months ago
I love Sheikh Hamza Yusuf.
mohammadahmad0790 7 months ago