I have to agree, this was terrible except for one pure line by David A. They didn't give him enough of the song to save it. Oddly enough he was better suited for this song than Shout to the Lord.
they got the chance to sing the most beautiful song from the most beautiful musical in front of millions of people. You'd think they could at LEAST put a little passion or feeling into it!
This wasn't the best version I've heard. I think Brooke can't sing high enough, so you can hear her voice really clearly, and they didn't give her a solo for the same reason.
Love the song though, and the broadway show Rent!
David get the words right. It's the way that she died, not the that she died. I'm sorry, but this is just a bad version of Seasons of Love. It's so over the top, and I don't know who but someone can't harmonize at all.
maybe she was really told to sing louder to stand out as u can notice shes the only one who didnt have a solo part...either way she did not sound good on this one...
woo .. i miss AI 7 :3
darelleo5 6 months ago
I can only hear Brooke and David xD
drdeathmania37 8 months ago
someones mic was up too high '>.>
tobiunderthemaskX48 8 months ago
haha people clapped hard but i guess they regret it after they heard the A.I version=)
emocast 8 months ago
I have to agree, this was terrible except for one pure line by David A. They didn't give him enough of the song to save it. Oddly enough he was better suited for this song than Shout to the Lord.
MusicfaninMO 10 months ago
My heart just melts when David Archie sang his line. He is so beautiful.
strawberryswit77 1 year ago
What a great song! So glad they were kind enough to fuck it up the ass!
hanshotfirststudios 1 year ago
WOW!!! It's absolutely disgusting!!
neelandesilva 1 year ago
this is absolutely terrible.
xxmasterchiefofahlo 1 year ago
they got the chance to sing the most beautiful song from the most beautiful musical in front of millions of people. You'd think they could at LEAST put a little passion or feeling into it!
LivetoRENT 1 year ago
what a wonderful song!! love david a.!!
joseph4723 1 year ago
I agree this was horrible
WhyDoUNeedSmack 1 year ago
I just like how no one even attempts to do Gwen Stewarts part at the end! ;-)
ninpokid 1 year ago
i love carly smithson!!!!
dorothyvillalobos 1 year ago
THIS IS SO NOT GOOD.
TheOriginalMuse 1 year ago
i like it...galing
bhang03 2 years ago
this was horrible except for carly and david a
Nattalyee 2 years ago 15
RENT does it better!!!!
coffeegirlnyc10014 2 years ago 5
@coffeegirlnyc10014 Of course they did, it is a Rent song after all. What else does one expect?
Smurfy1211 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i voted for david A.
but i should have voted for david cook cus he sings wayyyy better!
twinskittles16 2 years ago
holy crap im singing this is chorus in school!!!!!!!!!!!!11 i <3 this song lol
Mslolchicalol 2 years ago
o yeah go david!
bennettkaren 2 years ago 4
This was dreadfull.
mouthcomics 2 years ago 5
This wasn't the best version I've heard. I think Brooke can't sing high enough, so you can hear her voice really clearly, and they didn't give her a solo for the same reason.
Love the song though, and the broadway show Rent!
kaykeii 2 years ago 6
david i so hot
nickjonasluver101101 2 years ago
archuleta right?! I love me some archie:) He sang that one note realllly good and strong.
hickschick4 2 years ago 17
@hickschick4
haha yea but he messed up the lyrics. bad.
xBananaSurferx 2 years ago
David get the words right. It's the way that she died, not the that she died. I'm sorry, but this is just a bad version of Seasons of Love. It's so over the top, and I don't know who but someone can't harmonize at all.
LostGraveRobber 2 years ago 4
I agree.. someone sticks out like a sore thumb!!!! And it doesn't have enough passion.. I didn't like it..
Kandye 2 years ago
david a rocks
xxG00S3x4SS4SSINxx 2 years ago 2
i<3 david archuleta...:)
janisianne28 2 years ago 6
SUCH a cutie :))
katiekat09 2 years ago 2
awsome song lol:) i did this 4 graduation and i had boys solo:)
rockandroll518 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
God aweful
amandapanda9999 2 years ago
0:30 Brooke was overpowering EVERYONE
MrsBriaaJonas 3 years ago
she obviously can't harmonize cause i can hear clearly throughout
K33V4N 2 years ago
maybe she was really told to sing louder to stand out as u can notice shes the only one who didnt have a solo part...either way she did not sound good on this one...
yoururbanchic 2 years ago
Archuleta guys...isn't it obvious???
blue4everd 3 years ago 2
Omg david Is amazing!!!!
blue4everd 3 years ago
very good
hsmla 3 years ago