Don't Give Up [A Rose's Return Video] - Doctor/Rose - Doctor Who

[TARDISstowaway]

This video made me SO HAPPY!!! Wonderful job with the storytelling.

[Eriksoneandonly]

@TARDISstowaway I'm so glad! :D Thank you very much!

[IdinaisLife1]

I LOVE THIS VIDEO!!!!!!

And I really want this to be canon!

5* (and extra stars for the use of josh groban!)

[Eriksoneandonly]

Thank you so much! :D

(Same here... heehee...)

Thanks again! (Yay, Josh Groban!! <3)

[TheBadWolfGames]

No sound? I can hear the sound perfectly, lol. Anyway, loved it. :)

[Eriksoneandonly]

:D Yeah, they just reapplied the sound because I disputed the copyright claim on the video, but before, when ksdoctorwho commented, there wasn't any sound. Thank you so much, glad you enjoyed!

[ksdoctorwho]

Man! This was like one of my favorite videos from you and now there is no sound. I'm so sorry they did this to you. I'm sad now.

[Eriksoneandonly]

*nods* Thank you for the kind comment. If you can find a video with the same song (Don't Give Up (You Are Loved) by Josh Groban), you can play it simultaneously and get a similar effect (alternatively, use a CD player or MP3 player of your choice with the song in it), but it's just not the same. :(

[Queen0ftheCastle]

This was a really really well done AU, and I got to see plenty of my favorite doc (the 9th =D) So I'm pretty happy! 5*! =D

[Eriksoneandonly]

Why, thank you! I'm very glad you enjoyed. Yes, Nine was a wonderful Doctor, I wish he could have had more seasons... :) Thanks again!

[EosHeliosSelene]

Fantastic!

and

Brilliant!

[Eriksoneandonly]

Thank you very much! ;) (I saw what you did there. ;D)

[gemzn]

very clever !!!!!

[Eriksoneandonly]

Thanks much! :D

[DreameQueene]

Cleverrrrr!

[Eriksoneandonly]

Thank youuuu! XD

[nonnobis3]

This was FABULOUS!!! Excellent editing and it really made sense. My only criticism is that, in the parts where rose is speaking, it's kind of hard to hear what she's saying...

but other than that, this was bloody brilliant!

*****

[Eriksoneandonly]

Thank you! I'm so glad you enjoyed it! Right, I know, when I was editing it, it sounded a bit clearer, but when I got it up on Youtube, it was less easy to hear. Sorry 'bout that. :) Thanks again!

[Itunesbabe]

that was brillant, well done, 5 stared and faved! :)

[Eriksoneandonly]

Thank you very much! Glad you enjoyed it! :D

[xXxXxcozzaxXxXx]

WOW ....i would never be able to do that !

[Eriksoneandonly]

Aw, sure you will! Just takes practice and a good editing program! ;) Glad you liked it! :D

[xXxXxcozzaxXxXx]

thankyou and yh i will keep practicing !!

[laurabatham]

ah now that was clever

well done

[Eriksoneandonly]

Heehee, thank you! I'm glad you liked it!

[gamwyn]

Brilliant! Excessively clever, I love it!!

[Eriksoneandonly]

Mwaha! Thanks! :D Glad you enjoyed!

[kt27rule]

i love this video it so cool

[Eriksoneandonly]

Thank you!  Glad you liked it!

[yorkshiredeb]

Omg that would be great! if it happend.

Lol

[Eriksoneandonly]

Heehee, wouldn't it just? XD

[marcusmongoose]

OMG thats sooo clever!!! WOW!!!

[Eriksoneandonly]

Aw, thanks! ;)  Glad you liked it!

[nscara2]

That was absoluely AMAZING. Just WOW. very very very good!

[Eriksoneandonly]

Thank you so much!  I'm very glad you enjoyed it! :D

[DoctorWhoDave]

yep, i've checked out some more of your vids, they are AMAZING, so...I'M SUBSCRIBING :D

[Eriksoneandonly]

Oh, thank you! :) I'm very glad you like my videos, thanks for subscribing! :D

[DoctorWhoDave]

WOW

5 Stars and faved

One of the best videos i have ever seen, I am gonna checck out some more of your vids cos if they are anywhere near as good as this, I'll subscribe

[Eriksoneandonly]

Thank you so much! I'm glad you enjoyed! :D

[Rosetylermad111]

(wet and cold tears fall down) is the ninth doctor gonna try and find the tenth doctor i wasnt listening lol with rose, i cant wait! thos rocks!

[Eriksoneandonly]

Heehee, yep, that's the point of the story. Thank you!

[Emmatd]

Reaaaallly Really cute/sad/shippy video!

[Eriksoneandonly]

Heehee, thank you very much! ;) Glad you liked! :D

[PaintedReality]

Awesome stuff!

*Subscribes*

[Eriksoneandonly]

Oh, thank you! XD And thanks for subscribing! Glad you enjoyed!

[jacksterboy]

this almost had me in tears

[Eriksoneandonly]

Aw, I'm sorry! *huggles*

[jacksterboy]

i forgot to mention FANTASTIC i subscribed this isnt the 1st 1 of urs i thought was brilliant

[Eriksoneandonly]

Heehee, thanks so much! And thanks for subscribing! I'm so glad you enjoy my videos. :D Makes me feel all warm and fuzzy inside! XD

[jacksterboy]

dont mention it

[ksdoctorwho]

OMG! That was so clever of you. It was so beautiful. I love how even though Nine had to give up Rose to Ten (which was very sad, touching, and beautiful) he went back and still got to have her. It was such a smart idea. I'm surprise that no one has thought about this way before. Brilliant! I also thought the joke at the end about him talking about time travel was pure genius. I'm subscribing now. Can't wait to see your other videos!

[Eriksoneandonly]

Oh, thank you so much! Yes, I'm also surprised it hasn't been done before. I know it would probably mess up the timelines a bit, but I still think it's a pretty neat little concept. Heehee, thanks, it was almost unintentional, just sort of put the clip in there, listened to it, and started cracking up. It worked out really well! Thank you for subscribing, hope you like my other videos! Glad you enjoyed this one, thanks again! :D

[cazzykay23]

i love thsi video ti so cool and sweet

[Eriksoneandonly]

Thank you!  I'm glad you enjoyed it!

[folliesandnonsense]

I think my jaw actually hit the top of my desk. I can't believe how fabulous this is!!! The idea alone is incredible, but to then manipulate the limited clips with such skill is astounding! You have a rare talent!

[Eriksoneandonly]

Wow, thank you so much! This comment definitely made my day. I'm so glad you enjoyed it. :D Thanks again!

[electricfluff]

brill, 5 stars

[Eriksoneandonly]

Thanks ever so much! Glad you liked it. :)

[xXTardisDreamerXx]

woah!

tht was brilliant

reeli good idea loved it

xXxXx

[Eriksoneandonly]

Heehee, thanks! Glad you enjoyed it. :D

[LucyAllonsyFreak]

WoW Thats Amazing :D

[Eriksoneandonly]

Thanks very much! Glad you liked it. :)

[Wanabeeslayer]

OMG!!!! I loved it!!!!

[Eriksoneandonly]

Thanks! I'm glad! :D