Added: 1 year ago
From: rattleduser
Views: 71,147
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (120)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • liam gallagher > john lennon

  • The way I see it...... you have two options.

    To like..... or not to like. You choose.... it's not the end of the end of the world.

  • Plagiarism is the cornerstone of the music industry guys.... everyone takes a little influence from the bands/composer/vocalists that they listen to and (whether or not it's intentional is another matter). But the whole sounding like the beatles thing is just media spin... and it's not the first (or last) time they've applied this term to a band. And what's wrong with giving a nod to one of your influences? So what....

  • Its nice to see LG being humble for once

  • I don't get the Lennon personality love in. He regularly beat up his first wife.

  • If you want to write as well as the Beatles then you shouldn't really listen to them, but listen to what THE BEATLES WERE LISTENING TO.Then you might come close.Also go 'on the road' at 17 playing16 hours a day in a German club just a few years after WWII living in a storage room sharing socks,women,men,pills.Learning the arse off every song going ,even ones that people thought are uncool.Oasis sound like a wet weekend in John Lennon's composting toilet because they were listening too narrowly.

  • Well Noel could (have) sing like Lennon if he didn't do it from the back of the throat like he does.

  • ive met his son :))))))

  • I really never liked this Liam Gallagher guy - his brother is a lot more talented but still carries the same sort of 'down the nose' sneery attitude, which is difficult to understand. Its not really punk, and definitely not rebel. Its just, well, boring bad attitude really. I think a lot of it is born of insecurity. Sorry to hark back to that 90's popular-in-the-press rivalry, but give me Blur and the associated art any day. Albarn/Coxon v Gallaghers? No contest.

  • @larousserie to say they look down their noses at people when they say that they dont like middle class and hate snobs is a bit unfair. you could say a lot about liam gallagher but one thing you cant call him is boring.

  • Im gonna call my son Liam, not Gallagher

  • Comment removed

  • Fucking legend! (Both of them)

  • I donno what all the arguing is about. both of these men are/were extremely talented musicians and hell raisers. Lennon routinely shoplifted and was sent to the principles office in his youth. He even mugged a drunken sailor in Hamburg for his money... though he obviously grew out of that much more than liam has. But who knows, maybe liam just acts like an asshole for the camera.

  • Liam is an arrogant prick

  • thats what i wanna call my son Lennon :)

  • Liam&john's singing voice sound really similuar

  • The funny thing is Lennon was just as much a hellraiser as Gallagher in his day. So I don't think he really despised the 'macho' thing

  • I HATE this ASS but I do like John Lennon ...wow holy shit I got something in common with this NOBHEAD

  • The irony is John Lennon despised that kind of "macho" bullshit. Probably would have hated Liam too, and the fact that Oasis rip them off constantly. John encouraged people to be original and was pretty against any Beatle wannabe shit.

  • @piemakesmelol I'm pretty sure Lennon was a bit of a trouble maker back in the day, just as Liam is.

  • @YesterdayWentTooSoon- Difference is Liam is a knob and John wasn't. John was a trouble maker but only because he was anti-establishment and unique, Liam clearly isn't and the only reason he's a "trouble-maker" was because he was a mink who used to steal people's bikes when they went in shops. Just sounds like a chav to me. Lennon hated that sort of bravado shit, cause he saw right through it.

  • @piemakesmelol You don't think John hitting his women or cheating on his first wife makes him a knob?

  • @theredraven ??? did John beat Yoko/Cynthia up? or are you talkin about Liam.

  • @HogbenPeter It's a well known fact John hit Cynthia and Yoko. He also had an affair while married to Yoko too.

    Makes him a knob. Especially when he preached all the peace and love stuff.

  • @theredraven Well ??? I dunno what to say. Tormented souls, right, that's what everybodies interested in. I find that attractive about John Lennon, does that make me sick.

  • @HogbenPeter If you're saying you find it interesting that he hit his Women, I'd say that's rather odd.

  • @theredraven no, i'm saying he was a tormented soul, that's why he hit cynthia.

  • @theredraven- I've never heard of John hitting any women. Cheating is a thing that happens, it's not nice but it happens to everyone. John never went about claiming he was the best thing ever or acted tough, he was confident and spoke his mind and could be more than a little offensive to some, but he never put it on. Liam on the other hand does, he comes across as a fucking dolt with the IQ of a squirrel.

  • @piemakesmelol that's the point i was trying to make to @theredraven. liam has got the iq of a squirrel. John may have hit them, i dunno. but he acted with a bit more sense.

  • @HogbenPeter Lol the IQ of a squirrel.

  • @YesterdayWentTooSoon The only thing is John wasn't a knobhead like Liam. hehehehe

  • @piemakesmelol kinda late for replying but wasnt john a chuck berry and elvis wannabe

  • @CarEdy23- Difference is John never COPIED them. You can like and be influenced by an artist without ripping them off, Liam and Noel don't know that though.

  • @piemakesmelol He got sued for 'Come Together'. Please do some research before you come out with such statements.

  • @FlyingFishify- Difference is Come Together is ONE song....where as the ENTIRE OASIS discography is a rip of a different tune.

  • @piemakesmelol liam also had other influences, its not the same sound, its kind of a tribute

  • @CarEdy23- No, that's just what people say to get around calling it a rip-off. You don't copy the exact same tune, appearance, style, sound from another band and call it a "tribute", that's theft.

  • @piemakesmelol he was influenced by the sex pistols and other bands and he is really talented you know i dont think john would hate him

  • @CarEdy23- He's not talented. If he was talented he would be able to write an original song but he can't. He also wouldn't have a haircut that makes him look like a special needs kid. I think John would dislike him, he hated copy-cats and he hated the "macho-man" shit.

  • @piemakesmelol ok not an oasis fan i get it, but you got to admit he's got a great voice

  • @CarEdy23- Not really man, he makes for a good John sound-a-like.

  • @piemakesmelol

    The 'Oasis rip off the beatles' slogan, really is the height of ignorance. Just face the fact that Oasis blended so many classic rock styles and added their own wall of sound. Also, liam sounded fuckin amazing in his day.

  • @TheMrbollox- That's rubbish...there's nothing wrong with being influenced by a band or an artist. And even adopting a similar style is not that bad, however Oasis don't just do that. They take actual tunes and riffs from other bands and market them as their own, that's theft. Like Cigarettes and Alcohol it's the exact same riff as T-Rex's Bang a Gong. That's not inspiration or a tribute that's being a lazy writer.

  • @piemakesmelol, maybe they do take riffs off of other bands. However, when they take those riffs and put them into their songs the riff takes on a different meaning. I get a completely different sensation from Cigarettes and Alcohol than I do from Bang a Gong, which indicates to me that each song has a uniqueness that the other doesn't. Oasis, just like the Stones, take from their inspirations and build upon them. That's not lazy song writing, that's honouring the artists that inspired you.

  • @TubesforDudes- That's simply not true. They can't be credited as 'writing' that song if the main riff was written by another band. There's no way two ways around it, if you are taking another riff or piece of music from another band and are not giving them credit, that is theft. Oasis are therefore thieves. This whole "honoring' rubbish doesn't make sense, considering they aren't giving credit where credit is due. They're unoriginal song writers because there's nothing special about them.

  • @piemakesmelol , if that is the case then how do you explain blues music? Whenever I listen to blues music I feel like I can predict the note/chord that comes next. From what I can tell, blues musicians have been re-using guitar riffs since the inception of the genre. You can hear it in Clatpon, the Stones, Zeppelin, White Stripes, Black Keys... John Lennon himself did it on "Yer Blues." Personally, I would never call any of these song writers unoriginal.

  • @TubesforDudes- That's because follows the blues scale, that's how the genre is defined. It's not very original but that's just what blues is. And a lot of modern musicians, like the Black Keys and The White Stripes have managed to create interesting riffs within the blues scale. That's why they sound original. Because it is. They may sound similar, but they don't take actual RIFFS from one another like Oasis does.

  • @piemakesmelol Actually, it would seem these artists do take riffs like Oasis does. Zeppelin got sued for Whole Lotta Love, George Harrison for My Sweet Lord. The White Stripes took the Heart Shaped Box riff for I Can't Wait, and John Lennon was sued for Come Together. With the exception of I Can't Wait, these tracks are arguably the respective artists biggest hits, and yet they have been legally penalized for stealing. I just don't see why Oasis is deserving of any more scrutiny than they are.

  • Liam Gallagher is a true mancunian and that's how most of us act so hahah were all morons! Oasis livveee forevverrr-3

  • Can't understand a word this guy says...

  • @jaco5187 No need to, he never says anything of any consequence anyway, the thick twat.

  • Comment removed

  • @jaco5187 he speaks english

  • Liam is such a twat why do people big him up so much hes so cocky and he cant get enough of himself

  • Liam is so cool. He has the best voice I've listened... well I like very much Bon Scott's voice and Brian Johnson's voice but Liam's voice is different, he has something that make you listen and listen. I like so much.

  • the lead singer from oasis wants to stop tucking his sideburns down his socks the nob mmmmaaadddfffooorrriiiittt lol bye again

  • takes a city like liverpool to create geniuses theres no where in england that does the same as liverpool everywhere else are just wannabees like oasis they are shite some nob walkin round sayin mad ffooorrriiit lol trying to duplicate liverpool genius that why the whole of england dont like liverpool jealousy is an illness weve created the best music group ever to this day and the most succesful football club lfc 5 european cups no other team can do this ever bye enjoy

  • liam is genial ((°j°))

  • Lol, what a moron Gallagher is

  • @TheKenfig naah mate ya got it wrong he is a really passionate person and just wants to be adored cos he hasnt been as a kid and lennon brought light into his life. so dont be a hater to summat ya dont know

  • @oasis120596 Fair enough but he is quite arrogant and Lennon wasn't

  • Why name the kid Lennon in first name? Shouldn't he be named John instead?

  • @MoonwalkerWorshiper no because if he is called lennon then people will know he is named after john lennon but if he is called john then he may be named after anyone

  • @FLEXskateboards Sure but John is a good common english name and it's more suitable to name ones kids that and he could still say he's named after John Lennon.

  • @leedickens100 what is he then? a fucking gentleman? 

  • What an utter fucking cunt, The beatles had taken unlike this piece of excrement, go sell some of your tatty Tshirts dickhead

  • You know what I mean but, you know what I mean,but you know what I mean?

    Noel is the only talented Gallagher!

  • Mark David Chapmans son is looking to speak to this faggot lymie.

  • oasis = shit,  the beatles = epic!!

  • @beatleforce1 what a daft comment seeing as so many Oasis songs take inspiration from The Beatles...

  • @LukeHeyes Or do they just seem to take inspiration from the beatles?

  • @beatleforce1 so it's by complete coincidence that Liam is an absolute nut for The Beatles and Oasis songs emulate their style repeatedly?

  • @LukeHeyes yeah but the difference is liams a chav.

  • @beatleforce1 and the award for the most irrelevant comment ever goes to....

  • @LukeHeyes ..........YOU!!!!

  • I love Lennon, know what I mean eh?

  • I was going to watch this programme when it was on, but when this talentless prick came on, I turned it off straight away.

  • @spjdbauer And rightly so haha!!!

  • liam son with patsy kenset was named lennon hehhe

  • I know people don't like Liam or don't get him or whatever it is. But Lennon/Gallagher Beatles/Oasis.

    I bloody love it!

  • tihis guy liam is very obssesed

  • @mrrodpatrick1 thats not obsession. the beatles were and still are the best band in history.

  • @mrrodpatrick1 he loves him, and what's the problem if he's obssesed? he's a big fan that's all.

  • someday i'm gonna visit that "Let It Be" sanctuary as a pilgrimage

  • wich documentary is?

  • it's amazing to think that this chav moron produces such amazing music...real life persona and artistic persona are really two different people

  • @viralfunnies pity he never came up with a grown up persona. He's like an overgrown teenager. McCartney does none of that poncing about. He was just innately rock star. Still is AND a credible grown man

  • @viralfunnies brilliantly said mate spot on

  • @viralfunnies Wouldn't say he's a chav... Just the way he speaks. Real common but he's working class, what would you expect.

  • @viralfunnies

    liam aint a moron, LOL your a moron to even think that he is..

  • @quickmantan In what sense is he not?

    He's a fucking douche lol.

  • @viralfunnies But what makes him rock and roll is that he simply doesn't give a shit.

  • @viralfunnies liam is no chav you muppet

  • @viralfunnies Lol somebody had to say it, he also seems not so intelligent,

  • @viralfunnies Chav? hardly...

  • @viralfunnies I wouldn't say chav. He's just like that because of his working class background and where he lived when he was a kid.

  • @viralfunnies Your the fucking moron

  • @viralfunnies i hate you

  • Liam and Lennon, both brilliant <3 

  • @DogBalls182 Well...one is brilliant.

  • @DogBalls182 L0L a nice piece of humour!

  • he loves john hahaha

  • didn't john laught at a retard. ?

  • @JohnAllanification well john would of laffed at your spelling i think your the retard man

  • @kjf666

    i just don't like liam gallagher. i certainly didn't mean to imply a wider issue. i don't usually say such thing's as a rule.

  • @kjf666 how can you tell anyone about spelling you retard, LAUGHED*

  • @kjf666 you're the retard*

  • He is clearly stupid

  • Shame he's not even fit to tie lennons shoe laces....

  • hahahahhahahahhh

  • @FutureAbe cock

  • what documentary was this on ?

  • @MegaNoelM It was called 'The Day John Lennon Died' I saw it a while back on Sky Anytime, I think it was originally aired on Sky Arts...

  • @MegaNoelM

    As the other guy said, it was 'The Day John Lennon Died' but it was originally aired on ITV 1

  • georgous man

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more