knockin on heavens door.vocal harmony

[clown192]

cool version. I just did one using my TC helicon Gxt have a look and tell me what you think.

[mumd2003]

sounds good but synthetic somehow.maybe im prjudiced.send me your melody and if the spirit moves me i could re mix and do harmony if it works.love your set up .you iterested in mixing ?

[TeamFortressNoobspy]

ummm how did make the harmonies (trying not to state the obvious) with a voice synth or singing along with the track and if so wht key where you the lower or higher key / harmony

thnx,

Mr. TF2

[mumd2003]

PS .REQUIRES A MIXER WITH SOFTWARE. i USE AUDACITY FREEWARE. sEE MY CHANNEL BLURB RE WHAT I DO.

[mumd2003]

pps.its harmony made by me and not machine.

[jacobdorp]

its a good song

[mumd2003]

thanks

[Hustlermetalftw]

I think you should have varied more with the harmonized vocals. It was cool out the first verse, but then it just got boring. I think it'll be better if you also sing some parts unharmonized.

[mumd2003]

agree.thanks.all harmony is boring.thanks.

[Hustlermetalftw]

Cheers man! It was never my intention to drag your video down or anything. I really enjoyed listening to it :)

Keep on rockin!

[mumd2003]

no problem w.was helpful reminder.:-)

[1godfather01]

Sounds like Tenacious D :D:D:D, amazing job!!!!!

[mumd2003]

thanks so much.

send link

[music7169]

Good guitar, very good harmonies. Tempo was quick but harmonies were there. Different style but I thought it was good.

[mumd2003]

So kind of you. Yeah I agree in general. Actually this seemed terribly slow to me. I was trying not to go too fast. Also I do the guitar by ear and the chords are often too simple. I just get it good enough to try and do the song. I love vocals and harmony. Used to be college acapella first tenor.

We must share my musical time warp.

Originals lacking. Hard enough to find time for this . This is my relaxation/hobby. Food for thought .Thanks again.

[toxicair]

I really like your guitar part but I feel that the vocals were a bit too fast for this song

[larkofthemeadow]

all you need is a key of f on the harp. Good, very good singin'. thanks.

[Ange8]

Hi there !

That's a great cover :)

what is the last verse you sing ? Can't find it on the web :/

[mumd2003]

thanks. see my channel text re specifics of chordie on web.Has lots of stuff. So I added the words and the url here for you and all.Thank for your interest. :-)

[nightswimmings]

what intervals do you use ????

thirds and occasionaly fourths??

[mumd2003]

thanks for your interest.not really sure. I assumed it is thirds.I donot have any music theory but a good ear for harmony. If you play a few notes on the piano maybe you can tell.

[nightswimmings]

yeh its thirds.The good effect seemin like simon & garf responds more to the fact of being arranged in a particular sung line than alterations on diatonic thirds.So congratulations because the line you choose to sing the end of the second part of each verse its a perfect basis to create a perfect earmassage harmonization,just like it happens in "I wasn't born to follow" by Byrds,in which each verse end makes a great harmonic high point.I'm pretty sure Paul simon had did composed it the exact way

[mumd2003]

My harmonies are boring and I often do for whole song two or three sometimes 4 part.I dont have time to sing w group.My earmassage,(great word. It is exactly that). :-)

You have inspired me to try and pay more attenion as I guess theory dictates. Frankly some of it is crap but Im just relaxing this way. I may delete some of the bad tunes. I ll send you "oh susanna" separately. Thanks ever so much..ps send link to best version byrds song .Rsvp re harmony any time if you have interest.

[nightswimmings]

I don't know if you received my message :)

[nightswimmings]

/watch?v=IBv1mBkUCZw for the byrds song

Very nice arrangment again for the James Taylor song! You must be a kind of folk-chill inventor!!

[mumd2003]

JUST A desire to do harmony at the midbrain level. I dont have to think about it and out it comes.thanks.

[strimmer73]

This is good, very good. Reminds me of Simon & Garfunkel. Nice work.

[mumd2003]

thank you so much. Did not catch your comment earlier. The harmony is a bit overdone but I'm just fooling around with multiline harmony throughout the songs here. Just good therapy to relax. Thanks again.

[ShagggDiesel]

Sounds good. Work on mic placement for the acoustic guitar, and timing on the vocals.

[mumd2003]

thanks.Dont know if you are into recording etc. Appreciate feedback. I do this on the cracks of time of which there is litle.Definitely want to learn protools etc.mic etc.Your comment inspires me to do so.will message you.

[kleinmarci]

brilliant very nice voice. you are the singer from this song i want to see your face ;)

[mumd2003]

thanks

[Sortilegio1000]

!!!!!Il y a de l'harmony entre les voix et la musique, c'est pas facil de faire le decalage de voix, c'est de travaille, alors bon continuation et bon courage, vous chantez tres bien!!!!!

[mumd2003]

much appreciated.

[mumd2003]

i do not have a head. I sing from y neck. :-)

only kidding. Anonymity is better.Its just about the music not me. thanks.

[windoor7]

Good job. I like your softly voice. Your song always make me happy and I feel warm. Thank you.

[mumd2003]

thanks much.