Added: 4 years ago
From: JackMcConnell
Views: 74,859
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (213)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I always liked melissa R but I always felt like they didn't pick her because of her resemblance to nicole. Asia was always my least favorite I never found her entertaining

  • don`t hate asia

    she has a good voice

    I like her,but no much

  • OMGF

    Chelsea`s voice is wayy better than asia or melissa

    I love her voice

    It`s unique & nice

  • I love Chelsea !!

  • if Jaime was in this group it would be the people i thought could actually win :)

  • 1;47 chelsea flopped

  • i love Chelsea's voice it's awesome! :D

  • i miss this show !

  • Wow Chelsea has a really amazing voice! RESPECT! [:

  • true but she really couldn't dance:

    1:29

    also, I like Asia's voice/flare a lot better for some reason...

  • melissa looks to much like a young nicole asia used her daughter to win

  • i agree, i liked asia, i wanted her to win from the beginning.

    she iz like super mixed, black, filipino, and puerto rican i think

  • yall say that cuz shes black

  • Chelsea has the best voice, i really dont like asia at all, and Melissa is just awesome. I wish chelsea would have won, but i would have been happy with melissa, too. asia isn't good.

    but the reason she won was cuz robin and the judges were scared that chelsea or melissa would have upstaged nicole in the pussycat dolls, so they picked asia cuz she wasn't as good. asia found out and quit 2 days later, so this whole competition was a waste!!

  • how do u noe all this? o-o

  • lol i saw it on MM a while ago

  • am i the only one that noticed that chelsea's voice kinda gives out at 1:46

  • yea she forgot to breathe before the phrase ha

  • Chelsea wud totally own Nicole .. lol .

  • asia shouldn't have won, she used the competition as a way to become a single artist. i think chelsea would fit in more with PCD but melissa had a strong enough voice even though chelsea had a good voice it wouldnt sound right in the group.also she holds back when she dances, PCD is all about popping and shit when they dance and she would have had to step it up big time to even compare to nichole. :D <3 melissa and chelsea <3 i hate you asia. :D

  • yeah ur great..Chelsea was the best..but melissa r had to own it..b'cuz if chelsea won she is too strong and good as a backing vocal..so she should've been instead of Nichole..u know she is awesoume (better then melissa r) but melisa r was good as a backing vocal like tht but chelsea was POWERFUL!

    btw about asia...(( HATE YA BIACH ))

  • i agree hate that slut

  • Why'd that girl sing christina's part? Her voice is so... weak.

  • mm the third one??

  • Comment removed

  • melissa shud hav won

  • Asia totally didnt deserve it! I think Melissa should have gotten it. Chelsea was too good for the PCD anyway. She would own them.

  • Meillssia should of won shez so GOOOD!!

  • Nobody can do Christina's part better than Christina herself ^^

    But they tried their best lol

  • asia is so ugli i mean fix ur teeth bitch

  • omg of course it was fixed for asia to win. look at her outfit, it stands out the most with the two pink bows and she got the fast song while everyone else got a slow one. shes irratating tho. i think mellissa R shoulda won and Chelsea should go solo cuz her voice is beautiful !!!

  • they wanted asia to win from the start. that's why they gave only her a fast song for her solo in the finale, giving chelsea and melissa slow songs.

  • you all are freakin retarded they choose the songs that they want to sing from a list so stop hatin!!!!

  • duuude this was soo rigged

    why on earth would chelsea or melissa r sing slow songs then? if they were trying out for american idol sure. but for the freaking pussycat dolls? get real.

  • Fck man they

    Should Of been Girlicious !!!

    =)...

  • damm.

    i wanted chelsea or melissa to win but they didnt..i wonder wat melissa's parent would say about dis

  • i think TSFTND is just like girlicous. chelsea and jenna both have dancing trouble, and natalie is alot like asia!

  • asia sucks...

    Chelsea and Mel R were my favs !

  • asia always steals the spotlight.....

  • Omgg ! i Loved Chelse she was my fav!!!

  • wow am i one of the few people who actually like asia?

  • nah, i like her, too. but still don't think she was worthy of pcd.

  • i love her too she deserved to win

  • she does not derseve it

  • yes the fuck she did she get dumb bitch

  • one of the girls look like jenna from the girlicious thing i think

  • 1.20 to 1.40 Was My FAVE Part, Chelse Rocked This Peformance!

  • Melissa didn't do too good vocally during that performance...

  • i agree.. this is melissa r's weakest performance..

    its just bcuz her parts aint that strong too..

    if she had asia's part shw wuld hav shined

  • Not gonna lie though

    Chelsea couldn't really dance but she has a terrific voice.

    Melisa R had the voice and the dancing right.

    Asia has a voice and she can also dance however you can't really blame her for pursing a solo career. There isn't any REAL proof that she went straight to it. Not even CW could explain it. There was probably decisions to be made (she had a baby afterall) and who would turn down PCD anyways?

    I'm not trying to back her up or anything, but Melissa R should have won.

  • yea but dancing is easier to learn than singing.

  • i'm actually glad that Mellisa r didnt' win. It would have been a waste of her talents to be a backup singer for nicole. She's way better than that. The only person that sings is like nicole in PCD. everyone else is back up. But Asia looks weird. thought i'd add that in

  • OH my god, what you have said about Mellisa R I totally agree with you.

  • @DONGBANGSHINKI3 ASIAN DO NOT LOOK WEIRD! ND I AGREE WIT EVRYTHIN ELSE BUT NOT THAT

  • this is so unfair, did you so Asia singing "I don't need a man"???? she open that mouth like a slu* little bitc*... she even looks like a Who*e... Melissa R, sould have been thw winner, and Asia now turns down saying that she wants to sing on solo, lol, she doesn't have enough to be a singer, but she can be a prostitut* :D:D:D:D

  • the only reason melissa r never made it is cause she looked to much like nicole sherzinger. i HATED asia, MELISSA R ROCKS ! <3

  • Common obviously either Chelsea or Melissa R were the best year -- Chelsea should have won, Asia shouldn't have even made it this far, she should have been eliminated like 2nd or 3rd episode

  • i´m with you, i really like chelsea

  • yea but we need more den hear voice for PCD its ok tho who is famous Chel or Aisa? The answer is Chel b/c she is a member of robin's girl group Paradiso Girls

  • Are you kidding me? I'm glad they didn't win. Don't get me wrong, I love them to death. But Asia was perfect for the group. She looked different from everyone in the PCD, she was the best dancer, and she was good with the public. That's all they really needed anyways, another background singer. They didn't care if she wasn't the best singer, she wouldn't get any solo parts anyways. Chelsea and Melissa R would have wasted their talents in the group. Now, maybe they have a chance at something beta

  • Yeah that's true. Chelsea was just too good for the group.

  • These girls would be the bomb if they made a group together. Chelsea looked way prettier here than she did in the fever-big spender performance, though her arms look kinda chubby. Melissa looked just beautiful. And Asia sang really good.

  • This is 1 of the best performance in the show.They sound good,they look good (for Asia than not really),they look like a group,their moves were good.

  • love CHELSEA!is the best!

  • i agree

  • if it was girlicious theyd win ARRGH>:(I loved melissa R even CHELSEA BUT HATE ASIA ..ALOT:)

  • i love this vid. their all great preformers. and amazing!

  • aww i love them together they are all such strong singers !!

  • melissa looks too much like nicole of the pcd! i think thas y she didnt make it xD

    chelsea was toooo good a singer, so of course they can't have her makin nicole look bad

    asia one cuz she got "the look" and can dance

  • oopsies i meant [won] xD

  • Nicole wasn't even going to be in PCD, why do you think it's called "The Search For the Next Doll"

  • dats true

  • These girls were much more talented than the new season

  • too bad these people can't be in the new series they would have made girlicious for sure. But girlicious isn't that bad.

  • chelsey was so much better dan all of em, but i bet she juz didnt get chose cuz, honestly, she sings better dan nicole n dey didnt want a new member on PCD who wuld poutsing deir lead singer

  • I FUCKEN HATE MELISSA R SHE CAN GO FUCK HER MOM!!! Asia kicks all there asses where there everyone hates her they are fuckin jelous so they can go fuck there mom BITCHES!

  • she got kicked outtt of it ? :| ?

  • asia is a fuc*king bitch.....shes a good singer.....yeah....but her attitude is not s0 great dats why she got kicked out from being a pussycatdolls bec. her relationship with the others wasn't goin well.....its her fault for beinf so0o0o0 btichy....thinking that shed the best among the rest...s0o0o0ry asia......"UR NOT"

  • they chose asia because they didn't need an amazing singer. Just someone who could sing backup. duh. She is good. And she was a great dancer! YAY ASIA!

  • LOL

    that guy in the blue sweater ,Hat and Glasses

    Reminds me of Gay guy on Mean Girls

    when Se was Sitting in on that Meeting

    for the All Junior Girls Intervention thing lol

  • HAHAHAHAH LMFAOOOOOOOO DAMIEN YEAH I SO AGREE

    xx

  • this probably made robin think of making a girl group called girlicious

    girlicious has three girls (WHICH IS EXACTLY HERE)

  • hey bluehottiee do you like the new girls tell me what you think under this video.

  • the new girls? the girlicious? OH. i think they're good. i like carrie. she's pretty! haha! natalie's good but she is bitchy. UGH. too much. she's just starting out! i like jamie, too and nichole! there's so many!! we dint get to watch that here in the phils. coz we don't have that yet. it sucks! but i'm happy there's youtube to keep me updated. love love it! :D

  • do you like chrystina. you should see the chrystina sayers montage.

  • Honsetly I don't see all the hype around Chrystina she isn't that pretty and her voice is average. I thought Chrystina getting cast over Charyle was the dumbest decison Robin made, but after seeing the videos I saw that she doesn't want to sell music she wants to sell "SEX" and Chrsytina does have a bigger T&A over Charyle. But I wish Girlicious and Charyle luck in the future.

  • oh whatever. everyone hating on chrystina can just fall back

  • I have an opinion am not hating on anybody, please believe. I just feel she doesn't add anything to this group other then grown men who wanna bang her because of her body.

  • so what. charlye didn't even blend in with the group.

  • how she didn't blend with the group with looks, or her singing ability? Please don't say she didn't get along with the girls she got along with Tiffane and Nichole, she didn't wanna be fake and be friends with the lebso lovers....

    If you wanna make(Robin) a singing girl group 2gether, you put the best voices, NOT the girls with pretty faces because looks fade!!!!!!

  • are you serious. don't give me that. We all know that if charlye was in the group that the group would just take a nose dive into the least sold album

  • why, would u think that. don't u think natalie and chyrstina will do that on their own..

  • oh please charlye is just a pretty face. I mean she can sing and dance but you have to think what is best for the group.

  • ok if she can sing and dance, that's what it takes to be in the group. It just blow my mind that looks are above real talent.

  • oh my gosh like i said before you have to think what is best for the group. what don't you get.

  • ok... I get it now what best for the group is to cast two talented whore!!! THANKS for breaking it down =D

    Let this be the last comment between us.

  • they are are not whores. they are just sexy

  • girlicious is sooooooooo better agree anyone?

  • i agree but some of the girls on this show should have been on the last season.

  • chelsea definitely has the strongest vocals.

  • ok can somebody tell me how this show works??????

    like in a message????

    this was the last episode, and if u noticed how when they announced asia the winner, how weird it was that she already new the dance moves to dont cha

    ????

    all in the same night as the performance of lady marmalade???

    i think this show was rigged and from the start they chose asia:/

    all well

    ill enjoy seein chealsea in paradiso girls:]

  • i hate asia that is all im going to say

  • i hate asia that is all im going to say

  • Asia did the best in this performance,... I dont care what anyone says. She started the song off good, doing all good noteS..... Actually they all did good, this could have been a group right here.

  • Melissa's fake boobies really stand out 8D

  • Chelsea is better of as a solo performer, wich i tthink she's doing right?

  • Asia is so over the top

  • yankeees gatos

  • Esa Asia no me cae...como decia una de sus compañeras "baila como travesti"....aparte q cuando abre la boca parece un mandril!! me cae chinche!!

  • Asia is better than those two

  • asia is just okay. wonder why she won, esp when her competition is chelsea and mellissa ): both of them ae so much better than her!

  • chelsea should have won this copettition she has the best voice

  • The pussycat dolls don't have to have such an amazing voice like chelsea, but they NEED to know how to dance since only ONE of the pussycat dolls sing, so they picked asia cause she has a tolerable voice and amazing dancing ;)

  • mellisa R. is a better dancer, you retard. she dances impeccably at everything! she even has a better voice than asia. oh god, asia sucks when she sings, and looks like she can't reach the pitch. hahaha. the reason why they dint choose melissa R. is because because she is 100000 better than the pussycat lead singer, nicole. younger too, with high high potential.

  • There was no call for this type of language, you only use this words cause you're on the web...

    Melissa wasan't picked because she doesn't bring anything new to the group, Asia has personality, and learn some manners, but i suppose you only speak like that cause you're a baby ;)

  • yep...n asia sure did bring sumthin new 2 da group.....lyk leavin 2 get a solo career(whch she faild 2) n poor her got kickd outta p.c.d

  • i know right melissa is better than nicole and she sings better than her too. she should have one not asia. asia did not even stay with the group.

  • yeah i know. asia's ugly attitude and worse temper made the pcd dint like her. so that's the reason why she left. it's a good thing though coz i don't think she will succeed like that! ugh. she has very little fans, i have to say. no, none. or maybe there are, you know.. those black people tryna` support her all along even if they don't like her at all but bcoz she's black. hahaha. no offense puh-lease! lol :p melissa's way too good to be a back up dancer. she's better solo! way to go!

  • i know melissa would do way better solo. i know i hate ron fair but he did not even like asia but the other judges probably outvoted him

  • haha. exactly! ron fair dint like asia at all, coz everytime i watch his face, his was unsure of asia and he really dint liked asia's vocals. mm. yeah, lil' kim liked her a lot but she liked melissa r too. but robin?! migod!! she's too pro-asia! she compliments her all the time. like sheezzzz! UGH. anyways, what's up with asia now?

  • who knows. lol! maybe she dissapeared

  • SERIOUSLY? she left the pcd?

  • yer i guess so but still chelsea deserved to win

  • melissa!!!! Chelsea!!!! asia is ok...

  • melissa rocked with the dancing!and chelsea's voice was the best voice in the whole compotition!!

  • not fair, asia got all the big notes :|

    i wish chelsea got them, she would of done amazinggg!!!!!!!!

  • Chelsea has the best voice, no contest. Asia is just too much, too weird and her voice has a forced kind of thing going on.

  • asia is not on the PCD because she didn't sign the contract . You know why? its because all the haters made her feel so bad that she did not want to be in it anymore .

  • so who signed?

  • i love chelsea!!

  • i wanted chelsea to win sooo bad i mean she had the best voice out of all of them and i think she caught onto dancing pretty qick :)and whatever happend to asia?

  • i wanted chelsea to win sooo bad i mean she had the best voice out of all of them and i think she caught onto dancing pretty qick :)and whatever happend to asia?

  • Asia sounds kinda strained.

  • Hands down the best performance of the entire show...

    These girls were really the top 3 among everyone.

  • god i have asia

  • i wonder weather things are working out with Asia cuz I haven't heard much about PCD sionce she joined i mean shé's not on the inspirational vids they send the Girlious people I thought Milissa R should have won she rocked she also reminds me of Vanessa HGudgen before she got all Hollywood-ified

  • chelasy es lA MEJOR VOS MWJOR ROSTRO MEJOR CUERPO ERA LA GANdora le rovaron el concuerso asia es horrible y tenia grabes problemas de vozzzzzzzzzz

  • i dont speak spanish but i think i understood that and u are so right!!

  • chelsea <33

    i think that the pink panther performance was better than this but this was great too. <333 chelsea! she's not that bad at dancing. just a little practise that's all.

  • OMG chelseas VOICE is so good! she should have one no offense asia soinds like a lamb lol

  • okay i dont think asia was better than the others and i dont think they were better than her. but she has a good voice and a good dancer. and i think one of the reasons she won is becuz she is unique and would bring something different to the group. im not being racist but shes black and doesnt look like alot of other girls.melissa kind of resembles nicole and chelsea isnt very unique looking. shes pretty but she looks like that Jenna girl on Girlicious, so shes not different. anyone agree???

  • i love how we all come on here and dog on asia..my god just shut up. she won its over with. melissa and chelsea r guna be okay.christ. i actually really liked asia in this performance. chelsea is always really good, i liked her feeling good performance.

  • is it just me or does asia looked constipated when she sings lol.

  • Tallest girl was Definitely the best

  • Tallest girl was Definitely the best

  • you mean chelsea?

  • Chelsea was actually quite good at dancing on this video. Asia was so annoying.

  • I love Chelsea yea

  • loooooove melissa r.

  • melissa r. is the best out of all of them...but chealsey is the best singer!!!

  • Asia has the most irritating fingers!!

  • Mellisa R dance and voice r so great (l) just luv her

    Asia is like... "I want to be the best" but she just exagerate.

    CHelsea (L) (L) Her voice was the best...

  • I think both Chelsea and Melissa were much better than Asia. Any of these two should have won, plus Asia was "boosted out" of the group (even is they say she decided to leave them to pursue a solo career, we all know they boosted her out) so I guess Asia was a real msitake!

  • M3LLiSSA;z VOiC3 iiS SO STRONG!!ii THiiNK SH3 SHOULD OF WON!

  • hi i'm from germany

    i think melissa must won the contest !!

    she is so beautiful & a prize for the pcd !

    asia is ugly & her big mouth too

    she has won the contest because she sang all the high notes & she is the next bitch for the pussy cat dolls ...

  • Melissa R deberia haber ganado -.-"

    Asia baila como un travesti exagera muxo .

    Chelsea tiene una voz hermosa xD!!

  • y ademas Asia canta horrible!

  • MELISSA R SOULDVE WON!

  • in love with chelsea (L)

    chelsea should have won

  • Asia exaggerates her voice too much.

  • Asia shouldn't have won. Melissa R SHOULD have won.

  • AGREED!

  • melissa R or chelsea should have won their voices sound much better than asias,her voice sounds like If she were singing in the middle of an earthquake and I hate the way she's always moving her hands and the gestures she makes with her face

  • i hate asia, she is so.. weird ahahaha.. i hate her, i'm totally in love with melissa r. ahahahaah :$

  • jamie suckes at singing. i mean maybe she can sing but her voice sucks. asia's and chelsea's are way better im glad one of then won.

  • i still think melissa r did great..i hate asia's trembling voice..melissa r should have won..

  • they should become their own band together.

  • I love all 3 of themm <3

  • chelsea or melissa r should have won!

  • That Stuiped Asia!!!!!!!!!

  • i kno she trembles her voice and does tht stupid thing with tha microphone

    anywayz pussycat dollz kicked her out

  • Whhy...? Dont they need another person..?

  • they decided not to keep asia cause she was having personal problems so asia left they never kicked her out there i going to be a new season and robin is looking for a new pussycat doll or another girl band

  • Yeah i heard about that.... To bad i liked the PCD :D

  • um thats not what happend. asia wanted to go solo. shes still signed to geffen recirds ron fairs label still shes just going solo and shes debuting this year. and the new season of the pussycat dolls show is for a new group called "girllicious".