Omg... So depressing... I wish you would've found someone for Will besides the illustration on the cover of The Subtle Knife, but it's a cute vid... I'm a WARRIORS dork and a HDM junkie too... :0)
@danivideos09 There is also another book called Once upon a time in the north. It is about Lee Scoresby and Iorek Byrneson. It is on the same theme but has nothing to do with lyra.
@mariaangel2003 Personally, I think it had more to do with money issues than with sticking to the book. I might just be biased in all things HDM, but I didn't think they did such a bad job, except of course for the ending. :)
@AtaizMedia "Better" being their opinion, or yours? I always think the book is better than the movie, but what I was saying was that I thought the movie was okay. And agreed about the America thing, that's what I meant by 'money issues' ;)
Frankly, I'm sorry, but the truth - not opinion, but quantifiable truth - is that the movie was subpar. The book had intense and meaningful religious and philosophical text and symbols. The movie was beautiful visually, yes, but lacked the content, the "gut" of the book that made it what it is. The movie is an echo of that personality, with just enough to confuse non-readers, but not enough to substantiate reader love.
@tinyartist18 Of course I read the book!! I never watch a movie adaption without reading the book first, and you're right, the book is much better than the movie. But I don't think it sucked altogether; the cast at least was great. They did cut out some important stuff, but I've definitely seen worse.
@tinyartist18 To repeat: I don't think it's bad. I think it's good. You think it's bad and that's fine with me but don't expect me to change my opinion.
With the lack of clips for Will taken into account, this song really works out VERY well for these two (Particularly the "We were both young" line); nice job
the problem is that when I think about this OR/AND Harry Potter I get headaches coz these r th only books I ever shed tears (except during summer because of hayfever)
I really want the subtle knife to be made into a film!!
Will is sort of a co-hero that comes in the next book...he's from our world, not Lyra's, and that's why he has no dæmon. You'd have to read the books to find out more about him. :) And it's kind of irrelevant, lol, but I don't think she ever liked Roger that way. She's too much for him. ;)
THUMBS UP IF U THINK WILL SHUD BE PLAYED BY LOGAN LERMAN!
ClarasChannel 1 month ago
Best song ever even tho its making be insanly sad, when i hear it.
c00kie500 1 month ago in playlist Favorite videos
is it supposed to shiver like that?
birchdryadgirl 2 months ago
Dakota Blue...
depzi 7 months ago
Omg... So depressing... I wish you would've found someone for Will besides the illustration on the cover of The Subtle Knife, but it's a cute vid... I'm a WARRIORS dork and a HDM junkie too... :0)
WimpyTourist 8 months ago
@danivideos09 There is also another book called Once upon a time in the north. It is about Lee Scoresby and Iorek Byrneson. It is on the same theme but has nothing to do with lyra.
SimgirlAO 8 months ago
I wish the movie had stuck to the book exactly then maybe there would be a second one
mariaangel2003 11 months ago
@mariaangel2003 Personally, I think it had more to do with money issues than with sticking to the book. I might just be biased in all things HDM, but I didn't think they did such a bad job, except of course for the ending. :)
leafpool77 10 months ago
@leafpool77 Nah, they edited the storyline to make it better :S and the second wasn't produced as it didnt do too well in America
AtaizMedia 10 months ago
@AtaizMedia "Better" being their opinion, or yours? I always think the book is better than the movie, but what I was saying was that I thought the movie was okay. And agreed about the America thing, that's what I meant by 'money issues' ;)
leafpool77 10 months ago
@leafpool77 No, the movie just sucked, really.
tinyartist18 4 months ago
@tinyartist18 Fine, that's your opinion. I think they did a good job, and we'll just have to agree to disagree.
leafpool77 4 months ago
@leafpool77 Did you read the book?
Frankly, I'm sorry, but the truth - not opinion, but quantifiable truth - is that the movie was subpar. The book had intense and meaningful religious and philosophical text and symbols. The movie was beautiful visually, yes, but lacked the content, the "gut" of the book that made it what it is. The movie is an echo of that personality, with just enough to confuse non-readers, but not enough to substantiate reader love.
That's why there isn't a second one.
tinyartist18 4 months ago
@tinyartist18 Of course I read the book!! I never watch a movie adaption without reading the book first, and you're right, the book is much better than the movie. But I don't think it sucked altogether; the cast at least was great. They did cut out some important stuff, but I've definitely seen worse.
leafpool77 4 months ago
@leafpool77 Having seen worse does not make something that is bad any better.
tinyartist18 4 months ago
@tinyartist18 To repeat: I don't think it's bad. I think it's good. You think it's bad and that's fine with me but don't expect me to change my opinion.
leafpool77 4 months ago
@leafpool77 I admire your tenacity.
tinyartist18 4 months ago
Are you sure he is going to relese a 4th book of dust?
SpankmaNSwe 11 months ago
...
AriHale 1 year ago
@AriHale ?
leafpool77 1 year ago
@leafpool77 ...Nothing.
AriHale 1 year ago
Lyra and Will live forever!
myfriendsrule1 1 year ago
I was crying at the end of the Amber Spyglass
myfriendsrule1 1 year ago
OMG OMG OMG OMG I LOVE IT!
i'm so bummed they haven't made another one of the books yet.
vanillatwilight23 1 year ago 2
Fantastic job! This is so amazingly well done!
sailormoonfan1421 1 year ago
I mean His Dark Materials book 4 xD like u said
linedave1 1 year ago
Yeah a continuation of The Amber Spyglass
linedave1 1 year ago
Phillip Pullman should make a 4th book
linedave1 1 year ago 2
@linedave1 He is, sort of, if you count the Book of Dust. ;)
leafpool77 1 year ago
@linedave1 that is so wat i thought!
sailormoonfan1421 1 year ago
@sailormoonfan1421 do you know when he is going to release it
linedave1 1 year ago
MY FAVORITE SONG EVER!!,, MY FAVORITE BOOKS EVER!!,, & MY FAVORITE COUPLE EVER!!!! <3<3<3<3 good job! :D
will & lyra 4ever<3
pulgaenana 1 year ago 2
@pulgaenana Oh, thanks so much! :) That's so nice to hear! (I'm the same lol)
leafpool77 1 year ago
@pulgaenana i am same like you and leafpool77!
I completly agreed with you!
AjaHemster 1 year ago
@AjaHemster agree*
AjaHemster 4 months ago
They need to remake the Golden compass with the same cast and keep to the damn book! lol
Babs44sun 1 year ago
His Dark Materials Is The Best Story EVER!!!
The amber spyglas is the only book where i ever cried at!
I LOVE IT!
Long Live Phillip Pullman!
AjaHemster 1 year ago 6
@AjaHemster Agreed! :)
leafpool77 1 year ago
the single thing that upset me was there was no will role
AliceHaleCullen 1 year ago
With the lack of clips for Will taken into account, this song really works out VERY well for these two (Particularly the "We were both young" line); nice job
MarcusSLazarus 1 year ago
@TheKittyMistress No offense, but you were the one that clicked on it. I can't put a spoiler warning in the title--and the title is what says it all.
leafpool77 1 year ago
i haven't got words to say how gorgeous it is! :*:*:*
ufcia20 1 year ago 2
Dakota Blue Richards is my Renesmee Cullen. She's perfect even though Breaking Dawn only ends when Renesmee looks 6 she's Nessie to me.
MindyHackler 1 year ago
NICE SONG
martyndavey 1 year ago
aww so sweet
I absolutly LUV His Dark Materials!
the problem is that when I think about this OR/AND Harry Potter I get headaches coz these r th only books I ever shed tears (except during summer because of hayfever)
I really want the subtle knife to be made into a film!!
firststepinlife 1 year ago 2
luv the vid!!!!!^_^
Fradsaja 1 year ago
who is will is he that kid in the next book wit no daemon??/ i thou lyra like rodger?
brewsterlucy114 2 years ago 2
Will is sort of a co-hero that comes in the next book...he's from our world, not Lyra's, and that's why he has no dæmon. You'd have to read the books to find out more about him. :) And it's kind of irrelevant, lol, but I don't think she ever liked Roger that way. She's too much for him. ;)
leafpool77 2 years ago 2
Wow! love it! <3
XxAngelEliraxX 2 years ago
I love this! Too bad they're not making the other movies...At least that's what I heard.
Amari412 2 years ago
So saddddd, I loved that book!
Glasuri5 2 years ago
it was so lovely espasely pages 468 - 552 on the new paper backs of the amber spyglass and 266 new paper backs of the subtle knife
lyraandwillforever 2 years ago
i just finished the three books it was soo sad when they seperated i almost cryed
TheSimsas999 2 years ago
i cryed when i finished the third book.
psoapsoa 2 years ago 3
Me too. :'(
leafpool77 2 years ago
sad isn't it?
psoapsoa 2 years ago
SO sad!! The Amber Spyglass is the only book I've ever cried at!
(By the way, isn't Midsummer's Day coming up soon?)
leafpool77 2 years ago
Sorry, but I'm not quite sure about what Midsummer's Day comes to be...
psoapsoa 2 years ago
I love it!! Great job!
MissLyraBelacqua 2 years ago 3
Thanks! :D
leafpool77 2 years ago
Oh my gosh this is amazing I love it!!!!
GoldenCompassLuver 2 years ago 6
Thank you! :D I'm glad that you like it so much! :D
leafpool77 2 years ago
This video is splendid and georgeus!!!
xDakotaBlueRichardsx 2 years ago 11
Thanks so much! :D Glad you liked it!
leafpool77 2 years ago
excellent
i love this song
and i totally suits Will and Lyra
nice work
partypandas00 2 years ago 15
Thanks! :D I love this song too, lol...I really wanted to do this vid for a long time. :P So I'm glad you like it! Thanks again! ;)
leafpool77 2 years ago