@mariahmadrileno, I knew I wasn't crazy. I thought I noticed her take a breath at 0:35 when there wasn't one on the song...I think it was pre-recorded live and she just lip-synched here.
@mcdamian17 Yes it was dubbed but she also mimed some parts. Like 1:58 "Did you really care" that was mimed on the night. There are a few examples toward the end.
@mariahmadrileno No. Dubbed means that she re-recorded some vocals in studio. 1:58 wasn't mimed, she sang live and then it was dubbed. She performed 3 songs: Hero/Never too far medley, I'll be there and Reflections, and all the performances were live, but HEAVILY DUBBED in studio, they changed many notes. I know it was live cause this performance is in a lower key than the original.
@mcdamian17 Lol, I know what "dubbed means". The whole performance was dubbed, as well as NTF and I'll be there. She also mimed some notes on the night such as 1:58. She did the same thing on her recent Christmas concert. She very rarely (if ever) performs a whole song completely live, even when it's later dubbed. We'll have to agree to disagree on this, I'm afraid.
By the way: She still has 5 octaves. There aren't a lot singers who have 5 octaves, not even Leona Lewis or christina, not even celine or whitney. So what's the problem. If Elivis were alive, he also would sound different. It's called evoulution. We all get to comfortable with a singer's sound and when it changes we become dissapointed. Mariah haters are morons, soryy but that evolution I was talking doesn't apply to the haters.
BTW: She hit an G6 and briefly A6 in this performance.
Well probably but then again im not a bi racial 39 year old woman. Dont get me wrong Im a huge fan of MC but I just dont like this choice of hair solor.
Lol ok just pulling your string yanno! He-She it is...yea to be honest I know what you mean about the hair - I have a theory. It looks like she's got a bit of sunburn with the wack hair. Perhaps she just got back from another Carribean holiday in the sun. Anyways you can't deny her vocals here - definately live and a strong voice.
brilliant song...not just a foster child, but it reflects every lil' bit of our lives and sometimes goodbye could just make our hearts be tore into a thousand pieces...
do you perfectly know what you said?you should first ask your mom to teach you good values before you criticize others...look at yourself first and reflect from what you are lacking of...
i love this song so much..i really had a goose bumps when hearing this the first time..no question that she rules the music industry...i love u so much...
no one can ever deny that mariah is the most popular singer around the world and she has proven that she can sing live and perform very well and not only that she also had a good heart to those who love her and for me no one can ever take her place from where she is now, truly the singer and the diva.
Muito linda essa musica...ainda tem gente que diz que o cd Glitter foi um fracasso..e um dos cds mais bem trabalhados dela...com musicas belissimas...muito bem compostas...e so nao repercutiu tanto..pois foi abafdo devido a keda das torres gemeas...se nao teria sido um sucesso...so emoçao nessa musik...te amo...
this is my fav. song from the glitter album. i really like how she thought to change the line from "before you gave me life" to "that day you gave me life". I really love how deep this song is, and that's my fav. line from it.
CORRECT.GLITTER NOT ONLY IS OK FINE,not bad at all.few million US dollar cinema intake is much better than Millions Crap Hollywood movies.Mariah acting was fine enough to be in MOVIES.
The glitter album is so underrated...she did such a great job with the ballads, like this one...she writes all this stuff, that says so much about her as an artist. I appreciate whoever put this out on video for us, as I've never seen it performed...
Unfortunately Glitter was not released at a right time. At that time, the rap songs were not really so at the spot. If the rap song from Glitter ablum were released from now on. The feedback must be much much better. Anyway, Mariah is the best singer and song writer.
Of course no one sings Mariah's songs better than her, or actually no one can coz no one will ever be able to reach her high notes, check "Regine-Reflections* it's regine singing a medly and people all say that she's better than mariah, Iam having a quarrel with someone since days now hahaha it's fun
beautiful song & performance.i love the album glitter esp the ballad songs lead the way,never too far & this one.unfortunately the album didn't make it well,but still mariah's the best!!!
i am mariah carey number #1 fan of all my sister said i listen to her and sang her songs when i was 3 years old and would like to join your group but how old do you have to be cause i am really 10 and my sister is 18. she let me have her channel
Oops -3
littlejissy 3 months ago
Heartfelt!!! Gave me goose bumps!!! I love Mariah Carey -3
littlejissy 3 months ago
just one word WWOOOWWW !!
melilla32 7 months ago
I love this performance. Unfortunately it's part dubbed part mimed :( I'd love to hear the un-dubbed performance.
mariahmadrileno 8 months ago
@mariahmadrileno, I knew I wasn't crazy. I thought I noticed her take a breath at 0:35 when there wasn't one on the song...I think it was pre-recorded live and she just lip-synched here.
JayCroix 7 months ago
@mariahmadrileno this performance was live and then they dubbed it, but it wasn't lipped at all
mcdamian17 6 months ago
@mcdamian17 Yes it was dubbed but she also mimed some parts. Like 1:58 "Did you really care" that was mimed on the night. There are a few examples toward the end.
mariahmadrileno 6 months ago
@mariahmadrileno No. Dubbed means that she re-recorded some vocals in studio. 1:58 wasn't mimed, she sang live and then it was dubbed. She performed 3 songs: Hero/Never too far medley, I'll be there and Reflections, and all the performances were live, but HEAVILY DUBBED in studio, they changed many notes. I know it was live cause this performance is in a lower key than the original.
mcdamian17 6 months ago
@mcdamian17 Lol, I know what "dubbed means". The whole performance was dubbed, as well as NTF and I'll be there. She also mimed some notes on the night such as 1:58. She did the same thing on her recent Christmas concert. She very rarely (if ever) performs a whole song completely live, even when it's later dubbed. We'll have to agree to disagree on this, I'm afraid.
mariahmadrileno 6 months ago
So fat, size of the house.
beavertown2006 9 months ago
her voice is really so out of this world. amazing!
sherwin76502 10 months ago
who cares what her hair looks like. thats not what matters. the song is very emotional and heart felt and should be listened to by all.
dasm0092559 11 months ago
You can feel her soul...wow.
tipofmytongue1024 1 year ago
this is actually alive!! can't believe my ears
lixian0072000 1 year ago
do anyone know what year this came out?
jazzylovesmikey1992 1 year ago
@jazzylovesmikey1992 2001 (Glitter Era)
mcdamian17 1 year ago
@jazzylovesmikey1992 sorry, it was in 2002
mcdamian17 1 year ago
@mcdamian17 ok. thanks :-)
jazzylovesmikey1992 1 year ago
one of my favorite live performance of mariah carey...
102666 1 year ago
Wow!
JCGandMe 1 year ago
wow!!!!
ilovebadminton0916 1 year ago
She kind of looks bloated here. Love this song, shes such an amazing singer.
kaesheryl 1 year ago
@kaesheryl She had a pretty serious tan going on! :-)
ricobhi 1 year ago
awesome song! her hair looks cute..
cuntylicious 2 years ago
I love her hair ITS AMAAAAAAZING!
I love her voice that goes without saying ?
danihobinsen 2 years ago 3
shes.fatter.here
freakmeout2009 2 years ago
she rarely perform this live...So touched!!! :()
jakemdanduan 2 years ago 2
wow you gy r all wierdos this song is amazing and she looks amazing
ladymeraid 2 years ago
Her hair here is like her hair in Precious.
JCNRBA 2 years ago 3
its great performance!!her outfit is very simple!!
vez428 2 years ago 5
fantastic....Her voice 's great
PuenPenkonth 2 years ago 7
lagu nya bagus banget... suara nya dahsyattt... hebat!!
rrlovesmariah 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
By the way: She still has 5 octaves. There aren't a lot singers who have 5 octaves, not even Leona Lewis or christina, not even celine or whitney. So what's the problem. If Elivis were alive, he also would sound different. It's called evoulution. We all get to comfortable with a singer's sound and when it changes we become dissapointed. Mariah haters are morons, soryy but that evolution I was talking doesn't apply to the haters.
BTW: She hit an G6 and briefly A6 in this performance.
mage13011988 2 years ago
A G6? A6? what are you talking about? There's no such notes in this performance ...
lukituchi 2 years ago
low key....
sss09 2 years ago
Wow this reminds me so much of a situation that has split apart my family...I love you Anirrah Lee DuPree
phatohphat85 3 years ago
She don't need no back-up!
Dimplez816 3 years ago 2
She looks a hot mess with that Platinum Blonde hair lol. I wish she had it dark like it used to be.
enalls 3 years ago
i agree
buzzyshay 3 years ago
Bet she looks better than you
whitireia 2 years ago
Well probably but then again im not a bi racial 39 year old woman. Dont get me wrong Im a huge fan of MC but I just dont like this choice of hair solor.
enalls 2 years ago
Comment removed
whitireia 2 years ago
ok calm down. i dont see a reason to insult and and/or call me white when im not. Im just expressing my opinion.
enalls 2 years ago
Comment removed
whitireia 2 years ago
Say what you wish. Im going to listen to vanshing right now and hopefully this conversation will vanish from my memory lol
(I know its mad wack but so is tri racial she he. Oh and for the record, it HE-SHE not she he.)
enalls 2 years ago 5
Lol ok just pulling your string yanno! He-She it is...yea to be honest I know what you mean about the hair - I have a theory. It looks like she's got a bit of sunburn with the wack hair. Perhaps she just got back from another Carribean holiday in the sun. Anyways you can't deny her vocals here - definately live and a strong voice.
whitireia 2 years ago
wonderful wonderful wonderful
MARKOSYT 3 years ago 3
brilliant song...not just a foster child, but it reflects every lil' bit of our lives and sometimes goodbye could just make our hearts be tore into a thousand pieces...
passionchris123 3 years ago 2
i love this song...it really reflects on what happened in my life
karalinti 3 years ago 4
Best song Best voice.....hail you Mariah
Muzicx44 3 years ago 8
one of her most
emotionally heavy songs...
msiero07 3 years ago 13
I just love this song...
It make's me cry everytime I hear it...
allthatglitters83 3 years ago 7
Reflections of your love have come to wither
I thought I'd done my best to memorize
A picture fades of you and I together
I haven't come to terms with how we said goodbye
Did you really care
Care at all for me
Did you really care
Did you care at all for me
pisidum 3 years ago 4
her hair in this video annoys me. It seems so dated...i can't even remember whether people actually wore that in the early 2000s
crazy2hazy 3 years ago 10
Hahahaha Lol
saywhaatuk 3 years ago
This was during the whole Glitter era... She had it cut, styled and colored very '80s. It bugs me too. LOL But at least she's really singing. LOL
andrewdrew 3 years ago 4
tu est magnifique ta voi me reconforte des q je siut mal je t adore y love you de la pare d alexandra
ludovic69008 3 years ago
after 13 years I had one of my parents back on the line today... I've been playing this song the entire evening...
Steev82 3 years ago 5
one magnificent and unparallel performance of Ms. Carey..
kulith 3 years ago 3
WOW...Incredible...Fantasic...Beautiful...Touched my soul...LOVE U MARIAH!
MiKeNMiMi86 3 years ago 7
Awesome!!!
SCSA81 3 years ago 2
i think that glitte is a cool record...it was the period that was wrong and not the music............i luv mariah
colin858585 3 years ago 3
At 02:47 she lose her breath..but still a great song..
princericco 3 years ago
I like her voice
BoyFromPoland 3 years ago 4
what year was this?
TheWonOne1 3 years ago
this was from glitter which came out in 2001
skinandbone26 3 years ago 2
中国人民喜欢你和你的歌曲
ChinaRoHS 3 years ago 2
中国人民喜欢你和你的歌曲
ChinaRoHS 3 years ago 2
ella es muy guapa..
**takin first semester of Spanish.. lol..
tREdoM02 3 years ago
bien dicho amigo :)
es hermosa
biggang19 3 years ago
she looks a little different.
but, i luv the song and her voice. i wish i had that voice...
kkc0161 3 years ago
i love this its make me cry
Foreverriding290 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
The worst singer ever!!! Malandi, kereng-keng at malibog!
jowaan 3 years ago
do you perfectly know what you said?you should first ask your mom to teach you good values before you criticize others...look at yourself first and reflect from what you are lacking of...
kulith 3 years ago 2
i love this song so much..i really had a goose bumps when hearing this the first time..no question that she rules the music industry...i love u so much...
kulith 4 years ago 2
this song is sad it reminds me of when i was adopted i saw this movie i cryed all through this movie
auvi11 4 years ago 2
she sings w/ emotions..
go mariah!!!
hmb27 4 years ago 2
woah!!! i really love her. kaso matanda n tlga idol ko!
bbgedeon 4 years ago
i love this song very much .. i love you mimi... i like ur voice ... it keeps me inspires ... i wish she could be here in the philippines ...
jersest2008 4 years ago
que manera de manejar la media voz una voz multifacetica muy pocas unica y que bonita es
cinkey8 4 years ago
i L O V E Mariah Carey!!
She is My insperation!
..=] ♥
Kendyyl 4 years ago 2
i love songg ! very nice :D love u mariah ! NICEEE
orangeeu 4 years ago
no one can ever deny that mariah is the most popular singer around the world and she has proven that she can sing live and perform very well and not only that she also had a good heart to those who love her and for me no one can ever take her place from where she is now, truly the singer and the diva.
nilfsolano1979 4 years ago 7
very very very good!
she really can sing!!!
the DIVA!!!
Nuna0 4 years ago 2
i love song ! i lovee u mariah !
orangeeu 4 years ago
i love this song
jaz19 4 years ago 3
Muito linda essa musica...ainda tem gente que diz que o cd Glitter foi um fracasso..e um dos cds mais bem trabalhados dela...com musicas belissimas...muito bem compostas...e so nao repercutiu tanto..pois foi abafdo devido a keda das torres gemeas...se nao teria sido um sucesso...so emoçao nessa musik...te amo...
diego jesus
dicarey 4 years ago
mariah is one of the rarest person who does have this kind of talent!!! she is a legend!! she prove us a lot!!
ghurami 4 years ago
:( demasiadooooooooo :( me pone triste
Silviahouser 4 years ago
AMAZING, just as classic.
VelvetNick 4 years ago 2
she's beautiful here
filss 4 years ago
BRAVO! GR8 PERFORMANCE
mariahc1fan 4 years ago
this is one of ttha tightest songs in tha world glitter is one of my favorite movies!!!
00XsadieX00 4 years ago
me 2! i don't care what the hell critics say! glitter forever:D
MySoulBelongsToMusic 4 years ago
i love this song dont think anyone could sing it but only her....she has a brilliant voice
xxkellymc1986xx 4 years ago
this is awesome!
roxanamariah 4 years ago
This song is memorable. I always feel warm to listen. It is like a pleasant scent which always make me embarassed into the warm and intimate feeling.
Puikideo 4 years ago
LOVE HER there will never be anyone like her!!!
brandinj 4 years ago
i love this song and i love that CD
Krazygurl16 4 years ago
what a voice!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
h0nie24 4 years ago
some of mariah's most meaningful lyrics written... top notch!
marsattacksu 4 years ago
BEAUTIFUL!
MariahUK 4 years ago
wow she is very outstanding performer.
i hope somebody will have followed her footsteps as an exceptional singer, by the time she pass away
leviaragon 4 years ago
mariah is the bomb singer, every word that comes out of her mouth sound's so amazing,one day ill tell her this...lol
vilisoni 4 years ago
when dice died it was so sad
eastside4445 4 years ago
shes the best there is and the best there ever will be. no contest.
MDK489 4 years ago
She sang that beautifully, and i'm not a fan at all!
elston1991 4 years ago
I love this song its one of my favorites from Mariah Carey
BreBre22028 4 years ago
man i wish this song came out on one of her other albums. this would have sold hundreds of records
vilisoni 4 years ago
ajt or just 99 copies lol
kattbajs111 4 years ago
funny. grow up
vilisoni 4 years ago
I'm 6'9" and 300 lbs so I'm already grown lol
kattbajs111 4 years ago
this song! is very inspiring to everyone ... this song makes my feelings good!~ thanks to mariah carey she is my idol 4 ever!
gairyl 4 years ago
this is my fav. song from the glitter album. i really like how she thought to change the line from "before you gave me life" to "that day you gave me life". I really love how deep this song is, and that's my fav. line from it.
vixen234 4 years ago
Most of the Mariah's albums, there are at least one Thanks-giving song to show her graditude and love to God or parents or kids.
Puikideo 4 years ago
uncomparable....
h0nie24 4 years ago
Wonderful performance. She is so amazingly talented.
mlambguy2513 4 years ago
one of mariah's bests songs. She writes with such a passion thats unseen to many but known to millions.
mariah, you are so wonderful n fulfilled in my eyes. keep it up mimi.
vanessa78225 4 years ago
Thanks mariah...you are perfect and the best.i love so much
relacionador 4 years ago
I LOVE THIS SONG AND THE SINGER As WELL SHE HASN'T LOST IT
LCJBoi2007 4 years ago
GLITTER IS WONDERFUL
TRUST ME!!!
justmeee1234abcd 4 years ago
yes i Love this live and one and only we can find Live.
yet nobody really knows this great song of Mariah and also that she sang so fantastic well LIVE.
transhurray 4 years ago
i am dissapointed for that movie glitter i watch it and its good.Mariah Fans should spread and publitize the movie
dannylaki 4 years ago
CORRECT.GLITTER NOT ONLY IS OK FINE,not bad at all.few million US dollar cinema intake is much better than Millions Crap Hollywood movies.Mariah acting was fine enough to be in MOVIES.
and ofcourse the Album is one of my favourites.
YET HOLLYWOOD MADE SUCH A BAD NAME FOR GLITTER.
UnFair.
transhurray 4 years ago
Unique and extraordinary vocal...
A Pure star
rudememorial 4 years ago
to puikideo:
very ''king hei'' ar :P
samlockch 4 years ago
The glitter album is so underrated...she did such a great job with the ballads, like this one...she writes all this stuff, that says so much about her as an artist. I appreciate whoever put this out on video for us, as I've never seen it performed...
miguelkelley123 4 years ago
me too.. im excited about her new movie..!!! i cant wait
jelocarey17 4 years ago
Unfortunately Glitter was not released at a right time. At that time, the rap songs were not really so at the spot. If the rap song from Glitter ablum were released from now on. The feedback must be much much better. Anyway, Mariah is the best singer and song writer.
Puikideo 4 years ago
she look so funny but the song is nice.
melchewvin 4 years ago
Thanks for posting this video, this is such a great song :(
Alexsandercr 4 years ago
WHEN DID MARIAH SING THIS SONG? LIKE WHAT YEaR?
Beautifulmusicfan161 4 years ago
She performed this in 2001.
jaquen1977 4 years ago
oh my god, this is my favourite ever, and i found it for a long period of time ,
thanks !!!!!!!!!!
samlockch 4 years ago
Sam ah Lock, heee hee , you cannot imagine this video was uploaded by MEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE ! hahaha
Surprised?
Puikideo 4 years ago
How long ago was this?
joeyvoh 4 years ago
Hmmnnn... the pitch is somewhat... a bit lower than the one in the movie... hmnnn... try to listen, guys...
But well... MARIAH, YOU'RE THE BEST!!!!!!!!
I LOVE YOU!!!
ErisofScorpio 4 years ago
i noticed that too.. but she is really the best.. no one can match her success
jelocarey17 4 years ago
Except perhaps The Beatles?
Lol.
ErisofScorpio 4 years ago
Of course no one sings Mariah's songs better than her, or actually no one can coz no one will ever be able to reach her high notes, check "Regine-Reflections* it's regine singing a medly and people all say that she's better than mariah, Iam having a quarrel with someone since days now hahaha it's fun
MBen89 4 years ago
Only Philiphines people say that regine better than mariah but the whole dont so get real regine is aka clone to mariah carey beware !!!!!
REILMICRO 4 years ago
omgossshhhh u have no idea wat uv just done uwhoever uploaded this thing!!!
thank you so much! iv bin lookin for this!
tyediaz 4 years ago
very amazing..bravo!
luvumc 4 years ago
beautiful song & performance.i love the album glitter esp the ballad songs lead the way,never too far & this one.unfortunately the album didn't make it well,but still mariah's the best!!!
whel21 4 years ago
yay, someone finally put this back up. Someone else had it on youtube but took it down. :(
vanessa78225 4 years ago
very nice, thanks for posting video
k88ykatt 4 years ago
i am mariah carey number #1 fan of all my sister said i listen to her and sang her songs when i was 3 years old and would like to join your group but how old do you have to be cause i am really 10 and my sister is 18. she let me have her channel
cookiekd06 4 years ago
Is there any live perfomance of "outside" from her butterfly album.
gullimh 4 years ago
nice job
xtinagodess 4 years ago
love it love it 5 stars i have been looking for this since 2003 and thank you very much
cookiekd06 4 years ago
so amazing parfait live
sofiane93 4 years ago
She did a beautiful job. This song is really touching.
falconer 4 years ago