Probably is sore but most singers on tour end up a little scratchy. Look at David Draiman from Disturbed he didn't sound as good on the Uproar 2011 but they still kicked ass on stage.
@Stinkfist43 You know what fuck you I'm not just saying this because you dissed my favorite band I'm also saying this because you had to fucking dis music period I don't go around saying Justin Bieber sucks to all the fans because I don't like it. I fucking hate it but I aint spoutin my mouth off to the fans of his music and don't even reply to this cause I don't give a flying fuck about you or what you have to say asshole
yeah his voice is a lil off in this one almost like he's sick or something or maybe he's taking some artistic liberty many performers do that when you do the same song a million times, but this is very rare for Trent watch his other live performances he's one of the best at performing live, most of his live stuff is better than the actual record
@godsx Singing like this is actually really hard on your voice, so I'm sure it's just difficult to reproduce live. When you are doing a record you just track it over a couple times so you get each line right, but you can't do that at a show. It's also physically painful to scream like he's doing. He's doing pretty good considering all that. Personally I'm impressed by his performance. My opinion, speaking as a vocalist.
Yeah this is fucking awesome, I personally say a great live performance. And it's not about trying to recreate the album live anyway, it's about doing it justice and having a good time. That's exactly what this video says, mad props!! I'd be stoked to be there.
Omg! Where did you find a brilliant perfomance??? Trent missed many notes while singing.. may be he was sick? Totally out of tune and moreover Trent missed the keys when he played synth.. Poor perfomance.
Love NIN, how could anyone think Trent sounds bad is beyond me of course no one is going to sound perfect live as to when they are sitting in a studio with recording after recording, be realistic people, even Jeff Buckley didn't sound the same live.
@samisaberle probably saw Ozzy Osbourne without his clothes on one day and was like "Shit son, NO WAY!! *calls his agent to sign him up for a Golds membership*"
How well bands are live is the true definition of just how good they are. Anyone can get in a studio and dub and add effects. Bands like NIN are a rarity and should be appreciated as such.
Not as perfect as on the record? Are you hearing the same song as me?,,,,,,,these guys kick it! I dare 90% of the bands out there on tour to come as close to NiN live.
And these guys have been around for a long time......shame there done
@magicmarker77 Definitely not done, not sure where you got that from? Took a break and originally Trent even said they were not done. And early March he said "No Nine Inch Nails is not dead and I plan to focus on that next."
@magicmarker77 Have you ever heard of A Day To Remember,they are an amazing band on record and live, they are part of the 10 percent of the bands out there that can do better than NiN live, in my opinion ,you should check them out.
@magicmarker77 there's always some differences between live and album.. it's almost impossible for there not to be. Acoustics of a recording studio play a huge part of it as well as the fact that the singers tend to emphasize words a little different everytime they sing it so it doesn't get too monotonous for them when they sing the same song over and over.
Jajajajajajaj es un honor ver mi bandera ahí, pero aún más grande el que ellos hayan tocado en mi país. VIVA VENEZUELA Y VIVA NINE INCH NAILS. NIN+VZLA=BFF
HA!HA!HA!HA!HA! jaggy jobbies! yafuckintube that's brilliant! i reckon she needs a good pull through wi a xmas tree! sycofantic cow! what would she know!
cheers skacel71! your right about the footage. Don't know if you know, but they have added 7 videoes on the bbc t in the park site! bloody good! and read some of the comments-they're awesome!
FUCK THE KILLERS!!! NIN FUCKING RULE!!! one of the best performances i have ever seen at T in the P! been going for years and they blew me away!! WOO HOO!
wow good song and a the singer he is vary good
what is his Name
NadiaZharkikh 3 weeks ago
@NadiaZharkikh Trent Reznor
rageage5fifteen 1 week ago
@spentfromnz Lmao hahaha... too funny
2J08 4 weeks ago
WTF, why does the guitarist have camel toe at 3:42.
spentfromnz 1 month ago
that synth half way through is amazing. NIN for life. roll on year 2022...
b3n2m1 3 months ago
@xXCrazyLildevilXx He's right, Disturbed do suck.
doknero 4 months ago 4
magicmarkerker77 you are fucking stupi is 100% good you cooc sucer i will kill you coc sucing fag i will rape you in the ass fucker
n0giant 4 months ago
Probably is sore but most singers on tour end up a little scratchy. Look at David Draiman from Disturbed he didn't sound as good on the Uproar 2011 but they still kicked ass on stage.
xXCrazyLildevilXx 7 months ago
@xXCrazyLildevilXx Oops I meant 2010 lol
xXCrazyLildevilXx 7 months ago
@xXCrazyLildevilXx Disturbed fuckin sucks
Stinkfist43 6 months ago
@Stinkfist43 You know what fuck you I'm not just saying this because you dissed my favorite band I'm also saying this because you had to fucking dis music period I don't go around saying Justin Bieber sucks to all the fans because I don't like it. I fucking hate it but I aint spoutin my mouth off to the fans of his music and don't even reply to this cause I don't give a flying fuck about you or what you have to say asshole
xXCrazyLildevilXx 6 months ago
@xXCrazyLildevilXx Haha
Stinkfist43 6 months ago
@Stinkfist43 Wow hard to believe but you're a bigger dumbass than I thought
xXCrazyLildevilXx 6 months ago
@xXCrazyLildevilXx Love you too
Stinkfist43 6 months ago
@Stinkfist43 Whatever you say, your words not mine
xXCrazyLildevilXx 6 months ago
shut the fuck up hackmoune
JustinReznor 7 months ago
yeah his voice is a lil off in this one almost like he's sick or something or maybe he's taking some artistic liberty many performers do that when you do the same song a million times, but this is very rare for Trent watch his other live performances he's one of the best at performing live, most of his live stuff is better than the actual record
godsx 7 months ago
@godsx Singing like this is actually really hard on your voice, so I'm sure it's just difficult to reproduce live. When you are doing a record you just track it over a couple times so you get each line right, but you can't do that at a show. It's also physically painful to scream like he's doing. He's doing pretty good considering all that. Personally I'm impressed by his performance. My opinion, speaking as a vocalist.
aCynicalPie 7 months ago
Yeah this is fucking awesome, I personally say a great live performance. And it's not about trying to recreate the album live anyway, it's about doing it justice and having a good time. That's exactly what this video says, mad props!! I'd be stoked to be there.
Nofe20 9 months ago
Finck's guitar needs to be a LOT louder.
sonic777111 9 months ago
mit lederjacke da oben muss es ziemlich heiß sein^^
Quecksilber7 10 months ago
Espectacular
akiabara1000 10 months ago 4
Omg! Where did you find a brilliant perfomance??? Trent missed many notes while singing.. may be he was sick? Totally out of tune and moreover Trent missed the keys when he played synth.. Poor perfomance.
yrussq 1 year ago
Not as good as the on the record is a stupid thing to say about a live performance...
MrPeterjonge 1 year ago
Brilliant performance.
agentsmith39062 1 year ago
Why the Fuck is he wearing a jacket????? fucking ridiculous.
bma852 1 year ago
@bma852 Why the fuck are you so retarded??? fuckin ridiculous
Hackmoune 9 months ago
this is just fucking amazing...
changst3r 1 year ago
Asshole, I can sing better than that
yelling647 1 year ago
Trent looks pretty damn good to me for a guy who was born in 1965!
dbeecooks 1 year ago 3
holy shit hes looking old! not a very powerful vocal performance either
RomanianDaci 1 year ago
not the best live version ive seen :/ but probably some of the best music t in the parks seen
AdamBostockRocks 1 year ago
Loooove that electronic vibes!!!!!!
efkagore 1 year ago
Oh Trent, why do you suck live? :(
KidVlogger317 1 year ago
This is brilliant - we need this intensity in our lives every single day. Love NIN - let's put the 'free' back into the 'free world'.
morningglorify 1 year ago
This is an utterly terrible performance of this song.
atomicwave 1 year ago
@atomicwave How do you figure?
taylorsback101 1 year ago
You do know when its live its more people playing with trent but, when he makes the song its all him on all instraments.
cboewebra 1 year ago
@cboewebra Yeah, he has a live band. That isn't his real band.
KidVlogger317 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
trent, i luv you
sybis 1 year ago
Comment removed
sybis 1 year ago
anyone else notice this is under pets and animals?
rockrulesrapsucks 1 year ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
@rockrulesrapsucks They are animals.
llllJakubllll 1 year ago
where's the scream at 2:30? :(
BaasStuart 1 year ago
Love NIN, how could anyone think Trent sounds bad is beyond me of course no one is going to sound perfect live as to when they are sitting in a studio with recording after recording, be realistic people, even Jeff Buckley didn't sound the same live.
archaicevening 1 year ago
I Love Trent!!!!! This performance is super!
Iwantapinklife 1 year ago
doesnt ANYONE have the video of heresy the BBC put up, i cant find it anywhere :(
starstruckstarfuck 1 year ago
I prefer the record version, this version sux!
wildmangk 1 year ago
@wildmangk suck my nut sack motherfucker
YAZZ69er 1 year ago
lick the tip of my dick bitch
wildmangk 1 year ago
@wildmangk i bet ud like that u faggot ass bitch, go suck ur dads chode
YAZZ69er 1 year ago
Trent is pretty built, never noticed before
samisaberle 1 year ago
@samisaberle probably saw Ozzy Osbourne without his clothes on one day and was like "Shit son, NO WAY!! *calls his agent to sign him up for a Golds membership*"
magicalpoop 1 year ago
Police killed the vid! 3:15
Wowhead659 2 years ago
I assume Trenty wasn't in a guitar mood...
CriticsConfession 2 years ago
The soundman should be shot. Trent's guitar is way too loud, Finck's is too quiet, you can't hear any bass whatsoever. Poor at best.
stalinised 2 years ago 16
@stalinised haha, i was gonna post a comment about that, but your comment said exactly what i was gonna say. FUCK THE SOUND GUY.
BladeLemonMilk 2 years ago
How well bands are live is the true definition of just how good they are. Anyone can get in a studio and dub and add effects. Bands like NIN are a rarity and should be appreciated as such.
KUDrew21 2 years ago 7
Not as perfect as on the record? Are you hearing the same song as me?,,,,,,,these guys kick it! I dare 90% of the bands out there on tour to come as close to NiN live.
And these guys have been around for a long time......shame there done
magicmarker77 2 years ago 51
@magicmarker77 Definitely not done, not sure where you got that from? Took a break and originally Trent even said they were not done. And early March he said "No Nine Inch Nails is not dead and I plan to focus on that next."
Byrne3155 11 months ago
@magicmarker77 Have you ever heard of A Day To Remember,they are an amazing band on record and live, they are part of the 10 percent of the bands out there that can do better than NiN live, in my opinion ,you should check them out.
AeroBlade360 10 months ago
@magicmarker77 errm, MUSE ARE MORE EPIC. this is a really good song, but MUSE RULE!!!!!!!!!
alimdacmo 10 months ago
@alimdacmo Then go to a Muse video and masturbate there, you fuckin fag
Hackmoune 9 months ago
@magicmarker77 there's always some differences between live and album.. it's almost impossible for there not to be. Acoustics of a recording studio play a huge part of it as well as the fact that the singers tend to emphasize words a little different everytime they sing it so it doesn't get too monotonous for them when they sing the same song over and over.
But that aside, they sound absolutely awesome.
adarkenedmind 10 months ago
@adarkenedmind that and the fact that this was in scotland so he probably got a cold or something that kinda fucked his vocals
devilhunter123100 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I think his voice is not as perfect as on the record but it's still a very good live perfomance. I love it. Trent rules :)
Kathybabe1980 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
best song ever
chasd8898 2 years ago
Comment removed
Bluebelt777 2 years ago
i don't know man, on my computer it sounds great! i'm genuinely surprised, but for a studio project NiN is superb live.
BeauSylvester47 2 years ago 2
great! nin rules!
InfidelSnail 2 years ago
A bit hard to hear, but still a great song.
BlackDeath10000 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
didn't know robin williams was the lead singer? New career path?
marriedw4 2 years ago
didn't know retards posted on youtube? New feature?
tushar310 2 years ago
1:47 Trent's head is on fire
46lar 2 years ago 5
haha the singer is so sweaty
jaredpistoia 2 years ago
A Venezuelan flag at 1:06!! xD Yeah!!!!!
PDLIFrank 2 years ago
Jajajajajajaj es un honor ver mi bandera ahí, pero aún más grande el que ellos hayan tocado en mi país. VIVA VENEZUELA Y VIVA NINE INCH NAILS. NIN+VZLA=BFF
roninchnails 2 years ago
the shit
98dfox 2 years ago
not fair T in the park got a way better NIN setlist then sonisphere
Paulcowie64 2 years ago
lol damn he sang the song too late into the concert. he looks strained and tired as hell.
sparda9060 2 years ago
I think he might actually have a bit of a throat infection maybe?? you never know how much he's been overworking his voice before this gig.
AllanMcGreevy 2 years ago
Robin is such a sick player
killer92tacos 2 years ago 3
No kidding! I saw them live earlier this week! Finck is amazing. The whole show was crazy.
shredder27 2 years ago 2
Excellent
rockjose 2 years ago 2
Amazing performance!
betadine07 2 years ago
Trent's voice is going ;'(
xjustxthinkx 2 years ago
it's not going. It sounds like it might just be tired
killer92tacos 2 years ago
Yeah, and hopefully he can rest it for his 'break'
xjustxthinkx 2 years ago
What 'break' ?
killer92tacos 2 years ago
Umm...do you not know yet? Trent is on the 'wave goodbye' tour at the moment because he is having a break from nin
xjustxthinkx 2 years ago
No i didn't. But thanks
killer92tacos 2 years ago
No problem :)
xjustxthinkx 2 years ago
Does he actually play a wrong note at 2:12 ?
Haha
02smithm1 2 years ago
I love this man he is god and amazing to watch live
daniangharad 2 years ago
my hat!!!! 1;38!!!
ClareMcKenna91 2 years ago
Muahaha, the dude presenters face when introducing NIN!!
xTHExDUDExPK 2 years ago
sorry skacel71 that was me answering under my pal's name! duh! wot a total tube!
rockelfin 2 years ago
HA!HA!HA!HA!HA! jaggy jobbies! yafuckintube that's brilliant! i reckon she needs a good pull through wi a xmas tree! sycofantic cow! what would she know!
blariosputnik5 2 years ago
cheers skacel71! your right about the footage. Don't know if you know, but they have added 7 videoes on the bbc t in the park site! bloody good! and read some of the comments-they're awesome!
blariosputnik5 2 years ago
I hate Edith Bowman!
There! I said it.
zombie01 2 years ago 4
We all hate Edith Bowman. She knows fuck all about music. I hope all her jobbies are jaggy ones!
YaFukinTube 2 years ago 5
Epic lulz!
xTHExDUDExPK 2 years ago
sounds flat
rick2494 2 years ago
you're wrong
it's trent reznor to god flat only exists in ornaments
geefron 2 years ago
FUCK THE KILLERS!!! NIN FUCKING RULE!!! one of the best performances i have ever seen at T in the P! been going for years and they blew me away!! WOO HOO!
rockelfin 2 years ago 25
Agreed Rockelfin fucking amazing, would even go as far to say one of the best live performances i've ever seen. tv footage doesn't do it justice.
Skacel71 2 years ago
@rockelfin now thats respect
nonlazygamer2 6 months ago
absolutely fucking awesome... can't wait till sonisphere!
stork101 2 years ago
yet another sound guy who needs to be shot....
DavySolaris 2 years ago 7