Added: 2 years ago
From: RhinoEntertainment
Views: 1,525,792
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (2,471)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Suprisingly relaxing

  • wow that was a pleasant surprise! very different than I imagined. shit she can totally pull off the actress/singer thing as so few can!

  • Only dislikes cause a lot of her fan base are not into this sorta music. They just stick with mainstream shit.

  • Hell shes fine

  • Look!

    I like her so much as anything else,she is beautifull,nice actor,but i dont like here voice! :)

  • i wanna see her get banged....

  • i never knew she did music. her voice is pretty good but i like the lyrics and the music. not bad scarlett johanson keep it up :)

  • i wanna have sex with you

  • The most beautiful woman around, singin' good enough one the best songs of one of the best songwriters around!!!

    THE WORLD MIGHT STILL HAVE A CHANCE!!!

  • I only watched this video to see Salman Rushdie creeping on Johansson.

  • okaaaay ---> out

  • I can dig it.

  • She sounds like Cat Power in a way.

  • i love her, even if she doesn´t sing, but now that i know it, i love her even more.

  • She is great because she doesn't sound like autotune or typical catchy corporate crap

  • godd... I wanaa hav ze powher 2 make alll women in ze worldrld VirGin again... so men kan meerry them as Virgines... and allll wamen in The wordlrd waiting for Me like aim the nexxt Jesus Cristo... and winn ze Nopel prize for reinventingng LOVe... and then meditate and then take a Shit

  • I thought that her vocal interpretation of this song was quite good, but the video made it seem completely narcissistic.

  • @gravyboatK Did you expect to make her video about you?

  • why can't actors be actors and singers BE SINGERS!!

  • well ive always loved it

  • Omg...no voice.

  • Thats Bowie in the background!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • pshh...scarlett johansson doesn't need any makeup..

  • I like this song, played by tom and played by mrs. johansson too. I like David on background. IT'S SOUND GOOD

  • This video is really...really stupid. But I like the song.

  • ...this video is like a "line": it's only really good the first time...

  • You guys should stop with all those negative comments. She's the Black Widow for God's sake!

  • having David Bowie doing backing vocals doesn't hurt...

  • This chick is so pretty, she should try acting.

  • @JonasPolsky This chick has been acting for 16 years now, since she was 10 ;-) Music is only her secondary activity.

  • @JonasPolsky She is an actress..

  • I love her voice.

  • the first time I heard this I found it really weird and kinda bad, now??? after the second time I fell in love this song is amazing,,, congrats to scarlett for being different

  • This song is so magical

  • Ouch.

  • I wonder who told her this was a good idea, and if she has fired that person yet? I'm thinking it's the same person that advises her on work, as her "career" is in the toilet. Poor kid. She needs a new management team - and a vocal coach.

  • Love it! :)

  • don't ask for nothing?!

    well that's brilliant.

  • great song Scarlett

  • She can't sing but damn she's hot!

  • Very creative individual; definitely someone that doesn't need to rely on her movie star ability to make it as a singer, at least for me. I don't get that vibe at all. I think that she is just very talented.

    It doesn't hurt that she is physically gorgeous either. Claxxy person in her interviews and in person.

  • She had so many moles on her face...O_O

  • her voice makes me want to jump off a building. I'm gonna puke!

  • if i only heard the song without knowing it is scarjo, i must have thought it real singer

  • beautiful cover

  • was that salman rushdie? cool.

  • Sounds like Sinead O Connor to me...good though:)

  • I can't help thinking Sinead O Connor when I hear this...

  • I like the simplicity of showing just as she is and singing in their own way without copying other artists, very original and beautiful!

  • awesome

  • Cocteau Twins playing Tom Waits?

  • beautiful voice

    

  • Wow Scarlett look so pretty with no make up on

    not using her inner voice

  • She's just yelling the whole song. Probably with some vocal training it would sound half decent.

  • @DonkeyKongChick She is taking her que from Tom waits who sung this originally, if you listen to his version, scar's version makes more sense..

  • @DonkeyKongChick it's a tom waits song. kinda supposed to be like that.

  • stick to your acting career scarlett x

  • nadamas veo este video por la mamcita de scarleth

  • If they could just remove the music and the clothes from this video it would be a hit!

  • It's amazing to hear all of these people hate on this stuff. Let me guess none of you have any songs uploaded and none of you have any talent. Weak haters! If you want to show youtube what you've got why don't you sing us something (meaning all of the people who upload music here whether "good" or "bad") instead of just hating ALL THE TIME! I just did a cover of Dear Prudence. It is a demo. It's not perfect. But I did it, because I love it. Fuck all the music haters...Flint Dear Prudence.

  • well, I do admire her courage to go on and put out a solo album as alternate as this, I like to see these kinds of things, makes me appreciate her even more. I guess she also wrote her own songs and can play the guitar, which is another HUGE bonus over every generic female popstar nowadays. but I confess I didn't like it much myself, but I haven't listened to the whole album to be able to judge properly.

    idk how the album did commercially..was it a flop??

  • lovely.

  • I have no idea why, but.. I really like it.

  • @ThirtySecondsTooMars yeah.. I used to hate it.. but know I can't say the same.

  • Comment removed

  • worst song ever

    

  • Make it stop, my ears are bleeding.

  • @Krapukah LMFAO

  • SERIOUSLY!!! wow, has she learned nothing from the other flopps!! MAKE IT STOP.....im so embarrased for her!

  • she looks so beautiful at 1:13 before getting her makeup put on... *sigh*

    and to the ppl saying this is bad: 1st of all - id like to see u do better. 2nd - no it is not. 3rd - scarlett johansson. that is all.

    also i love this video. so simple and kinda thought provocing. love it.

    btw is that little girl in the pink dress acctually scarlett or just an actor or...?

  • <3

  • i like this, i know its fucked but i like it!

  • bad just bad

  • OMG she singes like a bitch

    lol

  • She doesn't suck, she doesn't sound like the typical female singer but she does not suck, she has an alternative voice, and she has excellent taste, she's covering Tom Waits who also has a very unusual voice. She sings really pretty in some other of her songs, so she chose to sound like this... I love it.

  • @shesthunderstorms23 no the typical female singer is actually good at singing

  • @shesthunderstorms23 No, she sucks!

  • reminded me of the cocteau twins

  • I like it

  • love it

  • Scarlett you are an amazing actress, but please don't sing!

  • Oh shit was that her singing? Wow. I thought it was ok. But, you all going on and on about It sucking. Well were is your video where you sing? Not that I care much about Scarlett but even in the nobodies who put up a vid... Why so much hate? How about some good old fashioned common curtsey.

    God dammit!

  • @suitmanjm

    i don't think it's so much about whether she can sing or not, i think the people complaining are tom waits fans. it was barely acceptable to us when rod stewart covered a couple of his songs and rod stewart can sing! we're just a funny lot who see this kind of thing as a form of blasphemy :-)

  • Its her take on it, just like your opinion. And I think its quite nice, without trying and being pretentious. After all its a song about giving up trying.. plus, plus, plus - she's got a nice rack

  • This is really about as terrible as a Tom Waits song should ever sound, you don't cover him just for the hell of it, especially with a voice as bland as hers. Im sure this girls heart is in the right place and credit to her for picking Waits to cover, it obviously isn't a sell out attempt. However, as far as art goes you may as well have Paris Hilton release an album covering Captain Beefheart or something.

  • @Nangus01 Oh, I'd love to hear that. I mean, Paris doing Captain Beefheart.

  • @Nangus01

    well said, this is the first time i ever listened to any of her covers, as i understand she produced a full album of toms stuff, so fair play to her, i'm assuming she must be a real fan. i love rod stewarts voice (his early r'n'b stuff) but even i wasn't impressed when he covered tom, although he did do it for all the right reasons (i.e. to get tom some cash when he needed it) but this is not my cup of tea :-)

  • gossip girl <3

  • OMG SORRY BUT SHE SUCKS!!!!! =/ HOly S***!

  • I would say she should stick to acting, but then again she's not very good at that either... Stick to have a nice rack!

  • Dingue de cette chanson! ♥ ♥

  • Not sure how I feel about the video; a bit too egocentric.. But the singing itself wasn't bad, just an off style, kind of eccentric. Reminded me a lot of Cat Power or Tilly and the Wall.

  • Comment removed

  • I truly Love it... It does sound sad, But then again It isn't a country song. It some meaning.

  • ......... A true Angel

  • Comment removed

  • Gotta say I love it.

    

  • Good lord...if her name wasn't Scarlett Johansson then this never gets made. Please stick to your so-so acting honey

  • I love you Scarlett, but please, switch to Porn.

  • Ma vie est femme je vous aime toutes!!

  • Quite nice to hear an alternative song from a model, this is so much better than the usual pop shit spewed out from talentless bimbo's....

  • @andyshrapnel she's an actress though, not a model.

  • @futurestar94britfan Yeah, ok sorry about that.. but could be a model though? either way still quite original and to be fair, I like it... thanks for the reply though.

  • she's a really bad singer..

  • David Bowie?

  • @HumanoidSparky ¡David Bowie!

  • @taretis lost in translation

  • stanley kubrick?

  • @MIGUEL2005LIMA salmon rushdie

    

  • I was prepared for the worst, and I am thereby plesantly surprised. It wasn't nearly as bad as J-LO's music

  • I submit to you, dear Youtube reader, the following notion: this would be taken at face value were it not for the identity of its vocalist. It's great, unique and totally idiosyncratic. Kind of like a contemporary take on Nico's legacy, but without being flat and painfully dull.

  • @mahajohn Yeah, I said it: Scarlett Johansson is more interesting than Nico.

  • she has a folk people voice, she needs a banjo and a mandolin and thats it. not weird techno esque beats

  • Hottie McHottie

  • hahahahahahahahaha... you have got to be kidding me? Annie Lennox must be laughing her ass off.

  • Terrible song. So terrible i feel I am wasting a comment.

  • idk i like it

  • It was great! ............. when it ended

  • It's like Ben Stein trying to sing.

  • Rod Stewart thinks this is a terrible cover of Tom Waits.

  • I love this song so much. I don't get what people hate about it?

  • whats salman rushdie saying

  • best part is bowie

  • las poster is right on the money :)

  • As I see, this song is to beautiful to be understand by everyone ....

  • Great Song Scarlett.

  • How did I get here from Led Zeppelin? Does she have the same hair as Robert Plant?

  • Jazz sounds better on her voice.

  • 3:15 Salman Rushdie ?

  • Comment removed

  • I love Scarlett, she's beautiful and talented but this is an abomination. At least get the fucking changes right, taking the Bb out of the verse completely ruins the song. Boooo.

  • Doesn't metter, still hot

    

  • I've now listened to a few of her songs and I've come to the conclusion that Scarlett is better off sticking to acting... and I mean that in the most respectful way. I will give her that at least she's taking a sort of avant garde/artistic approach; as opposed to the much easier and more customary bubblegum route... but she's just not a singer overall. I've even seen comparisons to floozies like Kim Kardashian, and that's just stupid. S.J. HAS a ton of talent, just not so much in singing.

  • its special..

  • scarlett, talar du dansk eda islensk? eda barre ensk

  • sounds like a more drawn out, more american Sigur Ros. Beatiful Woman! Beautiful Song! You can thank scandinavia for that

  • I love you Scarlett, but please, stick to acting.

  • Towm Waits version is superb. But this is alright.

  • this is horseshit

  • Falling Down? Scarlett, you're a DOWN already.

  • I will never understand why people should be so negative towards the most beautiful woman on this planet, a natural beauty

    you must all be jealouse virgins

    I love you scarlet

  • And a very nice ending

  • So beautiful song

  • i really don't get it

  • shockly bad. it's not singing, it's yelling.  noising.

  • I REALLY LOVED THE VOICE N SONG !! FUCK U HATERS

  • You should hear her sing "I Don't Know What To Do" with Pete Yorn. You get a much better idea of what her singing voice can be like.

  • it's indie. (!)

  • is it a cover? the song s mega...she is ugly, but i even like her singin i think

  • I think she has a very unique voice, and for the style of music she's doing her voice is perfect for it.

  • Loved it, sounded sad and haunting with a touch of folk music. Want to hear more.

  • I was going to voice my opinion via a youtube comment, but then I decided against it.

    You should do the same.

  • I gotta say I really like it. This song always puts me at ease. thanks

  • Some actors are versatile and can sing and act, some aren't. I'm afraid to say she definitely isn't. The video is good, though, and there are worse out there, I just think that she should give up singing and stick to what she's best at.

  • Meh.

  • I like it, don't know why ;)

  • all these hate comments... if you listen carefully and watch the video then you will see the story behind it all..

  • I like it.

  • i love the fact that she is trying...

  • Comment removed

  • Not great but I see who and what she is aiming for

  • I like it. I think any actor can understand it if they look at the content of the video. The music is perfect for it.

  • I Like it... its unique and there are many many bands that cant "sing" but are still amazing. And she's not bad.

  • A voice only Bob Dylan could love. And Woody Allen. lol Actually it's not SO bad.

  • Don't quit your day job, Scarlett. I've heard deaf people sing better.