@speakingtruly Because it is about bureaucratic nightmare in the legal process of an Inquisition judicial system - you know, a process similar to when you receive a speeding ticket. However, here it is push to the extreme, like a totalitarian government might do. In fact, it fit quite well with the justice system in the nazi regime - but that novel been made in 1925, quite early ;)
You can see this film however it is to you. I have my ideas as to it's deeper meaning, to do with the inner before expressed to the outer along similar lines to the death of Ivan Ilyich but not to me. It is certainly not weird, there is a myriad of meaning to be drawn from it. Only to the unimaginative would it ever be seen as a Jewish mans guilt. That to me is paddling pool shallow significance to draw from this film. Racism just ends the story that never began that way at all to me:)
guilty of being jewish, one man did nothing to be guilt of and yet feels bit guilty by looks and court guilty of being jewish-something bad corrupted actually this is how u turn art into writting... styles used... metaphoresv analogys
guilty of being jewish, one man did nothing to be guilt of and yet feels bit guilty by looks and court guilty of being uyjewish-something bad corrupted
This is not a typical book which one can "understand". there are many interpertations to it. anyway, as much as I like Roth and the other actors' play, the book is much better - the atmosphere is darker there and many of the details are missing in the movie adaptation.
wildcardxi's right. The final scene in the book is done at night. Kafka mantioned the moonlight a couple of times. It sets certain atmosphere that seems to be missing here.
yeah i know what you mean, its a bit fragmented as it is split in 3 and there are bits missing. its not really meant to make sense- kafka wanted to show fear and entrapment throughout. read the book and youl get it.
I feel like this adaptation misses the point of the book entirely, particularly in these two scenes. All of the drama is totally removed from the cathedral scene and it makes it seem a great deal less surreal. The scene is also too bright, which is unusal because the use of light in the book was in many ways quite cinematic and would have translated well. The final scene is just terrible. in writing it was not only increadibly bizarre and shocking it was also very very funny and surreal.
@wildcardxi K's also supposed to see one of his women (uncertain which one) on the march to his death, if I remember right. They got the general atmosphere about right, but not much else.
@speakingtruly Because it is about bureaucratic nightmare in the legal process of an Inquisition judicial system - you know, a process similar to when you receive a speeding ticket. However, here it is push to the extreme, like a totalitarian government might do. In fact, it fit quite well with the justice system in the nazi regime - but that novel been made in 1925, quite early ;)
However, I find that story boring...
therrydicule 3 weeks ago
@eramseyer its about pre war state when everybody can be killed for nothing.
SheedaBihacC1 9 months ago
You can see this film however it is to you. I have my ideas as to it's deeper meaning, to do with the inner before expressed to the outer along similar lines to the death of Ivan Ilyich but not to me. It is certainly not weird, there is a myriad of meaning to be drawn from it. Only to the unimaginative would it ever be seen as a Jewish mans guilt. That to me is paddling pool shallow significance to draw from this film. Racism just ends the story that never began that way at all to me:)
fredbloggs02 1 year ago
Comment removed
fredbloggs02 1 year ago
kafka is the most brilliant perfect writter, its not for everyone indeed
badsign1980 1 year ago
guilty of being jewish, one man did nothing to be guilt of and yet feels bit guilty by looks and court guilty of being jewish-something bad corrupted actually this is how u turn art into writting... styles used... metaphoresv analogys
badsign1980 1 year ago
guilty of being jewish, one man did nothing to be guilt of and yet feels bit guilty by looks and court guilty of being uyjewish-something bad corrupted
badsign1980 1 year ago
yeah.. this may just be the weirdest movie ever made.
EliseWhatever 1 year ago
I don't really like how the ending was made. It was narrated as if there is a next part to it or something.
Evica72 1 year ago
disturbing
Fakeblad 1 year ago
@eramseyer can you tell me where I can find whole movie of this masterpeace, please. Thank you.
termit989 1 year ago
@eramseyer WATCH METAMORPHOSIS...ALSO KAFKA'S WITH ROTH...REALLY WEIRD..BUT GREAT JOB
TheScheiss 2 years ago
This is not a typical book which one can "understand". there are many interpertations to it. anyway, as much as I like Roth and the other actors' play, the book is much better - the atmosphere is darker there and many of the details are missing in the movie adaptation.
Netalies 2 years ago
wildcardxi's right. The final scene in the book is done at night. Kafka mantioned the moonlight a couple of times. It sets certain atmosphere that seems to be missing here.
eriswraag 3 years ago 4
yeah i know what you mean, its a bit fragmented as it is split in 3 and there are bits missing. its not really meant to make sense- kafka wanted to show fear and entrapment throughout. read the book and youl get it.
almightyjass 3 years ago
I feel like this adaptation misses the point of the book entirely, particularly in these two scenes. All of the drama is totally removed from the cathedral scene and it makes it seem a great deal less surreal. The scene is also too bright, which is unusal because the use of light in the book was in many ways quite cinematic and would have translated well. The final scene is just terrible. in writing it was not only increadibly bizarre and shocking it was also very very funny and surreal.
wildcardxi 3 years ago
excatly!
alexanderlund91 2 years ago
@wildcardxi K's also supposed to see one of his women (uncertain which one) on the march to his death, if I remember right. They got the general atmosphere about right, but not much else.
Elcore 2 years ago
What?
fulsomstryk 3 years ago
a resevoir dog
7626b93bwf6 4 years ago
Like a dog
PrinsTan 4 years ago