countering attacks made against Joseph Stalin

[69Techno69pt]

Long Live Stalin!

[workergirls]

Long Live Comrade Stalin !!!

Long Live Marxism Leninism and Maoism !!!

[cosette2193]

Your ad hominem attacks cannot change the fact that millions of people fled Stalinism (and still flee it in places such as N. Korea). My America is a "workers' paradise" compared to a day in the life of Ivan Denisovich's richest uncle.

[CommunistNewZealand]

@cosette2193 you arguments are incredibly weak. Thousands, (millions?) escape over the Mexican border for a life in the U$A. Many Mexicans are shot, raped, abused, exploited, etc etc.. Is Mexico a capitalist state ?? YES. Therefore your argument is void

[cosette2193]

I do not see any difference between International Socialism and National Socialism. Opposition to one would get me sent to Siberia for rest, recreation, and reeducation. Opposition to the other would get me a one-way ticket to Dachau. I will take the British, the U.S.. or even the French constitution and their legislatives, courts, and police before I would sign up for a day of Stalinism.

[CommunistNewZealand]

@cosette2193 That's correct you would, as you are a puppet for western powers. you take on board all the shit and lies because to do the serious reading and research requires too much work, and you are probably a lazy cunt

[cosette2193]

I'll trust Alexander Solzhenitsyn before I trust this apology. Any cheers for Stalin in the Ukraine. Lock me up for "anti-Soviet activity."

[CommunistNewZealand]

@cosette2193 Solzhenitsyn was a nazi sympathizer and his statistics were and are incorrect-the Soviet archives prove this.

This vid is NOT an apology at all, stuff all of you anti-Communists, you are assholes

[CommunistNewZealand]

@cosette2193 maybe you should be locked up, thanks for the idea lol, there's a gulag in Siberia awaiting you

[Kurtlane]

I have personally met with at least two such people. Once was a Polish Jewish woman who went through Nazi concentration camps, and then through Soviet Labor camps. She said it was pretty much the same thing.

"Comment pending approval." What are you scared of? The truth.

[CommunistNewZealand]

@Kurtlane comments pending approval?

No longer will mindless right wing morons high- jack these vids. They took hours of work to make. You want democracy, want challenge this vid? make your own fukin vid then

[vivascargill]

@CommunistNewZealand well said!!!

[naizret]

This is a joke, yes?

[CommunistNewZealand]

@naizret no, unless you have a warped sense of humour.

This is a vid based on an academic article entitled "Lies Concerning the History of the Soviet Union" (from the Stalin Society web site). 

[jaza505]

sverigeeeeeeeeeeeee!

[MrCaptaincolbertfan]

And Lenin rolls in his grave...now.

[sandragardner1]

You are beneath contempt.

[CommunistNewZealand]

@sandragardner1 lol what an accolade

[AntidoteY]

@sandragardner1

Hopefully another Stalin will rise to show you the true meaning of contempt.

[moribas]

Where is the vídeo in which you defend hitler?

[beepeelow]

You Tube's #1 absurd video.

[jeanpaulfelix]

this video brought a video to my eyes...

absolutely beautiful...

Hail victory!!!1 Hail Stalin

[50Gut]

Robert Conquest told the truth.

[CommunistNewZealand]

@50Gut he was a pawn and a liar for the USA

[CommunistNewZealand]

@50Gut obviously not, the Soviet archives refute his assertions

[CrowKing001]

I guess you're choosing to ignore all of the documentation about Stalin that became available from the Kremlin's archives after the USSR collapsed. If you ever want to take your head out of the sand, you can read "The Black Book of Communism". It will tell you just about everything you need to know about Stalin.

[CommunistNewZealand]

you better be more specific than this. What's the source of these docs, who compiled them and when?

No one has there head in the sand, this vid, is based on actual authentic documentation

[alienwatcher93]

@CrowKing001 better read 'Stalin and the Struggle For Democratic Reforms' by Grover Furr, 'Another View of Stalin' by Ludo Martens and 'Lies Concerning the History of The Soviet Union' by Mario Sousa. That's all you need to know about Stalin

[marcelthemaoist]

@CrowKing001 Maybe you should search from criticisms of the Black Book, Harvard even admitted mathematical errors on the Chinese part of the book. Look up "MIM review black book" in google, and see why using Solzhenitsyn, fiction writer, is not historical science. It also doesn't explain how 60 million people died in a prison system that never housed more than 11 million during Stalin's time.

[MrHistoryman45]

Thanks comrade, it is good to see that the truth about Stalin is at last coming out. The truth is that he was a great and powerful leader, who struck fear into Capitalist vermin everywhere. They tell lie after lie about Stalin because they are terrified that ordinary people everyone will come to admire this great leader and follow his teachings. Long live Comrade Stalin!

[vivascargill]

1) Defend Comrade Stalin 2) expose the lies of Conquest et al

3)don't live in dream land Comrade Molotov admits many people died 4) Parenti and Mayer are good on this 5) I do not argue with anti Stalin scum who live in what is now the most expensive city in the world. You want terror in the 30's? Paint yourself black go back in time to sunflower county Mississippi

[MrSalamander7]

@vivascargill I know Parenti wrote about Stalin, but I've had some difficulty finding any of his writings. Could you recommend some?

[CommunistNewZealand]

@MrSalamander7 sure-

Ludo Martin's "Another View of Stalin" (on the net)

"Lies Concerning the History of ther Soviet Union" Mario Sousa (net)

"Stalin: the Myth and the Reality" Bill Bland, 2005 (Marxist internet Archives)

and also see RedNick's vids on Ukraine, Moscow trials, etc

[blahblahblah8183]

great video comrade. i've been arguing for Stalin's legacy for years. Stalin and the Soviet people SAVED civilization from Hitler's fangs, and this is thanks Stalin gets! Hell, even US President FDR liked him! and why not a gulag? I'd rather criminals do productive labor than idle incarceration.

[Guevaristas]

'It is absurd on its face that Stalin killed 20 million. That would mean one person out of every other Soviet family dead by Stalin's hand. Would such a population have fought successfully to save the USSR and defeat German Fascism? Ridiculous. It would have laid down arms and revolted as did the Czar's army in 1917.'

from "On the Stalin Mythology"

By an activist, 11 July 1998

[Guevaristas]

Fair enough Comrades, many of you like Stalin others hate him. If you disagree with the subject matter on the video you have every right to.

But, you should direct your disapproval to the Stalin Society web site, not Comm. NZ

[ssmusic214]

So what's absurd about it? My family has 1 victim of Gulag and 2 survivors who survived only because Stalin died.

[MoscowMaestro]

But Stalin *did* send millions of people to their deaths, you deluded wanker.

Do you know anything about the Belomorkanal Project? Or about the Road Of Death?

Try reading Varlam Sharlamov. He was actually *in* Stalin's camps. asshole. Unlike your amateur historian friend Ella.

Now fuck off and die.

All the best from Moscow, where we live with this shit, and don't need the opinions of Kiwi Cunts who've never been nearer Moscow than North Island.

[CommunistNewZealand]

put your head between your knees and kiss your arse good-bye

[MoscowMaestro]

ТЫ пиздец, настояший больтун. Ты хреня не знаешь о Россий. Пошел ты на хуй, БЛЯДЬ

[CommunistNewZealand]

eat shit and die

[MoscowMaestro]

Gutless murderous fuck, it's a shame you're so far away, or I'd come and cut off your balls with a machete, you cunt.

But your girlfriend said "hi". In fact she said ba-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-ah

Kiwi Stalinists - EPIC FAIL!!!

CUNTS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[CommunistNewZealand]

@MoscowMaestro eat shit and die

[CommunistNewZealand]

Thanks Comrade

[Sonnet1815]

great video

thanks