when i first watched this i was 19 and it rekindled my fear of the dark feel sorry for little kids who are afraid of the dark because now the doctor has given them something to genuinely fear
I think Donna is being extraordinary thick here, how can she travel with The Doctor and not get that The Doctor hasn't "met" River Song yet? Doesn't she understand time travel at all?
I do not like River. I hate how she bounces around thinking she's all sexy, and young, and clever! She's not. "Love Interest" is certainly not the archetype I would've chosen for her.
@doodl3bugg13 Doesn't matter what you like, in the story they like eachother, so what are you going to do about it? Don't be shallow, appearances aren't everything.
@TheCorreon I'm not talking specifically about her looks, I mean she's just too old! For her to be a love interest is weird for me. She's more of a mother figure or even a mentor figure (archetypically speaking) - not a young woman in love.
@doodl3bugg13 Of course it's weird, but don't think like a human, that's the purposes of the series, the doctor isn't human, he thinks like a timelord, afterall he is so old... I get that people don't see it at the start, but things shape as they begin to understand what the doctor and river really are, forget archetypes. ;)
O.k. SURVEY time! Thumbs up this comment, then answer the question: Who (NO pun intended) was the BEST Doctor? William Hartnell 1963–66 Patrick Troughton 1966–69 Jon Pertwee 1970–74 Tom Baker 1974–81 Peter Davison 1981–84 Colin Baker 1984–86 Sylvester McCoy 1987–89, 1996 Paul McGann 1996 Christopher Eccleston 2005 David Tennant 2005–10 Matt Smith 2010–present
"These monsters? Oh yea. They exist in shadow. Pretty much any shadow. You see a shadow? That might be one of them. They might even be in the dust in sunlight, who knows? And they'll just strip the flesh from your bones in seconds. Like that! Boom. Dead."
...Well! Thanks Steven Moffat for guaranteeing that I'LL NEVER SLEEP AGAIN.
As devastating as coming across The Doctor WHEN he's 100% oblivious to her existence is, hopefully she had the perspective that his earlier meetings of her very likely are what helped to make their bond what it was, 'cause while she had to endure something analogous to a loved one w/alzheimer's 'cause of him being someone she knew, well, perhaps better than we'd be interested in knowing about, what were later experiences for her w/him were earlier experiences for him w/her. SEEMED TO understand.
lol, Donna: "WHAT ARE YOU TALKING ABOUT! Do you know him or do you?!" lol I miss her so freaking much. TIP TO THE BBC, MOFFAT AND THE DW WRITERS: bring back Donna!!!!!!!!! She's the best companion ever.
re watching doctor who from the start... its just not the same as the first time you see it. MESAGE TO EVERY ONE, DONT SPOIL THE SERIES FOR YOUR SELF IT WILL RUIN YOUR DOCTOR WHO EXPERIENCE
Donna is so daft! She travels with the Doctor through time and space, has seen so many amazing things and yet cant wrap her head about the doctor meeting another time traveler in the future that he doesn't know now or that theres something on earth we don't know about...
I loved the Nine Doctor since 'Father's Day' and wasn't convinced by the Tenth until he had his monologue in 'The Satan Pit', then I loved him all the way until the end. And then Eleven popped his wet head out of a crashed sideways TARDIS and became Amelia's imaginary friend and I became a fan instantly. The Doctor's my favourite Doctor. Especially when Steven Moffat writes him. Then I'm glued to the screen.
@TerrifeyedProduction He was a bloody good doctor, but i'll admit i did get annoyed by him during his final series. I dunno what it was but i just prefer Matt Smith and Christopher Eccleston. Also i really did not like Donna, not in the Run Away Bride or the 4th series. All in all though he did a grand job of it.
somehow matt doesn't set off the whole 'serious' vibe. he's mostly joking around. I mean don't get me wrong he's funny but he doesn't act like that 900 year old time lord most of the time. sometimes he can get a little annoying
where's the love for river song?? both of the top two comments are about tennant. we get it, i'm a massive fangirl too, but how about alex kingston? she's amazing!
"...just run." Or you know, you could gas the place, set it on fire. It's not like they're invincible. It's a swarm. Some pesticides would do the trick.
Or it would just make them angry. What happens when you make a shadow angry?
@fishswishroxz the one watching the tv? shes what the libraries computer is using as a life source. and so when u see her its just showing her dreams.
This is what Song refers to when she said in the current series that she'll die from the sadness because she will the Doctor that doesn't know her yet, right?
"Nate, you know that dream you have, where you're in that desert and there are people being chased by a giant monster?"
"Yeah."
"Well, that's real. You're real world and everything in it is a lie. The only thing in your life that has ever really existed is that desert and those people."
"..."
"Oh and you're the only one who can save them. Bye!"
@ninthdoctorfan The only reason she looks down on The Doctor is because The Doctor taught her everything she knows he just doesn't know it yet because she's his future and he's her past.
God, I hate when River says "he hasn't met me yet," because obviously he just did. It's just that he hasn't met her for HER first time yet. Ugh. So annoying.
@dancingfreak94 agreed! And everytime she says spoilers don't you just want to slap her? She is so unappealing. she is unattractive and she has an annoying personality. Generally if someone hired to play a part and they aren't very good-looking the writers are usually smart enough to give the character some sort of pleasing personality. She actually encompasses all the worst traits of the former companions. The whining of Rose and Martha, the bitchiness of Donna and the trashiness of Amy.
Wait, so what's-her-face here marries the doctor when he's older, so that means in her time David aged and never regenerated! THAT FOOL! Because of her David didn't grow older as the Doctor because she altered time and so he had to regenerate :( DAMN YOU!
@kingt34 I think what she meant by her 'having' a 'different Doctor' is that she had another Doctor that had regenerated (e.g. it could be Matt Smith now, or the next one - but not David Tennant), rather than an aged David Tennant Doctor.
@MrTranceNinja But, she recognises him? oh well I'm too tired to argue lol. I don't mind too much: the scriptwriters for Matt got decent by the christmas special after a not-so-good start :)
@kingt34 I figured that was because he had the Sonic Screwdriver and had the flamboyant character of the Doctor; it was obvious to her. But hey, it's all for interpretation after all! And I'd call it a discussion, rather than an argument. ;P
@MrTranceNinja yes lol poor choice of words on my end :D and besides I don't see an argument as something that's always bad: It's just a conflict of facts which are compared biasedly to make an un-biased conclusion or something :D (I think I watched the argument clinic Monty Python Sketch too much lol)
I miss RTD's writing. And I know this ep is one of Steven Moffat's buuuuut RTD has said before that he did the rewrites for every episode to make sure everything flowed and the characters were genuine. I love Steven for creating River (she could be my favourite character ever) but at the same time I hate him for creating Amy :| Karen Gillen = Gorgeous, funny and talented. Amy = Annoying and too much of a caricature of 'the feisty companion'. *Sigh* Come back David <3
He focuses more on it being scarey, rather than including the cleaver plots. And don't get me wrong - i ADORE matt smith, but im so used to David being the doctor :'(
I'm only 16! I was introduced to it about two years ago by my grandparents... I'm sorry if I seem shallow but I'm only familiar with the ninth and tenth Doctors. I REALLY got attached to David Tennant's Doctor and I stuck there mentally. Sorry.
I miss David Tennant also, though I do think Matt is an excellent doctor. I am in America and finally was able to watch Series 5! He's really good. A madman with a box!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I balled my eyes out when David Tennant died. I haven't watched Doctor Who since. If there's a Doctor then he must be SEXY like David Tennant. Not icky Matt Smith... I haven't given him a chance, true but I want David Tennant to be the best!
@eviloverlordcaboose Doctor Who is about change. If you cant get to grips with that, then youre clearly not a fan of the show, only its previous lead actor.
This episode was written by the current head writer, and hes a genius.
If you got past the shallowness that your displaying, you might actually realise how fabulous the show is in its current incarnation.
If not, thats fine. Youre ignorance is letting you miss out on what is, without a doubt, the best current show on British telly.
@Furbydude05 Oh yeah, of course. There were Reality Bombs, farting aliens and burping bins. But RTD's era was also about people and in it's centre has a very strong morality. There's a "Don't believe everything the telly says", "Is faith good for people?" or "Fan clubs are great, friends are even better" in every one of his stories. In Moffat's stories, there's usually a innocent kid, a scary monster and in the end, the Doctor makes the monster go away. >> (continue)
@Furbydude05 >> (continued) It's great that you like it. Others don't and it has nothing to do with fancying the lead actor. The change of lead actor is just the most obvious change to casual viewers.
@TessExpelliarmus Really? Because I believe A Christmas Carol was the best xmas special so far. It was intelligent and complex, 10 year olds would have trouble keeping up, just like The Big Bang.
Now I look back at the lousy RTD christmas specials; Clearly aimed at the Lowest Common Denominator. Moffat has storyline behind his incarnation.
@JadesVidz The jumping around in time might be funny, but it makes every cliffhanger ridiculous. The Doctor trapped in a cave with Weeping Angels around him? A future version of him can save him! And he wears a fez, hahaha! The Doctor and Amy threatened to be killed by Daleks? A future Doctor can save them! It's lazy storytelling and might seem complicated, but just destroys the drama. Comedy solutions to threads make Moffat's Who seem like a sitcom with way too much budget.
when i first watched this i was 19 and it rekindled my fear of the dark feel sorry for little kids who are afraid of the dark because now the doctor has given them something to genuinely fear
89deadlock 3 days ago
I miss Tenny so much!
vanessahdepp1 1 week ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I used to have one shadow and then I took an arrow to the knee.. oh wait, my bad, it was the Vashta Nerada!
heapsofalice 1 week ago
Leave it Donna to make you laugh out loud during a sad and serious situation
PotterGal394 2 weeks ago in playlist Doctor Who
daleks aim for the eye stalk sontorans back of the neck vashta nerada run just run
lostsagadragon 3 weeks ago
So scared of doctor who baddies
ShadowCrafterX 1 month ago
creepiest dr who baddie ever
(exept maybe weeping angels)
UberEpicSam 1 month ago
@UberEpicSam Silence are up there too.
CABALCORE100 3 weeks ago
I think Donna is being extraordinary thick here, how can she travel with The Doctor and not get that The Doctor hasn't "met" River Song yet? Doesn't she understand time travel at all?
Merjia 1 month ago
The real world is a lie??? Oh god...that statement makes even the cake seem real.
kaizoisevil 1 month ago 2
I do not like River. I hate how she bounces around thinking she's all sexy, and young, and clever! She's not. "Love Interest" is certainly not the archetype I would've chosen for her.
doodl3bugg13 1 month ago
@doodl3bugg13 she thinks she's sexy? She never said that. But we all know she thinks the Doctor's sexy ;D
firestonegal1 1 month ago
@firestonegal1 And we know that the Doctor thinks she is sexy. :D
(And I have to agree with both of them.)
Ysu73 1 month ago
@doodl3bugg13 Doesn't matter what you like, in the story they like eachother, so what are you going to do about it? Don't be shallow, appearances aren't everything.
TheCorreon 1 month ago
@TheCorreon I'm not talking specifically about her looks, I mean she's just too old! For her to be a love interest is weird for me. She's more of a mother figure or even a mentor figure (archetypically speaking) - not a young woman in love.
doodl3bugg13 1 month ago
@doodl3bugg13 Of course it's weird, but don't think like a human, that's the purposes of the series, the doctor isn't human, he thinks like a timelord, afterall he is so old... I get that people don't see it at the start, but things shape as they begin to understand what the doctor and river really are, forget archetypes. ;)
TheCorreon 1 month ago
@doodl3bugg13 you do know the Doctor is over 900 years old, right?
electricsubmarine 1 month ago
@doodl3bugg13 You must be pretty young. :)
Ysu73 1 month ago
Death metal is strongly advised to be played over this
kepone405 1 month ago
List of things I'm now afraid of.
1. Shadows
2. Statues
3. Water
4. dejavu
6. dust in sunbeams.
Witchielake 1 month ago 5
Vashta Nerada: A new reason to be afraid of the dark.
BlockedYoshi 2 months ago
Pssh, wasn't planning on sleeping anyway......
dervishofwin 2 months ago
stevenscottoddballz 2 months ago
whats this episode called
LightDarkNinja 2 months ago
@LightDarkNinja silence in the library
TheJollynerd 2 months ago
screw the cake!!! the real world IS A LIE!!!!!
LightDarkNinja 2 months ago
"These monsters? Oh yea. They exist in shadow. Pretty much any shadow. You see a shadow? That might be one of them. They might even be in the dust in sunlight, who knows? And they'll just strip the flesh from your bones in seconds. Like that! Boom. Dead."
...Well! Thanks Steven Moffat for guaranteeing that I'LL NEVER SLEEP AGAIN.
JamesOhGoodie 3 months ago 6
@JamesOhGoodie Can't sleep...Vashta Nerada will eat me...can't sleep...Vashta Nerada will eat me...
LucianaShadow 3 months ago
@JamesOhGoodie It's only if they have a big enough swarm though, and that is quite rare.
Gamemaniac92711 3 months ago
@EmmanuelGoldstein2 then why are u even on this? HMM? HMMM?
KoolKid6500 3 months ago
The 10th Doctor is my favourite! I miss those days! Still, 11th is not that bad...
KoolKid6500 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@EmmanuelGoldstein2 that does not change the fact that you are commenting on a video you are not supposed to be watching.
kaizoisevil 3 months ago
@EmmanuelGoldstein2 c**t is a word used for a woman, and I am a man. So that last comment is meaningless.
kaizoisevil 3 months ago
@kaizoisevil IT IS USED FOR BOTH MEN AND WOMEN, SO JUST STOP WITH THOSE COMMENTS! DO YOU REALIZE THAT KIDS ALSO GO ON YOUTUBE?
KoolKid6500 3 months ago
@KoolKid6500 I realize kids go here, which is why I censored it. But the other commenter did not even censor it.
kaizoisevil 3 months ago
@kaizoisevil i know! i just wanted to correct you. i didn't meen anything bad, just to tell you that c**t is a word for both genders.
KoolKid6500 3 months ago
@KoolKid6500 oh, did not know that. Well...anyway...let's ignore that troll.
kaizoisevil 3 months ago
@EmmanuelGoldstein2 and you should be GIVEN HELL by the teselecta.
kaizoisevil 3 months ago
Adverts on a BBC channel. I'm disappointed.
carrickature 3 months ago
"whats in that book?"
"Spoilers"
*the docter opens it*
"Snape Kills Dumbledor"
*facepalm*
shadow11479 4 months ago 5
Not everyone comes out of the dark.
montyfox5 4 months ago
the shadows are moving..OMG my shadows!!!
TheNakamurai 4 months ago
God.... god... ! God damnit! God-god damnit! God damnit god damnit GOD DAMNIT! GOD. DAMNIT!!! WHY'D YOU BLOCK IT FROM SINGAPOUR
COZYTW 4 months ago
@COZYTW Yay It's not block from Malaysia!!!
TheNakamurai 4 months ago
@TheNakamurai ... You ass.
COZYTW 4 months ago
Loved this ep!
hath5712 4 months ago
Wats the episode called
PackManZz 4 months ago
@PackManZz Silence in the Library
tiffychua 4 months ago
Wats the episode called
PackManZz 4 months ago
ah i understand what river song is talking about now!
Museefan812 5 months ago
@EmmanuelGoldstein2 Then go die in a well
DoctorWhoRocks10000 5 months ago
What is the name of that piece of music in the background just before River says "Salad and a bit of chicken, knock yourself out."? I MUST KNOW
DoctorWhoRocks10000 5 months ago
Only the Doctor can hold a lunchbox in one hand and a flashlight in the other and still be epic.
DarkspineSonic759 5 months ago
As devastating as coming across The Doctor WHEN he's 100% oblivious to her existence is, hopefully she had the perspective that his earlier meetings of her very likely are what helped to make their bond what it was, 'cause while she had to endure something analogous to a loved one w/alzheimer's 'cause of him being someone she knew, well, perhaps better than we'd be interested in knowing about, what were later experiences for her w/him were earlier experiences for him w/her. SEEMED TO understand.
fgmPostApocalypticTV 5 months ago
@EmmanuelGoldstein2 So why are you watching this video?
aod2009 5 months ago
i miss David
new guy is good but i love David he is just awsome
DeviilBoy45 5 months ago
lol, Donna: "WHAT ARE YOU TALKING ABOUT! Do you know him or do you?!" lol I miss her so freaking much. TIP TO THE BBC, MOFFAT AND THE DW WRITERS: bring back Donna!!!!!!!!! She's the best companion ever.
shahoney 5 months ago
@shahoney They can't. If Donna ever remembers the Doctor, she will die. (Unless the metacrisis gave her the ability to regenerate, that is.)
Trukknotmunky 5 months ago
@Trukknotmunky - Um, I know... but if you're a good writer, you always find a way to bring character back.
shahoney 5 months ago
I love the line 4022 saved no survivors. It's so cleaver.
darkdorkninja 6 months ago
re watching doctor who from the start... its just not the same as the first time you see it. MESAGE TO EVERY ONE, DONT SPOIL THE SERIES FOR YOUR SELF IT WILL RUIN YOUR DOCTOR WHO EXPERIENCE
THETRUEVOICEOFROCK 6 months ago
Watching this scene is always weird once you've seen the episode, cause you can see the VN swarm enter Dave's suit
slightlyinsaneFTW 6 months ago
I love the flippy thing he does with the flashlight...
slightlyinsaneFTW 6 months ago
Donna is so daft! She travels with the Doctor through time and space, has seen so many amazing things and yet cant wrap her head about the doctor meeting another time traveler in the future that he doesn't know now or that theres something on earth we don't know about...
endless013 6 months ago
"Donna Noble has left the library, Donna Noble has been saved." Repeat 80 million times!!
CrazySmurf111 6 months ago
Donna Nobel ended up being the BEST companion.
Tanru2000 6 months ago 2
@Tanru2000 My favorite is Martha. Martha is the BEST for me. But that's just my opinion.
CrazySmurf111 6 months ago
"I'm The Doctor. We're in the biggest library in the universe. Look Me Up!"
gmerin 6 months ago
Donna Nobel has left the library
Donna Nobel has been saved
reptileman262 6 months ago 4
God, I love River Song
Jhovannoty 6 months ago 32
I loved the Nine Doctor since 'Father's Day' and wasn't convinced by the Tenth until he had his monologue in 'The Satan Pit', then I loved him all the way until the end. And then Eleven popped his wet head out of a crashed sideways TARDIS and became Amelia's imaginary friend and I became a fan instantly. The Doctor's my favourite Doctor. Especially when Steven Moffat writes him. Then I'm glued to the screen.
viridismonasteriense 6 months ago 36
@TerrifeyedProduction He was a bloody good doctor, but i'll admit i did get annoyed by him during his final series. I dunno what it was but i just prefer Matt Smith and Christopher Eccleston. Also i really did not like Donna, not in the Run Away Bride or the 4th series. All in all though he did a grand job of it.
linkofvev 6 months ago 2
Sometimes I think people hate on Ten because so so SO many people liked him. Love for ALL the Doctors!! :3
TerrifeyedProduction 6 months ago 2
Yo momma's a Vashta Nerada!
MrStephenRGilman 6 months ago
David Tennant was the best doctor :)
cutieallyp 6 months ago 5
Run. Run. Ruu!
Jvizzlezz 6 months ago
Akuna Matata
Anthonyk312 6 months ago
hey, who turned out the lights?
UmbraMooh 6 months ago
"Do you know him or don't you?" LOL Donna's hilarious
shahoney 6 months ago
2:24-2:30
Lol! I LOVE Donna so much. She is so... alive!
bigb0sss 6 months ago
used to be scared of this
alexgets98 6 months ago
I've never actually seen this show, but it looks good. Also, that Donna woman is a stupid cow.
SirDakkalot 6 months ago
@SirDakkalot Well, Donna's gone, The Doctor's changed, and now he has a married couple as his companions.
Tiltkid 6 months ago
My god Donna is thick. She knows the Doctor is a time traveler and yet the idea that he meets a "future" girlfriend completely escapes her.
Blasted2Oblivion 7 months ago
@Blasted2Oblivion No it's just jealousy getting in the way of reasoning ;)
smartverity 6 months ago
Doctor Moon reminds me of the guy from the Matrix when he talks about nightmares... wow... Neo...
theamvgirlx 7 months ago
somehow matt doesn't set off the whole 'serious' vibe. he's mostly joking around. I mean don't get me wrong he's funny but he doesn't act like that 900 year old time lord most of the time. sometimes he can get a little annoying
btw love Donna she's umm feisty hahaha
MusiicRoolz 7 months ago
Matt Smith rules.
NoahIdeaFilms 7 months ago
:( mehhh
MusiicRoolz 7 months ago
where's the love for river song?? both of the top two comments are about tennant. we get it, i'm a massive fangirl too, but how about alex kingston? she's amazing!
StaraziaSelin66 7 months ago 2
I want to see chicken legs being devoured by shadow monsters! I don't care about Beaver Falls!
JaceValm 7 months ago
I miss David Tennant, but I love Matt Smith. :)
CanaryKeeper 7 months ago 2
Doctor Who kind of looks like Tobuscus.
72Armed 7 months ago
such a cute little girl
Funkopotomis 8 months ago
"...just run." Or you know, you could gas the place, set it on fire. It's not like they're invincible. It's a swarm. Some pesticides would do the trick.
Or it would just make them angry. What happens when you make a shadow angry?
viridismonasteriense 8 months ago
@viridismonasteriense you die
CreepyButtons 7 months ago
"Hey, who turned out the lights?!"
Alavanderos 8 months ago 42
thats wasnt vashta nerada that was black people
dalektaliban 8 months ago
@dalektaliban That's cute. Now, are you sure you're allowed on the internet without supervision?
imrunningandscreamin 7 months ago
@imrunningandscreamin well my pimp is very stritct about what times i am allowed on the computer
dalektaliban 7 months ago
too*
cupcake7819 8 months ago
david tennant was fantasic but i matt is great to=)
cupcake7819 8 months ago
"daleks aim for the eye stock. sontarians back of the neck. vashta nerada?... run. just run"
bleeask1 8 months ago
whos the girl
the little girl
fishswishroxz 8 months ago in playlist Doctor Who
@fishswishroxz the one watching the tv? shes what the libraries computer is using as a life source. and so when u see her its just showing her dreams.
bleeask1 8 months ago
@fishswishroxz Spoilers.....
HGM1138 8 months ago
It's Melody Pond! Amy's daughter!
lankinator24 8 months ago
This is what Song refers to when she said in the current series that she'll die from the sadness because she will the Doctor that doesn't know her yet, right?
DexwardCuxann 9 months ago
Oh god. I have a psychiatrist. Now I'm scared.
"Nate, you know that dream you have, where you're in that desert and there are people being chased by a giant monster?"
"Yeah."
"Well, that's real. You're real world and everything in it is a lie. The only thing in your life that has ever really existed is that desert and those people."
"..."
"Oh and you're the only one who can save them. Bye!"
"Wait, WHAT!?!"
ZOINKSation 9 months ago 4
1:02 look at the painting in the background of a blonde girl and a wolf is that rose well of course it is
therobloxianfilmgang 9 months ago in playlist Doctor Who 3
@therobloxianfilmgang Badwolf reference maybe?
Heremateyerma 8 months ago
@Heremateyerma i know for definate it it is it was in my necices mag lol
therobloxianfilmgang 8 months ago
BLUE SONIC SCREWDRIVER :DDDDDDDDD
skyflaire 9 months ago
I don't like how rude Donna is to River Song... I guess I've grown quite attached to River Song in the last series! (And I love Donna!)
jaivomi 10 months ago 5
Love the bit at the end!
iwilldiein12seconds 10 months ago
Thank god david tennant is gone - melodrama and jazz hands in every scene, ruined the show.
Sceptilianus 10 months ago
Although she looks down on everyone
ninthdoctorfan 10 months ago
Spoilers starting to annoy me now. She looks down on tennant as the doctor like she's better than him
ninthdoctorfan 10 months ago
@ninthdoctorfan The only reason she looks down on The Doctor is because The Doctor taught her everything she knows he just doesn't know it yet because she's his future and he's her past.
MBGamingLegends 10 months ago
WOOOT! GOT DAVID T!
PhantomTheifKidKaito 10 months ago
did anyone else notice the picture of a blond woman and a wolf 0_o
Jammydodgereater 10 months ago
@Jammydodgereater Where??
Timelord106 10 months ago
@Timelord106 at around 00:51 in the background
Jammydodgereater 10 months ago
@Jammydodgereater OH MY GOD YOU'RE RIGHT!
Timelord106 10 months ago
@Jammydodgereater Did you notice a tall, cylindrical figure with bubbles on the sides right under the two paintings?
AndyRaslan 9 months ago
Okay......*runs off to turn on the lights* You have successfully terrified me of the dark.
SilvaAdrianiel 10 months ago 5
Vashta Nerada:Damn no mayo!!! This is BullShit!!!!!
TheAcer8910 10 months ago
TURN THE LIGHTS OFF ON THIS VIDEO MAN LOL
SimonTalksWHO 11 months ago
God, I hate when River says "he hasn't met me yet," because obviously he just did. It's just that he hasn't met her for HER first time yet. Ugh. So annoying.
dancingfreak94 11 months ago
@dancingfreak94 agreed! And everytime she says spoilers don't you just want to slap her? She is so unappealing. she is unattractive and she has an annoying personality. Generally if someone hired to play a part and they aren't very good-looking the writers are usually smart enough to give the character some sort of pleasing personality. She actually encompasses all the worst traits of the former companions. The whining of Rose and Martha, the bitchiness of Donna and the trashiness of Amy.
sallyjosie 10 months ago
TENNY!
OEBlaze 11 months ago
"Every shadow?" "No. But any shadow."
DaGerman2863 11 months ago
3 people were eaten by the Vashta Nerada.
aod2009 11 months ago 44
nomnomnomnom im under there :D
robloxvidsmaker1 1 year ago 2
Hey look its Hammond from Dead Space.
TheMacedonianGeneral 1 year ago
Catherine Tate ruined the series
DuckFeetProductions 1 year ago
Wait, so what's-her-face here marries the doctor when he's older, so that means in her time David aged and never regenerated! THAT FOOL! Because of her David didn't grow older as the Doctor because she altered time and so he had to regenerate :( DAMN YOU!
kingt34 1 year ago
@kingt34 I think what she meant by her 'having' a 'different Doctor' is that she had another Doctor that had regenerated (e.g. it could be Matt Smith now, or the next one - but not David Tennant), rather than an aged David Tennant Doctor.
MrTranceNinja 1 year ago
@MrTranceNinja But, she recognises him? oh well I'm too tired to argue lol. I don't mind too much: the scriptwriters for Matt got decent by the christmas special after a not-so-good start :)
kingt34 1 year ago
@kingt34 I figured that was because he had the Sonic Screwdriver and had the flamboyant character of the Doctor; it was obvious to her. But hey, it's all for interpretation after all! And I'd call it a discussion, rather than an argument. ;P
MrTranceNinja 1 year ago
@MrTranceNinja yes lol poor choice of words on my end :D and besides I don't see an argument as something that's always bad: It's just a conflict of facts which are compared biasedly to make an un-biased conclusion or something :D (I think I watched the argument clinic Monty Python Sketch too much lol)
kingt34 1 year ago
@kingt34 I'd call an argument a rant of conflicting opinions, which isn't entirely what we're doing, as our ideas are quite similar. But heck. :P
MrTranceNinja 1 year ago
one of my favourite episodes :D
raawron 1 year ago
I miss RTD's writing. And I know this ep is one of Steven Moffat's buuuuut RTD has said before that he did the rewrites for every episode to make sure everything flowed and the characters were genuine. I love Steven for creating River (she could be my favourite character ever) but at the same time I hate him for creating Amy :| Karen Gillen = Gorgeous, funny and talented. Amy = Annoying and too much of a caricature of 'the feisty companion'. *Sigh* Come back David <3
XNancieRoseX 1 year ago
It's not the same knowing that River only knows the Doctor as Matt Smith. :')
thecolevideos 1 year ago
@thecolevideos yeah, sad eh? lol
Scottishgal78 1 year ago
david tennant is way cooler than matt smith
jmc6787 1 year ago 6
The new writers ~dare i say it~ crap.
He focuses more on it being scarey, rather than including the cleaver plots. And don't get me wrong - i ADORE matt smith, but im so used to David being the doctor :'(
falakalak 1 year ago
@falakalak Moffat says that fans like it when Doctor Who gets scary
Furbydude05 1 year ago
@Furbydude05 Yes, once in a while :/ But not every episode - i want some plot twists! :'(
falakalak 1 year ago
I wish DT and RTD would come back and save the show from mediocrity
philyburkhill1 1 year ago 2
@philyburkhill1 RTD is still doing SJA and DT might return for the 50th anniversary special in 2013
Furbydude05 1 year ago
Also, the Vashta Nerada episode of RTD's Doctor Who was written by Steven Moffat.
Furbydude05 1 year ago
@JadesVidz
I'm only 16! I was introduced to it about two years ago by my grandparents... I'm sorry if I seem shallow but I'm only familiar with the ninth and tenth Doctors. I REALLY got attached to David Tennant's Doctor and I stuck there mentally. Sorry.
eviloverlordcaboose 1 year ago 2
this was an amazing episode!
AlwiShahab1 1 year ago
0:01
BuffyCharmedRule 1 year ago
@welcome2my2ndlife Grow up <.<
flamingSSJ4 1 year ago
"what are you talking about? are you just talking rubbish? do you know him or don't you???" LOL love it :')
rachel237linda 1 year ago 3
I miss David Tennant also, though I do think Matt is an excellent doctor. I am in America and finally was able to watch Series 5! He's really good. A madman with a box!
Rikotistic 1 year ago 4
David IS THE BEST Doctor !! <3
Phan801 1 year ago 4
spoilers
elmoloveseverybody 1 year ago
David was the best doctor! :-)
1walkgirl 1 year ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I balled my eyes out when David Tennant died. I haven't watched Doctor Who since. If there's a Doctor then he must be SEXY like David Tennant. Not icky Matt Smith... I haven't given him a chance, true but I want David Tennant to be the best!
eviloverlordcaboose 1 year ago
@eviloverlordcaboose Doctor Who is about change. If you cant get to grips with that, then youre clearly not a fan of the show, only its previous lead actor.
This episode was written by the current head writer, and hes a genius.
If you got past the shallowness that your displaying, you might actually realise how fabulous the show is in its current incarnation.
If not, thats fine. Youre ignorance is letting you miss out on what is, without a doubt, the best current show on British telly.
JadesVidz 1 year ago
@JadesVidz Not every change is a good change.
I watched S5 and the Christmas Special. It feels like it's made to entertain 10 year olds and guys who like Gillan's legs. Not interested anymore.
TessExpelliarmus 1 year ago
@TessExpelliarmus 10 year olds also watch a lot of the Classic Series of Doctor Who, you know. And RTD's version as well
Furbydude05 1 year ago
@Furbydude05 Oh yeah, of course. There were Reality Bombs, farting aliens and burping bins. But RTD's era was also about people and in it's centre has a very strong morality. There's a "Don't believe everything the telly says", "Is faith good for people?" or "Fan clubs are great, friends are even better" in every one of his stories. In Moffat's stories, there's usually a innocent kid, a scary monster and in the end, the Doctor makes the monster go away. >> (continue)
TessExpelliarmus 1 year ago
@Furbydude05 >> (continued) It's great that you like it. Others don't and it has nothing to do with fancying the lead actor. The change of lead actor is just the most obvious change to casual viewers.
TessExpelliarmus 1 year ago
@Furbydude05 NOT JUST 10 year olds, I do as well and im in my 30s
Scottishgal78 1 year ago
@TessExpelliarmus Really? Because I believe A Christmas Carol was the best xmas special so far. It was intelligent and complex, 10 year olds would have trouble keeping up, just like The Big Bang.
Now I look back at the lousy RTD christmas specials; Clearly aimed at the Lowest Common Denominator. Moffat has storyline behind his incarnation.
JadesVidz 1 year ago
@JadesVidz The jumping around in time might be funny, but it makes every cliffhanger ridiculous. The Doctor trapped in a cave with Weeping Angels around him? A future version of him can save him! And he wears a fez, hahaha! The Doctor and Amy threatened to be killed by Daleks? A future Doctor can save them! It's lazy storytelling and might seem complicated, but just destroys the drama. Comedy solutions to threads make Moffat's Who seem like a sitcom with way too much budget.
TessExpelliarmus 1 year ago