yeah, it was pretty canonically inconsistent. the brand new replicator ships erupt upon contact with a few rail bullets while ancient lantean ships can survive several wraith blaster barrages even without shields.
@SupremeCommanderO1 thats because everything they build is made out of them selves.... they are like lego. sepperated they are lose blocks but together they become objects like ships. stealing a replicator ship is abducting replicators to your own base, that would be stupid. infection risk.
replicator ships aren't composed of replicators, they're built conventionally. it's stated by ellis in first strike, "their ships aren’t built from nano-cells."
well its not that the asurans auroras sheilds were flawed its that inorder to power those kinds of sheilds you would need a zpm to power the auroras but the asurans were not all that good at going out side the blue prints as the lantians were (blue prints call for a alternate powersoruce rather than a zpm while the lantians modded there auroras to be powered by a zpm)
the auroras shields were not flawed. only atlantis needed a zpm, but that makes sense from its massive size and its ability to resist virtually any attack. the fact is, whether the asurans had a zpm or not only the 304's and the other aurora should have survived for more than five mins. but sense they did their ships would have had to be seriously dumbed down version, possibly because they didn't feel the need to invest those resources to bet the wraith
plus as far as i know most goauld technolagy is either based on or stolen directly from the ancients . so it would make sense there shields are the same . the weapons work the same way the tollan and asgard (old ones mind) worked . by passing through this gap they could hit the ship directly . the new design in the sheilds made by anubis must have defeated this problem .which leaves me wondering why replicators built so many flawed ships lol
the goauld tech is the equavalent of an ancient 6th grader's science project. the suspected flaws in the goauld tech was not in ancient tech. if anything Anubis's upgrades were a lot closer to ancient tech than before. but lets not we dont even know if those flaws existed as the missiles on the x301 was never tested until after those upgrades
ok this will take a bit of explainin....but i think i get the jist of it . goauld sheilds all work on a corrilating frequency or something which cant be seen by the neked eye .but if something is moving fast enough it can see the difference between the frequency and pass through it lyk they did in the stargate episode where they have them cool bracelets . and the elso mention it when the retro fit the death glider . they talk about arming there missles in the same way
Somehow, I expected so much more from Stargate Atlantis. Of course, this battle was very good, but still something was missing. Perhaps, they needed to show more close range footages of the ships.
also (sorry character limit) i had previously figured that the ships could only enter the same hyperspace window if they had similar engines, from when the daedalus and the orion jumped at different times during a previous episode, i forgot the name, yet almost every fleet i have ever seen in either series shows the ships in the same window. although it doesnt explain when thor entered the same hyperspace route as the replicator ship in sg1 when though both ships jumped at different times, idk
does this episode discredit what was seen in multiple other episodes of both series that multiple ships can enter the same hyperspace window? because i found it weird that both 304's traveled at the same time from earth yet exited hyperspace in different windows and of course later in the battle when fleet all jumped into their own windows. so is it no longer true or was this for some sort of tactical advantage, but this till doesnt explained when the 304 exited hyperspace at the beginning
yet some how they still had enough power to launch drones at atlantis and kill almost ever replactor copy of the atlantis team hmmmm... lol but its possible that that aurora had a zpm then again every one should have if they are turly as powerful as the Lantians after all the Lantians built auroras just a fast as the replactors if not faster and they all had zpm and if am not mistaken isnt it easy for the Lantians / Replactors to make zpms? atlantis had to be self sufecent so its possible
i have to agree with LinnandLina because even one on one with a Asuran aruora and a hive its still possible for the Asuran Aurora to lose while if it were a Lantian Aurora acording to Todd the wraith it would have taken many hives and many months to down a Lantian Aurora
This was a good episode but wern't the aurora class ships beaten far too easly, these ships are supposed to be created by the most advaced race in the knows universe who where millions of years ahead of most in technology!!
where did you get that from? they're build much more faster than the acients could've ever done it, but that doesn't mean that they are weaker. plus they have ZPMs powering their shields. i think the allied forces should have encountered far greater losses... great episode none the less.
Not all of the Replicator Auroras had ZPMs. Although the replicators were able to rapidly buil Aurora class battleships they were unable to produce enough ZPMs to power all of their ships, and therefore the allies were able to destroy them more easily. That and the Replicators use energy weapons and not drones for the most part.(probable due to inadequite power to lauch drones)
I agree with you. However, one could make the case that the Replicators have weakened the Aurora class, arming it with some kind of energy weapon and weaker shields(a missle from a -302 would never have penetrated an ancient warship's shields).
They may have done this because they realized even a ship so weakened would still be a match for the shield-less Hiveships.
Otherwise, the allied fleet would have been easily crushed, and our main character's lives would've ended over Asuras.
thats not exactly true in all cases, i seem to recall the odessey or promethius (sorry for spelling) in sg1 raising its shields before it exited, the same goes with one of the hatak's. (i think) but even then if i am wrong, atlantis and alteran constructed city ships (including the replicators) have to have there shields up in space when they enter, while there in, and when they exit hyperspace.
you are correct in stating that city ships can raise shields while in hyperspace, however most ships cant use shield when in hyperspace or just exiting hyperspace. Thor explaned in Small Victories (Season4 Episode1) that because of the vast amount of power required to travel in hyperspace it is immpossible to have shields. He also states that it takes a ship a moments to switch power from engines to shields when exiting hyperspace. However, this problem can be overcome with the aid of a ZPM.
ah well pointed out. But then im sure one of the earth ships was given an order to raise shields before they dropped out of hyperspace, which may show a flaw in the advanced asgard technology. cause like you said the ancients over came the problem with the ZPM. and the Ori 'appear' to never have their shields down unless they have landed. So it might only be a problem with certain types of technology. sorry i cant remember the name of the ship, possibly most likely then Daedalus.
which season was this? If it was a later season it may have been that the ship was equiped with a ZPM found by the atlantis expedition. However, I would need to know the episode to know.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
This is beyond the comprehension of realistic approah thus declaring it a fantasy adored by those who are squadaring their time and effort in devotion to events that have never taken place and never will.
Gee, it only says "From the episode Be All My Sins Remember'd" in the discription; might be some sort of suggestion that it's from that episode, maybe, perhaps, possibly?
There are two ships in the foreground, which one are you referring to? One is a wraith hive ship, which is getting fired upon by an upclose Aurora class Lantian designed warship.
The hive ship is indeed organic, a high city-sized bioengineered construct, working mainly through a mental connection with the wraith crewing it. Not very high tech though, no shields, just a very regenerative hull; and the hyperspace ability is rudamentry at best. Designed to last thousands of years, with several thousand crew members usually led by a queen or commander.
Yeah that was a replicator ship, why would anyone think that the Atlantis Expedition would order the destruction of a ship that is allied with them? Plus, you see the hot/badass commander lady after the skirmish, which was on the Traveler shit the entire time.
That is a Replicator ship. Not a traveler ship, or the orion. The 2 ships that are attacking it are out battle cruisers. Latter in the video it is a Traveler ship. The allied fleat of 6 hives, 2 battle cruisers, and aurora class ancient ship, and the travelers are fighing the replicators.
AND THEY CANCELLED THIS FOR UNIVERSE?!?!?!
plasm2 6 months ago 2
First thay would never have given the aourora class ship to the fucking travlers!
Second thay must have find blueprints and skimatiks for bilding a aourora ship.
And i never understod why thay dident beam some ZPM from the replicator to the ship thay could just beam the whole ZMP console.
All just so we earthlings cant get some cool anciant tec...
unknowna2 1 year ago
I recongised this tune the instant it started.... I played Halo too much lol
Wikkiter 1 year ago
How hard is it to find just the original clip... jesus christ...
Doorstopper5867 1 year ago
why didn't we make more ships....?
Or 1 big ship. a super ship or something...
Stanna5x 1 year ago
7 Hives, 5 Travellers junk-ships and 2 304's VS 30 Ancient War Ships + drone platform on the surface....
Does anyone else feels that this battle should have ended completly different way ?
Wierzbovsky 1 year ago
yeah, it was pretty canonically inconsistent. the brand new replicator ships erupt upon contact with a few rail bullets while ancient lantean ships can survive several wraith blaster barrages even without shields.
zzxcvb98 1 year ago
Halo 3 Music
SVFreedomFighters 1 year ago
yes!!
soldierdenley 1 year ago
is the music from the halo 3 soundtrack?? lol
blazinghawk666 2 years ago
good video bad music
jessikaort 2 years ago
why use the sound trak of halo for this its gota be one of the breaking penjamin songs would suit it alot better
sounds more war sci-fi
skycaprobb 2 years ago
Nice Video, but I miss the sounds of the battle...
Winnywindl 2 years ago
which episode and season no. is this episode
stickbombstudios 2 years ago
halo music with SGA...awesome lol
TheRunner217 2 years ago
all those replicator ships and we didnt steal a single one of them! C,mon!!!!!!!!!!!!
SupremeCommanderO1 3 years ago 11
lol i was thinking the same thing
apollo967 3 years ago 3
this was a perfect opportunity to beef up their forces
SupremeCommanderO1 3 years ago 2
i doubt it
the aurora ships can be tracked by the asurans
and attempting to take over a ship that can destroy you with 1 volley is extremely difficult
angrykid616 3 years ago
yea but the arora class ships were empty
SupremeCommanderO1 3 years ago 2
and they had a limited amount of time to destroy the planet before a super blob attacked them
and after dealing with super blob they had a very limited amount of time before the planet blew up
there wouldnt have been enough time to get aboard their ships let alone take control of one
angrykid616 3 years ago
It was safer not to, just in case some were still aboard
emyro134679 2 years ago
Comment removed
hedjede 2 years ago
i dont think they can steal a replicator ship, its made from replicators.
hedjede 2 years ago
it can be made from replicators cuz then it would be pull down towards the planet
starwillf6 2 years ago
i think the same thing pal
zidanetilo 2 years ago
@SupremeCommanderO1 thats because everything they build is made out of them selves.... they are like lego. sepperated they are lose blocks but together they become objects like ships. stealing a replicator ship is abducting replicators to your own base, that would be stupid. infection risk.
Stanna5x 1 year ago
replicator ships aren't composed of replicators, they're built conventionally. it's stated by ellis in first strike, "their ships aren’t built from nano-cells."
zzxcvb98 1 year ago
well its not that the asurans auroras sheilds were flawed its that inorder to power those kinds of sheilds you would need a zpm to power the auroras but the asurans were not all that good at going out side the blue prints as the lantians were (blue prints call for a alternate powersoruce rather than a zpm while the lantians modded there auroras to be powered by a zpm)
gothicn 3 years ago
the auroras shields were not flawed. only atlantis needed a zpm, but that makes sense from its massive size and its ability to resist virtually any attack. the fact is, whether the asurans had a zpm or not only the 304's and the other aurora should have survived for more than five mins. but sense they did their ships would have had to be seriously dumbed down version, possibly because they didn't feel the need to invest those resources to bet the wraith
anubis9910 3 years ago
plus as far as i know most goauld technolagy is either based on or stolen directly from the ancients . so it would make sense there shields are the same . the weapons work the same way the tollan and asgard (old ones mind) worked . by passing through this gap they could hit the ship directly . the new design in the sheilds made by anubis must have defeated this problem .which leaves me wondering why replicators built so many flawed ships lol
adam4evelyn 3 years ago
the goauld tech is the equavalent of an ancient 6th grader's science project. the suspected flaws in the goauld tech was not in ancient tech. if anything Anubis's upgrades were a lot closer to ancient tech than before. but lets not we dont even know if those flaws existed as the missiles on the x301 was never tested until after those upgrades
anubis9910 3 years ago
ok this will take a bit of explainin....but i think i get the jist of it . goauld sheilds all work on a corrilating frequency or something which cant be seen by the neked eye .but if something is moving fast enough it can see the difference between the frequency and pass through it lyk they did in the stargate episode where they have them cool bracelets . and the elso mention it when the retro fit the death glider . they talk about arming there missles in the same way
adam4evelyn 3 years ago
Somehow, I expected so much more from Stargate Atlantis. Of course, this battle was very good, but still something was missing. Perhaps, they needed to show more close range footages of the ships.
thomasturb 3 years ago
Kinda like some of Battle of Endor?
Seeing the battle right from off the top of one of the ships
Usul573 2 years ago
looks better with multiple windows ... scifi is alotta eye candy
bocky54100 3 years ago
also (sorry character limit) i had previously figured that the ships could only enter the same hyperspace window if they had similar engines, from when the daedalus and the orion jumped at different times during a previous episode, i forgot the name, yet almost every fleet i have ever seen in either series shows the ships in the same window. although it doesnt explain when thor entered the same hyperspace route as the replicator ship in sg1 when though both ships jumped at different times, idk
anubis9910 3 years ago
does this episode discredit what was seen in multiple other episodes of both series that multiple ships can enter the same hyperspace window? because i found it weird that both 304's traveled at the same time from earth yet exited hyperspace in different windows and of course later in the battle when fleet all jumped into their own windows. so is it no longer true or was this for some sort of tactical advantage, but this till doesnt explained when the 304 exited hyperspace at the beginning
anubis9910 3 years ago
the planet was blowing up and about to destroy the solar system ,its every man for him self
WLordnDRanch12 3 years ago
yet some how they still had enough power to launch drones at atlantis and kill almost ever replactor copy of the atlantis team hmmmm... lol but its possible that that aurora had a zpm then again every one should have if they are turly as powerful as the Lantians after all the Lantians built auroras just a fast as the replactors if not faster and they all had zpm and if am not mistaken isnt it easy for the Lantians / Replactors to make zpms? atlantis had to be self sufecent so its possible
gothicn 3 years ago
NO MORE MUSIC WERE IS STARGATE NOT THIS
eemland745 3 years ago 2
i have to agree with LinnandLina because even one on one with a Asuran aruora and a hive its still possible for the Asuran Aurora to lose while if it were a Lantian Aurora acording to Todd the wraith it would have taken many hives and many months to down a Lantian Aurora
gothicn 3 years ago
which episode did Todd say the Lantian Aurora's were more powerful than the replicators Auroras?
wilkoman3 3 years ago
nice =] i love the song haha halo 3 right?
Foehammer321 3 years ago
yeah, it's from when the humans and eleites go through the portal to the ark
8XanderX8 3 years ago
thanks =]
Foehammer321 3 years ago
This was a good episode but wern't the aurora class ships beaten far too easly, these ships are supposed to be created by the most advaced race in the knows universe who where millions of years ahead of most in technology!!
wilkoman3 3 years ago
i think because they were taken by surprise or something so they did not have chance 2 raise their sheilds maybe
xvader7725 3 years ago
and the replicator auroras are much weaker then the real ones. btw i love auroras watch my vids!
Eddifrillson 3 years ago
where did you get that from? they're build much more faster than the acients could've ever done it, but that doesn't mean that they are weaker. plus they have ZPMs powering their shields. i think the allied forces should have encountered far greater losses... great episode none the less.
kamikazeboed 3 years ago
yes but the replicators copied the ancient technology but they will never be able to make such great ships like an ancient aurora
LinnandLina 3 years ago
Not all of the Replicator Auroras had ZPMs. Although the replicators were able to rapidly buil Aurora class battleships they were unable to produce enough ZPMs to power all of their ships, and therefore the allies were able to destroy them more easily. That and the Replicators use energy weapons and not drones for the most part.(probable due to inadequite power to lauch drones)
Ryac3 3 years ago
I agree with you. However, one could make the case that the Replicators have weakened the Aurora class, arming it with some kind of energy weapon and weaker shields(a missle from a -302 would never have penetrated an ancient warship's shields).
They may have done this because they realized even a ship so weakened would still be a match for the shield-less Hiveships.
Otherwise, the allied fleet would have been easily crushed, and our main character's lives would've ended over Asuras.
knightofavalon86 3 years ago
i know how the first 1 was beat so easy because when ships cum out of hyperspace there sheilds r off line
xvader7725 3 years ago
thats not exactly true in all cases, i seem to recall the odessey or promethius (sorry for spelling) in sg1 raising its shields before it exited, the same goes with one of the hatak's. (i think) but even then if i am wrong, atlantis and alteran constructed city ships (including the replicators) have to have there shields up in space when they enter, while there in, and when they exit hyperspace.
OriChild 3 years ago
you are correct in stating that city ships can raise shields while in hyperspace, however most ships cant use shield when in hyperspace or just exiting hyperspace. Thor explaned in Small Victories (Season4 Episode1) that because of the vast amount of power required to travel in hyperspace it is immpossible to have shields. He also states that it takes a ship a moments to switch power from engines to shields when exiting hyperspace. However, this problem can be overcome with the aid of a ZPM.
Ryac3 3 years ago
ah well pointed out. But then im sure one of the earth ships was given an order to raise shields before they dropped out of hyperspace, which may show a flaw in the advanced asgard technology. cause like you said the ancients over came the problem with the ZPM. and the Ori 'appear' to never have their shields down unless they have landed. So it might only be a problem with certain types of technology. sorry i cant remember the name of the ship, possibly most likely then Daedalus.
OriChild 3 years ago
which season was this? If it was a later season it may have been that the ship was equiped with a ZPM found by the atlantis expedition. However, I would need to know the episode to know.
Ryac3 3 years ago
i believe it was in the later episodes of season 3 of atlantis. but im starting to wonder whether it was a dream or not ^^
OriChild 3 years ago
yeah but the city ship does not have 2 move around alot realy its just the home of the ancients they dont send them ships into battle or anything
xvader7725 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This is beyond the comprehension of realistic approah thus declaring it a fantasy adored by those who are squadaring their time and effort in devotion to events that have never taken place and never will.
usmanbr 3 years ago
Then why did u watch it?
apollo967 3 years ago 10
@usmanbr You dont realise that the US goverment might actually be able to conceal something like this... theres 'Classified' files for a reason
ADFcope 1 year ago
what is the name of this episode???? which episode is it????
Reidid15 3 years ago
Gee, it only says "From the episode Be All My Sins Remember'd" in the discription; might be some sort of suggestion that it's from that episode, maybe, perhaps, possibly?
s2k997 3 years ago
It's from the Season 4 episode Be All My Sins Remember'd.
MrEvil37 3 years ago
im watching it right now, i just saw the part when they destroyed the first ship
Eddifrillson 3 years ago
im watching it right now, i just saw the part when they destroyed the first ship
Eddifrillson 3 years ago
1.06, what ship class is that. Its heavily contrasted to other designs
Venatorial 3 years ago
There are two ships in the foreground, which one are you referring to? One is a wraith hive ship, which is getting fired upon by an upclose Aurora class Lantian designed warship.
s2k997 3 years ago
I meant the organic looking ship. I guess that's the hive ship?
Venatorial 3 years ago
The hive ship is indeed organic, a high city-sized bioengineered construct, working mainly through a mental connection with the wraith crewing it. Not very high tech though, no shields, just a very regenerative hull; and the hyperspace ability is rudamentry at best. Designed to last thousands of years, with several thousand crew members usually led by a queen or commander.
s2k997 3 years ago
ok, thanks for the information.
Venatorial 3 years ago
Nice video! Loved that episode and great use of Halo 3 music.
MrEvil37 4 years ago
I do bolieve he was trying to identify the allied Aurora class battleship, not the first one or the Replicator ones.. Hint Hint guy's..
Jackneill45 4 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
awesome, check out my sga vid
DarthHaurn 4 years ago
Yeah that was a replicator ship, why would anyone think that the Atlantis Expedition would order the destruction of a ship that is allied with them? Plus, you see the hot/badass commander lady after the skirmish, which was on the Traveler shit the entire time.
Roraeth99 4 years ago
7 hives not 6 and there are multiple traveler ships along with the ancient ship.
Keerakh23 4 years ago
That is a Replicator ship. Not a traveler ship, or the orion. The 2 ships that are attacking it are out battle cruisers. Latter in the video it is a Traveler ship. The allied fleat of 6 hives, 2 battle cruisers, and aurora class ancient ship, and the travelers are fighing the replicators.
felix3322 4 years ago
which season is this???
Zeljko9292 4 years ago
Season 4
apollo967 4 years ago
It's the Traveller's Aurora Class warship, not the Orion.. Orion was destroyed in Season 3
Jackneill45 4 years ago
the aurora was destroyed that ship is the Oryan
junksaver1 4 years ago