Paul McCartney & Eric Clapton - Concert for George: Something

[makdelete]

My sweet George :)

[c4r50n1]

@makdelete Wrong song. 

[marcstov]

@manatthewindow that's a perfect way of explaining how i WANTED it to feel like if i was there. it was a true gig...you get the feel from the video that these guys wanted to be there and would have done the same thing if no-one was in the crowd. good post.

[kn1ght0fcydon1a]

This is very emotive. If i was Paul there, i could not have lasted, i would break in tears there

[TheDug0]

RIP George, our beautiful friend. Hare Krishna!

[ftbnubs123]

Paul McCartney is belting a B nearly an octave above middle C in chest voice at age 60? I guess it's a perk that comes with being one of the greatest musicians of al time...

[InsaneNightmarePanda]

they did there own thing. they inspired every generation to be artistic and not hide who they are. jonas just inspire people to change the channel or buy a better album like the beatles. There icons that show how the average person can make a difference and even with all their faults still by admired. because they overcame their faulta and improved. can anyone honestly say that they've cried laughed and felt true deep emotions when listening to eminiem, tinie tempah and Jonas brothers? no? see.

[InsaneNightmarePanda]

@RockingJamboree

they might be revolutionary in some ways. but most movies are in 3d now so there's that. and all the beatles were unique and special and held moral views that are important even in today's society. oh and they had songs that were good and still are. Jonas brothers won't be remembered and there songs won't be studied or covered by generations. they'll be forgotten which is sad but true. The beatles were revolutionary because they didn't sell out they didn't give in to the media

[abridgedfan107]

anyone else have a tear in their eye right now?

[CinCin421]

And another weird observation..Eric Clapton is singing a song that george wrote about his wife....that Clapton stole from him....does anyone NOT see the irony???? LOL

[CinCin421]

It's blasphamy to even say the Beatles and the Jonas brothers in the same conversation! Bite your tounge....

[lovelymelly87]

@CinCin421 What who would compare those two? Jonas Brothers are at the bottom.

[md47bot]

sorry i mean life

[md47bot]

RockingJamboree needs a live or an ear or two maybe

[juse88812]

who is on lead guitar?

[roccosixxx]

what a kick in the ass is that bullshit?? compare the jonas who?? with the fabolous BEATLES!!! OMFG!! I CAN´T BELIEVE IT!! why this people exist?? men go to the army and die in the desert PLEASE GOOOO!!!

[frankycr]

hahahaha who's the poor, stupid, ignorant or deaf that compare those terrible kids with THE beatles?

[sensai61]

i think its insulting to the beatles to compare them to the jonas brothers. no band will ever be as good as the beatles

[Samsonous]

whoaaaaaa whao! slow down there! the beatles are legendary. but that is extremely opinionated. it is fairly obvious this douche is wrong comparing the jonas bros to the beatles, but the stones, the who, jimi? you cant stack them upon one another.

[lovelymelly87]

@sensai61 Here Here

[bannedspencer]

@sensai61 Jesus christ, tell me someone didn't do that :)

[c4r50n1]

@sensai61 Or as bad as the Jonas Brothers.

[anamanza]

no comparen the jonas brothers con the beatles xk no se parecen en nada

[QueenHeartKiss]

what i dont know is why people compare the jonas brothers to the beatles

[bughead3]

ah...some people are so blind and ignorant that it is pointless to even argue with them. I think someone confusing the Jonas Brothers with the Beatles falls in this category.

[allaalskaranna]

their music isn't even comparABLE, so it's gotta be the hair or something like that :P

[plmwlz1126]

There is ZERO comparison, that's not even a funny joke.

[RockingJamboree]

The Jonas Brothers are young. Charming. Tuneful. Funny. Very appealing. And they are just at the start of their careers. Yes, comparisons with the Beatles are premature. But seriously, "Love Bug" is a more complex and melodic song than "Love Me Do" or "Please Please Me." Even the Beatles developed over time. The Jonas Brothers may develop into even better musicians and writers than they are now. Maybe not. For now, their success and talent are remarkable, especially for kids so young.

[LennieMelvin]

Um... I don't think I can trust myself to say anything right now...

[RockingJamboree]

As soon as you decide that the Beatles are sacrosanct, beyond comparison, once you canonize Lennon and/or Harrison as Saints, you trap their music like a butterfly under glass, a fly in amber. It's just a museum piece, a thing of the past. It's wonderful, but it's dead.

The Beatles weren't Saints or Gods or Mythic Heroes. They were four lads with charm, talent, hutzpah and vision. Their music a living challenge and inspiration worthy of comparing anyone against.

Besides, isn't Nick dreamy!

[starwarsfreak1111]

@RockingJamboree Dead? Void of life, rhythm and such? You may have a far more complex view over what their music represents to us than I but music never dies. Each time I or anyone elses taps a foot, claps their hands or belts out one of their songs it's very much alive and kicking. Their music is timeless and you will notice that eventually, until you start seeing not only the Beatles but all music that is enchanting you cannot pass judgement.

[RockingJamboree]

@starwarsfreak1111 I didn't call the Beatles' music dead. Read my comment carefully and you will see that I'm arguing the exact opposite. The Beatles music is effervescent, full of life. I just don't see how seeing the Beatles as GREAT means you have to, by definition, dislike the Jonas Brothers or any other musician. I also don't think that thinking the Beatles were great shouldn't mean that you can't see where they were flawed and imperfect.

[cherrypop1771]

@RockingJamboree

Preach it! They were very talented human beings!  Their music is evergreen! They put Liverpool on the map!

[jts001]

pure gibberish "rocking" jamboree. pure gibberish. talking right out of your arse.

[googenshlagen]

Fine, more complex. But look at the absurdly complicated music that we've had since then.

What the Beatles did for their time, you can almost not compare with anyone, except a few truly revolutionary bands.

The Jonas brothers have not created anything new. At all.

And their music is very basic.

Please. Stop.

[RockingJamboree]

The Jonas Brothers have created a new 3-D Concert Movie!

Look, the Beatles were amazing, visionary and unique. A great band. But, it's pointless saying they are "the best band ever" or "NO band can EVER compare to the Beatles!" That's as silly as saying the Jonas Brothers are already as good. We'll have to wait for the third JB album to judge for sure.

Yes, the Jonas Brother's music is VERY basic. It's heavily Beatles influenced! Have you heard their cover of "Hello Goodbye"? Good stuff!

[googenshlagen]

Hahaha. Well, there are few bands in history who have changed music as much as the beatles. And plus, what they did in the 60's, and how they really brought it to the world, no one did that.

Look, I was just replying to a comment. I totally respect your opinions, and I have no interest in getting into a youtube debate about the Jonas Brothers vrs. the Beatles.

But there is no way to say that they will be able to do what the Beatles did.

[RockingJamboree]

Saying, "NO band will EVER be as good as the Beatles" is silly. EVER is a really LONG time.

It's like saying, "NO one will ever be as great a musical genius as MOZART!" OK, so what. That won't stop some people from enjoying the Beatles more than Mozart! Or vise versa. You can argue, but there's no saying their joy or opinions aren't valid.

Who do you like more Jonas Brothers or Hudson Brothers? I wish the JB would get their own TV show! They could have Ringo on as a Guest Starr!

[googenshlagen]

A: That's the second time you say that I said that...but I haven't so...

B: I'm done arguing. Good day.

[RockingJamboree]

A: I never said that you had said it. I just said that saying it was silly. You did say, "you can almost not compare with anyone, except a few truly revolutionary bands."

B: I never started arguing, because we can agree that the Jonas Brothers are a truly revolutionary band! Nick is the dreamy one. Joe is the mystical one. And Kevin wears ascots. They should call him "Ascotto" Jonas!

And the new JB move is in 3-D! Even "HELP" wasn't in 3-D! So, truly revolutionary! Good day! :)

[laybackinthapark]

Awesome tribute from two legends to another, you could tell they put alot of feeling into that one.

[laybackinthapark]

Cant forget RIngo either.

[colmanaucoin]

his son is so like him

[rync0r]

thaks for high definition the video is realy good ................beatles forever

[feoinfunroe]

Thank you.

[ciarandel548]

Notice Macca's harmony with Clapton...... true class! a wonderful version of a lovely song. I think George would have approved with a smile.

[manatthewindow]

I don't think I've ever seen a better concert and I've certainly never felt such a fantastic spirit sustained throughout a musical performance.

An unbelievably good gig.

[montereypopfestiva67]

@manatthewindow It was a show not for fame, money, or power. It was a show that was about the music and spirit, which is how George would have wanted it. Fantastic show, RIP to "the quiet Beatle"