Added: 1 year ago
From: 2009Eclipse
Views: 28,716
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (146)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • great great song!

  • RIP John. What a beautiful song. If you guys like this song, you will love the new Ashtar Command CD - American Sunshine..it sounds a lot like this and it's on iTunes

  • everytime i hear this song, i get tears in my eyes...john, you were a true friend, it don't matter if you were real or not. Some of you will say this this person got problems, but it's the way i feel...Rest In Peace John!

  • I miss playing this wonderful game. Oh the memories!

  • lol a cowboy respawning bwahaha.

  • I played the game thrice and I NEVER heard this beautiful peace of music :'O?

  • @LetYaRock It's in the credits :')

  • @HeartsOfTheHorse yea.. see... I skipped those xD

  • 1 dislike from satan.

  • Comment removed

  • Johns death doesnt make since hasnt john killed over 10 people surrounding him at once before??I did enjoy killing edgar ross after he died i shot him some more like what he did to mr. marston

  • i hate the ending.... he could've just ran away like abigaile and jack did...

  • @aboshanak real men dont run 

  • @aboshanak Thats basicaly a "what if" for undead nightmare. because uncle dies and becomes a zombie and you guys get away.

  • @aboshanak I AGREE but apparently he wanted redemption for his sins throughout the game and he figured this was the only way

  • @zoza4 and bill williamson

  • I kiled Edgar Ross with 200 shots!! that feels good!

  • 188 people salute you on this, millions more around the globe. R.I.P John Marston.

  • come back john :'(

  • :'(

  • goddammint, well now i just ruined the ending for myself, love the song anyway

  • RockStar was blasted with "Why did John Die" mail so thats why undead nightmare was invented Great game Great game.

  • RIP john, we all love and miss you.

  • Not ashamed to say this ending made me cry - twice.

  • they could have used a better song for the credits like...

  • Hey at least he is alive and i think STAYS alive in undead nightmare dosent that lighten people up a little

  • @killing0dager he becomes a zombie

  • @hitbot5 a zombie with a heart

  • The ending why must he die he was the best man ever why Rockstar why did you do it to John Marston John will be missed

  • @ocdrumjr if John didnt sacrifice himself, his family would be in danger from being killed by the goverment so he did it for Jack and Abigail :(

  • yo this song is great it made my little sister and my younger sister crying

  • Any game with a story that makes me cry goes into my personal top 5..this game is one of them

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • @killing0danger: Yeah, this song should have really been played when

    SPOILER: John died SPOILER END

    but that would have made me cry even harder XD It's not only the music that makes you feel sad. It's the lyrics, too. A "deadman's gun" and "giving you a reason to fight"... it nearly describes in what situation the player was at the end *sniff* But never the less it's a GREAT song!

  • THE ONLY PERSON WHO DISLIKED THIS VIDEO WAS EDGAR ROSS

  • @zoza4 And the second one was Victor Vance from GTA cuz he's jealous

  • @zoza4 and his deputy..

  • @zoza4 and Ducth and bill.....javier escuella thought this was actually a good song

  • Heres to John Marston.

  • when john marston dies i think this song should be played

  • @killing0dager Yup.

  • @killing0dager that would be great!! the only problem is...I would die drowned in my own tears!!!

  • @matodragonespor5000 i would die as well but i almost drowned in tears when he died without this song

  • Favorite Song of 2010 for me

  • Rockstar has made i really great job with the GTA series, but Red Dead Redemption was better than all of the GTAs. The Story was more interesting and dinamic, it has a really well made dramatic end.

    John Marston was a really interesting protagonist and likeble character, you keep hoping everithing to go ok for him and he have a happy ending. The game makes you feel really sorry for him at the end. You don't get that 'likeability' from CJ or Niko in the GTAs games.

    Sorry for my bad english.

  • wow, awsome soundtrack :'( thanks for upload x

  • in my eyes red dead redemption is the best game i have ever played. the story was amazing, i cried when john died at the end, the missions really helped me make a connection with john and through out the game i was rooting for him. the music is phenomenal, the game play is top notch. this game really will stay with me for the rest of my life.

  • WHO THE FUCK DISLIKES? Y U NO LIKE?

  • also sonst lässt mich sowas ja kalt aba das......als der da erschossen wurde....da war ich den tränen nahe

    John Marston........R.I.P

  • A game which I wish wud never end brill game the song brought a tear to my eye a real meaning to the song

  • The ending evokes a trully humanity aspect to video-games. It's impossible don't feel moved by this ending, and by this game. A true masterpiece, a ending made of real, human sadness, pain, and loss. And, kill Ross by the river, is priceless.

  • That game's a really smart analysis of how the law doesn't prevent chaos at all, it just provides a different brand of it. Poor John found that out the hard way.

  • @JackBrindelli indeed indeed i wish i could have killed all those law guys >/

  • should have used a tactical insertion

  • I am glad to hear i am not the only one who cried at the end of Red Dead

    :'( R.I.P John Marston

  • why didnt john just respawn ;_;

  • @peterados cus he rage quit :P

  • @peterados He did. He respawned in heaven.

  • @UncleSpankification Or hell, depending on how you played through. :P

  • @UncleSpankification No in Undead Nightmare! :D

  • @SparrowGTA I'd rather not think he came back as a hideous, monsterous rotting corpse. That sort of defeats the purpose of killing him anyway.

  • The death of John Marston is really the second video game character that actually 'grieved' the death of. You know what I mean? The first was Chomper from Ace Combat 5. Oh and I cannot properly express my enjoyment for this game and song. Hit the nail on the head.

  • It's always good when a game makes you feel sad at the end.

    John truly was a hero, and it was saddening to see his end. It just shows that even the most noble of men will still fall.

  • Sadly i didnt cry at the end. i was too busy boiling with rage at those cops. First act as john marston: Genocide of blackwater

  • @YTargain (Jack can kill edgar mate)

  • fantastic game, great soundtrack, awesome gameplay, overall, its a true game experience that brings you into its world...and another note-i know alot of people say modern warfare 2 is the best game, but that game is not as true to gaming as red dead. don't get me wrong, i like mw2 but red dead takes the cake! 'nuff said

  • i also cried at the end

    but credit 2 rockstar for another great ending to another fantastic game

  • :'(

    R.I.P. John Marston.

  • I WANT JOHN MARSTON BACK.

    I MISS HIM.

    I Cried at the ending. :'(

    BRING HIM BACK :@ :'(

  • :'( sober

  • The multiplayer is WTF compared to the singleplayer. Multiplayer has so many bugs (aka loading probs).

  • he was one of the few heroes i really was able to feel like him and now this....

    R.I.P. John Marston

  • I cried for a long time when he died. I felt like i was there.

  • I recon that this is a sad game because you go through a lot with John Marston and in the end your connected with him and when he dies its sort of like loosing a good friend. The ending was probably the only way to end a perfect game. R.I.P John Marston (Original bad ass of America)

  • @codfish776 Unbelieveable what videogames can do these days.

  • @codfish776 Spoiler alert man, haven't beat the game yet :(

  • agree wit all of u, best game ending ever and i didnt expect that...buts its such a good game! BUY IT, EVERYONE OF U

  • a epic end for an epic Game <3

    One of the best games ive ever Played

    Ein episches ende für ein episches spiel <3

    Eins der besten spiele die ich je gespielt habe

    und das beste ende überhaupt <3

    Thanks to Rockstar

  • where in this game this song appears? 

  • @aleigor in the credits

  • @aleigor the credits, tip you havent completed the game until the credits roll, look in the blackwater train station for a stranger task when you think you have finished it.

  • I know between God and The Big Bang. Us humans are just a lost cause, we will never know, we try so hard to prove our superiority yet the fact remains, every good thing comes to an end. The reality of it is humans worry too much about dying and instead of trying to make this world great they just follow along like jews thinking they will get more money, when they could just use their time wisely and appreciate a little more, and begin to understand, this is it, one chance.don't be a stereotype!

  • @KoolProductionsInc I agree with what you say except for the Jew remark. Its human nature to want more.

  • this song really gets me thinking about the true meaning of life and whatnot, bravo. I really like this song.

  • Fitting in so many ways.

  • this game & MGS made me cry.

  • Fucking R.I.P JOHN!!!! :(

  • This song makes me regret the stupid things I did in the game without thinking that got innocents killed.

  • @forman1200 This is why when playing I said to myself What Would John Do?

  • Blessed are the peace makers.

  • tthis is a tune wish i knew somewhere to download it

  • The contrast between John's acts and his motives is so beautiful - He's acting like a badass but he remains a true hero because he knows it's not right and the only reason he's doing it being to save his family. I think that thought is what makes this song so beautiful..

  • @TigerMilitia. Not all his friends lived happily eva after. *********SPOILER********** Seth found his treasure, marshal retired to get away from hellhole (armadillo), Landon Ricketts died in his sleep, Irish died by trapping himself in an out house, Abraham Reyes became mexican president and also became a tyrant dictator (which John warned him not to become) and Jack is now leading the life his father fought to protect him against (vigilante). thats all i can think of atm.

  • @Marblez3 how did you find that out?

  • @Marblez3 Actually, Irish shot himself by accident while pissing.

  • @Marblez3 how did you find that all out?

  • pt2

    and luck won't save them tonight

    they've given reason to fight

    and the storms you've been chasing

    about to rain down tonight

    and all the pain you've been facing

    about to come into the light

  • your hand's upon a deadman's gun and you're looking down the sights your heart is worn and the seams are torn and they've giving you a reason to fight and you're not going to take what they've got to give and you're not going to let them take your will to live cause they've taken enough and you've given them all you can give
  • Comment removed

  • amazing song, amazing game, it's truly affected me, best game i've ever played.

  • @BillinZootz where in the game this song appears?

  • i ahd to restart my game at 99.9% complete because mo van barr was bugged for the last outift.. :(

    ah well i'm replaying as evil john now.

  • R.I.P. John - wished you taught Jack to drink whiskey and to smoke as well. His voice needs more character.

  • theres 3 endings,but i picked the 2,

    1.john dies

    2.john lives

    3 john lives but acts like hes dead and dresses up as some one els

  • @cuzzythewolf2 How do you get the different endings?

  • @MrBrandonXP go to water stone and youll then go to the train station and then you meet a dude then go to remeber my family, somewhere on the map.

  • @cuzzythewolf2 Where is waterstone and WTF is all this about alternate endings?

  • @Clon3Troop3r he means go to the train station at blackwater there will be a federal agent there speak to him and just go to where it says on the map it's not an alternate ending it's the just rest of the ending

  • @cuzzythewolf2 *SPOILER* You said there is 3 or 4 different endings theres only 1... john does and you become jack...

  • I thin it's kind of strange that a video game can have a way better original song then majority of the movies made today. If not just this song, the whole soundtrack even.

  • This song made me ride straight up to blackwater to finish those b*tches off once and for all :-)

  • after i finished it i loaded the game to play as john

  • trying to find the lyrics somewhere online. I've listened to the song many times and I can sing along to it but I'd still like official lyrics for it. xD

  • best game ive played on, miss playing as john but jacks just as good :)

  • @iRadiiCaLIIx ending made me sad and mad why couldnt they keep it as the perfect life on the farm?

  • You're gonna carry that weight,cowboy

  • :_: manly tears

  • @REfan001

    defo manly tears

    i had a few i admit... the fact that God himself told John where he was gonna be buried made it creepier.. "this really is a beautiful spot john...."

    i'm glad john's friends lived on well finding riches or retiring as per the paper.

  • The ending made me cry manly tears.

  • @THNF89 im suer it did that to us all. it did that to me.

  • @THNF89 I did too Bro.

  • @THNF89 who the fuck cries manly tears? you can say it you cried like a bitch we r all men here and we've all been there its OK :)

  • @THNF89 The ending made me angry, and i just wanted to kill all of those bastards!!

  • R.I.P john

  • One of the few songs that you can cry to while remaining male.

  • anyone know for the guitar chords and lyrics for this song please ?

  • the only game that i felt sorry for someone(John).... game of the year!

  • @kbullay i felt really sorry for john to and if you really look at him he knew he was gonna die but it was for his family id do the same thing

  • R.I.P John. M

  • @Waffles250

    Put a spoiler you stupid fuck

  • @TheHardestMusic who cares dude its a game a good one at that anyways why did u fucking read this and if u havent finished the game by not or reached that part ur retarded 9 year old cuz all of us have finished and anyways eveey one who finished the game and read my earlier comment would agree with me so im the stupid fuck?

  • this song pretty much sums up the story of read dead redemption

    R.I.P John Marston

  • R.I.P John Marston

  • Looking forward to the second one (hopefully). This game rocked and this song topped if ott nicely

  • @blue1985stfu this was the second one....the first was red dead revolver

  • This song is fantastic. And Red Dead Redemption is the best Free Roaming game i ever played. Period. :)

  • Just beat the game.

    Fucking love the song.

  • @cifeso me to

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more