Added: 1 year ago
From: marytravain
Views: 36,906
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (181)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Shut up about One Direction, this isn't even their song.

  • It annoys me when people say "I like this better than McFly's version, or One Direction's version" First of all Tom's was the original and it is a DEMO so is this. It was written to be given away to another artist. But I have to say that the song doesn't really work for one direction. It was clearly written for a girl to sing.

  • I know that Tom wrote it and Carrie sings it good, but I love One Direction and I don't think it's fair how people are saying they don't deserve the credit because even if they didn't write it they made it there own and they sing it just as well as Carrie and Tom, so please be respectful.

  • I feel sorry for Carrie & Tom in a way because One Direction are getting all the credit for this song, and most One Directions fans don't even know Tom wrote it. Amazing cover, better than One Directions to be honest.

  • see the dislikes bar, yeah me neither:) ♥

  • this song is perfect for carrie. i absolutely adore mcfly and 1D, but Carrie definitely wins on this.

  • i like more the one directions version. but this is cool

  • 1.) Carries Version

    2.) Mcfly Version

    (1D havent got the talent to be on this list)

  • @SuperSuiteJess Can I marry you ? 

  • @mama73250 why ahah?

  • Carrie should of kept this song! 1D have killed it, not gonna lie :)

  • I love Mcfly soo much but

    Carries version is the best

    then one directions version

    then mcfly.

  • 1. Carrie's version

    2.McFly's verson

    3. One direction's verson :)

  • In all dictionaries, near perfection there's written: The Fletchers :) AMAZING TALENT!

  • @Claudia15123 NEAR?!

  • Se escribe perfección se dice Fletchers

  • I like all versions but I think Carrie's is the best one :)

  • I love her voice and Tom AND ONE DIRECTION!

  • really good :)

  • she should go to x-factor or something like this :O her voice is just ... incredible

  • @lilJeess She's already signed so doesn't need to :)

  • This is soooo good!!!!

  • love carrie's voice =) Tom's too haha

  • she is way better than one direction, tome should have kept the song... x

  • she is AMAZING, i love 1D but i love Carrie too... i love the 2 versions

  • wow she has an amazing voice

  • but this version is sooo much better

  • i dont like one direction but i think this song is awesome

  • I'm a die hard directioner, but this version is SO much better! beautiful Carrie! xxx

  • i love carrie, i love mcfly, i like one direction. this is the best version :-)

  • I absolutely love this version better than the one direction one :) she sings amazing...

  • Carrie, you're my idol.

  • I love this so much, Carrie is my idol♥

  • This will forever be better than one direction. Carrie has such an amazing voice and she needs a singing career and the recognition she deserves!

  • I don't know which version I prefer, I like them both! Carrie, you sound amazing :)

  • I think that Carrie is AMAZING, but I prefer the version of One Direction♥

  • both carrie's version and the one direction version are amazing, but one direction changed the meaning of the song. They should of kept the meaning of the song more like the original

  • Dear Carrie Fletcher...

    Y U NO MASSIVELY FAMOUS LIKE 1D..?

  • carrie needs her own, massively successful music career. she is AMAZING.

  • OMG! both versions are really good! love them all...

  • I don't think we all need to say which one is better. They are all equally good, and different in their own way. :)

  • Where can I find a karaoke cover??

  • amazing

  • this is amazing :)

  • awesome song! i know Tom sang this before. this is also awesome! awesome siblings! <3

  • The piano and the guitar are so McFly. It's an awesome song and I like One Direction's version but I think that Carrie's one is so much better

  • i could listen to this over and over again!!

  • OMG!! this is on one direction's album!!:O well done Carrie!! what a song to be on someone else's album! love both versions!Xx

  • I think Carrie should sing this with One Direction and/or  be the 'love interest' in the video if they make one.. Hehehe

  • i love how one direction, and mcfly sort of blended and made something beautiful.

  • QUELLA DEI 1D E' UNA COVER O COSA?! O.O

  • omg this is the 1D song tom wrote for them! waaaaaaaah ><

  • Oh my God. I like 1D but this is SO MUCH BETTER!

  • This is Tom and Carries song all the way Tom wrote it after all! bit gutted hes given it to One direction :S I prefer Carries version all the way! awesome song from my Tom Fletcher!!!!!!!! dont actually think this will ever truely 'be' one directions song...

  • Carrie totally rocks this song

  • One Direction song hehhee

  • i love that this is 1d's song now.

  • @LeighMariana

    Thank you so much (:

    McFly! Haven't heard of them for so long!

  • This is Carrie's song in my opinion. She rocks it.

  • I'm a big fan of One Direction, but this is just amazing! every time I hear it by One Direction I just think Carrie's version is better,

  • @123enoughsaid me too!!!

  • What has this vid to do with a 'Tom'? And which Tom is meant?

    I like that Song! Never heard of it before, but now.. (:

    Amazing that 1D will sing it!! <3

  • @HappyPixieLilly Her brother, Tom Fletcher of McFly wrote this song - you can hear him in the background at times :)

  • OMG. 1D gonna sing it ! can't wait!

    so excited (:

  • OMG THIS SONG IS AMZAYN AND ITS GONNA BE EVEN MORE AMZAYN WHEN ONE DIRECTION GONNA SING IT.

  • @nicoleproductionz No. Carrie's version is better. And that's coming from a 1D fan.

  • @ToffeeMeggy I agree with you

  • @nicoleproductionz no, i love one D but i love carrie a tinie winie bit more so no.

  • ONE DIRECTION IS MAKING THIS THEIR SONG!

  • La voz de Carrie es sorprendente! Me encantaaa!! y claro su hermano es mi idolo como no me iva a gustar jaja Te quierooo Carrieee!!!

  • I like One Direction but Carrie is amazing! I really like her voice and this song is just perfect for her!

    I want, I want, I want...her album!!!

  • carrie sing really awesome *-*

  • I love Tom's version . I love One Direction's version (well the bit I've heard from it) But Carrie's will always be my favourite ..

  • When One Direction sing this it may have the same lyrics and music but it's gonna be completely different!

  • as much as i love One Direction, it's going to be really hard to sing it better than Carrie does. she's brilliant! :)

  • This song is going to be on the Album of One Direction...I think thats the secret plan....just sayin ;)

  • @missischaos Yeah but I don't think it was originally written for them though. He gave them the song :) I'm actually very excited to hear the full song by 1D as the preview sounds awesome :D

  • OMG Tom Fletcher wrote this for One Direction 0.o it´s gonna be awesome!!

  • @Sneeuwwitje393 actually he gave it 1D after Carrie sang it soo..  ~*hopette forever*~

  • @McStephStar :)

  • Tom Fletcher wrote this for one direction and its on their new album

  • This song is for One Direction! I can't wait, gonna be awesome!

  • haha you can really hear the mcflyness in this song :P

  • Apparently Tom wrote this for One Direction and it's on their new album. Ugh, fuck that, I'm gonna just listen to this version, 'cause I don't want this song to get autotuned and fucked up by them.

  • @1235532155 wth? they are all talented and CAN SING. shut up

  • @13julinda if they are all that talented they wouldn't be using autotune that much. And you can't tell me to shut up dear. :) I used to be a big One Direction fan, I followed them all the way through XF and loved their performances. But their music now is just, not good. That's my opinion, and if your opinion is that you think it's the most amazing music you've ever heard then fine. :)

    But MY opinion is that Carrie's voice is better than all of their voices combined. So yeah, you shut up. :)

  • carrie, this is your best cover!<3 you should do more mcfly songs!! maybe POV?<3

  • Comment removed

  • been looking for this song forever! :D

  • Comment removed

  • THE FLETCHER FAMILY IS THE BEST OF ALL.

  • Saint Fletchers !! ♥♥♥

  • thumbs up if you can hear tom's voice

  • LOVE LOVE LOVE

  • I like this version better :)

  • I love this song!Love Carrie`s voice....god,so much talent in one family =))

  • wow this is amazing!!

  • so i think that carrie is recording an album with tom's help. maybe she was signed to super records. that would be awesome!

  • HOLY CRAP. I'm speechless. Again. WOW!

  • I swear this song was written for Carrie. I must say it is better than McFly's <3

  • great voice

  • Comment removed

  • I would LOVE for them to properly record this together and release it. I want an official McFly/Carrie duet really bad.

  • I love this song <3

  • Ok so I love Tom but this is much better...

  • me encanta su voz es muy bella ojala tenga mucha suerte!! :D

  • Wow her voice sounds so good here! It's a shame she doesn't have many other songs properly recorded it makes such a difference :) x

  • What idiot disliked it? She is amazing! I love this song so much!<3

  • i love mcfly's version, but i think the song is better suited for a female voice. this is awesome!

  • Half of these views are from me!

  • I'm really excited to find out what are Tom's secret projects.

  • i love this song is amazing congratulations for your voice carrie =)

  • My theory is that Tom's written a musical or something of the sort and Carrie's involved (starring?) in it. She's definitely involved in one of Tom's secret projects ^_^

  • @gymkhanaJunkiex I agree. It would be sooooooo awesome!

  • @gymkhanaJunkiex ooooh it would be SOOOO lovely!!! :O *o*

  • I prefer this version to McFlys ;)

  • Awww! I really love the way she sing! <3

  • 1 person don't want, don't want, don't want :D

    this version is awesome!

  • someone dissliked it..........hhhmmmm there wrong!

  • Either Tom and Carrie wrote it together, or Tom wrote it for Carrie.. but it's Carrie's song.. and I love it.

  • It fits perfectly for Carrie's voice! lovely!

  • is Carry a singer? has she got any cd?

  • @Nereea07 she hasn't got any cd's but she has a load of covers on her youtube channel :)

  • @Nereea07 she is a singer, but she hasn't been signed yet (who knows why, she's awesome)

  • Love this

  • why did you use a picture up her nose

  • I've only heard Tom's version on SC before, but this is good!! :)

  • my mouth was wide open through the whole song :OO AWESOME!!! i absolutely love it *-* <3<3

  • Guys, I think she wrote it with Tom and that one sing by Tom is the demo for her just to show her how was it like. And then they recorded it properly later.

  • no no no! this is originally carries MCFLY COVERED IT

  • my god i got the goosebumps!! she's epic

  • i like mcflys version but its too high 4 tom and this is origionally carrie's btw :)

  • Anyone have the chords?

  • i'cant believe that rebecca black has more views than Carrie's...she's way better :)

  • @juambelz55 who's rebecca black?

  • @michelle80025 you don't wanna know... believe me

  • @juambelz55 i've done my research and i feel sorry for her - death threats...she's 13!

  • @michelle80025 no shes 18 soom to be 19th but stiil

  • @xRayRay2x oh lol but even so death threats is harsh people need 2 get out more

  • @michelle80025 oh i though you were talking about carrie opps but yeah no sould have death threats

  • Comment removed

  • @juambelz55 Rebecca black got so many views because people don't like it.. which is soo stupid! xx

  • How can so much Talent belong to one family?? Carrie and Tom can sing, its the same with Danny and Vicky.. they're all amazing!!!

  • lol how embarrassing.... tom sings higher than her

  • the family is oviously talented!!

  • great work!

  • Shes good :)

  • Woah... o.o

  • this is better than mcflys version lol

  • OMG HER VOICEEE IS SO AMAAAAAAAAZING !!!!!!!!!! O_O FLETCH'S BROS ARE THE BEST !

  • It's a shame she doesn't have a record deal.

  • Tom Fletcher as a brother and a Amazing Voice, Is there anything else a girl could want?...

  • Fletchers rules !

  • ME ENCANTA!!

  • think im in love!

  • i think she does it better than McFly! ahaa xxx

  • awesome.

  • I wish I was her... :( :)

  • muahaha no dislikes (Y)

  • wow this is awesome <3 she has an amazing voice ! who knew? xx

  • Yeah, this song fits best to Carrie. But I think McFly did a decent cover as well :)

  • it's better than mcfly's version

  • @Joana7793 both are great, she's got a beautiful voice

  • @Joana7793 well its origianly her sing eg girls songs and the only man who can sing girls song is justin bieber and that not a gud thing :L mcfly r still awesome

  • @MissRandom007 i didn't say MCFLY was not awesome I LOVE MCFLY, is just i prefer this version of the song but that's my opinion of course (:

  • I love she singing this song! It's amazing!

  • It's gotta be in the genes.

  • this is soo wonderful!!

  • she is amazing :D woohoo

  • is she covering this or are mcfly covering her?!

  • @lADyLEahG She's Tom Fletcher's sister. idk if it's hers or theirs. But I think Tom wrote it for her.

  • @lADyLEahG She.s covering it. It.s McFly's technically, but they scrapped it.