I personally heard that because Talat Mehmood insisted that his voice was not matching for Mnajo Kumar rather for Dilip kumar so he quited and let Mahindar kapoor sing this song in the film.
Rafi Saab's & Mahendra Kapoor's voices are so clear & melodious in LOW OCTAVE,really incredible.Just ask a singer how difficult it is ?Jagjit Singh could sing in Low Octave beautifully but never used to go in Higher Octave.Here one must accept that Mahendra Kapoor could sing in nice flow and without strain in lower Octave as well in Higher Octave.Versetile singer should be able to sing easily in all 3 octaves & in fast rythems too.After all Mahendra Kapoor got Vocal training from Rafi Saab.
Rafi voice overwhelms and subdue mahendra kapoor's voice, listen with gd head-phones on, rafi hasmore dh, purity and maturity and sweetness, be impartial
THE TRUTH IS THAT RAFI SAHAB SHOULD HAVE SUNG EVERY OUNCE OF THIS SONG BY HIMSELF ONLY. NOR TALAT OR MK SHOULD HAVE SUNG WITH HIM. ITS A NICE SONG AND WE WANT TO HEAR ONLY RAFI SAHABS HEAVENLY VOICE IN IT. NO ONE CAN SING EWITH RAFI SAHAB. NEVER EVER WAS ANY ONE EVEN ONE PERCENT OF RAFI Sahab. wallahi he was god gifted
The original song was recorded in Rafi+Talat voices. But Manoj insisted on Mahendra as playback! However, the sales rights to the songs are owned by the producers. So Naushad explained that the Talat version will sell better. An experiment was conducted using both versions. And the listeners preferred the Talat version! This how the soundtrack has the MK version while the records were released with the Talat version!!
This has been flagged as spam show
I personally heard that because Talat Mehmood insisted that his voice was not matching for Mnajo Kumar rather for Dilip kumar so he quited and let Mahindar kapoor sing this song in the film.
STARLIGHTZIA 2 months ago
Rafi Saab's & Mahendra Kapoor's voices are so clear & melodious in LOW OCTAVE,really incredible.Just ask a singer how difficult it is ?Jagjit Singh could sing in Low Octave beautifully but never used to go in Higher Octave.Here one must accept that Mahendra Kapoor could sing in nice flow and without strain in lower Octave as well in Higher Octave.Versetile singer should be able to sing easily in all 3 octaves & in fast rythems too.After all Mahendra Kapoor got Vocal training from Rafi Saab.
sureshshah3 3 months ago
its rafi and mehndra kapoor
shashibhatt 6 months ago
No one can even come close to Rafi sahab as far as playback singing is concerned.
vinaysudan61 7 months ago
Rafi voice overwhelms and subdue mahendra kapoor's voice, listen with gd head-phones on, rafi hasmore dh, purity and maturity and sweetness, be impartial
kulsoompasha 1 year ago
MEHENDRA KAPOOR SOUNDS VERY TALENTED AND EQUAL IN THIS SONG TO RAFI.
MrDSOLANKI 1 year ago
THE TRUTH IS THAT RAFI SAHAB SHOULD HAVE SUNG EVERY OUNCE OF THIS SONG BY HIMSELF ONLY. NOR TALAT OR MK SHOULD HAVE SUNG WITH HIM. ITS A NICE SONG AND WE WANT TO HEAR ONLY RAFI SAHABS HEAVENLY VOICE IN IT. NO ONE CAN SING EWITH RAFI SAHAB. NEVER EVER WAS ANY ONE EVEN ONE PERCENT OF RAFI Sahab. wallahi he was god gifted
FAQEERAHMED 1 year ago
Dear Nickkohri
Thanks for resolving this mystery and the interesting information.
Regards
Swaminathan
swaminathan63 2 years ago
The original song was recorded in Rafi+Talat voices. But Manoj insisted on Mahendra as playback! However, the sales rights to the songs are owned by the producers. So Naushad explained that the Talat version will sell better. An experiment was conducted using both versions. And the listeners preferred the Talat version! This how the soundtrack has the MK version while the records were released with the Talat version!!
nickkohri 2 years ago
Manoj's playbacking Mahendra kapoor, not Talat.
In an other version Rafi & Talat sing together
simlock62 2 years ago