"Rare case of Ian Gillan handling a Mark 1 song?!?!" More like he ate it!! every mark I song that Gillan sang is better than the original. After him singing it i never listen to mark I original.
@Dimagg1973 thanx!, fantastic version of fantastic song, fantastic picture of the faboulos 5, paice king of flowerpover, and glover not even recognized by me, but i can see it clearly now, what a heavy heavy group sitting on these stairs in 1969
@theyorkshirewhites so at least you would agree that it would have been a rather special pic, if it had been gillan and simper, at the samer pic !? but u r right, it was too bad i could not recognize glover, because it clearly is glover. gillan and simper are freinds, by the way. both pretty wonderfull persons.
As to who was better singer, I think there are many songs that show Ian to be awesome singer and not just a screamer. Actually even when some think he screams in CIT he actually sings there and not screams.
@Dimagg1973 - let's not get caught up in the better than/worse than, they are both brilliant in their own ways. I so wish that Rod would resurface and let his fans show him the love he has earned. This business of the 80s bogus Deep Purple is long ago now, let it stay dead and buried. If Rod resurfaced we could perhaps get a tour of the cream of Deep Purple from all marks, one that perhaps even Ritchie B would embrace and participate in. Anyway, raise a glass to both Rod and to Ian!!
@Dimagg1973 - thanks for noticing and for caring. My favourite Mark One album is the third one, though I do love their version of Help! from an earlier one. As well as the album version of Bird Has Flown, I love Lalena on that album too.
@oberfour I agree...this version is missing the deep moody vocal tone Evans brought to it, don't get me wrong -I like Ian Gillian quite a bit however Rod Evans vocals had a certain charm and tone that fit the mk 1 material far better the Gillians voice...although I'm thinking Ian Gillians voice might work on Emeretta
rod evans never screamed like that......i think this was first put out on an E.P. with grabsplatter and another track (smoke....?) in '77 or '80......another record you lend to somebody and dont get back.......eh, Phil?
What a great idea..get all past Purple members to do a concert..say 3 or numbers from each line-up..then "Smoke"..as an encore with the vocalists and guitarists each taking a turn.
Wow, when i saw the name of this video I thought it would be a crappy bootleg, but OMG this is amazing. I knew it would be cool 'cause Gillan would be singing MK1 stuff, but the quality is perfect. Is it a studio recording?
BBC Deep Purple Mark 2 recorded this track for the BBC on 11 August 1969 and it was released as a track on New Live and Rare vol 3 in 1980. It remained (officially) unreleased on CD until the 6 CD set in 2002.
I really want this on CD but the box set is so expensive when you find it. Wish they'd bring out a single or double CD of rarities that includes this. I've got the Mark One version but I'd just like this for completion's sake.
The version with rod evans will always be the definitive version of this song, but this version is fantastic! they should've released this. kinda strange, though, its like a cover version, but by the same band
I have the Live In Montreux 1969 Live album, and Gillan does a damn good job on 'Kentucky Woman' there, which they do as an encore. Apart from that one, they also do 'Mandrake Root', 'Wring That Neck' and of course 'Hush' from the MK.I era. Heard rumours of that they rehearsed 'River Deep, Mountain High' with Gillan, but never knew they ever did this. Thanks for sharing!
Stranger still that this song is just over 40 years old but still breathes life and contemporary excitement in it..... If I had a band I would record it.....
A show with all the members of Deep Purple would be a super show. Imagine Satriani, Blackmore and Steve Morse on stage with Nick, Roge and Glenn. ( Maybe Boiln's brother will honor Tommy?)
I would love to hear Burn or Mistreated with David, Glen, Blackmore, Lord and Pice again, that would be a treat man.
Or Chasing shadows with Nick and Rod with the rest of Mark 1.
This thought has crossed my mind as well. Every lineup performing a handful of songs each. Would be a huge success. Too bad Tommy Bolin and probably Rod Evans would never do such thing.
There's no denying that this version is ballsy and has guts, but I prefer the slower, more thoughtful version with the Rod Evans vocals and the extended keyboards from Jon Lord.
I wish Rod Evans was still around today, I'd love to see a Purple show with all lineups having a set each. Good enough for Yes to do just that, good enough for Purple. But it'll probably never happen, can't see Ritchie Blackmore giving up the folk trail for DP again, can you?
You are probably right! I doubt Ritchie would do it. Rod Evans wherever he is, would never do it. I think Nick Simper would. I bet Glenn Hughes and JLT would do it as well. I also think Lord would do it, if it was only for a couple of shows. Satriani never did anything with the band (studio). He did excellent Live renditions of 'Ramshackle Man' and 'Knocking At Your Back Door' though. Sadly Tommy Bolin wouldn't be there either.
its not ian singing here its rod fuck me ,, get real
gazzzza 3 weeks ago
this pic, this band, this day, this year.
all i can say is:
drive carefully!
SUPERMANfromMETROPOL 1 month ago
oh wow!
monkeycrud 1 month ago
A Heavy Pop song , It sounds good / Not flooded out with That church Keyboard sound.
rothsuede 1 month ago
amazing.....!!! I think the original vocalist sing it before.... but in 1:30 , oooh yes... It's Gillan...
toekeejoe 2 months ago
Comment removed
kyleschmidlin 2 months ago
"Rare case of Ian Gillan handling a Mark 1 song?!?!" More like he ate it!! every mark I song that Gillan sang is better than the original. After him singing it i never listen to mark I original.
Bluznjacha 2 months ago
1:30!!!!!!!!
Bluznjacha 3 months ago
Ian really gave this song a whole new level !! :-)
peace
Bluznjacha 3 months ago
VERRY GOOD
4533GEORGE 8 months ago
wow, amazing version
antipop412 1 year ago
wow, amazibg version
antipop412 1 year ago
The guy most to the left at the picture at 1:14 , is that glover or simper?
if it is simper this pic is quite special!!!
SUPERMANfromMETROPOL 1 year ago
@SUPERMANfromMETROPOL Its Glover, around the time of the Concerto.
Dimagg1973 1 year ago
@Dimagg1973 thanx!, fantastic version of fantastic song, fantastic picture of the faboulos 5, paice king of flowerpover, and glover not even recognized by me, but i can see it clearly now, what a heavy heavy group sitting on these stairs in 1969
SUPERMANfromMETROPOL 1 year ago
@SUPERMANfromMETROPOL
Use your brain superman..Simper wasn't in purple when Gillan was, Gillan is in the picture so it has to be Glover.
Then again any real Purple fan would know Glover without having to ask.
theyorkshirewhites 1 year ago
@theyorkshirewhites so at least you would agree that it would have been a rather special pic, if it had been gillan and simper, at the samer pic !? but u r right, it was too bad i could not recognize glover, because it clearly is glover. gillan and simper are freinds, by the way. both pretty wonderfull persons.
SUPERMANfromMETROPOL 1 year ago
@SUPERMANfromMETROPOL
It would have been special, but not very likely.
theyorkshirewhites 1 year ago
@SUPERMANfromMETROPOL I can see why you ask, that doesn't look like Glover but it is sadly. Loved Nicked Simper
exc123 1 month ago
@exc123 I agree, but also love Glover. everything about mark 1 is tip top.
i would not have changed mark 1, but look what happened when they did.
SUPERMANfromMETROPOL 1 month ago
@SUPERMANfromMETROPOL Good Point
exc123 1 month ago
@exc123 Thanx!
SUPERMANfromMETROPOL 1 month ago
Life long Gillan fan. Gillan is the MAN!!!
mikemonti66 1 year ago
I'd like to hear David Coverdale and Glenn Hughes cover this track! Wish Mk.3 had played a couple of Mk.1 numbers.
GreenerHill 1 year ago
This is so GREAT>>>>>>>>>EXCELLENT!!!!!! \m/
IanGillanGurl 1 year ago
that is not deep purple and there is no gillan on it.
mathemator 1 year ago
from which lp or cd is taken? maybe a bonus track? please let me know, thanks!
Kankweezler 1 year ago
Ian Gillan greater screamer. Rod Evans greater singer. That is the main difference. God bless we had a Mrk1 Purple to enjoy.
oberfour 1 year ago
@oberfour
I agree that Mark 1 was magical,.
As to who was better singer, I think there are many songs that show Ian to be awesome singer and not just a screamer. Actually even when some think he screams in CIT he actually sings there and not screams.
listen to CIT original in Rock.
Rod did good job in the Mark 1 era
Dimagg1973 1 year ago
@Dimagg1973 - let's not get caught up in the better than/worse than, they are both brilliant in their own ways. I so wish that Rod would resurface and let his fans show him the love he has earned. This business of the 80s bogus Deep Purple is long ago now, let it stay dead and buried. If Rod resurfaced we could perhaps get a tour of the cream of Deep Purple from all marks, one that perhaps even Ritchie B would embrace and participate in. Anyway, raise a glass to both Rod and to Ian!!
EmeraldGemstar09 1 year ago
@EmeraldGemstar09 Couldn't agree more,
great reply, yes a tour of all the members would have been something.
Like it or not we are running of time, the lads are not getting younger.
Maybe Tommy brother Johnny Bolin can be in his stead for couple of good songs.
Dimagg1973 1 year ago
@Dimagg1973 - thanks for noticing and for caring. My favourite Mark One album is the third one, though I do love their version of Help! from an earlier one. As well as the album version of Bird Has Flown, I love Lalena on that album too.
EmeraldGemstar09 1 year ago
@EmeraldGemstar09
Rod cannot sing DP songs now, after the bogus tour he signed an arrangement to say he would not.
theyorkshirewhites 1 year ago
@theyorkshirewhites That was sad part. I think changes in the agreement can be done if he stepped forward.
After all today only the drummer Ian Pace is original from the Mark 1 era.
Dimagg1973 1 year ago
@oberfour I agree...this version is missing the deep moody vocal tone Evans brought to it, don't get me wrong -I like Ian Gillian quite a bit however Rod Evans vocals had a certain charm and tone that fit the mk 1 material far better the Gillians voice...although I'm thinking Ian Gillians voice might work on Emeretta
MightySaturn5 1 year ago
@oberfour
I hope you're not suggesting that all ian gillan did was scream..if you are you need to open your ears.
theyorkshirewhites 1 year ago
This would have been hard for Gillian to sing because he sings higher than Evans.
l mean the song was written around Evans vocals style .
l didn't know Gillian could sing that low .
Bit like asking Evans to sing Child in time i suppose.
greg0058 1 year ago
rod evans never screamed like that......i think this was first put out on an E.P. with grabsplatter and another track (smoke....?) in '77 or '80......another record you lend to somebody and dont get back.......eh, Phil?
VUPdingCLICK 1 year ago
Ian Gillan rocks!!!!
Banner1979 1 year ago
@Banner1979
You are correct.
This was the EP and it also fitured Freedom an aoutake from Fireball.
I never could figure why it wasn't included as its a great song.
Dimagg1973 1 year ago
@Dimagg1973 Freedom was cool. You can get this version of Bird Has Flown in a Deep Purple box set that has lots of rarities from 1968-76.
Banner1979 1 year ago
You are rigth!!!!...thanks man!!
eddyhunter69 1 year ago
thats gillan singing for definite
theneil100 1 year ago
This is not Ian Gillan its Rod Evans!!!
eddyhunter69 1 year ago
@eddyhunter69
You are wrong.
This is Ian Gillan, Rod with all the respect didn't have this range of voce and the melodic screaming (singing so high) As Ian Gillan could.
Did you even listen to this version of the song? ANd did you listen to the version with Rod which I love very match.
Dimagg1973 1 year ago
True, it's Gillian !
Lucian078 1 year ago
@Lucian078
It's NOT GILLIAN.....It's GILLAN.
FOOL !!
theyorkshirewhites 1 year ago
@eddyhunter69
Definitely Gillan...Evans could never scream like that.
theyorkshirewhites 1 year ago
@eddyhunter69 its clearly gillan...
shotguy1 1 year ago
This is cool! Thank you for posting this
MRINSTRUCTIONBOOK 2 years ago
This is Ian Gillian singing. Rod Evans had a smoother voice with out the scream.
oberfour 2 years ago
Thanks for posting this. I have this but it's being sung by Rod Evens. This is really a rarity. Thanks Clive.
Lobsterlady2362 2 years ago
3 or 4 numbers *
seventiesclassic 2 years ago
What a great idea..get all past Purple members to do a concert..say 3 or numbers from each line-up..then "Smoke"..as an encore with the vocalists and guitarists each taking a turn.
Leave all animosity and ego's at home !
seventiesclassic 2 years ago
This is definite proof of the metamorphosis to the In Rock sound. The rest is history. Thanks.
1lemurian 2 years ago
Yes, great way of putting it. That pivotal turn of the decade, when rock went from hard to harder.
charlessavarese 1 year ago
Wow, when i saw the name of this video I thought it would be a crappy bootleg, but OMG this is amazing. I knew it would be cool 'cause Gillan would be singing MK1 stuff, but the quality is perfect. Is it a studio recording?
simonsblackmore 2 years ago
BBC Deep Purple Mark 2 recorded this track for the BBC on 11 August 1969 and it was released as a track on New Live and Rare vol 3 in 1980. It remained (officially) unreleased on CD until the 6 CD set in 2002.
Unofficially circulated on BBC Stew Bootleg.
Dimagg1973 2 years ago
I really want this on CD but the box set is so expensive when you find it. Wish they'd bring out a single or double CD of rarities that includes this. I've got the Mark One version but I'd just like this for completion's sake.
EmeraldGemstar09 2 years ago
@EmeraldGemstar09
In 1982 I think there was a CD released called rare, live etc
It has this song on it and also couple of other out takes like Freedom.
Dimagg1973 2 years ago
Comment removed
jcevap 2 years ago
This song was one of my faves to play live
s2trash 2 years ago
When Ian Gillan screams at 1:30 something happens inside my brain...
sudhavishwanath 2 years ago 2
Every one in this band called Deep Purple is a star.
A band of Stars
Dimagg1973 2 years ago
BEST ROCK VOCALIST OF ALL TIME
purplerocks666 2 years ago 2
I agree with you man!!!!!!!
IanGillanGurl 2 years ago
and Freddie Mercury
mixxmexx 2 years ago
Comment removed
SUPERMANfromMETROPOL 2 years ago
DOESNT GET ANY BETTER
purplerocks666 2 years ago
Thats debatable. I liked Rods voice and this is a classic of Mark 1.
But Ian's range and power are far greater and different.
Hey there are people who liked Coverdale better , this is individual.
I treasure Mark 1 and Rods, Nick's contribution to the band, don't get me wrong.
But Ian and Roger was a complete revolution and as Jon Lord tell god bless them what made Deep Purple most famous and classic Mark 2.
Dimagg1973 2 years ago
Good but he just ain't Rod. Rod had the richer better voice !!
psychodamned 2 years ago
I love this voice!!! Thanks for all Ian!!
greccovox 2 years ago
The version with rod evans will always be the definitive version of this song, but this version is fantastic! they should've released this. kinda strange, though, its like a cover version, but by the same band
57250tr 2 years ago 2
I posted the BBC Stew boot leg version.
But there is a better quality and cleaner recording available on Deep Purple - Listen, Learn, Read On cd 2
3. Ricochet (BBC Session)
4. The Bird Has Flown (BBC Session)
9. Speed King (BBC Session)
11. Hard Loving Man (BBC Session)
12. Bloodsucker (BBC Session)
13. Living Wreck (BBC Session)
Dimagg1973 2 years ago
I have the Live In Montreux 1969 Live album, and Gillan does a damn good job on 'Kentucky Woman' there, which they do as an encore. Apart from that one, they also do 'Mandrake Root', 'Wring That Neck' and of course 'Hush' from the MK.I era. Heard rumours of that they rehearsed 'River Deep, Mountain High' with Gillan, but never knew they ever did this. Thanks for sharing!
SilverTounge85 2 years ago
Is this officially released, can I find this bootleg, cd or whatever somewere? Gillan does this well!
SilverTounge85 2 years ago
Its funny that Mark 1 or Mark 3 only would need to borrow
Ian Pice from current mark.
Dimagg1973 2 years ago
Stranger still that this song is just over 40 years old but still breathes life and contemporary excitement in it..... If I had a band I would record it.....
EmeraldGemstar09 2 years ago
A show with all the members of Deep Purple would be a super show. Imagine Satriani, Blackmore and Steve Morse on stage with Nick, Roge and Glenn. ( Maybe Boiln's brother will honor Tommy?)
I would love to hear Burn or Mistreated with David, Glen, Blackmore, Lord and Pice again, that would be a treat man.
Or Chasing shadows with Nick and Rod with the rest of Mark 1.
God bless them
Dimagg1973 2 years ago
This thought has crossed my mind as well. Every lineup performing a handful of songs each. Would be a huge success. Too bad Tommy Bolin and probably Rod Evans would never do such thing.
SilverTounge85 2 years ago
Comment removed
theyorkshirewhites 2 years ago
Dimagg1973, Yeah, I've always loved Chasing Shadows. Pity Purple never performed it live with Rod or Ian Gillan on vocals.
joelombrdo 2 years ago
My first Deep Purple song that I loved was Lalena mark 1.
The third deep purple mark 1 album was and still is a respected and wonderful guest in my car and home stereo.
Unlike the previous 2 albums this one is heavier and I love all songs on it.
Masterpiece
I agree that original Mark 1 version is awesome, And the ending of this song with building tension and drums getting fuller and louder.
Dimagg1973 2 years ago
There's no denying that this version is ballsy and has guts, but I prefer the slower, more thoughtful version with the Rod Evans vocals and the extended keyboards from Jon Lord.
I wish Rod Evans was still around today, I'd love to see a Purple show with all lineups having a set each. Good enough for Yes to do just that, good enough for Purple. But it'll probably never happen, can't see Ritchie Blackmore giving up the folk trail for DP again, can you?
EmeraldGemstar09 2 years ago
You are probably right! I doubt Ritchie would do it. Rod Evans wherever he is, would never do it. I think Nick Simper would. I bet Glenn Hughes and JLT would do it as well. I also think Lord would do it, if it was only for a couple of shows. Satriani never did anything with the band (studio). He did excellent Live renditions of 'Ramshackle Man' and 'Knocking At Your Back Door' though. Sadly Tommy Bolin wouldn't be there either.
SilverTounge85 2 years ago
Wow, I was not convinced it was Gillan singing until I heard his signature scream mid-song. Great music and pics. Thanks for the post!
rizzdog 2 years ago 2
It WAS on the New Live and Rare volume 3 single (along with Grabsplatter, and a version of SOTW from the '72 BBC In Concert show).
friarsnig 2 years ago
This is fucking ( sorry ) brilliant..excellent post..thankyou for this amazing piece of musical history.
Should have been on one of the New Live And Rare issues.
midnighttilldawn 2 years ago
Ian has amazing range.
Miwaser2008 2 years ago