Feedback?
3:36
Added: 2 years ago
From: MakeupByRisa
Views: 9,279
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (178)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • you look better without makeup

  • I admire you so much!

    You're sooo pretty and I love your hair. =]

    Great idea for the videos.

    I might have to send you some pictures.

  • great video!

    p.s: I love doing makeup breaks.

  • It just means to expand your make up horizon and learn new things. You can take our advice or leave it; it is up to you but know that is it not a personal attack

  • Exactly, there is nothing wrong with constructive criticism. Some people do not know where to draw the line though. Conscrutive criticism is not insulting someone and it is not a personal attack on someones character. Here is a prime example of conscructive criticism, "Pink lipstick looks nice on you. However, you might want to try other colors AS WELL (I am not yelling, I capitalized to emphasize those words) in addition to what you already have" I do not mean in replace of.

  • send it lol

  • i cant wait for this, GREAT idea.

  • I would love to get your opinion. Whenever I get my make-up done by an artist, they always do it totally different than I do. And I tend to not like how they do it. So I always wonder if mine it too extreme or who knows?I'll be sending pics. Thanks

  • I think it's a great idea, I'd love to see such videos!

  • I think this is an EXCELLENT idea !

  • Do a clockwork orange look for halloweeeeeeen!!! Something girly-ish.

  • awesome idea!!

  • I love the idea!!!! I'm IN!!!!

  • I live in the bay area and lovefest is coming up and i was wondering if you can do a look for lovefest?

  • GREAT idea!!! Go for it!!!

  • neat!

  • sounds awesome! can't wait!

  • i think it pretty cool

  • What a neat idea!!

  • No actually i believe it was your doll look for a friend you said, the one where you used a magenta color with a burnt burgundy color on top, sorry, my brain is so blank right now Im so tired!! LOL But I hope you know what Im talkin about!

  • Well, it seems that my eye lids are super tiny, i kinda have Asian looking eyes, sort of!! I barley have much of a crease. Just want to let you know that I tried your " Purple vamp look" and my hubby went crazy!! He loved it, so he too says Thanks Risa!! Keep those tuto's comin hunni!!

  • wow this is a really good idea risa!

  • Great idea!

  • Awesome... will be sending my pics.. I would love for you to show me what I can improve on. Thanks Risa!

  • Love the idea!

  • sounds great

  • im deffently all for your critisim.. its a great idea!

  • Sounds great. I'm sure we'll all learn a thing or two.

  • Great idea, methinks :D

  • that's fierce risa work

  • Yeah that sounds like a wonderful idea!

  • you are a doll...really sweet and a great idea! Thanks so much

  • This is such a cool idea!

  • such a GREAT IDEA... cant wait to send you my pics

  • God I love you!! lol I think this is a great idea and so original...really a great way to help all involved parties to learn!!

  • iam so gonna try find som pics thats isent ediet to hell ... have a lot of issus with my eyes starting to look old when i do the stuff i used to - so need help with that

  • I've got so many things i would love to get your help with that i don't know what to choose xD But it's so so so sweet of you :-* you are great Risa!

  • the extent of my make up is eyeliner, clear mascara and lip gloss...but i find myself watching all of your videos and loving them. watching an artist who is great at her chosen craft is amazing in itself, but watching an artist who is amazing at her craft share her knowledge with others makes you a goddess. <3

  • this is a fantastic idea! i have a quick question that i was just wondering do you have a fan facebook or fan myspace just for subbies ( i know some YTgurus dont like using their personal FB or Myspace for fans.) i was just curious.

  • Nice idea ^^

  • Fantastic idea Rise, many thanks!!!

  • great idea

  • this is an awesome idea! I love constructive cristicism but people just say oh you look pretty... it's nice but I can't learn from that

  • Love the idea.

  • Comment removed

  • good idea like to hear what you opinion is .. so happy in the spring mac is coming out with 3 diff shades of flesh tone eye pencils :) .. enjoy your style of videos nice job.. I like you am asked in real life for my opinion from others about there makeup honesty best policy..

  • This is a great idea!

  • Hay alguien que me lo pueda traducir?? no entiendo muy bien inglés y me encantaría saber lo que dice! por favoooor!

  • That's a great idea!

  • Great idea Risa!

    Just another supject: Could you do a video on how to cover acne and acne scarring?

  • i love that idea! this is really interesting... we could sooooo learn from that. or may be get an new angle on looking on our make up!

  • Hey Risa!!

    I think this is an awesome idea. I was wondering if you could possibly pick out some eyes that are smaller. I have really small eyes and sometimes its hard to make a look on you, work on me!! LOL So that would be of great help!! Thank you

  • What exactly do you mean by small eyes, because I actually have small eyes myself. Are you referring more to hooded eyelids?

  • I really like this idea.

    Considering I think I sent you an email for feedback once.

    maybe. xD don't remember.

    but yeah

    great idea!

  • Sounds like a really good idea and it would be awesome if you could pick, of course different parts of the face but also pick a few different eye shapes etc. I'm so bad at explanations but I hope you understand what I mean.

  • i love you so much

    youre so great :)

  • That's such a great idea :)

  • That's an awesome idea. I can't wait to watch those videos, I'm sure they'll be helpful.

  • This is such a great idea!

  • That's a great idea :D :D

    I'm definitely gonna send you a picture!

    I often have trouble applying my eye makeup because my eyelidspace up to my crease is so small so when I put my basic color on my lid and then start shading in the crease, it always turns out that my base color is barely visible in the end x.x...

  • Wohooo that's such a GREAT idea!

  • searching for pics to send you!

  • This is a great idea!!! Have a nice day! :-)

  • Great idea love! I will send you pictures :)

  • Love this....looking forward to watching it!

  • That's a great idea and it would benefit a lot of us as we most probably make mistakes we don't even take notice of. Thank you for making the time to do something like that for us. :)

  • SUPER IDEA!!!!LOF YA!

  • You obviously know what makeup works on you, so it would be cool to hear your take on people with different eye/nose/lip/face shapes, skin colors, etc. Great idea!

  • Ohhh this is a great idea! We'll learn from each other's mistakes!

  • Great idea!!!!

  • That's a great idea!! Please do that

  • I think it is a great idea! I look forward to watching that series of videos!

  • Super good idea.

  • Amaaazing ideaaaa

  • Makeup OCD uh oh you must cry when you see me LOLOL

    This is SUCH a unique idea, which is really what the whole youtube beauty guru world needs, SOMETHING that no one else has already done. Kudos to you!!

  • AMAZING idea!, please please PLEASE do this!

  • that's so awesome of you! you're like a makeup editor! (i'm a copy editor for my college newspaper and i am OCD about newspapers. i like your ability more than mine though ahaha)

  • this is awesome!

  • lovely idea! Definitely do it

  • Awesome idea!

  • great idea! please do this!

  • Really Good Idea.

    Yeah we all look for flaws in everyone's makeup.

    But I don't know how to fix them. I think that's a cool idea.

  • fab idea, risa! so excited to see your tips and ideas!

  • looooooove thank you

  • i think thats a great idea. i was thinking maybe do some how to videos if u r interested in doing that. especially how to apply eyeliner properly. mine usually smudges or just looks kinda sloppy and also tricks to puttin on eyeshadows. mine never looks as good as the videos i see. just an idea. i love watching how to videos and learning new tricks. thanks so much. i think its great that you share your tricks and looks. it really helps i love makeup but dont know the best way to apply it

  • thats a really amazing idea

    your so generous risa <3

  • Great idea

  • great IDEA I just emailed you some autumn masks I did.

  • great idea

  • great idea. i think if you do a constructive criticism videos they should have some type of theme like blending, foundation and etc. that way you could help other makeup lovers who make the same mistakes. can't wait to see these videos :)

  • I'd looove to! I think I'll go compose an email right now... :D

    Wonderful idea, Risa.

  • great idea - I am sure that a lot of think we are doing amazing work, but may still need some help. Atleast for me I cannot say anything bad about my own work - if I think it looks great. Does that make sense?

  • I believe it's a great idea and a very nice way to learn some more things. I might send you some pictures myself but still don't know. I'm kind of timid : )

  • I would send you pics. but my camera sucks... ;(

  • This is such an awesome idea!!!

  • Risa I wouldn't even bother responding back to ignorant people. Everyone else sees their ignorance, there is no need in giving such comments validation.

    Ya dig? I am here for your tutes, carry on!

  • Aw, you're the first one I've seen who's done this. I like that you care enough to give out constructive criticism. (:

  • I am i PERFECTIONIST too so i totally understand. It takes this sort of attitude to be a truly GREAT makeup artist. I think this is a fantastic idea too.

  • risa you're awesome! i do my hair in twists like you showed in your hair tutorials. i am in loveeee! i do it a lot with the pomp. i can never find creative ways to do my hair and when I saw that video I was so stoaked! thank you for the insight. also, all of your looks are amazing and you always give me great ideas on how to improve on my makeup! but of course im sure you hear that all the time haha

  • I loveeeee this idea Risa, sooo much, Im trying to really get into more halloween an costume makeup to audition for this big makeup thing for Universal Studios next year and I would LOVEEE to send you some pictures to get feedback ..so I will deff send em in but Im fine w/ not being anonymous

  • i like this idea about feedbacks

  • I think this is a fantastic idea. :]

    CC is one of the things I've had the hardest time acquiring. It's one thing to offer criticism, it's another thing to be mean. I'd love to get tips on how to improve.. that helps me. If someone doesn't like my face.. well I can't do much about that. LOL

    I'll be sending some photos your way. Thanks!

  • I think that would be an AMAZING idea, no one I know does or that I've ever seen knows much about the type make-up that I like to do (they mostly do neutrals and very normal, work, everyday make-up) While I wear mine everyday, but I like it a little wilder and if people are going to see it everyday....I want to make sure it's not shit.

  • WHO GIVES A FUCK ABOUT OCD & SHIT LIKE THAT, RISA YOU FUCKING ROCK DUDE, I LOVE YOUR TUTORIALS.

    & TO THAT ONE lovemakeup15 bitch, you damn hater lol, get a life darling!

    Risa, keep doing what you do, i love your skills. :))

  • Wow. I'm really sorry to see people thinking it's cool/ok to judge you based on your grammar or whatev. Seriously? If they have nothing better to do than bitch at people on youtube...?!  Yea. ok. OCD rules. I think it absolutely help us to accomplish the things we'd like to be better at. Keep up the fantastic work. LoL Speaking of OCD, I'm detail oriented... picking up on them that is. Like purple much? Your room's awesome.

  • Risa you are amazing. Dont let haters get to you hun!

  • yes this is a great idea WOW amazing I wouldn't have thought of that!

  • oh my goodness this is going to be totally awsome. but yeah i know what you mean when you want to fix peoples make up. there are a few girls at my school that litterally have sploches on their eyelids for eyeliner..and it just really grinds my gears but i hold my tounge. =P

  • Risa thank you so much for being such a doll! I have been dying for an opportunity like this since it is rare that you can ever receive honest and subjective feedback from someone about something in the artistic realm. Thank you for pledging so much of your time to us, I know that must be taxing and I really appreciate all of the hard work that you invest into your videos and subscribers!

  • This sounds like an awesome idea! I'm totally interested in it. I would loooove to know your tips!! So please act on this brilliant idea! haha <3

  • I think your videos are awesome and that you are beautiful!

  • I NEVER comment on videos, but I'm making and exception for you. Can I just say that I am in love with your channel. I know that there are a ton of people on YouTube that do makeup tutorials (far too many in my opinion, but that could just be me) but you are perhaps the most helpful. You always make sure to explain not just how but WHY you do things a certain way, which helps people take tips and apply them other places. Be on the lookout, because I'll be sending you an picture soon ;)

  • Wow, that is very generous of you! I hope I can get my act together and submit something b/c I need help!

  • I would prefer it if you didn't speak for all people with OCD, thanks. While I understand being annoyed at people using it as a random phrase, it was also pretty clear how she meant it. So just calm down a bit, alright?

  • Ok you're being extremely confrontational. Calm down. You dont know me. And you're obviously not a psychiatrist either. FYI OCD presents itself in different ways and just because it may not rule EVERY aspect of someone's life, doesn't mean that they are not afflicted with it. There are other things that Im OCD about - just because I dont share every part of my life with you, doesn't mean it doesn't exist. I'm very aware of who I am, so please, stop trying to tell me who you THINK I am.

  • I wish your "OCD" was HAVING to correct your spelling and grammar errors.

  • Btw my comment wasn't to Risa, it was to lovemakeup15.

  • lol i knew who you were talking to, but it's good you clarified that so no one jumps on you because lord knows she rubbed off on me and my own grammar/spelling/punctuation got a little messy in my response.

  • LOL! Anger does that, but at least you don't spell "feel" as "feal".

  • As someone who suffers from OCD, I would really prefer that you didn't try to speak for all people with the condition. I have met MANY people with my condition who would never get mad at someone for saying they are OCD about something. Furthermore, as Risa said, you don't know her and don't know how she is using this term.

    As you yourself said, this is only youtube... calm down.

  • I didnt speak for everyonewith that condition WTF.

    I spoke for my self and my friends.

    Its what i believe and i can stand up for it ok....

  • I'm glad this has gotten a good response!!! I have quite a few emails already and Im working on the next video :)

  • awesome idea!!! i love it!

  • genius idea!!! Something new and exciting to the makeup channel!!! woohoo

  • Actually it's been 12 hours since I washed my hair. My hair is shiny and healthy. Thanks for being a hater though. I appreciate the love!

  • Yeah, most of us would love for our hair to be that shiny . If only I liked hats...

  • wow you are dumb!! Her hair looks very shiny and healthy, not oily. Judging by your comment, i bet ur hair is a frizzy fried mess

  • Also, I tried to click reply and accidentally clicked remove butttt you're entitled to your opinion, and I agree (i think you meant to type rules? Am I right? You typed rolls) that makeup doesnt have rules. That's not the purpose of this video. You obviously missed my point.

  • great idea. I'm definitely interested in watching the vid.

  • im sending u one tomorrow :) !!

  • Awesome! I'm going to have trouble deciding which to send, there are so many choices...

  • i would love feedback

  • Sounds good! Lookin for some pictures to send to you now.

  • great idea!! thanks, ill definitly be doing this :)

  • i think its a good idea cause you'll have the chance to touch on common mistakes that we might fall for

    love it and its a success vid for me

  • ahhhhh that's fantastic. do it. makes sense for a guru to do that :)

  • Good idea!

    and/or do halloween tutorial using other people... ^^

  • I would love using other people for tutorials period, but most people I know are uncomfortable on camera or very busy with their kids. I *may* borrow my bff's daughter for a tutorial though. :)

  • I'd like that, we could see what you pick up on as far as accenting certain features and which colors would look best etc...

  • LOL...a few months ago I tried using my bff's daughter for a series I was TRYING to start on childrens pageant makeup.She is 6 so it took FOREVER and she talked through the whole thing...FAIL!! :0(

  • great idea!

  • great idea!

  • Great Idea, im gonna email you some pictures!

  • sounds cool. I would love personal feedback.

  • cool idea

  • I think this is a fantastic idea. It's always nice to know what "professional" people think b/c a lot of us interested in makeup would love to do it for a career someday. I think you're the perfect person for giving the constructive criticism as well; you have such a great attitude, and I really respect what you have to say. :)

  • good idea!

  • this is such a fabulous idea

    i dont think anyone has done something like this before!

  • Fantastic Idea!

  • save it and i will look for it maybe on the 5th? favorited in case i forget

  • that would be great! go risa

  • I absolutely love this idea.

    It sounds amazing.

  • I think that is a very cool idea. As long as it's honest, but not meant to be cruel, you know? Like you wrote, as long as it's constructive and not mean, I am all for it. Because I am for giving people tips so they can become better, but I hate it when people essentially take away people's joy when it comes to what they do - and that can happen when criticism obviously is meant to hurt.

    So yeah. Go for it.

    I probably wouldn't send anything in though. Mainly because I take criticism badly :D

  • Definitely! I would hope you guys kinda have a sense of my personality in that I would never be cruel towards anyone.

  • True. I wouldn't have pegged you for the cruel type. It's just that I always get a little iffy about these things because I have seen some people let forth their inner bitch, so to speak, when someone just asked for advice. So did I think you'd react like that? No. I don't think I'd be subscribed to you if I had gotten that vibe :) I just felt the need to put my opinion on the matter out there :D

  • That would be cool!

  • Great idea! xx

  • AWESOME idea really its a great idea Risa!

  • great idea risa

    x

  • Great idea! Can't wait to see the vids

  • GOOD IDEA :)

  • i would love for you to do something like this it would be a big help espe for people like me who are always looking to learn more and get better

  • omg I love that idea!

    that would be so helpful to me and so many others. :D

  • you're SO awesome for doing this!!! =] i CANNOT wait for these videos.

  • great idea girl!

  • I think this is a great idea :)

  • This is such an amazing project. Omg this is really nice of you. you're going to be swamped by photos.

    * tsunimee - Feedback please * (anonymous category). Will be sending pictures next week. Is there a deadline for this 'special offer'? thank you so much xx woop

  • This is an awesome idea :) Hope you get lots of entries

  • Thats really nice that you will do this, I know that some people dont want to give feed back because they are to busy. You are one of my favorite gurus! You are so nice and your makeup is wonderful! Thanks for being awesome!

  • i actually think this is a great idea

  • this is a really cool idea