Added: 4 years ago
From: susanjared
Views: 118,492
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (190)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • d truth is, slash & axl is guns n roses!!!

  • Guns and Idiot

  • Man the sound quality is crap compared to back in the day. Your all arguing over nothing! Some times in life there is a spark! The old line up had that spark! Now they have all gone the life has gone outa the band and ironically like axls own song says 'sometimes i feel like i'm beatin a dead horse'. Does he not feel that now? He's floggin a dead horse. All the original guys brought some magic to the table. Thats what created the music/band. That all died long ago.

  • Still the best living entertainer,God bless Elvis and Freddie! P.S. Rod also has a bad voice but is still a great singer and entertainer.

  • Am I the only one who hates the fact he's using an autocue?

  • @WishYouWereHere75

    To be fair he's used them since the early 90s. I don't think I've actually ever seen him stop and look at them but I suppose with the way he moves around onstage he could get distracted so they're handy for a quick glance to remind him where he is in the song.

  • i think axl is a terrible singer. his voice is so... blegh. i like listening to him on my ipod to hearing him live.

  • axle has lost it there is no g n r with out slash or duff or izzy or dizzzzy read or matt

  • @muppet022 Dizzy Reed is still in the band and it wouldn't matter if he wasn't. The truth is, whether you want to believe it or not, Axl Rose IS Guns N' Roses.

  • @muppet022 Dizzy is still in the band dipstick.

  • Evidentlyavid, its not Slash's job to write lyrics, its Slash's job to play guitar you stupid fucking loser. Epic FAIL.

  • I don't line this line-up at all. But you can heard the crowd singing "Sweet child O' mine" GNR has just gotten bigger and bigger with time! What if Axl, Slash, Izzy, Duff and Sorum got together and toured the world now?? It would be insane! And I said Sorum and not Adler because he has lost it. He still can play the drums but i dont know if he's any better than sorum!

  • That would be the most epic music event EVER! I would buy tickets to that, no matter what the cost, and no matter where the seats would be

  • I sure would be! :O I would be there even if i had to sell everything i own xD Seriously, I would eat donkey shit to be there!

  • Yeah. I've always loved GN'R

  • @MarshallATV keep dreamin we will probably see Duff maybe back and Izzy has plaed and given his blessing on the new gnr but slash is a double-talkin jive motherfuker axl has not publically talked shit on slash but anytime slash is put on t.v. or in a mag thats all he does TALK SHIT!his bands have been shit the new album is shit he is nothing w/out Axl he needs to figure that out!

  • I read somewhere that Axl use to suck dick just to survive when he first came out in L.A.

  • And I heard you're a dick wrangler . whoops. too soon?

  • the intro riff was actually made bu accident whenslash was messin around one da doin lil circus tunes n stumbled upon ..at the time sounded good to axl ...n slashed replayed the lil intro to lil repeats changin it up only by notes....only then n there was the intro to sweet child born...but yeah guns aint guns unless slash , duff, axl, izzy, matt sorum.....not so much adler...are all back together ....

  • Yep. Slash and Izzy were screwing around with it while Axl was writing, and it came together during a rehearsal

  • You are absolutely right! Anyone who says anything else is wrond, 'Cause Slash has said it himself a hundrer times in interviews. That he was drunk and so where the others in the band and then he started playing this little riff which was a bit difficult because you're fingers cross eachother, so he played it till he got it and then the rest of the band came in, and Axl started thinking about the lyrics :D

  • Axl walks around like Jason Voorhees in this vid.

  • the new generation of Guns N Roses suck, with out Slash they are nothing :P

  • @victorfredriksson You have no idea what music is then.

  • Axl + slash = Guns N Roses... But nothing lasts forever... Even Guns n roses ((((

  • @piksasuna Axl = Guns N' Roses.

  • lol did you realise you just quoted november rain when you said "But nothing lasts forever" ?

  • slash says he wrote the whole "MUSIC" to coma and locomotive by himself. nevermind the lyrics,he delivered the songs as they are to axl.and axl put word son them. thats first.second,axl didnt give him writing credit for the guitar pars on piano songs,i played the piano for a few years btw,its boring.cause thats how the piano is,specialy in a rock song...anyway we saw chinese democracy..is the writing as good as old gnr? axl needs a good song writer to give him basic ideas.."IZZY" was the link.

  • i know the chemisrty was done,they all had different lives and interests..but as slash says,there was mutual creativity,and whomever brought whatever song ,they all worked on it to improve it,thats what he said in his book..so it was still GNR ,with the GNR sound,though it was less raw,and thats the beauty of it,that their work reflexted their status at the time,,,but now,theres no band..theres axl.."though im soo happy to hear his voice singing on chinese..

  • SLASH WROTE COMA & LOCOMOTIVE. he came out with sweet childs riff,and welcome to the jungle's riff as well..he wrote guitar parts to complicated piano songs that sucked as..to make them masterpieces "estranged & nov. rain" so please everyone shut up... guns n roses works when izzy comes up with smthng simple,axl-slash and even duff turns it into smthng legendary..its chemestry..cant be duplicated.

  • slash did NOT write coma &locomotive by himself. like i said there's not one GNR song slash wrote entirely on his own. all lyrics to locomotive & coma are axl's.

    the fact that you call piano parts as elegant as november rain and estranged sucky says a lot about your ability to judge quality music- or i should say the lack thereof.

    alan niven, the GNR manager who hates axl admittede clearly that slash needs high quality song-writers like axl and izzy around him otherwise he cant deliver.

  • the chemistry you speak of had already changed by the time UYI was made. slash and izzy had a rift between them and there's only 3 songs on UYI that they collaborated on as opposed to the AFD days. steven was already lost.

    sitting there romanticizing something thats gone is far less than productive than moving on like a rational human being. there's life beyond AFD and life beyond old GNR.

  • Ha someone else got your goat. fuckhead

  • @amentveddergossard, only in your dreams, old boy. :)

    keep humming along to Slash's paradise City with fergie and Cypress Hill. hahahaha!

  • Man the crowd sings to where you can hear them plain as day !

  • Axl wrote November Rain, Estranged, Dead Horse, Shotgun blues,Breakdown, My World, This I Love by himself, The Garden and Yesterdays with west arkeen and del james.

    besides this axl has song-writing credits on almost every single song on Use Your Illusion (besides the 2 covers) and of course on AFD and This I Love.

    axl was always GNR's major lyric-writer. remember that. Welcome to the Jungle, Sweet Child, most of Paradise City, Coma- axl's lyrics are part of rock history.

  • do you think Axl Rose wrote "Axl Rose" by Def Karaoke Jam???

  • no. def karaoke jam wrote that.

  • i think he was joking dipshit

  • @tjrey2, none of your business, retard.

  • uh, you posted your comment on a public message board so actually the contents are pretty much everyone's business.

  • just so you know I do agree with your other comments about Axl being the main creative force in GNR. I just commented about the Def Karaoke Jam thing because its obvious the guy was joking. Lighten up and stop taking yourself so seriously dude.

  • @tjrey2, hehe! how am i taking myself too seriously? i thought USTrojan was genuinely asking a question and i answered him. i did not in any way insult or attack him.

    your response to that was totally uncalled for. being on a public forum is no reason for pointless attitudes.

    primarily on this video, i was talking to amentveddergossard, a guy who goes from one GNR video after the other to attack Axl and the post-96 GNR.

  • there's not a single song slash wrote alone in GNR. here's some songs izzy wrote ALONE:

    patience, bad obsession, double talking jive, pretty tied up, used to love her.

    some songs he co-wrote with axl:

    Dont Cry, 14 years, You Could be Mine, Youre crazy, Think About You, Anything Goes.

    the main riff of Nightrain is Izzy's. Dust n Bones is mostly izzy with some contribution from duff/ slash.

    axl and izzy have more song-writing credits than anybody. look up the record and see.

  • its good but its just not the same feeling. Axl needs to change the name to something like the "Axl Rose Exeriment".

  • @777Cena4Life777 No, if Axl was to change the name it should be Guns N" Roses Afterglow !

  • he is the best, but he was better when Guns was still Guns .

  • the audience haha priceless and great long live Axl rose

  • damn now..the rose got bunches of cunts with him as a famous guns n roses...huh ...its cunt n roses now...fuck off..!!

  • Well yeah it IS more of an 'Axl N' Co.' situation now but who cares? The Chinese Democracy album was awesome and alot of the songs on there I prefer to old GnR stuff and I hope to GOD there's another album in the pipeline, hopefully not a 12 year long pipeline mind you but you never know : )

  • @BirdIsTheWord89 he's got a second album thats supposed to come out the end of this year!

  • axl haters are out here in force. slash left Guns N Roses. you expected axl to let GNR die because of a choice slash made?

    kudos to Axl, Dizzy Reed and the guys in new GNR for keeping Guns N Roses alive. these "new" guys have been in the band longer than the old ones. they dont deserve the hate people throw at them.

  • U got a point. But you cant replace some people from bands:

    Lemmy Kilmister IS Motörhead

    Angus Young IS AC/DC

    Eddie Van Halen IS Van Halen

    Steven Tyler IS Aerosmith

    Freddie Mercury IS Queen

    Slash IS Guns N' Roses

  • how exactly is slash guns n roses when he wasnt even a founding member of GNR?

    for kids who only learned about GNR in retrospect & adore slash from Guitar Hero, GNR facts are blurry. truth is, axl & izzy were the major song-writers for GNR, NOT slash. axl was beyond a doubt the bigger star in GNR's heyday-check out who got more Rolling Stone covers in that era.

    GNR's biggest hit Sweet Child o Mine wouldnt even exist if slash had his way- he wanted to bury the song but Axl made it happen.

  • Sweet Child was founded by Slash jamming around on the pentatonic D scale and Izzy adding some chords to it. So yeah. Izzy Stradlin is cool, but the major songwriter? He wrote you aint the first and 14 years which is probably not the 2 songs every person knows of GnR. Maybe stupid people like Slash from guitar Hero. I like for the music, his bending, the way he can improvise a solo by using just the blues scale and play 3 note beats, as seen in the end solo in hair of the dog, and his precision

  • again, your knowledge is woefully inadequate. im not saying this to be insulting but you really need to brush up on GNR 101. the fact that axl and izzy were GNR's major song-writers is pretty basic knowledge.

    sweet child o mine started with slash jamming on a riff but like i said, slash is on RECORD along with duff and steven for opposing the song fiercely. it was axl who made the song happen. if slash had had his way, the song simply wouldnt exist.

  • @evidentlyavid You are right about that. If Sweet Child "O" Mine hadn't been pushed by Axl I have no idea of what would of happened to GN'R. That song opened the door a million times over for GN'R.

  • @evidentlyavid I don't feel that too many know that the only original members of Guns N' Roses were only Axl and Izzy. When Izzy left the only original member left standing is Axl. Some people don't seem to understand that slash-Duff-Matt-Gilbey were only replacements and there was contraversory with bandmates about slash being hired.

  • you cunt

  • @amentveddergossard -Truth is the truth hurts huh !

  • woooo i was there

  • Its not grn at this point dude

  • yah, i'm surprised he didnt stop the show cuz everyones singing and jump into the crowd and hit someone

  • haha

  • think of what could have happend if someone put an arm around him when he was a kid and said i love you

  • haha :) geniuse !!!! :D

  • you know, or throw the kid a football in the yard now and then say good catch son

  • thankfully no ever did and have the mellow damatic over the top axl that we have today :) funny how things work out, wish i was hated, i ight turn into a rock legend then lol :D

  • If that had happened then grn would never have exsisted

  • yah, beat your kids to have rock

  • I am happy Axl will still perform. But this is Guns N' Roses in name only.

  • Guns n roses es la mejor banda de hard rock!

  • Guns N´Roses without slash is not guns n roses! v.v :'(

  • generally this is Axl with others.. not Gun n Roses. WE WANT BACK GUNS N ROSES :)

  • axl hates that kind of comments

  • nah, axl´s problem! guns n roses need slash man!!

  • steven adler is doing better than any of them at the moment in respect to making music and touring.

  • isnt he in a band called Stevens Appetite? cuz one of my friends down in Cali said he was going to a show with Steven in it.

  • its adler's appetite and they are touring their asses off. having alot more fun than any of the other members of gn'r id imagine

  • I agree with the last comment. I have a question... Does anyone remember Mick Jaggers solo career or do we all remember the Stones?

  • Guns N Roses is never the same and fuck anyone who says different. the only origonal member is Axl. and in my opinion, everyone else (Slash,Duff,Matt,Izzy) have done waaaaaaaaaaaaaaay fuckin better than Axl. I would love to see them do a reunion before they get old in stuff. but man whatever Axl has against Slash or whatever he needs to just let it go! life is to short to be holding grudges against poeple!

  • yea, kinda like what your doing right now....

  • ....Nice! but i wouldnt call it a grudge when you hate the new sound of Guns N Roses.

  • True......The stadiums are still sold out though.

  • Touche!haha!

  • "life is to short to be holding grudges against poeple! " Awesome.

  • Although Axl looks great for his age i can't say the same about his stage behaviour. It's sad to say but he looks so indifferent.

  • lol u cant hear axl over the crowd!

  • if its not his voice its his clothes. god he's 50 years old!

  • 47 years right

  • Wtf, since when has Axl come fully dressed to a concert?

    In any of the old concert videos he'd normally have something missing.

  • You have to remember he is in his late 40's.

  • More and more people will begin to hate Axl.

    I think you know why...

  • HE will do the inverse of M. Jackson!

    He allready has tressed hair and use large jeans one day he will turn black!

  • I don't care how many fucking negatives I get. But this is shit. Axl in his prime was truly the king of rock n roll. This is a sham. Even the way he dresses- like that guy from Simply Red. Sounds sad but if he'd died through rock n roll exile around 91 then he would have gone down as a legend

  • you just seem like a convulsive hater.

    axl looks great for his age and he sounded very good in the 06/07 shows. he's a human being. youre wishing for his death just so you could remember him the way you liked him?!

    axl and the new GNR put on great shows. if youre interested in knowing reality watch the kroq inland invasion show or just watch Nightrain from Rock AM Ring.

  • axl was much cooler dressed before now he got big pants was up with that???

  • hes almost 50 man..b4 he was in his late 20s

  • Axl rOseEeeeEeeee 4ever !!!

  • why doesn't Axl ever do his moves anymore? i mean like that from side to side stuff. might be simple but i love him doing that, lol. seen that only in older videos though :(

  • i went to that concert it was awesome best time of my life and bullet for my valentine were there

  • woah bullet for my valentine supported guns n roses? i love BFMV but i didnt think they were the sort of act that would apeal to most guns n roses fans.

  • nice

  • is he singing? i only heard the people

  • i agree with nightrain 76 they need to go back together they were godly i grew up on appetite for destuction and it dont get better then that album or any of the old albums if they would just not be babies about this and grow up then they would become like 10x richer cause axls got lie 25% of his fans happy right now we just need the oldies back

  • lol,25% of fans happy?If thats true and their still selling out arenas and their newest album went platinum in 2 months.Your just an afd junkie.If you actually listened to the rest youd see how good gnr really is.

  • Emmm. I'd rather listen to GNR pre 1991 anyday. Compare this bloated crap to Ritz shows in NY for instance.

  • yo estube aya

  • i was at this gig it was fuckin amazing!

  • What's That Screen Below Axl?

  • the monitor, it gives singers a cheat if they forget lyrics. basically they play singstar without the pitch noted.

  • Im not sure. Slash made the guitar solos complete. not too many people can play like he could. you know?

  • wow that crowd damn

  • These shows would be 10X's better if Axl and Slash reunited.

  • i still love Axl but i agree with Nightrain76

  • yeah thats very true

  • hey whos the keyboard player behind dizzy?

  • AXL WEAVE ROSR

  • bfc1391, i listen to them and im nothing like you.

    or are you too stupid to realise how you were actually descwribing yourself in your comment....

  • i saw them 2006 and god has he still got it! 2002... not a good year for him =/ but when I saw then they were amazing XD and to the many omg omg slash *wanks* the band is still good without him! and I don't like VR anyway OMFG YES I SAID IT THERE!

  • yeah he is right slash come back guns without you mstnt exist.......

  • get slash back

    come on guns, do a runion

  • Who needs Axl. The crowd did the song all by themselves ;-)

  • the world needs axl rose.

    ass or not he is much better than most things we have now.

  • i AGREE...MY 13 AND 12 YEAR OLD KIDS LOVE GuNs N' roSes OLD ALBUMS I HAVE FROM WHEN I WAS IN HIGH SCHOOL...SPAGET, ILLUSION 1 n 2 AND GREATEST HITS... THEY ALSO MAKE SOME KIND OF FUN OF ME WHEN THEY HEARME SINGING ALONG :p IM 32 AND THEY DNT BELIEVE I ONES PARTY WITH gNr...JUST LOVE THEM AND I NEED AXL!!

  • CAPS LOCK IS CRUISE CONTROL!!!!

  • axl doesnt ever bring up slash anymore. its always slash talkin bout axl, or slash fans talkin shit bout new GNR (case in point, many on here).

  • Personally I am more a slash fan but Rose is and was a great frontman.

    The band slit years ago, I think people should just get over it.

    Why do people bitch at each other over the break up?

  • Guns n roses sucks without Slash!

  • i dont like axl cause he keeps going on about how much he hates slash

  • you know fuck all.

    please be quite from now on

  • this sucks

  • garbage

  • wtf this is lazy

  • Ok I love GNR and I love Axl !! But what the frigin fuck is he doing walking? Axl isn't walking, he aint soaking ! He IS the master of running and screaming .... !!! Bring back the old Axl !!!

  • Listen, all I have to say is... HE IS NOT IN HIS TWENTIES ANYMORE! He is 45/46 here I believe. He has gotten old. But he can still sing.

  • finally... someone with I.Q.

  • The old red mongoloid

  • SAY BOOOOOOOOOOO!

    to the Vocal of Velvet revolver

    hes like singing DOG..

    fuck All HAters Of Guns n Roses

    Nowadays

    Go to your Scott(velvet Vocal)

    and pass his Dog Face to you

  • Did ya really have to say that twice ya twatfraggle ?

  • you do know he's been fired? dipshit lol

  • SAY BOOOOOOOOOOO!

    to the Vocal of Velvet revolver

    hes like singing DOG..

    fuck All HAters Of Guns n Roses

    Nowadays

    Go to your Scott(velvet Vocal)

    and pass his Dog Face to you

  • hes such a good singer! i love axl and all other members of guns n roses

  • Well ya aint got shit do ya ? GNR is AXL, SLASH, DUFF ... Rest of them? Period fuckers !

  • you forgot some people gnr would be nothing with out izzy and adler added somthing special to apetite that no one could have

  • Totally agree!

    Adler and Izzy were 2 huge players in making the band.

    The original 4 created something amazing. People rant over Axl and other Rant over Slash but at the end of the day, all 4 created this machine they were ALL instrumental in one way or another for the breakup.

    Every band has its hayday and I'm glad I saw them when they had it (late 80's to early 90's).

    Instead of everyone slating various members (or ex members) of the band. Why not just appreciate what once was?

  • Appreciate what it is now as well. Or appreciation of the past has no meaning. :(

  • I do appreciate it, cant have GnR without Axl, in my opinion it can roll on with any guitarist, I personally had liked Finck and Bucket, I like bumble but his sound is different

  • I'm young, 18 in a few days and I agree with all you old people out there. Old GNR > New GNR no one will ever be able to fully replace Slash/Izzy/Duff/Matt. Hopefully one day they'll put their diffrences aside and give us the concert we all dream of on the inside

  • Matt??? fuck Matt!! he couldnt come NEAR Steven, stevens beats were raw and powerfull and in your face, while matts tuning was bad, with weak and soft beats... also adler played double set until gnr forcded him to be a 4/4 RNR drummer

    also matt's playin ADLERS stuff...

  • wow

    all crowd sings

  • that's what happend at my concert wish they didn't

  • axl is the best..

  • It's funny that a lot of us are getting negatives next to our comments. Were the ones who grew up watching GNR. And some 13 year old kids are now giving us these marks. hahaha

  • totally agree! (wonders if I put my age on here*

  • lol, Im not making excuses but he wasnt well that night - he collapsed at the end of the show - dunno if that might have something to do with it!

  • To be honest if you look at any Axl live footage since the real band spilt up it's just the same. Axl just strolling. I know he's getting older. But look at Steve Tyler or Mick Jagger they still put on a show. Anyhow Gnr died in 1993.

  • the lead guitarist has slashes les paul and is trying to get a cool hat but failed miserably! thell only be good again if they get slash.

  • the new guitarrist of guns and roses is stupid and he play so bad fuckkkkkkkkkkk but i love guns and roses

  • I Love GNR butt what the fuck is Axl wearing? He looks like a pregnant women!

  • y was 2006 his last of his shows wtf!

  • sweet izzy lol

  • he sounds good as hell and that is something a true guns n roses fan cannot deny. he's gonna make it and then when he does i will remember this and laugh.

  • dude axl traded a fucking cool guy with a cool tophat for a dick with a bucket and mask.

  • slash didn't wear the top hat when he was with guns n roses and new guns n roses doesn't have bucket head anymore dummy.

  • what are you? a retard? He weared it all the time.

  • not as much as you think. check the live vids. thats the real guns n roses. find one with a top hat on. it is rare when you do. so shut up you fag.

  • haha, my bad xP

  • it's cool.

  • how can you tell. you cant hear him singing becuz the crowd. you got VR. I GOT GUNS N' FUCKIN ROSES. I HOPE THEY CAN BRING BACK SOME FLAVOR ON THEIR NEW ALBUM SO JUST GIVE EM A CHANCE. JUST BCUZ HIS VOICE CHANGED DONT FORGET WHAT HE HAS DID AND STILL CAN DO.

  • Noone does it better than slash. they could do whateva they like. but witout slash or anyother da crew memba new GnR are shit.

  • Fuck, what a crowd!