Added: 5 years ago
From: BiggestPossible
Views: 79,459
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (327)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Am... I believe it's a new form to interpreted this song... i think so.

  • that wasn't that bad, you tried to make it your own <3

    I'm a big fan of Jazz and I know when I see a new born jazz player! You should be a jazz player, you're perfect for it! <3 BIG HAPPY HEARTS AND HUGS <3

    From,

    Golden Musician

  • bad

    terrible terrible terrible terrible terrible terrible terrible terrible terrible terrible terrible terrible terrible terrible terrible terrible terrible terrible terrible terrible terrible terrible terrible terrible terrible terrible terrible terrible terrible terrible terrible terrible terrible terrible terrible terrible terrible terrible terrible terrible terrible terrible terrible terrible terrible terrible terrible terrible terrible terrible terrible terrible bad

  • It's not terrible. You just played it your own way. That's what you are supposed to do with music is make it your own.

  • What the Frick are you saying man! Your really good! It's your version of playing Linus and Lucy

  • wow, you do suc!

  • haha good title. funny one.. HAHAHAH "TERRIBLE" bahhaaahahaha

    my tummy hurts from laughing so much. anyways, you're really funny

  • Dreadful.

  • I liked the second half a lot! If you fixed some of the unevenness in the first half, this would be a great variation! But this vid is quite old so I bet you have forgot most of it.

    Anyway, great job! You have a great musical ear.

  • best pianist ever. linus would be so proud!!!!

  • FYI, I put the Vince Guaraldi Version into midi by ear, showing the keys, on my channel. It's almost exactly the same as the CD. Both regular speed and very slow for anyone who wants to see the keys clearly. Check it out if you're interested.

  • Hey.u did a good job.

  • Why'd you say this was garbage you trying to fuck with us?

  • original way to play it lol it wasn't that bad

  • 75,000 views xD lolz just had to watch it and you don't suck, yet you're not the best, but it's pleasant :D

  • I liked it, I agree it could do with some improvement, but I still like it a lot.

  • i liked it :D

  • It is not garbage your great! You play really well!

  • amazing

  • My friend is learning how to play this on piano so we r at my house and she typed it in.... and i have a microphone on my computer and she grabs it and starts going dun nun nun na dun na na nun!!!! and she starts going crayzy so then i grabbed the mic from her and i start going crazy and she starts to pretend playing the piano!!!! it was SOOOOOO FUN!!! thanks for making this vid!

  • cool

  • Ahahahahah, thanks, I needed that.

    BTW, crack is bad.

  • 0:50 cool shit!

  • Were you playing by ear?

  • Comment removed

  • I guess my tolerance for musical interpretation is much lower than most, but I thought he butchered this piece. Kudos for the interest in jazz though...practice practice.

  • In all fairness, he pretty well said as much in the video description. I'm not going to be as harsh as you, but no doubt it could use a lot of improvement.

  • yeah the timing is off... you turn into a fucking spaz at 0:51 lol

  • hey its better than i could ever imagine of me being able 2 play that :)

  • its better then me since i cant put the 2 hands together haha

  • me either

  • I was about to say, this isn't that bad.

    But yeah, there were repeated notes, and some of the timing was off.

  • And BTW, No, i didn't say that he plays bad. With my timing on this song, and his ability to play faster than i can, this would be perfect.

    I love this song, and i WISH i could play as well as him.

  • piano looks sooo smal X]

  • you're great especially at 0:51

  • This is really good its just the left hand's timing...but from what I can tell im sure you can fix that

  • what brand is that piano?great playing.

  • Is this considered jazz or blues or what?

  • how does this make you blue! :O

    this is so jazz! lol

  • yehh its not badd its jus hes off

  • ure not bad at all wut da hell r u talkin bout???

  • his timing is off

  • well done..

    ..btw you are a left hander, or? :D

  • comon you shouldnt say that you're bad, you are like awesome

  • oh shit!

    Thats so good! Dam! Why would you say to not watch it?

  • dude that was good but it sounded a little off but it was not garbage

  • It was good but it didn't sound ike it fer sum reason

  • cause he couldnt synchronize both hands

  • Well done, just like this juicy steak im eating..............please xcuse me while i go fetch the A1.

  • you're so much better than you give yourself credit for...keep up the awesome job!

  • kinda weird, this morning, when my alarn woke me up, this song was on

  • that was better then I can do, I play by ear, (used to play by nose, but got too messy on the ivory with the blood and all.. LOL) anyway, that was great, keep up the great work..

  • Yer good but this is all wrong. The base line is coming in late, and you change the time signature, why i don't know. Those three extra chords don't add anything to the song. Remember the syncopation is the most important and most difficult part of this song. For positive crit, :54 sounds awesome.

  • wutever...

  • OMG! u r really good!!!!

  • what's so good about that?

    look for other videos so u know what's good and what's not

  • That was incredible!

  • aart6u8

  • What the hell was that?

  • i wish i had a piano like that, maybe someday

    Other than that i think this is brilliant :D

    Keep up the wonderful work! Rock on

  • well done!

  • nice performance =D curve your fingers and it will be even better good performance =D.

  • That's a coincidence. You created this account today to promote some guy's rather mediocre performance of a song that I mentioned was poorly played. Never mind the fact that I already mentioned that I can in fact play the song perfectly according to the sheet music. I've left this up because it's different and a few people seem to like it. All that aside, at least I can use the correct version of "you're." Congratulations on being an idiot. Take care, Asian invasion.

  • OMG! Don't say that! Hes good.

  • hey i was kidding

    i was just bored

    ur version is pretty good its just off tune fix it and itll be perfect

  • man this is terrible!!!

    its off tune like that other person said geez

    mine is way better check it out!!!

  • Actually Azninvasion I listened to your version and its not great...certainly not technically as good as this version.Yours is slow and repetitive.So before you put other people down give yourself a reality check

  • yea okay caliko cat but mine isnt repitive im just doin what my sheet of music is written!!! lolz

  • Its Ok. A great looking piano doesn't mean you play better than others.

  • hahaha my dad made me play on my friends piano..

  • howdy!

  • iloveit;babe.

  • i can see why this is garbage like u said in the description lolol. the tune is off lolXD

  • El tempo esta pesimo pero por lo demas esta bien la melodia!

  • once you understand the concept of rhythm, you'll be golden. hang in there champ.

  • This is pretty good! Slow down a little bit though. I think you did an amazing job! Its not garbage at all!

  • Pretty good; seems like with a more consistent tempo it would be a lot better tho.

  • i think this is one of the best ones i've seen.

    you should give a lesson video of how to play it or something.

  • guess you haven't seen too many then.

  • lmfao

  • Interesting rendition. Not awful, really. I've heard the song butchered far worse.

  • what's that terrible about it? It's pretty good, right key, good rhythm, but make some of the note more stacatto.

  • interesting rendition. not sure if its good or bad...but A for creativity

  • slow down a lil

  • Interesting left hand rythym. Sounds good though. I'm a believer that a song shouldn't be the same as the original to be good.

  • Wow... you have skill yet you have the simple left hand rhythm wrong.. Else that, the rest is good.

  • well i thought he did a good job. who cares if he didnt do it perfectly? I'd like to see some of you figure it out:p

  • awsome!

  • GREAT!!!! Thanks for sharing and allowing yourself to be criticized by others. I really enjoyed it.

  • your mom

  • cud u do better i know i only play by ear but his was very creative and it was interesting so post a video of u playing it and c wat we all think this is very creative

  • just as advice PLEASE don't take this the wrong way, but some of the rythms are completely off. Besides that, it sounded really good.

  • although you are missin some notes, great job! i myself are 'attempting' to learn that song ;D

  • anyone who can master this song, I am impressed with. That said, the way this is played is SWUNG which it is clearly stated on the original score that it is to be not SWUNG. Please don't swing it as you do a bit here, as it hurts my ears and anyone else who knows how to PLAY it properly. No, don't get hostile those of you who can't play the piano, i'm making a general observation. Congrats on learning it though, putting the left and right hands together is somewhat of a challange

  • what are you talking about! that was great!

  • mhm, this is pretty terrible.

  • id say that was pretty good

  • u a spaz

  • how am i a spaz?

  • i liked it

    but for advice for improvement i'd say u should lessen the sforzandos and do a bit more with crescendos and decrescendos

    in other words, work ur way up to the main riff and go all out when u do reach it

    also im not so sure but i think ur missing some notes on hte left hand's chord progressions

  • You're good. Very good. But this song is NOT one that you want to stylize. Really!

    I Cr 13;8a

  • stop slurring and get your beats right. Then get a piano teacher to help you. You are missing sooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo­ooooooooooooooooooooooo many notes.

  • hell, he plays it better than i do! ;)

  • hmmm not quite, good try though..you're "jazzing it up" with your own fillers, and your left hand is leaving out some charming and playful notes that really really make the song. And your timing, beat and flow of the song, overall, sounds too even and calculated; jazz is a lot spunkier, with like, those cool lil missed beats, you know? good piano playing anyway

  • not sure if the left hand being played completely different from the original is a mistake or a personal touch. BTW you managed to ruin an amazing song.

  • Hey that was really good! Can u shiw us how u play that? Cuase I been lookin all over in the musci stores and I cant find it I wanted to play it 4 dad 4 faters day he love the peanuts! so yeah :)

  • Your damn good but change the bass then it sounds better

  • how are u terrible?

    there were some mistakes

  • its not terrible. its pretty good actually. but your just going a little to fast

  • No actually the piece was meant to go fast.

  • it was?

  • yep

  • oh, i never knew that

  • hey can u send me the sheet music for this

  • me 2

  • I wouldn't say terrible... I think bland and hasty may be a better discription.

  • wow, you actually get hard near the end..which is dramatic..GREAT JOB!

  • Can someone please tell me where to get the sheet music for this song? I've been looking for it forever. Thanks

    Oya, and great playing.

  • I wish I could play like that.

  • Why is he saying it's terrible that's the best I've ever heard.

  • Yes, it sucks! You should get some more lessons.

  • so you got "terrible" and "dont watch it" in the header and you can obviously play so it sounds like you are a self-indulgent asshole who wants to hear everyone say "no your really good piano player" well fuck you you suck

  • Have you ever thought that maybe he was thinking that wasn't one of his best? Did the thought even occur to you?!!!

  • youre an idiot

  • So, if I can "obviously play" then how do I suck? And this version is terrible, because when I recorded it I had the rhythm all wrong. So for those who want an accurate performance of the song, they are warned to stay away because it is in fact 'terrible.'

  • You aren't terrible, the bass was just wrong the whole time.

  • They just want to be considered "obviously idiots". i could hardly tell, but then again i'm a amature so....

  • dude, you're awesome and it sounds fine. It's original!

  • prettey gpod

  • Dude we all suck at something, you just happen to be really bad at piano.

  • lol jeez dont criticize yourself besides some tempo problems it was fine!

  • why are u goin so fast though.. its a little slower but other than that your awesome!

  • its a pretty easy piece but this was good 5

  • yeah do it again...oh wait ur dead

  • omg, is he really dead? you should be ashamed if he is.

  • that's good!

  • yew need to curve yewr fingers ALOT!!! it'll help yew play wayyyy cleaner...

  • The left hand is off the whole time. I think thats what he meant by "horrible".

  • the first time i saw this i thought it was awesome, but know that i can play the song pretty well at a low speed, you're right the left hand is off. It doesn't fit the music that i have and i doubt its written like hes playing it. its the timing, not the notes.

  • I would hardly say that's terrible. The coordination with your hands sounds a little weird at the Ab Eb Ab part, but still that was pretty sick

  • It was good playing, and the hands were correct, but the righthand-lefthand timing was off.

  • this is beautiful! really

  • everyone, why must you be so harsh? it is great! 5 stars from me. maybe he thinks its terrible that is his opinion. all you should say is nice or eh its ok

  • man all you people are so mean! it wasn't that bad! and you need to have a higher self-esteem!

  • wasnt this labled TERRIBLE? i mustuv gone to the wrong vid...

  • Amen!

  • its his finger posture not the way he plays. he plays fine its just that he's not playing the piano even correctly. but its gud. he needs to curve his fingers. He can ruin his fingers not playing the right way. yew build the muscle in yewr fingers playing the rite way.

  • A little improvisation never killed anyone. =)

  • needs alittle more pactice...was a little shaky and 'scary'. :(

  • um.. okay thats like a biggilion times better then i could EVER PLAY so yeah.

  • thats good what are u talken bout!!! i could never play that..

  • stop sayin shit about this vid. ITS FINE!

    I'd like to see you do better u little piece of shit!

  • I doubt it would sound better than this..that would be pretty disgusting..

    Good job 5*s.

  • if you're gonna tell everyone that it's garbage and they shouldnt watch it then why did you pt it on here?

  • good dynamics

  • pretty good, left hand in wrong but it WAS NOT horrible, i kinda like this version actually. good job :)

  • Dude are u just saying it sucks to get more complements if so that is not cool

  • That was fabulous!!!!!

    I wish I could do that...

  • same

  • that was good wish i could play that

  • Did you have to pee during the middle of it, because it sounded like the song sped up a little. Wear depends next time fart.

  • I loved that!!! Thanks!

  • wow i wish i can play that!!!

  • 10/10 haha =]

  • OMG it is fast! It is definetly similar to the theme song. I love it. Who ever doesnt like it should die a horrible death lol! (-_-)

  • That's not garbage, what are you saying?

    That was pretty good, I liked it! No, strike that, that was REALLY good. Like wow. Okay I'll stop.

  • dude, don't be modest! that was FAR from garbage. I don't know much about pianos, so I wouldn't be able to nit-pick the mistakes. so to me..5/5

  • I loved the improv. This is only an opinion but I think you should let this song go and write a song to your own style. That's not a criticism, only a well intended comment. Merry Christmas Charlie Brown fan.

  • Hrm... well, better than I can do, but that ain't sayin much. 4/5.

  • Not bad at all. It needs some work but you still rocked it! :D

  • Its got 4 flats...

    i'm just now learning this and that really helped the rhythm on the loud part was hard, but watching you i got it.

  • I just want you to realize I'm trying to format this from ear onto Finale notepad, you have greatly helped. 4 flats. THANK YOU.

  • thats like amazing i cant play anywhere nere that good

  • omg that's so awesome!!

    holy crap

    you make me wasnt to learn it now  =]

    is it in the key of A flat??