David was "THE SOUND" of Pink Floyd.The FACT he wrote the Final 2 Albums without Waters also shows he was the Heart of the Band.Dont forget,"On an Island" went #1 World wide.Waters has never approached that by hisself.Not even close.
@DaytonaGary in waters's defense, topping charts and turning profits was not really his "aim" with any of his solo work.. good music is personal expression, not fitting demographics.
in the words of David Gilmour: "Art must be completely selfish, the fact that others enjoy it is simply a bonus"
Nick Mason easily has the most sophisticated playing style in an extremely fun yet simple way; Nick Mason can hold his head high amongst the likes of Bonham, Moon, Peart, etc. just as long as he brings his mustache ;).
FYI folks.......Richard Wright wrote this song.........Jeeze, how old are you people?.....maybe 14 or so.
Anyway just another FYI for you people almost all Floyd songs were colaberations within the group however there are on some albums more of one artists imput than on other...EG Waters and The Final Cut.
You really seem like an angry Floydian , that makes me think you just try to argue so you can argue , maybe you should try out the Bieber Belieber site
@joeysmokesz195 He's a great guitarist; anyone who knows anything about music will tell you the same thing-- and, BTW, Roger wrote the song, so he and his band can play it as often as they like.
@dufortrph yes the song structure is there, I heard it 100 times, but than here are David and Richard who polished it along with Roger... all that songs would not sound that good without David and Richard... and common, the only dickhead that I see here is you
great to see nick on the drums but please plese roger dont let dave kilminster do the solos let snowy do them or get doyal bramal II back he is way more authentic that kilminster i think he seems smug when he plays the solos
That guitarist needs to go. I know Roger will never play with a someone like David again but this guy dosen't do Pink Floyd well. Let Snowy do the solos, at least he has a history with Pink Floyd.
I don't feel the sense of these songs unless I see the whole band playing it and unfortunately they are very old and rare I wonder why did not they record in a high quality their old live concerts like the wall and the dark side of the moon, I think We should have got the opportounity to see that.
I love the way Nick in 2006 would do a couple of gilmours shows in London and then a few of waters shows also. Maybe waters and gilmour should take a leave each from Nick's Book for a change.
What the fuck are you talking about?!?!?!?! In what way he "ruined" the solo?! It's almost identical of the one recorded on the album. If you don't like his "moves" that's one point, but it's very very stupid to say that he ruined the solo. Actually, he played it very well. Even Gilmour sometimes doesn't stick to the original on his live performances. I really can't understand you guys.
He played the solo note for note. perfectly.. as good as Gilmour does, tho' it didn't have the unique Gilmour resonance, but very impressive! No way!! did he ruin it, & his movements showed he played it with soul & passion. I've heard tons of bootlegs where Gilmour goes off the rails playing different versions, some excllent.. some not so good.
I understand your point, but every guitarist has his own style where they combine their guitar playing with their ''soul''. And he does it like he's the god. Saw him in Holland. But I must agree with you, David is way better. He is a god.
thanks for the post was a great concert i took my son to it he was 15 it was his first ..snowy white on guitar was amazing ,do u remember when the power went off and they were singing perfect sence was soooo great ..thanks again ,,,
In the original fotage 1973 of time u can see that in a part gilmour stops singing for a few secs and u can hear waters voice singing to and pretty well. You can also compare the voice of Shine On... when Waters says You where caught in the crossfire... and it souds like the same vocals in Time. The thing is that Waters sings too in Time
nice vid thanks for posting !!! i love all these guys !! not to sure about ! the floppy haired guitarist !!! a bit to metal in his actions for me !! but hey who i'm am I to say !!! check out ukrelicsband on here !! i'm the fat bloke on guitar !! i hope i do a better job than floppy hair !! long live all the floyd !!! regards chris
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
To be honest, i saw Gilmour in his solo concert and was not impressed. He screwed up the solo on Time! Played it like a kid with a guitar. Of the two i'd say Roger puts on a better show
How the hell can you say that??? Musically, Waters is INFERIOR to Gilmour! Who do you think wrote the solos and the catchy licks to most of Pink Floyd's songs? You're a fucking dousche.
I agree with both of you in that Gilmour is the lifeblood of much of Floyd's music, but Waters was by no means expendable, and I think he led the band and guided Gilmour to be great. Without Waters, Floyd was not the same. But you're right, Gilmour fuckin' rules.
Pink Floyd is the greatest band in the world because of all the members. First you have Roger Waters, the most creative writer of all time, who came up with many great ideas for the band. Second, you've got David Gilmour, the best guitarist of all time, and a master vocalist. Rick Wright, the soul and "secret weapon" of Pink Floyd. Nick Mason a very positive friendly funny guy, who has some fantastic fills and deserves more credit than he gets. Don't say one member is better an another.
Agreed. One member is certainly not better than another, thats kind of like saying once Roger Waters stops touring, there is no PINK FLOYD. Eeeeeeh, there still is, just not with the original members.
@Hogweed11 -You are 101 % correct Floyd is just not one member but a pool of very talented artists who came together and give us the best days of our lives.
@Hogweed11 100% agree. All of them are great individually but when you get four strong talents like that working as one then you get something extraordinary. Pink Floyd will forever be one of they greatest bands of all time.
@Hogweed11 You forgot the most important part. Syd Barrett. Not only the first songwriter of the band, but even after his departure, his downfall served as the inspiration behind their best work. Dark Side Of The Moon, The Wall, Wish You Were Here, all inspired by Syd.
I very much agree. I'm not bashing Waters. Brilliant lyricist and THE best conceptual artist, in my opinion. I just think it's silly to say one was better than the other or that Pink Floyd was only possible because of blah blah blah. It's silly. Waters was and will always be an amazing artist, and Gilmour is such an incredible guitarist. He conveys a distinct mood through his guitar work. I think I like Gilmour more as a solo artist. I saw him in LA for his "On An Island" tour. Amazing show!
@billbenblue well put man, ive also seen On An Island in Manhattan, i was wise then. was perfect, but ive also see all of floyd together during the Animals tour in 1977 in Oakland. i was a crazy, invincible 16yr old, still learning life
both amazing times but impossible to compare. if i had to choose, id definately relive the 70s Floyd over Gilmour solo.. doesnt change the fact that both were the best two shows anyone could hope to experience in this lifetime. they just always fit perfectly ;)
Yeah. It's true. But the guitarrist DOES suck, and so does Roger singing this. The guitarrist seems more worried about posing and looking good than in playing. And see how Roger has to this... thing, with his neck, to handle the vocals. Not that Gilmour's that better at the vocals, since he's old. But he's better than the guitarrist and Roger :X Gotta admit it...
well, naturally of course David Gilmour's singing is better than Rogers on time because he origianlly sung it. But for the condition they are in without the original guitar player and singer...this version is great.
Waters is 63 years old, and has not always been the best singer in the world and ill say that Roger's voice does not fit in with the feel of time.
As for guitar playing, I think it is really good. He sounds alot like Gilmour and his vocals for Rick's part are done well too.
mason is a badass. he needs his mustache back though!!!
cpage07 2 months ago
I think Roger Waters sex appeal is underrated
fishtruckthatloads 2 months ago
the most captivating , musical , mesmerizing drum solo ever
brb0713 3 months ago
electric guitar guy loves himself
kieran360 6 months ago
David was "THE SOUND" of Pink Floyd.The FACT he wrote the Final 2 Albums without Waters also shows he was the Heart of the Band.Dont forget,"On an Island" went #1 World wide.Waters has never approached that by hisself.Not even close.
DaytonaGary 7 months ago
@DaytonaGary in waters's defense, topping charts and turning profits was not really his "aim" with any of his solo work.. good music is personal expression, not fitting demographics.
in the words of David Gilmour: "Art must be completely selfish, the fact that others enjoy it is simply a bonus"
:)
Jagethemage 6 months ago
waters can blow, what a cry baby. saw momentary lapse of reason in the late 80S and gilmore kicked butt
metejs22 7 months ago
fantastico
drrollano 10 months ago
Interesting that Mason is turned (away) from Waters.
Very interesting indeed!
aberdown 10 months ago
@aberdown He's only turned away to hit the roto toms for the song. It is in plain sight.
MrJro2 9 months ago
Nick Mason easily has the most sophisticated playing style in an extremely fun yet simple way; Nick Mason can hold his head high amongst the likes of Bonham, Moon, Peart, etc. just as long as he brings his mustache ;).
slappydum 11 months ago
hey, the song was not over yet, despite that last line...
webtweakers 11 months ago
FYI folks.......Richard Wright wrote this song.........Jeeze, how old are you people?.....maybe 14 or so.
Anyway just another FYI for you people almost all Floyd songs were colaberations within the group however there are on some albums more of one artists imput than on other...EG Waters and The Final Cut.
jaytduce 1 year ago
@jaytduce Richard Wright didn't write Time other than as part of the group. You might be thinking of Us and Them which he did write the music for.
vipersdragband 9 months ago
@vipersdragband He did sing it , so there is a chance he had a big part in it
brb0713 3 months ago
@brb0713 He did sing what? He sang back up on Us and Them and also swapped a few vocals on Time, but Wright didn't do lead on either...
vipersdragband 3 months ago
You really seem like an angry Floydian , that makes me think you just try to argue so you can argue , maybe you should try out the Bieber Belieber site
brb0713 3 months ago
STILL FUCKIN AMAZING
Floyd4201000 1 year ago
no David = FAIL
pageynumbert2 1 year ago
i`ts simply!!!! (syd) waters, gilmour,wright and mason wuuauuu!! PINK FLOYD just PINK FLOYD!!!!! , PINK FLOYD FOREVER AND EVER!!!!!!!
jagger183 1 year ago
get that head bobbing clown pussy with fuckin curley hair playing guitar off the stage
immediatley
only Gilmour can play this song
joeysmokesz195 1 year ago
@joeysmokesz195 Gilmour can play it, but he sure as hell could NEVER have written it.
dufortrph 1 year ago
@joeysmokesz195 He's a great guitarist; anyone who knows anything about music will tell you the same thing-- and, BTW, Roger wrote the song, so he and his band can play it as often as they like.
dufortrph 1 year ago
@dufortrph I assume that Roger wrote a music or guitar solo for this song ?
msaric10 1 year ago
@msaric10 He did write the music, dickhead. Listen to his demo - the chords and song structure are there. Of course he didn't write the guitar solo.
dufortrph 1 year ago
@dufortrph yes the song structure is there, I heard it 100 times, but than here are David and Richard who polished it along with Roger... all that songs would not sound that good without David and Richard... and common, the only dickhead that I see here is you
msaric10 1 year ago
Guitarist ruined the whole video for me
DancesWithNarwhals 1 year ago
I don't know why people are slagging on the Guitarist, he's good, David won't play with Roger, its time to get over it.
Rustyshackleford08 1 year ago
@Rustyshackleford08 You were wrong...:)
PaulBFlydFan 1 year ago
@PaulBFlydFan
Yeah I found that out:)
Rustyshackleford08 1 year ago
@Rustyshackleford08
PaulBFlydFan 1 year ago
i fucking hate people that play solos on tele
FUCK
and that gay is like sucking an epic dick jesus christ its a fucking guitar fagg
Kuhlyedascope69 1 year ago
hogweed11... is a genius
WesternJam 1 year ago
Jon Carin is such a talented musician,. great video. Roger will allways be the creative genius of Pink Floyd. David, Rick And NIck are great too do.
chichipotle 1 year ago
great to see nick on the drums but please plese roger dont let dave kilminster do the solos let snowy do them or get doyal bramal II back he is way more authentic that kilminster i think he seems smug when he plays the solos
4acid 1 year ago
That guitarist needs to go. I know Roger will never play with a someone like David again but this guy dosen't do Pink Floyd well. Let Snowy do the solos, at least he has a history with Pink Floyd.
9mikeb4 1 year ago
@9mikeb4 i agree wayyy over the top that guy, jeez .....just bad
BurnThisMutherDown 1 year ago
Its nice but...damn I have a stupid feeling when I see some random guitarist or singer making Gilmour or Wright parts...maybe a feeling of a crime
Fl0yDian86 1 year ago
I don't feel the sense of these songs unless I see the whole band playing it and unfortunately they are very old and rare I wonder why did not they record in a high quality their old live concerts like the wall and the dark side of the moon, I think We should have got the opportounity to see that.
ebeidmahmoud 1 year ago
Waters "No one could replace Gilmour", you made a big mistake when you left them
ebeidmahmoud 1 year ago 3
I love the way Nick in 2006 would do a couple of gilmours shows in London and then a few of waters shows also. Maybe waters and gilmour should take a leave each from Nick's Book for a change.
OfficialNeilGard 2 years ago
i'm suprised the guitarist wasn't dressed like a disco ball and hanging upside-down from the ceiling... what a clown.
zombieboy9x3 2 years ago
do u know who ur talking about??
D guy i think ur on about is doyle bramhall eric claptons sessions player and the other is snowy white from thin lizzy
trevber 2 years ago
no my friend he is not doyle bramhall jr.he is dave kilminster a great axeman to!
meddle3 2 years ago
I know He goes totally overboard with the posing ! Good solo though !!!
yellow2000fluff 2 years ago
genius!!!!!!!!!!!!!
diegocap80 2 years ago
the solo sounded perfectly fine to me... dunno what the fuss is about
LondonKumamoto 2 years ago
What the fuck are you talking about?!?!?!?! In what way he "ruined" the solo?! It's almost identical of the one recorded on the album. If you don't like his "moves" that's one point, but it's very very stupid to say that he ruined the solo. Actually, he played it very well. Even Gilmour sometimes doesn't stick to the original on his live performances. I really can't understand you guys.
Kurbisa 2 years ago
He played the solo note for note. perfectly.. as good as Gilmour does, tho' it didn't have the unique Gilmour resonance, but very impressive! No way!! did he ruin it, & his movements showed he played it with soul & passion. I've heard tons of bootlegs where Gilmour goes off the rails playing different versions, some excllent.. some not so good.
nottingtohide 2 years ago 5
What is this guitarist??????????????? He 's not in a reality show, flegmatic David Gilmour misses so much............
jajah62 2 years ago 2
actually nick mason and another drummer is playing at the same time
aong with the rest of the band
hackysackdude120 2 years ago
wtf is the guitarist doing? is he actually jamming to the solo? u cant do that, u have to feel it, its so emotional, he killed it man he killed it
DEADMAN3467 2 years ago 4
i agree Deadman, he killed it, its suppose to be felt not jammed too
PinkisthePigFloyd 2 years ago 2
I understand your point, but every guitarist has his own style where they combine their guitar playing with their ''soul''. And he does it like he's the god. Saw him in Holland. But I must agree with you, David is way better. He is a god.
Ferankooo 2 years ago
Oh shit, I thought that was a chick playing the guitar for a second.
Desperado8600 2 years ago
great to see them able to keep playing together
Obelisk2290 2 years ago 2
strat > tele
mightyzeppelin 2 years ago 3
Nick Mason Rocksss!!!!
oscarivan1021 2 years ago
altos capos los dos
TheOpmvideos 2 years ago
who the fuck was that tring to cover richard wrights part? way to ruin it.
TheAudioFlex 2 years ago
It's Jon Carin...played for post-Waters Pink Floyd
quincyq03 2 years ago
I love Nick's intro
skateboarding118 2 years ago
Waters is god
MilkShack 2 years ago 3
WTF? who plays the drums on the first ten seconds after the intro... And who is playing that bass fills when roger is singing his las verses???
ObiManMDQ 3 years ago
probably backtrack man:)
chriswikkid 3 years ago
there is a second drummer man:)
chriswikkid 3 years ago
There is a second drummer (graham broad) and in Time Andy Fairweather-Law always plays bass (so there is a double bass) together with rog.
Nick at rottotom is the best!!!
as040412 3 years ago 2
This is not Doyle Bramhall II... this guy is better, but David Gilmour is unique and he's the best. Roger too.
eucriatura 3 years ago
I miss Doyle Bramhall II and David Gilmour on this song! Only they can pull this off :D
LeifJohan 3 years ago
thanks for the post was a great concert i took my son to it he was 15 it was his first ..snowy white on guitar was amazing ,do u remember when the power went off and they were singing perfect sence was soooo great ..thanks again ,,,
flaxfields 3 years ago
Waters the genius of PINK FLOYD.
rockaires 3 years ago 4
Giusto una canzoncina....questi sono i più grandi di sempre.Nessuno regge il confronto.
sissokki 3 years ago 3
they were all at their best when they were together.
lucyfaire1980 3 years ago
Diossss, menudo solo de guitarra!!! tocarlo debe de ser una liberación. Qué bonico Nicki tocando la batería. Amo esta canción.
pfloyaryadna 3 years ago
The greatest Lyrics, Music and Solo EVER !!!!!!!!!!!!!!
motokev 3 years ago 2
was this from tripped out in cork? because you may want to remove it ASAP!
tenordude14 3 years ago
Still enjoy the split singing between Gilmour and Wright. Gilmours guitar has much more emotion, however this was enjoyable.
zooropa2day 3 years ago
Waters is god! The way he does this song is amazing i like his voice much better but that is my own opinion.
deadheadwookie17 3 years ago 5
In the original fotage 1973 of time u can see that in a part gilmour stops singing for a few secs and u can hear waters voice singing to and pretty well. You can also compare the voice of Shine On... when Waters says You where caught in the crossfire... and it souds like the same vocals in Time. The thing is that Waters sings too in Time
ericponsv 3 years ago
nice vid thanks for posting !!! i love all these guys !! not to sure about ! the floppy haired guitarist !!! a bit to metal in his actions for me !! but hey who i'm am I to say !!! check out ukrelicsband on here !! i'm the fat bloke on guitar !! i hope i do a better job than floppy hair !! long live all the floyd !!! regards chris
mrplopplop 3 years ago
Funny... in the roto-tom intro Mason stood in front of the screen - Waters and the guitarist tried but obviously he didn't hear them...
DaBlaubaer 4 years ago
thanks to everyone playing , singing or trying to be Pink Floyd - keep on rocking !!
baruch216 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Gilmour is an old fart. Eat your heart out. This is great stuf by the only real legend of Pink Floyd, Roger Waters. WOW.
hansvandenburg 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
To be honest, i saw Gilmour in his solo concert and was not impressed. He screwed up the solo on Time! Played it like a kid with a guitar. Of the two i'd say Roger puts on a better show
ragsiruh 4 years ago
Waters is older than he is, and can't sing anymore.
Comparing the two is pointless anyway.
Andrew72287 4 years ago
How the hell can you say that??? Musically, Waters is INFERIOR to Gilmour! Who do you think wrote the solos and the catchy licks to most of Pink Floyd's songs? You're a fucking dousche.
caliginoushaze 3 years ago
amen 2 that. roger is a poet, gilmour is a musician. anyone can write and play music but only a real musician can give music a soul.
nannynicklife 3 years ago 2
I agree with both of you in that Gilmour is the lifeblood of much of Floyd's music, but Waters was by no means expendable, and I think he led the band and guided Gilmour to be great. Without Waters, Floyd was not the same. But you're right, Gilmour fuckin' rules.
waterbean05 3 years ago
Pink Floyd is the greatest band in the world because of all the members. First you have Roger Waters, the most creative writer of all time, who came up with many great ideas for the band. Second, you've got David Gilmour, the best guitarist of all time, and a master vocalist. Rick Wright, the soul and "secret weapon" of Pink Floyd. Nick Mason a very positive friendly funny guy, who has some fantastic fills and deserves more credit than he gets. Don't say one member is better an another.
Hogweed11 3 years ago 50
you nailed it man, it couldn't be said any better, p.s nick mason is totally the best most under rated drummer
benjamminwoodhouse 3 years ago 3
Agreed. One member is certainly not better than another, thats kind of like saying once Roger Waters stops touring, there is no PINK FLOYD. Eeeeeeh, there still is, just not with the original members.
Thumbs up.
RollinRolex 2 years ago
@Hogweed11 -You are 101 % correct Floyd is just not one member but a pool of very talented artists who came together and give us the best days of our lives.
asydwaters4u 1 year ago
@Hogweed11 100% agree. All of them are great individually but when you get four strong talents like that working as one then you get something extraordinary. Pink Floyd will forever be one of they greatest bands of all time.
iLLUSiiONS111 1 year ago
@Hogweed11 You forgot the most important part. Syd Barrett. Not only the first songwriter of the band, but even after his departure, his downfall served as the inspiration behind their best work. Dark Side Of The Moon, The Wall, Wish You Were Here, all inspired by Syd.
Mikemaniax 7 months ago
Musically, Gimour was better ,but alone he wouldnt have made it. I mean, Roger's lyrics and concepts were also mastermind
qwerty09121209 3 years ago
I very much agree. I'm not bashing Waters. Brilliant lyricist and THE best conceptual artist, in my opinion. I just think it's silly to say one was better than the other or that Pink Floyd was only possible because of blah blah blah. It's silly. Waters was and will always be an amazing artist, and Gilmour is such an incredible guitarist. He conveys a distinct mood through his guitar work. I think I like Gilmour more as a solo artist. I saw him in LA for his "On An Island" tour. Amazing show!
billbenblue 3 years ago 9
@billbenblue well put man, ive also seen On An Island in Manhattan, i was wise then. was perfect, but ive also see all of floyd together during the Animals tour in 1977 in Oakland. i was a crazy, invincible 16yr old, still learning life
both amazing times but impossible to compare. if i had to choose, id definately relive the 70s Floyd over Gilmour solo.. doesnt change the fact that both were the best two shows anyone could hope to experience in this lifetime. they just always fit perfectly ;)
Jagethemage 6 months ago
guitarist sucks!,ever seen David Gilmour posing like that?
anyway Waters' voice is different,it fits perfect in some songs but not to this one.Nick Mason is perfect! Legends!
Sidewindertr 5 years ago
Every artist has his/her own style. Not fair to do any comparison. But seems the original's always better.
ac338 4 years ago
I thought the guitarist did a Phenomenal job!
ninjasnowai 5 years ago
Roger is not a good singer anymore, but the guitarist was all right I must say. You cant be as good as David Gilmour. ;)
stjarnjerry 5 years ago
thnks 4 posting!!! nick and roger rock!!
maninabox11 5 years ago
No need for two drummers... if he's going to invite Nick to play the drums then he should not have two drummers. Bad Roger.
carlosariars 5 years ago
the guitarist is a dope
dan19x77 5 years ago
Yeah. It's true. But the guitarrist DOES suck, and so does Roger singing this. The guitarrist seems more worried about posing and looking good than in playing. And see how Roger has to this... thing, with his neck, to handle the vocals. Not that Gilmour's that better at the vocals, since he's old. But he's better than the guitarrist and Roger :X Gotta admit it...
GilmourishFan 5 years ago
well, naturally of course David Gilmour's singing is better than Rogers on time because he origianlly sung it. But for the condition they are in without the original guitar player and singer...this version is great.
Waters is 63 years old, and has not always been the best singer in the world and ill say that Roger's voice does not fit in with the feel of time.
As for guitar playing, I think it is really good. He sounds alot like Gilmour and his vocals for Rick's part are done well too.
pjennings111 5 years ago
its not like GilmourishFan's comment is biased or anything...considering his username is GilmourishFan
pjennings111 5 years ago
Hee Hee Hee....
frank6306 5 years ago
umm?? Are there two drummers there?
Or a backing track?
ratemydrums 5 years ago
Quem é esse poser na guitarra? Parece uma mariposa. E Roger cantando essa msusica é um saco. Mas é assim... tem gente que nunca sabe parar...
Intrudo 5 years ago
If the solo and the vocals didn't suck, it would be great =X
GilmourishFan 5 years ago