@ddsharper Thanks for your comment--participial phrases always function as adjectives, not adverbs. "Who owns stock" answers the question "which person" ("the one who owns stock--that's which person"). Things that answer "which" questions are adjectival. Adverbs answer questions about how, when, where, and why things happen.
@mrthoth I think you just made an honest mistake at 7:27. You state that because "whom you know" answers 'which person', it is an adjectival subordinate clause. You then say that "who owns stock" is answering 'which person', but is actually functioning as an adverb.
Was that just a slip of the tongue, or am I missing something?
How about 'Is it that the British are coming?' In English the sentence the British are coming can be made subordinate simply by adding a subordinating conjunction in front, so '...that the British are coming.' But this is not necessarily the case in other languages. For example consider the German sentence 'Die Britische kommen jetzt' and '...dass die Britishce jetzt kommen.'
This good and i understand it. but for people who are just beginning to learn it, I don't think they'll understand, u'd have to start from the beginning for them.
@dwhitefant "Can you believe another year has past / passed?" is like "Can you believe another year has gone?" That tells you that what you want after "has" is the past participle of a verb. "Past" is either an adjective (as in "past presidents") or a noun ("the past was better"), but "passed" is the past participle of "pass," and it's what you want in the sentence "Another year has passed," or "You have passed the test."
i really apreciate your explinantion, you are great. i studied subordinate clauses at the university since 1999. i got the impression that forgot almost all the things, but thinks to your video i start
"what you see is what you get, thats what you get, what you see is a subject, and therefore thats noun. what do you see? what you get is what you see, see what you get is what it is, see is."
hahahah even though that makes no sense the video was good, thanks :D
wow this video sucks who cares about that crap
1966gopackgo 1 month ago
Thank you so much! I was having quite a bit of trouble doing my work until I saw your video!
MosesMyPeople 4 months ago
@mrthoth, why can't the question be asked "what person" as opposed to "which person?"
McLarryson 6 months ago
7:27 did you say that last sentence is functioning as an adverb? modifying person?
ddsharper 8 months ago
@ddsharper Thanks for your comment--participial phrases always function as adjectives, not adverbs. "Who owns stock" answers the question "which person" ("the one who owns stock--that's which person"). Things that answer "which" questions are adjectival. Adverbs answer questions about how, when, where, and why things happen.
mrthoth 8 months ago
@mrthoth thank you.
ddsharper 8 months ago
@mrthoth I think you just made an honest mistake at 7:27. You state that because "whom you know" answers 'which person', it is an adjectival subordinate clause. You then say that "who owns stock" is answering 'which person', but is actually functioning as an adverb.
Was that just a slip of the tongue, or am I missing something?
Thanks! Awesome video as always.
regan4000 2 weeks ago in playlist English Grammar Lessons
@regan4000 Right. I should have said "who owns stock" is functioning as an adjective.
mrthoth 2 weeks ago
How about 'Is it that the British are coming?' In English the sentence the British are coming can be made subordinate simply by adding a subordinating conjunction in front, so '...that the British are coming.' But this is not necessarily the case in other languages. For example consider the German sentence 'Die Britische kommen jetzt' and '...dass die Britishce jetzt kommen.'
Myrtone 9 months ago
Thank you for your consistently clear and emphatic teaching.
Flawhound 1 year ago
thankyou so much you really helped!
MattandMaxAdventures 1 year ago
Explain catch-22 please.
TheGravyGuzzler 1 year ago
HELPED A LOT! thanks!
thecapone45 1 year ago
Is "left," in the last sentense, a subjective complement?
jonnybik12 1 year ago
@jonnybik12 "Left" is the main verb ("has left" is the whole verb phrase).
mrthoth 1 year ago
This good and i understand it. but for people who are just beginning to learn it, I don't think they'll understand, u'd have to start from the beginning for them.
badass147 1 year ago
Dear Yossarian,
Can you please settle an ongoing dispute between my ex-husband and myself?
Which sentence is grammatically correct:
a. Can you believe another year has passed? or
b. Can you believe another year has past?
Thanks.
dwhitefant 1 year ago
@dwhitefant "Can you believe another year has past / passed?" is like "Can you believe another year has gone?" That tells you that what you want after "has" is the past participle of a verb. "Past" is either an adjective (as in "past presidents") or a noun ("the past was better"), but "passed" is the past participle of "pass," and it's what you want in the sentence "Another year has passed," or "You have passed the test."
mrthoth 1 year ago
relavtive pronouns or relative adverbs what? 7:55
wwwmw100 1 year ago
i really apreciate your explinantion, you are great. i studied subordinate clauses at the university since 1999. i got the impression that forgot almost all the things, but thinks to your video i start
to refresh my memory.
thannks abundle
TheTachelhit 2 years ago
thanks test tommorow u saved me
taleoftwo 2 years ago
Thanks. :)
TheLarssan 2 years ago
VERY NICE INDEED! THANKS
hawaela 2 years ago
i have a test tommrow on this and i dnt get it to
capricorntib 2 years ago
i don't get this and i got it for homework that i have to hand in tomorrow :(
nighthunter135 2 years ago
If we lose we will feel happy. LOL
Slasherboi24 2 years ago
Yossarian the Grammarian is an excellent teacher - a master teacher!
Your clear and concise explanations are energetically delivered and a joy to hear.
Thank you for your good work!
RL
rlewis19461 2 years ago 2
thanks! helped me to study for my final!!!
eric3ryan 2 years ago
Thanks teacher, you are great, I appreciate ur help , that was amazing, thanks again...
Angeljosetoronto 2 years ago
Thank you so much for explaining so nicely.
suvendurinku 2 years ago
Awsome, Thanks
suroviecg 2 years ago
Excellent. Thank you.
mousegeek 2 years ago
I learned something from this video
The sentence above is a independent clause HAHAHAHAHAHA
spatesel 3 years ago
"what you see is what you get, thats what you get, what you see is a subject, and therefore thats noun. what do you see? what you get is what you see, see what you get is what it is, see is."
hahahah even though that makes no sense the video was good, thanks :D
taho113 3 years ago
thxx it helped me in my exam cuz my teacher is inbeliveable i cant understand a word from him
katkatkoo 3 years ago
i mean unbeliveable
katkatkoo 3 years ago
thank you for being an amazing homework helper!
anderwaldmanman2 3 years ago 2
thanks!!! you helped me with me homework!! hahaha
Joshman621 3 years ago 3
wow he's awsome i can understand it now jsut thx to u xD thank you
belon95 3 years ago 3
Great job!!!!
orazalinz 3 years ago 3
your such a good teacher thanks
mayosh77 3 years ago 6
thanks!! so much please post more on this
im4evaurzz 3 years ago 9
Thank you teacher!!
garotobossanova 4 years ago 14
Please post more!!!
mskothlow 4 years ago 14
please keep up the good work
pazzamex 4 years ago 10