@Thegreatbuk Not only vague, but full of magical-mystical mummery like "poetry first," "infinite colors," blah, blah (are "hearts" and "clovers" involved too?). So playing Scarlatti (or any other composer) in a way in which he would recognize his own music is delusional and empty... Hmm... I guess you'll be happy to know that John Tesh's album of Satie and Bach is in stores now!
@Thegreatbuk Surprising as it may seem I actually agree with many of your vague points. But this is NOT the end of pianistic development for Ms. Wang. Horowitz: I consider him one of the greatest, but simply prefer not to grovel at the altar of St. Vlad. His '86 Moscow version of K380 is superb (partly in fact because it is "fleet and facile"); but his '68 Carnegie version, though brilliant its own idiosyncratic way, is slow and overpedalled, and should be attributed to "Horowitz/Scarlatti".
@ekrenek How big of you to agree. There is nothing vague about my points. I heard Horowitz in person in '86.
All great artists impart something of their own when interpreting works. The same could be said of Heifetz, Feurmann, Casals, Toscanini. This notion of "modern" interpretation where one thinks one is merely presenting the score is delusional and often merely empty.
@Thegreatbuk Based on the inchoate responses to all previous posts, I think you're a total fraud. Otherwise by now you'd have provided a theoretically-grounded musical analysis for your assertions, instead of throwing around meaningless words like "robot" and endless Horowitz boot-lickings. My prediction is that your next post will be no different.
@Thegreatbuk 1) I'm not a particular fan of Wang at this point - just recognize very real potential 2) you didn't answer my questions, thus exposing your musical ignorance to everyone. 3) I can't believe I got sucked in by a troll...
@Thegreatbuk Here's your "homework": First, provide a purely musicological definition of playing "like a robot" w/o gushing appeals to personal idols like Horowitz. Second, since you've "discovered" that "by the early 20's, if one plays like a robot, it probably isn't going to change much," you should be able to name a few pianists who started out playing "like a robot" & stayed that way througout their careers, & a few who were later able to move beyond their earlier "robotic" style of playing.
@ekrenek Robotic playing: lack of nuance, over simplifying phrasing and tone coloration, a 2 dimensional approach to a work as a whole. Treating every composer in a similiar manner, in her case... a fleet and facile technique slathered over any and every composer and piece. Not such a bad thing, but not true artistry. Contrast that to Horowitz (for example): infinite colors within a single phrase, much more life, poetry first, technique serves the poetry.
@ekrenek btw, Horowitz was a personal idol to many artists greater than I. I'm in good company. Furthermore, am happy to be at odds with an intelletual cripple such as yourself.
@Thegreatbuk Please let us all know when and where your so-called "discovery" will be published. I'm sure we'll all be dazzled your impeccable research design and data collection methods. Until then please refrain from floating these worthless BS statements.
On the contrary.... I very much appreciate young talent. But I've discovered that by the early 20's, if one plays like a robot, it probably isn't going to change much.
I like Ms Wang's Scarlatti interpretations quite a lot. BTW, did anyone notice her vocalizations? Not quite as obvious as Gould's but definitely there.
@Winterstick549 You DO know who that pianist, Horowitz was, right? He had more music in his right pinky than every cell in her body. Again, my opinion. I can't help it if you have no class or culture.
Yuja Wang is truly great for Scarlatti ... Check out Fernando Valenti on the Harpsichord for other great versions. Arturo Benedetti Michelangeli is also amazing for Scarliatti on piano. All available on YOUTUBE ....
Liszt is not just a composer. Read the book "Liszt: The Virtuoso Years." It has been written by many musicians, composers and pianists how absolutely incredible his playing is. I will take their word for it.
As for me, I don't really care how I compare to her. I don't have to like her playing just because she plays better than me. That's an absurd suggestion.
I like these Scarlatti performances. A lot of her other performances I don't like.
@MrStrav81 Mr Strav, there is alot of desperate, foolish and immature people here. Just ignore. Of course Liszt was a colossal genius and performer, far better than pianist alive. Just look at his writing. Doh!
I like very much, simplicity and sincerity from her fingers and heart, it seems to me. In certain moments she reaches Horowitz' levels, I think she has taken inspiration from him. Surely one of the best pianists, today.
All pianists in the world must be taking lessons from Yuja Wang. Perhaps Liszt himself could could not play as well. All composers she plays are applauding her. Fingers like hers are seen only once in a hundred years.
I agree completely. Furthermore, if she were half the musician that Liszt were, she would be making her own creations and not be doing her own superficial modifications to well known transcriptions. In my opinion, that is really lame. I have nothing against her otherwise really, but that really irks me.
For that matter, a lot of pianists on the stage today would take Yuja Wang to school. Argerich, Freire, Kissin, Volodos, Perahia, Hamelin just to name a few.
@MrStrav81 i dun really wanna compare her with Liszt. One is the player and the other is composer. I have never heard Liszt played lived and I have no doubt he was great.
As for you, i am 100% sure you are not even 0.1% the musician that Yuja was at age of 10.
@MrStrav81 Excuse, but who is the pianist at the moment been half of the musician who Liszt was?. Tell me one please! By all means none of that you name, but in other way, all exelents!
Nevertheless, there is a venezuelan pianist called Gabriela Montero who perhaps is the 8% o 10% of the music that Liszt was. (sorry about my english)
@lsbrother There was a young girl, a Liszt student, her name was Amy (I don't remember her last name). She likes writing and years later she became a professional writer which was her way of living. She left us an enormous extended documental aspects about the musical life of Franz Liszt. Also there were more people that left testimonies about Chopin, Schuman, Brahams, etc. The people who study this kind of documents are the musicologists.
@lsbrother There was a young girl, a Liszt student, her name was Amy (I don't remember her last name). She likes writing and years later she became a professional writer which was her way of living. She left us an enormous extended documental aspects about the musical life of Franz Liszt. Also there were more people that left testimonies about Chopin, Schuman, Brahams, etc. The people who study this kind of documents are the musicologists.
Excellent, brillant même, mais pas non plus renversant : Yuja Wang manque d'esprit, de verve : elle n'est pas Marcelle Meyer, pas Horowitz, pas Ciccolini, pas Gilels, pas Clara Haskil. Elle est Yuja Wang ce qui n'est pas si mal...
Yuja IS the modern piano. She is imo the worthiest successor of Horowitz, who was the interpreter of our/his time. Her interpretation of both Scarlatti and Scriabin is the most original since the great maestro. And remember that he was the prodigy sensation of his time. His Scriabin is the greatest ever. Hers is the most original since then.
Could anyone tell me the name of the first sonata Yuja plays? I can't seem to find anything that sounds like it on youtube....:( even though i typed in all the names listed in the description.
Beautifully and sensitively played, with a regard for the counterpoint present in the work, and evocative of another time and place. The following pieces also beautifully done.
yes 10 fingers very big!!!!!!
camitful 1 month ago
i see very big hands!!!!!!!!!!
camitful 1 month ago
yes ...... But when componist?
camitful 1 month ago
Stupenda esecutrice ma quando compositrice?
camitful 1 month ago
@camitful
E quando compositrice stupenda da esecutrice ?
geertdehoux 1 week ago
My fav Scarlatti pieces. Love it.
lllllllllllllll88 1 month ago
I would love to hear her play the K27, K135 and K141
lousycactus 1 month ago
These four Scarlatti pieces will now forever be known as the "Cricket Sonatas of Yuja Wang."
WJE37FCSM 2 months ago 3
@WJE37FCSM LoL!
otterhouse 2 months ago
@WJE37FCSM
Yes!
MrGyurica 1 month ago
Bellisima - Bravo!
fcg2367 4 months ago
it's really special to play with crickets..........I wish I were there to listen live=V=
toolatetobeapianist 4 months ago
@thebloads she plays beautiful and she also looks beautiful
jafskater1 5 months ago
@jafskater1
Agree!
MrGyurica 1 month ago
@Thegreatbuk Not only vague, but full of magical-mystical mummery like "poetry first," "infinite colors," blah, blah (are "hearts" and "clovers" involved too?). So playing Scarlatti (or any other composer) in a way in which he would recognize his own music is delusional and empty... Hmm... I guess you'll be happy to know that John Tesh's album of Satie and Bach is in stores now!
ekrenek 5 months ago
@ekrenek umm, a little far fetched. Now... your credentials? Silencio.
Well, let's hear your musical analysis, please... I can't wait. I can't believe I've wasted my time
responding to such an uncultured ignoramus. Goodbye.
Thegreatbuk 5 months ago
@ekrenek obviously you are a total mediocrity like your namesake.
Thegreatbuk 5 months ago
Comment removed
Thegreatbuk 5 months ago
@Thegreatbuk Surprising as it may seem I actually agree with many of your vague points. But this is NOT the end of pianistic development for Ms. Wang. Horowitz: I consider him one of the greatest, but simply prefer not to grovel at the altar of St. Vlad. His '86 Moscow version of K380 is superb (partly in fact because it is "fleet and facile"); but his '68 Carnegie version, though brilliant its own idiosyncratic way, is slow and overpedalled, and should be attributed to "Horowitz/Scarlatti".
ekrenek 5 months ago
@ekrenek How big of you to agree. There is nothing vague about my points. I heard Horowitz in person in '86.
All great artists impart something of their own when interpreting works. The same could be said of Heifetz, Feurmann, Casals, Toscanini. This notion of "modern" interpretation where one thinks one is merely presenting the score is delusional and often merely empty.
Thegreatbuk 5 months ago
@Thegreatbuk Based on the inchoate responses to all previous posts, I think you're a total fraud. Otherwise by now you'd have provided a theoretically-grounded musical analysis for your assertions, instead of throwing around meaningless words like "robot" and endless Horowitz boot-lickings. My prediction is that your next post will be no different.
ekrenek 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@ekrenek I see you chose not to answer my question proving that you are a desperate 15 year old fanboy.
Thegreatbuk 5 months ago
@Thegreatbuk 1) I'm not a particular fan of Wang at this point - just recognize very real potential 2) you didn't answer my questions, thus exposing your musical ignorance to everyone. 3) I can't believe I got sucked in by a troll...
ekrenek 5 months ago
@ekrenek Nice logic! not answering your questions= exposing my musical ignorance!!! Hahaha!!!! Lovely.
I'm actually asian, and went to Juilliard. Ever hear of that place? Now what are your credentials.
Thegreatbuk 5 months ago
@Thegreatbuk Here's your "homework": First, provide a purely musicological definition of playing "like a robot" w/o gushing appeals to personal idols like Horowitz. Second, since you've "discovered" that "by the early 20's, if one plays like a robot, it probably isn't going to change much," you should be able to name a few pianists who started out playing "like a robot" & stayed that way througout their careers, & a few who were later able to move beyond their earlier "robotic" style of playing.
ekrenek 5 months ago
@ekrenek first you should get over your gushing fanboy appeal of Wang. LOL!
Thegreatbuk 5 months ago
@ekrenek Robotic playing: lack of nuance, over simplifying phrasing and tone coloration, a 2 dimensional approach to a work as a whole. Treating every composer in a similiar manner, in her case... a fleet and facile technique slathered over any and every composer and piece. Not such a bad thing, but not true artistry. Contrast that to Horowitz (for example): infinite colors within a single phrase, much more life, poetry first, technique serves the poetry.
Thegreatbuk 5 months ago
@ekrenek btw, Horowitz was a personal idol to many artists greater than I. I'm in good company. Furthermore, am happy to be at odds with an intelletual cripple such as yourself.
Thegreatbuk 5 months ago
@Thegreatbuk Please let us all know when and where your so-called "discovery" will be published. I'm sure we'll all be dazzled your impeccable research design and data collection methods. Until then please refrain from floating these worthless BS statements.
ekrenek 6 months ago
Comment removed
Thegreatbuk 6 months ago
@ekrenek I guess any opinion that doesn´t line up with yours is a "worthless BS statement". That´s very cute.
Now go do your homework.
Thegreatbuk 6 months ago
On the contrary.... I very much appreciate young talent. But I've discovered that by the early 20's, if one plays like a robot, it probably isn't going to change much.
Thegreatbuk 6 months ago
I like Ms Wang's Scarlatti interpretations quite a lot. BTW, did anyone notice her vocalizations? Not quite as obvious as Gould's but definitely there.
ekrenek 6 months ago
The most important thing is that she is pretty. This helps her career 100000x more than any piano playing would.
grumblekin 6 months ago
@grumblekin The sad truth.
Thegreatbuk 5 months ago
Comment removed
Thegreatbuk 6 months ago
@Thegreatbuk Yeah, we will take your untalented word for it and agree she sucks. I cant hear your playing on yourtube, but I'm not holding my breath.
Winterstick549 6 months ago
Comment removed
Thegreatbuk 6 months ago
@Winterstick549 You DO know who that pianist, Horowitz was, right? He had more music in his right pinky than every cell in her body. Again, my opinion. I can't help it if you have no class or culture.
Thegreatbuk 6 months ago
@Thegreatbuk Your language tells me all about your culture and how you cant appreciate the skills of such a young talent.
Winterstick549 6 months ago
@Thegreatbuk In my opinion, your negative coments about Miss Wang is because you are racist!
Sophiestelle 5 months ago
@Sophiestelle A racist asian i guess.
Thegreatbuk 5 months ago
@Thegreatbuk Also a dirty Nazi?
Sophiestelle 5 months ago
@Sophiestelle LOL! Nazi? You're really sick.
Thegreatbuk 5 months ago
Comment removed
Thegreatbuk 6 months ago
Yuja Wang is truly great for Scarlatti ... Check out Fernando Valenti on the Harpsichord for other great versions. Arturo Benedetti Michelangeli is also amazing for Scarliatti on piano. All available on YOUTUBE ....
cabottobac 8 months ago
Shes sooooooo talented and amazing!! My piano teacher says she plays the K380 the best out of any pianist who's ever played it
KPopluver869 8 months ago
Liszt is not just a composer. Read the book "Liszt: The Virtuoso Years." It has been written by many musicians, composers and pianists how absolutely incredible his playing is. I will take their word for it.
As for me, I don't really care how I compare to her. I don't have to like her playing just because she plays better than me. That's an absurd suggestion.
I like these Scarlatti performances. A lot of her other performances I don't like.
MrStrav81 10 months ago
@MrStrav81 Mr Strav, there is alot of desperate, foolish and immature people here. Just ignore. Of course Liszt was a colossal genius and performer, far better than pianist alive. Just look at his writing. Doh!
Thegreatbuk 5 months ago
I like very much, simplicity and sincerity from her fingers and heart, it seems to me. In certain moments she reaches Horowitz' levels, I think she has taken inspiration from him. Surely one of the best pianists, today.
Wonderful document that I have saved on my pc.
medtner1970 11 months ago 6
@medtner1970
You are absolutely right!
MrGyurica 1 month ago
Great!
harukou38524 1 year ago
Kill those disrecpectful crickets!
nabzz1978 1 year ago
@nabzz1978 Haha, no ! If you listen carefully, you will realize that Yuja is the only one able to make crickets understand music =)
Zanpra 1 year ago 2
All pianists in the world must be taking lessons from Yuja Wang. Perhaps Liszt himself could could not play as well. All composers she plays are applauding her. Fingers like hers are seen only once in a hundred years.
StephenChin1 1 year ago
@StephenChin1 Franz Liszt would take Yuja Wang to school any day. Come on.
Ckorn123 1 year ago 5
@Ckorn123
I agree completely. Furthermore, if she were half the musician that Liszt were, she would be making her own creations and not be doing her own superficial modifications to well known transcriptions. In my opinion, that is really lame. I have nothing against her otherwise really, but that really irks me.
For that matter, a lot of pianists on the stage today would take Yuja Wang to school. Argerich, Freire, Kissin, Volodos, Perahia, Hamelin just to name a few.
MrStrav81 1 year ago
@MrStrav81 u know shit about music, stfu nerd and get a life, shes excelent.
DjFloyd007 1 year ago
@MrStrav81 i dun really wanna compare her with Liszt. One is the player and the other is composer. I have never heard Liszt played lived and I have no doubt he was great.
As for you, i am 100% sure you are not even 0.1% the musician that Yuja was at age of 10.
KitaroED 10 months ago 3
@MrStrav81 Excuse, but who is the pianist at the moment been half of the musician who Liszt was?. Tell me one please! By all means none of that you name, but in other way, all exelents!
Nevertheless, there is a venezuelan pianist called Gabriela Montero who perhaps is the 8% o 10% of the music that Liszt was. (sorry about my english)
Sophiestelle 9 months ago
@Sophiestelle Never heard Liszt play so couldn't say - don't see how anyone could.
lsbrother 7 months ago
@lsbrother There was a young girl, a Liszt student, her name was Amy (I don't remember her last name). She likes writing and years later she became a professional writer which was her way of living. She left us an enormous extended documental aspects about the musical life of Franz Liszt. Also there were more people that left testimonies about Chopin, Schuman, Brahams, etc. The people who study this kind of documents are the musicologists.
Sophiestelle 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@lsbrother There was a young girl, a Liszt student, her name was Amy (I don't remember her last name). She likes writing and years later she became a professional writer which was her way of living. She left us an enormous extended documental aspects about the musical life of Franz Liszt. Also there were more people that left testimonies about Chopin, Schuman, Brahams, etc. The people who study this kind of documents are the musicologists.
Sophiestelle 5 months ago
@MrStrav81 Thank you for having at least a shred of musical knowledge and an "ear". Something that's obviously missing in these posts.
Thegreatbuk 5 months ago
Excellent, brillant même, mais pas non plus renversant : Yuja Wang manque d'esprit, de verve : elle n'est pas Marcelle Meyer, pas Horowitz, pas Ciccolini, pas Gilels, pas Clara Haskil. Elle est Yuja Wang ce qui n'est pas si mal...
pianotonton 1 year ago
Yuja IS the modern piano. She is imo the worthiest successor of Horowitz, who was the interpreter of our/his time. Her interpretation of both Scarlatti and Scriabin is the most original since the great maestro. And remember that he was the prodigy sensation of his time. His Scriabin is the greatest ever. Hers is the most original since then.
BUS344Yankees 1 year ago 3
@BUS344Yankees these ARE you opinions. I find horowitz's scriabin a bit much, personally.
mikejr41387 1 year ago
YEAH !!! Yuja is incredible ! Technique. Like a kinfe !
LukeMD 1 year ago
Comment removed
Edi7oR 1 year ago
Could anyone tell me the name of the first sonata Yuja plays? I can't seem to find anything that sounds like it on youtube....:( even though i typed in all the names listed in the description.
l0lperson 1 year ago
This is Sonata by Scarlati, you can easily find it in "Horowitz in Moscow" album
Kelimu 1 year ago
@l0lperson They are listed out of order. The first one, K380, is the most famous. It's followed by K427, then K87 and K455
rosten736 11 months ago 2
This proves that she has to be taken seriously, not just as a technically proficient performer, but as a real artist.
spamlove 1 year ago
she look's like sarah geronimo................
princesselaze 1 year ago
She plays great! She also has really long "piano fingers" as I would call them. The cicadas are pretty funny in the background...
CAPGEMS 1 year ago 2
Interpretations of a Master,
Heart of an Angel, Technique of a Devil.
Bravissimo!
GGefter1 1 year ago 10
I agree a6282, as good as it gets here, shes every bit as good as Horowitz. What wonderful talent!
brtn460y 1 year ago 5
@brtn460y As much as I admire this outstandingly gifted young lady I beg to differ with your assertion.
meredith218461 2 months ago
True beauty! Thanks.
gc0619 1 year ago 5
Beautifully and sensitively played, with a regard for the counterpoint present in the work, and evocative of another time and place. The following pieces also beautifully done.
hearts0ngs 1 year ago
Excellent playing! As good interpretations of Scarlatti as any I've ever heard.
djg3619 1 year ago 3
@djg3619 ever listen to Horowitz play Scarlatti? makes you cry. well it does me anyways lol.
uptonman666 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
no scarlatti in there...sounds chinese...ping pong...
searchsingle 1 year ago
@searchsingle LOL you're saying only CRAP
Steph54an 1 year ago
@searchsingle are jealous >5th grader? she can play piano as good as she play ping pong i bet
ILOVEHATESOMUCH 1 year ago 2
@searchsingle LOL you know nothing about classical music u fool...her playing is expressive and brings new life to this often-played piece.
hearts0ngs 1 year ago
@searchsingle agreed. 100%. You are merely speaking the TRUTH.
Thegreatbuk 5 months ago
@searchsingle You speak the truth.
Thegreatbuk 5 months ago
noise in the music please fix that =[
oOAndrewsOo 2 years ago
Maybe with some bugspray? :)
Radio 4 forum
radio4forum 2 years ago 4
The cicadas????
itsanthonyhere 1 year ago
this sound very nice!
actually use what brand recorder best?
kongkiakeng 2 years ago
J'aime beaucoup..
La pianiste et le fait qu'elle met sa fabuleuse virtuosité au service de la musique.
aviseurs 2 years ago
outstanding!
stagesix6 2 years ago 2
Comment removed
itsanthonyhere 2 years ago
Beautiful sound in this recording. And of course beautiful playing. Thank you.
Paters1234 2 years ago
well actually these are cicadas, but nevermind. I *love* the atmosphere, I'm sure she did as well :)
pianowolfi 2 years ago
Very clean!
bachaddict 2 years ago 9
MAgnificent
usheryel 2 years ago 7
This has been flagged as spam show
Scarlatti est déjà si magnifique, mais sous les doigts de Yuja Wang, c'est purement magique !
Quelle clarté, quelle transparence, quelle lisibilité, vraiment du grand et beau piano. On oublie très vite les cigales !
chlagaguel 2 years ago
Comment removed
chlagaguel 2 years ago
lol now i know what she looks like! you never see her face when she's playing! :P
bachaddict 2 years ago 3
cette pianiste est tout simplement géniale!
michelclavecin 2 years ago 4
I was there :D
mumming1 2 years ago 3
Very clean. As good as Horowitz played them. Well done.
a6282 2 years ago 36
@a6282 You can definitely hear a Horowitz influence
BizzMarki 1 year ago
Comment removed
eddopianist1 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@a6282: 'As good as Horowitz' ?? What planet are YOU from!?
eddopianist1 11 months ago
her playing is beautiful
thebloads 2 years ago 24
@thebloads Well.... Not only her playing ^^
canowxy 6 months ago
crickets heheh... no kidding
tartinitrumpet 2 years ago 6