@raspberry996 Are you joking? It's like a direct cover. Even the solo guitar bits are the same. The only real differences are there's less vocal harmonizing in this and the delivery of Foster compared to Cuomo. Even if you prefer Foster's vocals I can't see how this is different enough to be "sooo much better". And considering they didn't make it their own, at all (they did justice to the original in being so faithful, nothing more), all credits gotta go to Weezer anyway.
@Enchurito To each their own, I prefer Rivers' voice to Mark's (not that I don't like Mark's) but I still don't think it's fair to say that the cover itself is way better than the original when the only significant difference is the quality of their voices.
Man, would I have loved to be there. Weezer is one of my all time, favorite bands, and Foster the People, has become one of my favorites as well.... Good music, with a ton of emotion, talent, and rockin lyrics.
This recording is better than the previous one I viewed. Not as compressed.
Oh and no one cares if you don't like this cover. Gtfo this video and go listen to something else. Weezer did an excellent cover of their Pumped Up Kicks song and FTP did an excellent cover for Say It Ain't So. They're both fantastic bands. If you can't handle the awesome, go fuck a opossum.
@GREENFucka Well, Pumped Up Kicks has been out for about a year while Weezer was touring with the memories tour. Say It Ain't So has been a song for 17 years and, more than likely, someone in the band is a Weezer fan.
Big difference between the two songs in chronology alone.
@lazrpo yeh your right ftp are weezer fans and use them as one of their influences, id say they were stoked to see weezer cover their song so they said they'd cover this
Who cares who covered the other's song first? Stop trying to compare this little hipster band with Weezer, they're on completely different levels. Thanks.
Not only did you just COMPARE Foster to Weezer, you said their cover was better?
Not only did you just say their cover was better, but you COMPARED Marks voice to Rivers' voice?
Not only did you just COMPARE their voices, but you said MARKS WAS BETTER?
I'm sorry, but let's see Mark WRITE "Wrestle with Jiiiiiiiiiiimmmmy" and sound as good as Rivers Cuomo, one of the best rock tenors of the past 20 years, and then we'll talk.
Not only am I insulted by your comment, I'm amused.
@dancrapanzanofilms Yeah pretty much, in the span of 3 sentences. I don't really think that line "Wrestle with Jimmy" is that fantastic (you can explain the deep and resembling significance of it to me). I like the original too. And now you're going to hate on me saying "too". I'm glad your amused, but don't be insulted. I don't want Weezer fans to take it personally. Go along and comment on Weezer videos now.
@dancrapanzanofilms Hey men, chill down, BOTH bands are awsome, they play two different styles of music. It's hard to imagine Rivers Cuomo singing Helena Beat and it's hard to imagine Mark Foster singing Island in the Sun
@Coldcooler3 Don't get me wrong, FtP is a great band (their album is in my car right now), but they'll never be "the next Weezer". Reason #1, NOBODY will ever be the next Weezer. Rivers Cuomo re-invented music the way he wanted it to sound, just like Ray Charles or 'Queen' did. While FtP is a great band, until they completely change the music industry and go mainstream WITHOUT sacrificing their musicality, they'll never amount to Weezer. Reason #2, They'll never write as many songs. Simple.
@Coldcooler3 next weezer?? have you ever listened to weezer..before they started to suck? not even close. don't do foster the injustice of taking away their originality by labeling them as the next anything...
This has the best sound of all the videos of them covering this song. I'm turning it into an mp3! I can't listen to the original any more without feeling it's missing something.
Weezer's cover isn't bad. They took "Pumped-Up Kicks" and made it their style. Here, Foster the People take "Say it Ain't So" and did the same thing. It becomes theirs around 2:30. They basically come out and own this song like Weezer does live. Fantastic cover, and a hundred million billion times better than the Deftones.
@jerimierothwell Uhhhh, what are you talking about? Weezer in no way made the song sound better. To be honest, Foster the People has about a bilion times the talent that Weezer has.
@joojoosasa Really? FtP has a billion times the talent of Weezer? We are talking about the same band here, right? The one who's lead singer and songwriter went to the BERKLEE COLLEGE OF MUSIC and HARVARD UNIVERSITY? The guy who wrote EIGHT albums (twelve if you include solo albums)? The band who's been touring for almost twenty years, now? Yeah. Let's have a reunion here in twenty years and see who's still talented.
@robpang12 Pumped up kicks is a relatively new song compared to Say It Ain't So which is a VERY well known record by weezer, which was recorded like 16 years ago.. cant fault rivers cuomo fro making sure he got the lyrics right can you?
@augustrunsred just because the upload date is labeled as before doesn't mean thats when it happened. Mark that in your books as another loss for team logic.
@kingdavidtrialruns Really? Because Foster the People performed on August 12th, while Weezer performed on August the 4th. It seems to me that you are quite confused. No matter though, everyone makes mistakes. ;) Cheers
not bad, not bad......
Grippli78 1 week ago
this was horrible...weezer=WAY BETTER! rivers will always have a place in my heart<3
jjmagallanes 1 week ago
stop arguing and just appreciate Mark Foster's beauty and voice and pure amazingness
MissBeaLines 1 week ago
Foster the Peoples cover of this was better than the original. - Just.Sayin. -
Bellamione07 3 weeks ago
They did each others songs lol
Killsquad9009 4 weeks ago
this is sooo much better than the original
raspberry996 1 month ago
@raspberry996 Are you joking? It's like a direct cover. Even the solo guitar bits are the same. The only real differences are there's less vocal harmonizing in this and the delivery of Foster compared to Cuomo. Even if you prefer Foster's vocals I can't see how this is different enough to be "sooo much better". And considering they didn't make it their own, at all (they did justice to the original in being so faithful, nothing more), all credits gotta go to Weezer anyway.
peanutbrittle50 3 weeks ago
@peanutbrittle50 "Even if you prefer Foster's vocals" that's what makes it SOOO much better. River's voice is kind of annoying.
Enchurito 3 weeks ago
@Enchurito To each their own, I prefer Rivers' voice to Mark's (not that I don't like Mark's) but I still don't think it's fair to say that the cover itself is way better than the original when the only significant difference is the quality of their voices.
peanutbrittle50 3 weeks ago
@raspberry996 Despite all the hate your getting for no reason. I completely agree
Bellamione07 3 weeks ago
Don't really like the band...only came here cus i heard the cover was good, i heard right
suduki360 1 month ago
Wow they can do Neil Young AND Weezer really well, not to mention the amazing album they made on their own!
shanneonthegreat 1 month ago 3
Man, would I have loved to be there. Weezer is one of my all time, favorite bands, and Foster the People, has become one of my favorites as well.... Good music, with a ton of emotion, talent, and rockin lyrics.
RustedLocket 1 month ago
god i wana meet them so bad, so talented, so cute, such good taste
rokouttilur80 1 month ago
so good...
Justmehunterc 2 months ago
Well done !!!!
flipper330 2 months ago
A solid cover. Awesome.
classicpolo 2 months ago 5
ha weezer does one of their songs they do one of theirs
LoveFTP 2 months ago
Mark Foster didn't need to read lyrics to sing it because everybody knows this song
Kriskazam 2 months ago 13
applause, respect no need lyric to sing!
johanesbrain 2 months ago 2
Comment removed
Fredonia2k 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@johanesbrain applause, respect no need English to write!
Fredonia2k 1 month ago
This recording is better than the previous one I viewed. Not as compressed.
Oh and no one cares if you don't like this cover. Gtfo this video and go listen to something else. Weezer did an excellent cover of their Pumped Up Kicks song and FTP did an excellent cover for Say It Ain't So. They're both fantastic bands. If you can't handle the awesome, go fuck a opossum.
Thatonekimikidtwo 2 months ago 4
i think they should each cover another one or two songs from each other
and put it on a single
i'd definitely buy it.
ReiK96 2 months ago
huh its funny rivers needed a sheet of lyrics?wierd.
GREENFucka 2 months ago
@GREENFucka Well, Pumped Up Kicks has been out for about a year while Weezer was touring with the memories tour. Say It Ain't So has been a song for 17 years and, more than likely, someone in the band is a Weezer fan.
Big difference between the two songs in chronology alone.
lazrpo 2 months ago
@lazrpo yeh your right ftp are weezer fans and use them as one of their influences, id say they were stoked to see weezer cover their song so they said they'd cover this
MrAdamocovic 1 month ago
Who cares who covered the other's song first? Stop trying to compare this little hipster band with Weezer, they're on completely different levels. Thanks.
trentmorris 2 months ago
@trentmorris You're totally true !
swissfred8 6 days ago
1:00 ahhhhhhhhhhh(:
11RoxySurf 2 months ago 2
@11RoxySurf oh my goddd *le dead*
Sophz235 2 months ago
Nice treat, thanks guys.
schwags1969 2 months ago
I like it way better than the original lol
Brandonskizz123 2 months ago
It's difficult to compete with the original, but this is a pretty solid cover.
diamondgal29 3 months ago
What a good voice.
97supernintendo 3 months ago 2
At least they new the lyrics and didnt read it of a paper
123GuerreroFan 3 months ago
@123GuerreroFan The Blue Album came out in 1994. He's probably known the words for awhile :)
FacingUsAll 2 months ago
The way he says "chills" gives me chills:)
kex318 3 months ago 3
The way he sings "bubblin'." It makes me melt.
ftpjunkster 3 months ago 7
fnjklhvbyufoegsbek I can't even. I fucking love this.
Sophz235 3 months ago
Mark, I love your voice!! This song is amazing!! Sorry Weezer fans, I think this one's better :)
snipsnapclapable 3 months ago 5
@snipsnapclapable
Not only did you just COMPARE Foster to Weezer, you said their cover was better?
Not only did you just say their cover was better, but you COMPARED Marks voice to Rivers' voice?
Not only did you just COMPARE their voices, but you said MARKS WAS BETTER?
I'm sorry, but let's see Mark WRITE "Wrestle with Jiiiiiiiiiiimmmmy" and sound as good as Rivers Cuomo, one of the best rock tenors of the past 20 years, and then we'll talk.
Not only am I insulted by your comment, I'm amused.
dancrapanzanofilms 3 weeks ago
@dancrapanzanofilms Yeah pretty much, in the span of 3 sentences. I don't really think that line "Wrestle with Jimmy" is that fantastic (you can explain the deep and resembling significance of it to me). I like the original too. And now you're going to hate on me saying "too". I'm glad your amused, but don't be insulted. I don't want Weezer fans to take it personally. Go along and comment on Weezer videos now.
snipsnapclapable 2 weeks ago
@dancrapanzanofilms Hey men, chill down, BOTH bands are awsome, they play two different styles of music. It's hard to imagine Rivers Cuomo singing Helena Beat and it's hard to imagine Mark Foster singing Island in the Sun
MrNaya8 2 weeks ago
im a hardcore weezer fan, but this is really good too!!
cballet315 3 months ago 4
thums up if you think foster the people is the next weezer
Coldcooler3 4 months ago
@Coldcooler3
Thumbs up if you think theyll be better then weezer
TheDIC3productions 3 months ago
@Coldcooler3 Don't get me wrong, FtP is a great band (their album is in my car right now), but they'll never be "the next Weezer". Reason #1, NOBODY will ever be the next Weezer. Rivers Cuomo re-invented music the way he wanted it to sound, just like Ray Charles or 'Queen' did. While FtP is a great band, until they completely change the music industry and go mainstream WITHOUT sacrificing their musicality, they'll never amount to Weezer. Reason #2, They'll never write as many songs. Simple.
roborobiee 3 months ago
@Coldcooler3 next weezer?? have you ever listened to weezer..before they started to suck? not even close. don't do foster the injustice of taking away their originality by labeling them as the next anything...
rmaxtpmx 3 months ago
rivers cuomo taught mark foster how to play this on guitar so he decided to do a cover of it.... just informing you if you didn't know....
OCPAA0123 4 months ago 6
The sound quality on this is amazing. Kudos.
Mechagnomics 4 months ago 3
@thecharmingpoppie827 yea fuck that guy
alexd765 4 months ago
@TheDIC3productions Fuck you, man.
Everybody knows the lyrics to say it ain't so. Its a classic.
thecharmingpoppie827 4 months ago 15
This has the best sound of all the videos of them covering this song. I'm turning it into an mp3! I can't listen to the original any more without feeling it's missing something.
hollyhollywood92 4 months ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
... That... Was... Great. I have to check out this band.
thura3 4 months ago
Ooo. I like their version better; can't help the voice. Loooooove it.
IllJudgeIt 4 months ago 4
Weezer's cover isn't bad. They took "Pumped-Up Kicks" and made it their style. Here, Foster the People take "Say it Ain't So" and did the same thing. It becomes theirs around 2:30. They basically come out and own this song like Weezer does live. Fantastic cover, and a hundred million billion times better than the Deftones.
Radioactive2321 4 months ago
Not quite the same as Weezer covering Foster, Weezer actually made the song sound better
jerimierothwell 4 months ago
@jerimierothwell Uhhhh, what are you talking about? Weezer in no way made the song sound better. To be honest, Foster the People has about a bilion times the talent that Weezer has.
joojoosasa 4 months ago
@joojoosasa Really? FtP has a billion times the talent of Weezer? We are talking about the same band here, right? The one who's lead singer and songwriter went to the BERKLEE COLLEGE OF MUSIC and HARVARD UNIVERSITY? The guy who wrote EIGHT albums (twelve if you include solo albums)? The band who's been touring for almost twenty years, now? Yeah. Let's have a reunion here in twenty years and see who's still talented.
roborobiee 3 months ago
@roborobiee You do realize that Weezer is covering their song, right?
joojoosasa 3 months ago
@jerimierothwell are you even a foster fan?! da fuck!
THEericadee 4 months ago
I think I just jizzed in my panties
gigglegirlie 5 months ago 2
THUMBS UP FOR NO? FUCKING REASON ! :P
digitaltactics 5 months ago
kids got a whole lot of f**ckin talent!!!
darylstewart89 5 months ago 2
Leads voice is kind of annoying..rest is not bad, but can't compare to Weezer =p
FlyingWithFishes 5 months ago
love it !!!! so much passion thats all i have to say
judithsantano98 5 months ago 2
at least he knows the lytics and doesn't need to read them
robpang12 5 months ago 5
@robpang12 Pumped up kicks is a relatively new song compared to Say It Ain't So which is a VERY well known record by weezer, which was recorded like 16 years ago.. cant fault rivers cuomo fro making sure he got the lyrics right can you?
smalc0lm 5 months ago
really great cover!
elicolyermusic 5 months ago 2
Damn right! Foster the People givin Weezer a run for their money! XD
97supernintendo 5 months ago 3
This sounds so great!!! Ohmygosh!
frigginpinkninjas 5 months ago
can u like team up with weezer? like FOSTER THE WEEZER?
tuleli 5 months ago 7
i'd like to see weezer and foster the people on the same stage! what a team-up!<3
The1EyedDoughnut 5 months ago 100
i was right next to you!!!!!
tripppy
Sm0k3w33d3v3ryDay 6 months ago
Wow they are good. Probably returning the favor to Weezer. This was pretty good. Can't wait to see them in October. :D
peekaboo499 6 months ago
Haha, returning the favor to Weezer I see.
augustrunsred 6 months ago 103
@augustrunsred incorrect, this was first
kingdavidtrialruns 2 months ago
@kingdavidtrialruns Well, the video I saw of Weezer covering Pumped up Kicks was dated Aug 5th.
augustrunsred 2 months ago
@augustrunsred just because the upload date is labeled as before doesn't mean thats when it happened. Mark that in your books as another loss for team logic.
kingdavidtrialruns 2 months ago
@kingdavidtrialruns Really? Because Foster the People performed on August 12th, while Weezer performed on August the 4th. It seems to me that you are quite confused. No matter though, everyone makes mistakes. ;) Cheers
augustrunsred 2 months ago
@kingdavidtrialruns Very incorrect. This was in response.
MikesUltimatum 2 months ago
Awesome!
Vanhaley 6 months ago
whoa you guys haven't posted in a while
meeroar 6 months ago
killed it
Immafun12 6 months ago
@Immafun12 yes they did
infamousboone 6 months ago
@Immafun12 HELL YEAH they did!!!!!!!!!!!!
CoralStellaLou 5 months ago