Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (121)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • In my opinion Haley and Pia should have made it all the way to the end.

  • This guy's computer is a potato.

  • it was brilliant, i still give the best version of this song to Gina Glocken....I dunno maybe Gina backstory had everything to do with it. This is technically the best, but 2nd best for me... she is stunning and a great stylistic singer.... she will be huge if her fans stays with her.

  • anyway, pia performs really well. she outdone scotty at first, indeed, but she didn't outdo herself in the weeks to come, unlike scotty, which puts her in a disadvantage. others managed to pull votes but she didn't. that's why she was eliminated

  • HQ? it's not even LQ it's FLQ

    bet some idiots won't get this

    L means low and F is a vulgarity. get it?

  • This is so not HQ , this is HQ billion years ago

  • For me your the best singer!!!i like this song.your no.1 Congratulations!!!

  • i still dont understand how scotty won

  • Any day this woman could sing the pants off Scotty. This performance proves that!

  • Scotty who ?

  • wow

  • The like and dislike bar is like a green pencil with a red eraser on the end! x

  • OMG!! WTF AmericanIdol2011TV? ..the video and audio quality SUCKS!!!!!!!!!! ..but some how Pia made it still look and sound GREAT!

  • Comment removed

  • dum fuks had who win this year?

  • loveeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee itt

  • She looks so much like her mother♥

  • i love how they announce her as " former make-up artist "

  • ......how could she have gotten voted off of THIS Song?????? That was Sooooooooooo wrong!

  • @Crazy4CountryMusic11 it wasnt her fault it was the judges if they wouldn't hav esaved Casey a few weeks b4 she would hav emade it to the finale

  • Okay? >:( Who messed with the public voting counter? >:(

  • Carrie definitely outdistance Pia by a mile. Like I said before Carrie doesn't strain her vocals like everybody does. Pia may have gotten high vocals but you could see the strain on her strain. There is a no comparison to Carrie at all. Besides Carrie proved she's better by winning her season, whereas Pia didn't.

  • @row759 who cares if carrie won i like both but there equally great i think pia is great by herself she didnt have to win to be noticed she probably already has a record deal and carrie shes going Down on the charts FAST

  • @bearluv1234 she probably does have a record deal. And I won't be shocked, when Carrie's new album hopefully by end of this year or beginning of next year. It will probably fly right by Pia's album.

  • @row759 Pia Toscano will always be the best!:)

  • @bearluv1234, I guess you will just have to agree to disagree about Pia and Carrie. You will think Pia is best and I will always think Carrie is better. Pia will never top Carrie.

  • Amazing voice!!! I have no idea how she did not win:(

  • whos the girl beside ashton jones??

  • Wow.. Just Amazing voice!

  • oh my god.she sings like celine!!!!!!!!!!

  • HQ my ass!!

  • @insiyongful Horrible Quality :$

  • I love how that girl at 2:42 is like "How are we soposed to top that?"

  • I swear the top three should have been Pia, Haley and James.

    Pia and haley are just so freaking awesome. Smh america..

  • Pia and James final...................

    I like Scottys voice and Lauren's ,but safe, pleasant, nice tone, just not standouts like Pia and James. Time will only tell!

  • The 3 people disliked this suffer from jealousy.

  • She did amazing their should be absolutely NO reason why she got voted off!! All I can say is shame on u america!!!

  • She did amazing their should be absolutely NO reason why she got voted off!!

  • Não tem como não se apaixonar por essa voz *_*, pena que saiu :(, então me resta somente o top 3, que são meus favoritos :)

  • Pia should have won. Really. I'm really shocked that she got eliminated. First standing O of this season then she gets eliminated? WTH. PIA TOSCANO SHOULD HAVE WON!

  • HQ where????? in some 3rd world country??

  • Wow, and she got voted off. Her & James should've been the top 2 finalists. How is Scotty still in? Wow...America's gone crazzyyy.

  • Wow, and she got voted off. Her & James should've been the top 2 finalists. How is Scotty still in? Wow...

  • Bring back Pia...she is the next Elizabeth Taylor with a VOICE!

  • PIA ia sooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo­ooooooooooooooooooooooo hawtttt

  • I FEEL BAD FOR THOSE 3 WHO DISLIKED THIS VIDEO.IT MUST BE VERY DIFFICULT FOR THEM TO BE DEAF AND BLIND AT THE SAME TIME....GOD BLESS YOU 3 !!!

  • AMAZING she is the BEST!!

  • WHAT'S THE MATTER WITH YOU, AMERICA? PIA IS PURE TALENT! SHE DESERVES TO WIN.

  • @LittleMissAlpha10 she got sign with Interscope Records

  • You know what I like about Pia, when you can just stand up there and sing like that. Unbelievable. If she's not already in a studio recording, something is very wrong. The best ones don't need to run all over the stage or need fancy lighting or gimmicks, when its just you, the microphone, and your voice, that's when you can tell the good ones from the really great ones like Pia. I wish I had 1% of her singing ability, but that was a talent I was not blessed to have. Go Pia!

  • she is AMAZINGGGGGG

  • god i love pia AND standing o's :)

  • this is an amazing video she is good one of the best i ever i seen

  • She DESERVED that standing ovation!!!

  • Pia should have won the competition.!!!!! I dont even want to watch the show anymore

    

  • @weeworldchikax3 either girls who are completely envious of her, or guys who just hate women.. (or even sombody who maybe misclicked the like button with the dislike haha) coz anybody else would've loved that.. could have, would have, should have.. ♥ PIA

  • Oh, why you look so sad?

    Tears are in your eyes

    Come on and come to me now

    I'll stand by you

    I'll stand by you

    Won't let nobody hurt you

    I'll stand by you

    Pia, yes we're sad to see u get voted off and we cried too. But the world will stand by you now, no one can hurt you anymore. Love u. Thumbs up if you agree!!

  • ABSOLUTELY AN AMAZING PREFORMER!! I WILL DEFF BE BUYING HER CD!!

  • I hear on the news she got a great record contract Awesome.

  • People sound like American Idol is everything. The only ones who got to be real known in the music industry overseas are Kelly and Carrie. She was voted out, sorry, but there are so many opportunities to someone who has already singed in front of 20 million people!

  • Its the crazy tweenies who are voting they have no idea what real talent is all about. Like keep Steffano over her OMG lololo. They need to change the voting rules.

  • @kateandutube dts why bieber is so famous..lol

  • has ANYONE else noticed that American idol is now just a pretty boy competition?

    last 3 winners, David cook, Kris allen, Lee dewise, ALL PRETTY BOY GUITRISTS. its not fair to the ladies who have talent.

  • What the hell!! she's out? America you must be kidding me!!..

  • O: I Broke the replay button!!

  • wish she'd not been voted off :((

  • i just love pia, <3i feel soo guilty for not voting for anyone last night:/

  • cant believe pia went :(

  • Oh MY fucking God!!! She is flawless!!!!

  • Pia deserved to be the finalist! At least is there james and jacob.

  • @hillo2010 Yeah, good thing theres adam "lambert wannabe" and "guy who wont sell records". Pia deserved to win.

  • @bouyo32123 James isn't a "lambert wannabe" - he's incredible & has incredible stage presence. He belongs on that stage. Difference between the 2 is - he will sell records because (unfortunately) a lot of people are put off by the flamboyantness of Adam. He can sing - but he's more Broadway & James is Rock. I luved Pia and was pissed she was voted off - so now I hope James or Lauren wins. The rest suck!

  • Pia went home over STEFANO of all people. You know, the guy whose falsetto was so off-key it was disgusting. Pia, who absolutely nailed "River Low, Mountain High." James is my favorite, but Pia should have been in the Top 5.

  • sadly , she went home ..

    :'(

  • Pia should of not been voited off this sucks i think paul is the one that needs to go.

  • @judith6ful Seriously, why is Paul still there? Pia left over Paul, wtf? is america crazy?!

  • @judith6ful well i don't wanna sound mean but i agree. Paul is good but just sth sth. Pia's performances are flawless.

  • i love this girl i got goosebumps

  • too bad she is gone... thanks to the bad advice of jennifer lopez

  • @thepapiulookin I don't blame Jennifer Lopez because it happened to Casey(not a fan btw) already before right? and Jennifer Lopez said she is a spectacular singer.

  • oh god :* i love her voic so much

  • not my favorite contestant this season but i cant deny the fact this lady can really sing . she is amazing . absolutely loved this performance

  • WHO DISLIKED THIS? FOR GOODNESS SAKES THEY HAVE NO TASTE

  • THE BEEEEESTTTT!

  • @maimolestina no she's not the best her voice is just ordinary. Her voice is not that high. She is inhaling so deep before the high part and it is so obvious unlike celine, charice jennifer hudson it's so effortless for them.

  • if i had a dollar for every pixel in this video.. id have ten dollars.

  • The best never win... and she is the best. So even though she probably won't have "American Idol winner" on her resume, she will still sell more records than all of the contestants combined!

  • hiftydydst gsfdtsd gdgftgsfgt ggfrafyrytr yyfytry ryyrtu yeeyrue uu uu7k8 yhtyy7jdueued hjdfhdhfjfh fhdhgdfhjujf vhdghdfc hrgf fhgvfhhgf hfjf h g y;toy g'gluueuyrffyryrytu hddffyrf ujfrfuurfjfryhgufyhhhhhhhhjgyh­ufjgkfughkfhkgfjhgjfgfuygjfhjg­fofifjttttrkrjktjkrjkrjktjrktj­trlgtuuyrtyturyyrufufyugugfygf­ufygiygigfyidfgidgfuygfigfygfi­yigffgigifgfgigfuigfyugfyfgyfu­gygfygfyguhggklh ghi ightyuu uu tuytuiu i iturrf ytuytt litit ruuuyruyuyfugufugfuyguyg y7y56y456554415523551447/
  • hiftydydst gsfdtsd gdgftgsfgt ggfrafyrytr yyfytry ryyrtu yeeyrue uu uu7k8 yhtyy7jdueued hjdfhdhfjfh fhdhgdfhjujf vhdghdfc hrgf fhgvfhhgf hfjf h g y;toy g'gluueuyrffyryrytu hddffyrf ujfrfuurfjfryhgufyhhhhhhhhjgyh­ufjgkfughkfhkgfjhgjfgfuygjfhjg­fofifjttttrkrjktjkrjkrjktjrktj­trlgtuuyrtyturyyrufufyugugfygf­ufygiygigfyidfgidgfuygfigfygfi­yigffgigifgfgigfuigfyugfyfgyfu­gygfygfyguhggklh ghi ightyuu uu tuytuiu i itur ytuytt litit ruuuyruyuyfugufugfuyguyg y7y56y456554415523551447/
  • thia

  • amazing the judges stood! omg she should just win right now!!!!!!!!!

  • I am so feel into this lady "PIA"! Wow...Amazing and Beautiful!

  • OMG! She's my idol after Thia Migia...

  • Heres your winner

  • 2:14 - amazing!

  • I have stopped watching Idol because I think it's went a little off track since the first few seasons but after hearing this WOW, I hope this girl wins, she is AMAZING. I may have to start back watching it now.

  • pia please sing Selena Dreaming of you..

  • ahh i absolutely love her. goosebumpppps.

  • It's a winning performance!

  • like if you got goose bumps! I most certainly did!

  • @m5u4s3i2c1 ill stand by you

  • @m5u4s3i2c1 I got goosebumps looking at the quality of this video, it literally made my skin crawl.

  • Comment removed

  • You are the next American Idol

    and my home town girl

    @AdamsMom76

  • awesome........no doubt.....

  • Amazing! I love this song so much....it reminds me of the beautiful past :-)

  • HAMEYZING!!! PIA TOSCANO, the NEXT AMERICAN IDOL! Humble, hard-working, beautiful inside and out, has personality and an outstanding vocal! What to ask for? :D

  • go PIA i'm UR #1 FANS HERE IN PHILIPPINES..!

    ...GOD BLESS U...

  • First half was...alright, but she picked it UP in the second half!

  • Unbelieveable! Its time from a contestant from the New York to WIN IDOL! LONG OVERDUE!

  • Comment removed

  • She's so beautiful and I was blown away with this performance!

  • This was AMAZING!

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more