ne jure pas, gros mécréant!

[Serpette94]

Incroyable son jeu d'acteur je trouve, il arrive à laisser transparaitre toute sa souffrance et nous faire pleurer sans musique ni rien.

[grobbledonk]

This is one of the best films I've ever seen. Wuthering Heights (1939), John Huston's "The Dead", & Cinema Paradiso likewise devastate me

[chaeliejean]

j'aime cette vidéo mais il faudrait l'enlever car ca gache la surprise de la fin du film

[bloodyweasel1]

"vivant... mais bossu..."

c'est trop dur !..

[Ksenija73]

jedan od najboljih filmova svih vremena.

[pontias1]

pure merveille merci

[Josh0473]

Great scene, no cuts at all when it zooms to his face as he hears the truth. Not many actors can do that. Tremendous acting and film.

[borninparis]

Elle fait mal cette scene... Un grand moment dramatique et un malheur qui a bien du arriver dans ce bas monde, bien que l' on ne le souhaite pas a son pire ennemi.

[Simsboy1987]

C'est certainement l'une des plus horribles punitions. Papet s'est acharné a détruire la vie d'un homme qui n'était autre que le fils qu'il n'avait jamais eu.

Il m'a fallu trois jours pour me remettre de ce film

Sans compter que Depardieu en Jean de Fleurette vous arrache le coeur, Daniel Auteuil en Ugotin fait pitié, il n'est pas méchant, juste manipulé et Yves Montand est grandiose

[roumi1982]

quel film extraordinaire avec un Yves Montand grandiose



[mowriter]

it's a rare American actor who can act with his face like this Lion.

[biggus8888]

@mowriter Who is American?

[mowriter]

@biggus8888 : LOL, no one in this brilliant movie. I'm simply saying there are precious few American actors who can act as good as this man, as evidenced in this movie!

[danielodyssey]

Superbe. Tout est là. Pourquoi chercher des beaux acteurs jeunes quand les anciens contiennent toute l'emotion du monde. Amazing performances.

[60easy32]

Montand , acteur grandiose , son visage à la fin de la scène , mémorable

[scarletjamable]

this classic scene is just so tragic.

[wollin20]

ça, c'est pas une publicité pour la poste!

[Gmmodel]

il etait bossu

le mot qui tue

apprendre qu'on est passé a cote de sa vie quand on est vieux

Quoi de plus horrible

[3anaurv2]

est ce que elle sait la douleur qu'il va avoir quand elle prononce le mot bossu ?

[hartsty]

Yves Montand was a real old fashioned performer who could sing and act. A rare talent.Un vrai bon acteur.

[IRFRAJ]

best scene in the history of cinema.... a real real tragedy.......

[ticote16]

la scene la plus tragique du film,"et il est né vivant...........oui,mais bossu........le regard du papé a ce moment du film est la plus belle scene du cinema français,montand ne joue pas un role il le vie,auteuil etait aussi grandiose dans ce film!

[che1609]

I think this is quite possibly the most memorable movie scene I have ever scene. After watching two long films - this is the ultimate sting in the tail. Incredible cinema.

[BabyGirlGoddess]

saw this today in my french 3 class ( we saw Jean de Florette a couple of weeks ago) and i was just speechless.

[speedstertje]

What's the name of this old lady, need it for school :s

[XaTF]

@speedstertje Delphine

[Zerwas999]

Hätte er doh Gewußt das der Buchlige sein Sohn ist! Welche Tragig!!!!

[jehanon]

devastating

[cbak12sg]

This is a marvellously shot scene. It is mostly the blind old woman who is speaking, but most of the attention is on the great Yves Montand, playing a bitter old man who is totally crushed by what the old woman is telling him, which is all about a letter he should have got many years earlier from the woman he loved.

The words "Enceinte" and later "Vivant, mais bossu" finish him off.

[ClubDeTiroNalon]

He visto esta escena no menos de 10 veces y hoy todavía me ha hecho llorar.

[foreverashcroft]

a heartbreaking end to this most beautiful film, my heart breaks always at this point..

[BaaBaaRaa]

Comme qqn a dit: une tragedie greque... Il a tue son propre fils et perdu l'amour de sa vie par sa propre ignorance et fierte... et une lettre perdue par la poste. J'ai toujours adore les livres de Pagnol. Yves Montand etait superbe en tant que le papi Soubeyran.

[pawleenuhboo]

BOSSU :(

[nokolson]

" vivant ... mais bossu " ralala quelle scene, la plus belle du film. Je m'en lasse pas je pourrais la regarder 20 fois a la suite. J'ai remarqué beaucoup de commentaires etrangers ... et ça, ça me fait super plaisir de voir que cette tragedie provençale est apprécié hors de nos frontieres.

[usfins]

HEARTBREAKING ENDING TO THE FILM.

[simonjambe]

Fabuleux Montand!

[snupiloz]

These are my 2 favorite films ever. Montand's dramatic acting capability makes this scene go deep into your soul: his eyes, lips, skin make you feel all the suffering from this greek tragedy.

"Chapeau bas" all'arte francese dall'Italia!

[fnslr308]

dont speak french so need subtitles

very good tho

also try Ryans Daugher

[ColdTearSP]

6:00 best acting ever, it really looks how the book describes it.

[Kitesurfer34]

Puis vient cette longue scène de 7 minutes. Que veut dire la vieille Delphine? Ou veut elle en venir avec son bel accent du midi teinté d'ironie et de compassion.

Et puis c'est la révélation, comme un coup de point dans le coeur et l'âme. Toute la salle est en pleur et souffre avec César Soubeyran et Montant qui n'est plus depuis longtemps dans un rôle de composition. C'est épouvantable, insupportable...

Merci pour ce moment de cinéma ... j'en ai encore les larmes aux yeux.

[Loickeri]

exceptionnel

[rudycolas]

Superbe cette scene

[anselmej]

it remembers me Sophocle

[papadydy]

certainement la scène de cinéma qui ma fais le plus pleurer ,tous simplement magnifique de réalisme,jouer par deux acteurs d"exception

[gregg941]

best film ever

[Cachibym]

The most emotive scene I have ever seen in a film. J'ai des larmes aux yeux chaque fois...

[percythepiggo]

I think this is one of the best films ever made [I recommend reading the book, too!]. I recorded it from the UK Channel 4. They're bound to show it again, sooner or later. It'll have English sub-titles too, but when you record it they seem to disappear. I don't know if there's any way around that.

[anselmej]

incroyable, incredible

[clairoobscur]

The best scene of my preferred movie. In other words, the best scene I ever seen in a movie. Montant at his best, deeply sincere, and heart-breaking.

[clairoobscur]

La meilleure scene de mon film prefere. En d'autres termes, c'est pour moi la meilleure scene que j'ai vue au cinema. Incroyablement bien jouee et "vraie" (j'ai ete eleve dans le sud de la France par ma grand-mère, et j'ai connu bien des gens agés. La scene m'a frappe par la verite des attitudes).

Montand a son plus haut niveau. Et touchante a briser le coeur.

[soupinette13]

cette scene est extraordinaire il realise qu'il a tué son fils

[udetz]

les textes et émotions de Marcel Pagnol inégalables!!!!!

[denzelwash06]

Montand's performance is awesome, up there with the greatest ever !

[Lora83640]

I live where this film had been shot "la provence" in the south of france, it's a beautiful place, I like watching Marcel Pagnol's film. They're so powerful, and more for the one who live where the films take place, like me. see his film, they 're very beautiful I assure you

[rishbademha]

Whats the movies name....and is it available on english subtitles?

[thetenia]

It is manon of the spring. Yes it is on dvd with subtitles. This scene is very very powerful if you had seen the film. Make SURE to get Jean De Florette first

[anselmej]

it remembers me Oedipus from Sophokles the moment when he knows whom he is

[anselmej]

extraordinaire a pleurer toutes les larmes de son corps

[violinbloke]

This is a truly majestic pair of films (with Jean de Florette......but maybe people should not see the denoumente????

[richjvernon]

the climax of the best 2 films i have ever seen. I get everyone i can to watch them but sadly most of my friends find it boring. It it torturous watching Montand, he is incredible.

[Baldenlong77]

Yeah, Yves Montand's expression at the around the six minute mark is DEVASTATING. Even without subtitles here I could still remember the line from seeing this the first time inmy high school French class. "

"Yes....it was born a hunchback."

.

[anselmej]

in french it is

yes he was born alive ... alive  and ... hunchback

[Oualtaire]

Read Marcel Pagnol's novels prior to watching all the adaptations... You'll have more fun.

[mysbe]

maybe you can try to download it from a torrent ....

[lilmizzsxc24]

does anyone know where i can watch this movie on the internet?!?! we started it on the last day of the term in french class and i wanna know what happens!!!

[Zorg2006]

One of the greatest scenes in history.

[x03x06]

awesome movie, I consider the two movies some of my favorite movies.

[BabaYaga25]

Saw this movie in French class, it's amazing. Very sad at the end.

[sparrowking999]

It's sad what happened to ugalin

[plaidi]

At 6:06, I adore the look on his face when he realizes who he plotted against and murdered. This is possibly one of the best scenes in movie history.

[kn0xyb0y]

Une scène magnifique.