Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (182)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Fantastic build up to the end!

  • Why did the put their hands up for like a minute?

  • Tomorrows my last day as a 17 year old. I'm freaking sad.

  • this is one of the best videos on youtube.

  • It's Jimmy Shaw!!!

  • Amy, Emily and Leslie together is always the best. One of my favorite BSS memories was seeing them in Toronto at Lee's Palace in spring 2003 and they did this and Amy sung it and did and an incredible version. Best BSS show I ever saw.

  • i get goosebumps and instant hope for the world when i hear this.

  • If you've ever seen emily haines and Fiest in a picture together, they have really similar facial features. they're look almost like sisters....the most beautiful sisters ever!

  • @111dogon555 It's Feist you moron.

  • @SayCremeFraiche oh no a typo, please forgive me asshole

  • @111dogon555 Say Creme Fraiche

  • I can't stop hitting replay. So perfect.

  • I can't stop hitting replay. So perfect.

  • Favorite video on youtube? I think so

  • :')

  • THIS IS BEAUTIFUL.

  • Real mantra. Beauty.

  • aww That wasn't quite the end of the song. :( Still great though.

  • <3 Emily Haines <3

  • This was absolutely phantasmagorical. Yep. That's the only time that word has ever just 'popped' into my head.

  • 6 people talk trash under their breath.

  • These guys are so magical, I want to a member of Broken Social Scene. They have so many members that hopefully they won't even notice I'm there..

  • That was great.

    Some guy at 4:04 even made a Polaroid picture and you know how expensive these films are ;-)

  • @ertobi I thought I would've been the only person to notice that! Good eye. :D

  • Thank you so much for puting up these videos. :)

    

  • This band makes my life in so many ways, I came over from listening to Stars, and found that Stars had all been with this band, I know where the next 60$ in iTunes gift cards I get are going.

  • Amy dress like going to interview a bank job :D

  • Love love LOVE is all I can say....but aside from them bein in the movie the movie itself SUCKED!!! These guys made the movie!

  • This is the concert that was filmed for This Movie Is Broken... SO GOOD

  • at 0:38 seconds, i got so many chills :D

  • plz if anynone knows how to play this song on guitar, can you share the chords? thanks!

  • this is life.

  • Im going to there concert tonight:)

  • i like when feist plays the air guitar.

  • well that was just lovely

  • cantankerousrot - thats the most talented guitar player ever...really?

  • cantankerousrot - thats the most talented guitar player ever...really?

  • This is the first song to ever bring tears to my eyes.

  • i don't even understand how this doesn't have more views. i just listen to it on repeat all of the time.

  • this song is so soo beautiful. if i saw this live i think i would cry.

  • my heart just broke. best moment of my life

  • Jimmy is totally the most talented guitar player ever.

  • Hehehe my mums promised me 6 gigs for 2010 :D I soo want BSS to come to England, play this and be one of them!! :D

  • I love how this reaches such a level of intensity that wind starts blowing through everyone's hair at the end

  • yay I get to seem them tonight... too bad these three lovely ladies aren't gonna be there.. I still love Lisa too though

  • there's no words to describe what i feel when i listen to this song, its out of this world !

  • 4 people arent even people.

  • @TThirdplaneTT or they forgot it in people

  • fuckinggggg epic!!!!

  • Was this the concert in Toronto that was in "This Movie Is Broken"?

  • @Kylethedudeman32 yes sir!

  • I'm totally in love with those three women... Especially Emily... Gosh she's sexy!!!

  • Does anyone know who has the writing credits to this song?

  • Feist playing air bass..so cute

  • you need a drink of liquid

  • the states got wu tang and canada has broken social scene = )

  • stars, metric, feist... all awesome

  • Too bad this one ends a little early, before Emily says "I missed my friends." So sweet, and so genuine.

  • @seurat2 oh my god that is so sweet. man, this is the most amazing performance i have ever seen... wish to god i could have been there

  • This is probably my favorite video in YouTube. I'd give anything to see this live. Emily leaves me speechless.

  • park that car

    drop that phone

    sleep on the floor

    dream about me

  • This fills me up with so much awesome it leaks from my eyes.

  • LOL

    they all wavin' hands an' shi'''

    Big hair! Beautiful Song!

    And, g*d,.... don;t we all look drop dead sexy wearing cut-off T-shirts?

    She sure does ----whew!

  • LOL

    they all wavin' hands an' shi'''

    Big hair! Beautiful Song!

  • LOL

    they all wavin' hands an' shi'''

  • Amy looks like she walked out of TD bank trying to apply for a loan, bro

  • emily haines is my hero.

    BSS make me feel so proud to be Canadian.

    OMG i just realized, James Shaw is there too!

    Metric <3

    OKAY I THINK IM CRYING NOW LOL CUZ I MISSED THIS SHOW :(

  • emily haines is my hero.

    BSS make me feel so proud to be Canadian.

  • magical mystery whore?? wow. who could ever top that name.

  • Saw them in Austin Tx when they were all together. It was one of the best shows Ive ever seen. When they sang '17' the crowd went straight nuts. The only shows Ive seen that were as emotionally moving were the Flaming Lips and maybe Wilco.

  • SO, I went to Canada once. . . and I'm convinced there's nothing but beautiful, healthy looking people there.

    ANYWHOO, love Broken Social Scene and this made a manly man like myself totally tear up.

  • monkey show

  • God, I wish I had been there. This Movie is Broken was close enough I guess. Not really.

  • imagine k-os came out and started rapping on this

  • Is Feist playing air guitar at 2.04?

  • @Bruceeddie01 I think it's more like air bass

  • Did anyone else tear up when Emily started to sing in the beginning? THIS is music

  • @quickgears, this is music at its best in fact.

  • my dad just e-mailed me to ask how i was feeling and i sent him a link to this video...this is past incredible.

  • Why the fuck is everone talking!

  • Awesome Q__Q

  • thanks for this great vid

  • I can only here Haines' voice. She really out-shadowed Feist and Amy!

  • Comment removed

  • Feist, Emily, and Amy? Wet dream for sure.

  • amazing i thank you so much ! <3

  • This is the best video on the internet. Hands down.

  • One of my favorite live performances ever.

  • i was there, it was fuckin awesome

  • Wow, Emily, Amy and Feist... the way BSS should be.

  • i always got the chill and an urge to cry everytime i hear this song....and I'm even a boy....

  • @alkupra the song is written from the perspective of both genders. It could work as a girl waving goodbye to her best friend who's gone a bit plastic, or an ex boyfriend to his converted girlfriend. That's exactly what makes this song a classic.

  • Yesss...BSS are perfect, fantastic team!..Great music!

  • The way Feist's hair is blowing in the wind at 3:51 makes this so much more epic

  • I get the chills every time. This has to happen again this Summer

  • Feist, Kevin and Amy sitting there looking at Emily Haines is just perfect. Love this song. Can't wait to see This Movie is Broken.

  • best shit ever.

  • Bahaha i love that Feist, Drew, Haines, Shaw, Millan and Peroff are all closed in in this little circle. So awesome.

  • WTF IM CRYING TOO! this is a musical orgasm

  • @burnsoutbright44 Musical orgasm? Proper term is eargasm

  • yes! this is theee best! wish i could have seen a peep more of kevin drew ♥ ♫ ☮ love miss emily haines...thank you for posting

  • feist gives the finger at the end

  • sooo gooood

  • this is like dying and going to indie heaven...

  • this made my heart smile.

  • if all of them came together and made one super band i would die!!!!

  • @brianne13910 broken social scene is one super band!!!!!

  • @brianne13910 I think they did all come together and make one super band. This one.

  • @brianne13910 They did. It's called Broken Social Scene.

  • great show, i was so baked

  • feist and kevin drew need to go back to bss

  • Was hoping for a reunion of this group at the BSS show in Vancouver this week, since feist, stars, and jimmy shaw were in town.

    Absolutely amazing vid! Favorited as this is my fav BSS song.

  • ... :'D

  • That was beautiful. ='D

  • So Good! Saw Metric live...

    Emily Haines has incredible Stage presense

  • Oh. My. God.

  • ps i looove canada.

  • why was i not on that stage with them.

    seriously, thanks for taking this.

  • @philphie you're an asshole.

    and that has nothing to do with the epicness that is this performance.

  • 3:25 and on... This band is incredibly in sync with each other. This is music at its absolute pure state, it's so easy to tell when a band is passionately making music for all the right reasons. I'm jealous of all of them. Every single one of their hearts is in the music. Not the fame, righteousness and definitely not the profit (there wasn't even a profit here!). Fortunately we benefit from their love and passion.

    I love this band so much. Much respect.

  • Nigga.

    If i heard this live, i would drop dead.

    God, why am I crying?

  • @MagicalMysteryWhore - everytime i watch this video it makes me cry! I was so lucky to be there that night and it was so perfect, this song is absolute genius, no doubt whatsoever :)

  • @MagicalMysteryWhore Awesome name. lol

  • @MagicalMysteryWhore  HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

  • @MagicalMysteryWhore i'm crying with u.

  • Yeah.. Feist and Emily. Def among my favs. Nothing against Amy. Don't know much about her.

    But I've seen Metric twice this year. Yet to see Feist. Makes me sad.

    This year has been crazy.

    Fuck I love music.

    <3

  • isn't amy in Stars?

  • yeah she is, she also does solo stuff which is pretty good, too.

  • Eh, her solo stuff is "meh." I think she lacks something without Torquil's songwriting.

  • I can't believe I fucking missed this show!!!

  • I was there in the middle seats. Good show overall, but this song was totally ahead of the others that night. This video doesn't do it justice, you had to be there to hear how epic this really was.

  • Best performance ever or the best song ever..

  • beautiful

  • this was the best show i had ever been to! they were absolutely amazing

  • Feist + Emily Haines + Amy Milian = my top female vocalists of today singing together?

    Gosh i really shoulda been there

  • @davidmjeong926 some fan you are, haha I'm this playing. This set up is truly boss shit.

  • @davidmjeong926 Lisa Lobsinger

  • wow you were so lucky to have gone... and your video is so clear and just wow... amazing it was a free concert and it was the whole crew

  • i've never got shivers that much from listening to a song. amazing

  • Its cute that Jimmy and Emily start the song together

  • This is nothing short of amazing!! <3

  • Emily Haines is the star of this song.

  • This is like watching a high school reunion, except since leaving, everyone's become a, well, rockstar.

  • god i love emily. marry me please

  • so great to see lisa and julia out there, bss is not really the same without that violin...

  • so true

  • Such an amazing night <3

  • I'd given a lot to be there, but noooo, stuck overseas. thanks for sharing

  • it was such a good show. wow...this video is even giving me chills. the crowd went nuts when they played this song. amazing. thanks for uploading!

  • Is it just me or is Emily Haines way hotter with BSS than with Metric? And I think Amy is hotter here than with Stars too.

  • Comment removed

  • according to wikipedia there's like 23 people in this band lol

  • Yeah, they swap in and out a lot. Each album has different members.

  • why are you watching this video if you hate them so much?

  • The fact that you attend the Juno Awards might be an indication of why you were bored by them :)

  • Wow I love it.

  • thanks for the upload and the good quality

  • anyone know the chords?

  • watch the bassist

  • My best concert experience ever was Broken Social Scene in 2005 with Feist as the opening act and, of course, she performed in the BSS set. I'm insanely jealous that you got to see BSS live with the trinity: Feist, Emily, and Amy! Thanks for this awesome quality video though.

  • Thanks for the comments, everyone. As for the camera, I use a Panasonic Lumix ZS-3.

  • great quality!

  • Fuck yeah, female voices of BSS are awesome. And i love the quality of the video.

  • Jesus christ that seems like it was AMAZING. I saw Metric live last year in Toronto, cant believe I missed this :(.

  • ive seen so many live shows, including Sigur Ros and Radiohead...and i can say with confidence, that this was the #1 show i have ever witnessed...life changing

    they poured everything they had into this show...hope This Movie is Broken catches that spirit

  • Amy, Emily and Leslie... you're killing me.

  • Holy shit. That was rather spectacular. Thanks for the excellent camera and sound work!

  • Okay so pretty much this was the best concert I have ever seen and will prob continue to be ... I have been following brokens music for like 5-6 years now and this was the moment i was waiting for ...This performance was to good for words.

  • jesus fucking christ, I cried during this performance.

  • Best Concert of my life...i dont think something like this will come by for a long time...it was a beauty to see so many from the Broken Social Scene family together...and in TORONTO!